School me on modems (router discussion welcome too)

Cantido · August 2015

Alas, I have departed Korea and settled in Washington DC. My apartment building only allows Comcast cable internet. I packed my own router when I moved here, but to my suprise, Comcast leases out Modem/Router hybrids. The Xfinity modem doubles as a dual band router.

Meanwhile, I have a perfectly good Cisco Wireless N router collecting dust, but I am intrigued by the hybrid. Speedtest.net reveals pathetic results (compared to Korea) at 180.88 Mbps Download and 12.13 Mbps Upload. I am open to purchasing my own hybrid if its more effective and consumes less electricity, or is the xfinity device a superior deal leased at 10$ a month (I refuse to believe this.) What are good alternatives to this device?

Trace · August 2015

Cantido wrote: »

Alas, I have departed Korea and settled in Washington DC. My apartment building only allows Comcast cable internet. I packed my own router when I moved here, but to my suprise, Comcast leases out Modem/Router hybrids. The Xfinity modem doubles as a dual band router.

Meanwhile, I have a perfectly good Cisco Wireless N router collecting dust, but I am intrigued by the hybrid. Speedtest.net reveals pathetic results (compared to Korea) at 180.88 Mbps Download and 12.13 Mbps Upload. I am open to purchasing my own hybrid if its more effective and consumes less electricity, or is the xfinity device a superior deal leased at 10$ a month (I refuse to believe this.) What are good alternatives to this device?

you poor bastard

tsmvengy · August 2015

Having a separate router and modem is good in my opinion. It lets you upgrade your Wifi as you see fit, and with Comcast you can save some money with your own stuff.

Modem: http://www.amazon.com/ARRIS-SURFboard-SB6141-DOCSIS-Cable/dp/B00AJHDZSI

We have FIOS so we basically have to rent the modem/router.

EDIT: and yes, internet service in the USA is garbage compared to Korea. DC has a public fiber network but can't offer service to residential customers, because LOL Congress and LOL free market competition!

Cantido · August 2015

tsmvengy wrote: »

Having a separate router and modem is good in my opinion. It lets you upgrade your Wifi as you see fit, and with Comcast you can save some money with your own stuff.

Modem: http://www.amazon.com/ARRIS-SURFboard-SB6141-DOCSIS-Cable/dp/B00AJHDZSI

We have FIOS so we basically have to rent the modem/router.

EDIT: and yes, internet service in the USA is garbage compared to Korea. DC has a public fiber network but can't offer service to residential customers, because LOL Congress and LOL free market competition!

I bought the modem, thanks. It pity my brother, he loves Comcast and Xfinity. He has not tasted first world internet overseas like I have.

It took all night for my 3DS to download Entrian Odyssey Untold 2 last night. The little droplets were coming in two at a time. What the hell...

Mugsley · August 2015

I know you bought already, but the Surfboards are on sale at Woot.com at least once a week. Also, once you get the modem, you'll need to call Comcast to give them the MAC address for it.

I'm still debating updating the FiOS router we have; although we don't have any device that connects faster than N as it is.

Cantido · August 2015

Mugsley wrote: »

I know you bought already, but the Surfboards are on sale at Woot.com at least once a week. Also, once you get the modem, you'll need to call Comcast to give them the MAC address for it.

I'm still debating updating the FiOS router we have; although we don't have any device that connects faster than N as it is.

I have addtional questions.

I completed the installation, and Speetest.net is producing far diminished results. Download speed around 80 Mbps yesterday, and now its at 60 today. Is that a weekend thing or am I experiencing configuration issues? Or is Comcast being a dick and throttling me because I changed devices?

LD50 · August 2015

Cantido wrote: »

Mugsley wrote: »

I know you bought already, but the Surfboards are on sale at Woot.com at least once a week. Also, once you get the modem, you'll need to call Comcast to give them the MAC address for it.

I'm still debating updating the FiOS router we have; although we don't have any device that connects faster than N as it is.

I have addtional questions.

I completed the installation, and Speetest.net is producing far diminished results. Download speed around 80 Mbps yesterday, and now its at 60 today. Is that a weekend thing or am I experiencing configuration issues? Or is Comcast being a dick and throttling me because I changed devices?

It's likely a weekend thing.

Mugsley · August 2015

Unfortunately, "because Comcast" is going to be the answer to most of your problems

a5ehren · August 2015

Cantido wrote: »

Mugsley wrote: »

I know you bought already, but the Surfboards are on sale at Woot.com at least once a week. Also, once you get the modem, you'll need to call Comcast to give them the MAC address for it.

I'm still debating updating the FiOS router we have; although we don't have any device that connects faster than N as it is.

I have addtional questions.

I completed the installation, and Speetest.net is producing far diminished results. Download speed around 80 Mbps yesterday, and now its at 60 today. Is that a weekend thing or am I experiencing configuration issues? Or is Comcast being a dick and throttling me because I changed devices?

Going from 80 to 60 pretty much means your modem got to use 3 channels instead of 4, probably due to congestion between the modem and the closest fiber access. Your slow downloads on the DS are far more likely due to Nintendo's god-awful online infrastructure than anything to do with your connection.

Also, it could always be worse. My parents pay more than I do on Comcast for half the speed on a small regional cable company.

Penny Arcade

Quick Links

School me on modems (router discussion welcome too)

Posts