As was foretold, we've added advertisements to the forums! If you have questions, or if you encounter any bugs, please visit this thread: https://forums.penny-arcade.com/discussion/240191/forum-advertisement-faq-and-reports-thread/
Options
Symbols that change meaning...
grendel824_
Registered User regular
Registered User regular
Okay, I'm teaching a unit on "The Scarlet Letter" and I've stumped myself trying to think of a comic character whose symbol (or something else identifiable about them) was originally supposed to be a mark of shame but has been turned into something else. I'm already planning to use the cross (pre-Christianity was a punishment for really bad criminals) and the swastika (co-opted by the Nazis from a couple of different sources).
I know Superman's "S" shield is technically his family crest, but that's not "Scarlet Letter" enough. The closest I've come is Destro from G.I. Joe whose ancestor was punished by having to wear the mask, but it has since become a point of pride for the family. Any ideas? It feels like there should be quite a few, but both my prodigious comics trivia knowledge and that of most of the people at my LCS have come up empty...
I know Superman's "S" shield is technically his family crest, but that's not "Scarlet Letter" enough. The closest I've come is Destro from G.I. Joe whose ancestor was punished by having to wear the mask, but it has since become a point of pride for the family. Any ideas? It feels like there should be quite a few, but both my prodigious comics trivia knowledge and that of most of the people at my LCS have come up empty...
grendel824_ on
0
Posts
For the Confessor, the cross is a symbol of his faith, a symbol of his weakness as a mortal, a painful reminder of what he has become, and finally a symbol of the good he does.
However, you probably want someone more well known.
Also Dare Devil's name and garb. In the origin mini Man With Out Fear we find that the school kids would make fun of little Mat Murdoch by calling him Daredevil which was supposedly a point of shame, maybe somehting to do with his dad's "Devil" boxing persona. But yeah point of shame for little Matt.
I'll try and think of something later... it's too late right now.
You could make the same argument for Baron Zemo, although he kept his own mask after his scars healed.
I *know* there has to be at least *one* X-Man or New Mutant whose name or costume reflects pride in being an outsider, but nothing is springing to mind! Does Bishop's M tattoo count? He doesn't really make a big deal of it as a point of pride, but he doesn't hide it the way Marvel Girl hides her "hound" markings.
Guy Fawkes is traditionally remembered as a traitor and symbols depicting him retain negative connotations (In the UK, we immolate his effigy annually). Of course, V assumes Fawkes' persona, so to speak, as a symbol behind which to overthrow a corrupt modern-day UK government, so turning it from traitor to hero.
Of course, some would consider the original Fawkes a hero anyway, but in general we make a point of remembering him in condemnation of what he and his co-conspirators tried to do.
If that is true it is a good one.
Bruce's fear of bats lead him to as his parents to leave the opera, which lead to their deaths. Later, he uses the image of a bat to intimidate criminals. "Bats frighten me. Its time my enemies shared my dread."
A stretch, maybe.
I don't think it's a stretch, just another facet to the same idea.
The Batman thing also gets into the concept of symbolic relativism. In short, how a symbol can mean one thing for one group while meaning the direct opposite (in extreme cases) for another. In Batman's case, the bat is generally looked at as an undesirable and "evil" creature. He banks on this idea in order to instill fear in criminals.
To law-abiding citizens however Batman is viewed as a heroic icon and, as an extension of that, so is the symbol of the bat.
Boy, it feels good to stretch that anthropology muscle.
then later it turns out to be his brand of shame
It used to represent peace and harmony, and was often found imprinted on statues of Bhudda. Hell, it wasn't uncommon to find it in a Synagogue, up until Hitler came along.
Yeah for most of Top 10 I figured the hand print was what made his laser chest thing happen. Then when I found out what it was.
I would use that. Not really Batman famous but its a very good example.