Also, remember that even if someone started with more Scares, they still couldn't use a gift last night. Gifts have to be given, you can't buy and use it yourself.
lonelyahavaCall me Ahava ~~She/Her~~Move to New ZealandRegistered Userregular
So then the question becomes, who would get rid of Egos on day one?
Egos is a crafty player, and one of the best at deducing things. If he wasn't a mafia kill them there's likely somebody in the group that finds Egos intimidating.
Which is fair enough, I'd say. Coming back into it from this long an absence I'd totally be intimidated.
So I'm thinking of somebody whose been around as long, if not longer.
So then the question becomes, who would get rid of Egos on day one?
Egos is a crafty player, and one of the best at deducing things. If he wasn't a mafia kill them there's likely somebody in the group that finds Egos intimidating.
Which is fair enough, I'd say. Coming back into it from this long an absence I'd totally be intimidated.
So I'm thinking of somebody whose been around as long, if not longer.
! Romantic Undead
Egos appears to be a village kill, Preda was the mafia kill.
+1
Options
BrodyThe WatchThe First ShoreRegistered Userregular
Yeah, I'd be concerned about who killed KetBra (regardless of how happy I am with their current targeting), and obv the mafia.
"I will write your name in the ruin of them. I will paint you across history in the color of their blood."
As the party goers when about talking about the Doctor's Brain and it's possible whereabouts, a strange scent of gingerbread filled the air. When the creatures gathered to see what Jack had planned, they found KetBra (Oogie Boogie) stuffed full of little brown sugary houses, with a note saying "That's hopefully the last time I hear that song, Potato Sack!"
I won't say I know at much about them at I did Egos.
KetBra also played a lot of Phalla. Not as "old guard" as Egos, but pretty sure they've played for years? Close enough. Could be similar reasons to Egos, really.
I won't say I know at much about them at I did Egos.
KetBra also played a lot of Phalla. Not as "old guard" as Egos, but pretty sure they've played for years? Close enough. Could be similar reasons to Egos, really.
Or, it was day 1, a random shot?
Half this game is old guard, including you and I. I've been on a phalla break for a while, but if I was the SK I'd hit particularly analytic folk early in order to make my late game easier. Did KetBra have that reputation? Were they the recipient of any grudges from previous games?
BrodyThe WatchThe First ShoreRegistered Userregular
Honestly, even having played in I think every game for a while now, I can't even remember any grudges, so I don't expect the grudge search will turn much up. I think we are going to be better off combing for mafia and praying for a lucky seer hit.
"I will write your name in the ruin of them. I will paint you across history in the color of their blood."
My memory is basically always bad. It's sometimes fun to read through old Phalla threads and have absolutely no recollection of the things I said and did.
Also, remember that even if someone started with more Scares, they still couldn't use a gift last night. Gifts have to be given, you can't buy and use it yourself.
It's not impossible for people to have started with items though, or possibly for mafia to "give" and force the use of items
Sorry to hear it JPants, hope things work out alright.
Woof, bad results. At least that's one mafia down, but I have a feeling losing a blue-role isn't going to be anything good.
Thanks, one of those good news/bad news situations. Good news, no kitty lukemia or FIV. Bad news, new kitty has kidney failure. Had to take her in for IV fluids and more tests.
She's all settled at home now though, with her special Kidney food! I don't have any pics on my computer here but I'll try to post one later tonight from my phone. I've never seen a more emaciated kitty than when we found her. 2 days of us feeding her and she only weighed 5.4 lb at the vet. So sad
As for phalla, part of me wants to vote for Knuckles for the above. But then again maybe it's almost TOO much of a mafia-like post. My other thought was Bluecyan for being the other late voter besides KetBra. The thinking there being maybe the mafia get extra scares for being on a wagon that kills a villager with the vote, so they voted late to ensure it..... idk. Neither is very strong. Nor is anything else I've seen posted so far today....
Ok, all caught up. First of all: Austin deserves a gift, but as I don't yet have enough scares for a fun one, a vote will have to do.
Second of all, my (vague) recollection of KetBra is as a competent player who is vastly more dangerous once networked. Certainly a worthy victim, more so in a game with every likelihood of lots of early seerings & masons. I'm of the opinion that he'd be more likely a victim of a more seasoned player but if I'm being honest I'm not particularly stressed to find the SK any time soon. More valuable to work on the mafia since A) they are networked and hence more informative, they have fewer necessary victims, and C) the main beneficiary of a village attempt to root out the SK would be the mafia. If a seer happens upon the SK (which, given that we know there are mechanics to obscure alignment, I would think unlikely at the moment), sure, great, vote for them. But in the meantime I say let Santa have his fun.
Unless you're the mafia. You guys killing Santa would be just the sweetest. *wink*
Made a post to that effect in which I noted that "didn't get a PM" can also code as "lol totes village."
It's kind of crazy that merely BEING AWARE of the consequences of my explanation is enough to garner suspicion. Guess I should just be dumber in the future?
0
Options
lonelyahavaCall me Ahava ~~She/Her~~Move to New ZealandRegistered Userregular
CesareB
My vote reasoning is actually different.
Your post about the SK doing this or that and the other thing and we should just ignore the SK reads to me as a "oh god I"m the serial killer please don't pay attention to me".
And a Serial Killer is not the kind of Neutral we should be keeping around.
Posts
I think you mean Sandy Claws.
It'd be so perfect.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Egos is a crafty player, and one of the best at deducing things. If he wasn't a mafia kill them there's likely somebody in the group that finds Egos intimidating.
Which is fair enough, I'd say. Coming back into it from this long an absence I'd totally be intimidated.
So I'm thinking of somebody whose been around as long, if not longer.
! Romantic Undead
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
Egos appears to be a village kill, Preda was the mafia kill.
The Monster Baru Cormorant - Seth Dickinson
Steam: Korvalain
-! INCOMING BLATANT ATTEMPT TO APPEAR VILLAGE ALERT ALERT !-
Not having received a PM, I didn't realize that the game had started. My bad. I'll read over the thread when I get home.
Sorry I'm at work and catching glimpses between calls.
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
Suspicions are currently that Sandy Claws (Santa Claus) is the serial killer based on:
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
So who would want KetBra dead?
I won't say I know at much about them at I did Egos.
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
KetBra also played a lot of Phalla. Not as "old guard" as Egos, but pretty sure they've played for years? Close enough. Could be similar reasons to Egos, really.
Or, it was day 1, a random shot?
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Penny Arcade Rockstar Social Club / This is why I despise cyclists
My memory from before baby is bad, so I'm struggling to figure things out.
And doing this on a phone in between work isn't the easiest for analysis.
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
The Monster Baru Cormorant - Seth Dickinson
Steam: Korvalain
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
It's not impossible for people to have started with items though, or possibly for mafia to "give" and force the use of items
Thanks, one of those good news/bad news situations. Good news, no kitty lukemia or FIV. Bad news, new kitty has kidney failure. Had to take her in for IV fluids and more tests.
She's all settled at home now though, with her special Kidney food! I don't have any pics on my computer here but I'll try to post one later tonight from my phone. I've never seen a more emaciated kitty than when we found her. 2 days of us feeding her and she only weighed 5.4 lb at the vet. So sad
As for phalla, part of me wants to vote for Knuckles for the above. But then again maybe it's almost TOO much of a mafia-like post. My other thought was Bluecyan for being the other late voter besides KetBra. The thinking there being maybe the mafia get extra scares for being on a wagon that kills a villager with the vote, so they voted late to ensure it..... idk. Neither is very strong. Nor is anything else I've seen posted so far today....
Always happy to help!
Sorry about the kitty
Second of all, my (vague) recollection of KetBra is as a competent player who is vastly more dangerous once networked. Certainly a worthy victim, more so in a game with every likelihood of lots of early seerings & masons. I'm of the opinion that he'd be more likely a victim of a more seasoned player but if I'm being honest I'm not particularly stressed to find the SK any time soon. More valuable to work on the mafia since A) they are networked and hence more informative, they have fewer necessary victims, and C) the main beneficiary of a village attempt to root out the SK would be the mafia. If a seer happens upon the SK (which, given that we know there are mechanics to obscure alignment, I would think unlikely at the moment), sure, great, vote for them. But in the meantime I say let Santa have his fun.
Unless you're the mafia. You guys killing Santa would be just the sweetest. *wink*
Will try to check in to jump on the winning wagon see if anything else comes up.
The Monster Baru Cormorant - Seth Dickinson
Steam: Korvalain
I don't buy this, I'll be honest. CesareB
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Penny Arcade Rockstar Social Club / This is why I despise cyclists
Will hopefully be able to participate more tonight after taking the kids trick or treating!
CesareB is the closest thing to an actual reason.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Going to go with CesareB because I need to throw a vote down, they appear to be in the lead, and I'm apparently on the block for some reason.
I mean unless it's a double fakeout and they're trying to seem fake. Hmm...
Just to be clear, the reason is that:
A) I missed day 1.
Made a post to that effect in which I noted that "didn't get a PM" can also code as "lol totes village."
It's kind of crazy that merely BEING AWARE of the consequences of my explanation is enough to garner suspicion. Guess I should just be dumber in the future?
My vote reasoning is actually different.
Your post about the SK doing this or that and the other thing and we should just ignore the SK reads to me as a "oh god I"m the serial killer please don't pay attention to me".
And a Serial Killer is not the kind of Neutral we should be keeping around.
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
But remember, in Phalla everything is suspicious
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
I don't actually think Cesare's suspicious, but it looks like that ship has already sailed and I want more Scares!
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
Cesare: Et tu, Brute?