My wife bought me a pair of Stacy Adams shoes for my birthday and they fit well except they're kind of loose around the ankle. I'm not familiar with these sorts of shoes and so I didn't know if that's normal or if we should exchange them for a different size. The ones I got are a size 11.5 which is about what I usually wear for most other shoes. I took a picture to illustrate what I'm talking about:
I posted this same thing on a Reddit subforum but I thought I'd also ask here if y'all had any advice. If it matters my instep is about where the middle eyelets are and my big toe is about an inch from the tip of the shoe. It's very snug everywhere except at the ankle.