The good, the bad and [The Mandalorian] OPEN SPOILERS

Harry Dresden · November 2019

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XmI7WKrAtqs

Star Was first tv series debuts this week on Disney+.

Here's the panel from D23.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GrlTosbjylA

EriktheVikingGamer · November 2019

Show was hype. Looking forward to more. Especially more stuff having to do with Mandalorian culture. I remember a fair amount of the EU stuff and am interested in seeing what they decide to make canon and what new stuff they decide to add.

King Riptor · November 2019

So the end

The doctor and the species of the baby make me think this is a clone of Yoda that they didnt want to accelerate aging on

The Zombie Penguin · November 2019

King Riptor wrote: »

So the end
The doctor and the species of the baby make me think this is a clone of Yoda that they didnt want to accelerate aging on

I really hope not, personally - I'd love to actually have more on that species rather than... well.

But yeah, that was hypee as Erik said!

Athenor · November 2019

King Riptor wrote: »

So the end
The doctor and the species of the baby make me think this is a clone of Yoda that they didnt want to accelerate aging on

I don't think so. Not exactly.

If the baby is 50 years old, that would put its birth before the clone wars no matter how things were sliced. I can't tell how far after the fall of the Empire it is set, but even then...

Still, who wouldn't want to get ahold of their own Yoda?

This show was so damned hype. I loved the puppetwork, the side characters, the world building... about the only things that really stood out to me was the blue guy at the beginning's manner of talking compared to what I'm used to, and a bit of CGI about midway through that seemed to have a soap opera effect for me.

thatassemblyguy · November 2019

Watched the first episode - It's good, but not great. Could wait for a couple more weeks to get a few episode backlog built up and then watch it all the way through.

S1E1 Spoiler:

I'm a bit biased but writing off Taika Waititi voiced droid is poor form. POOR FORM!

Cristoval · November 2019

I mean, the Droid is on the poster, I'm sure he'll be back!

Loved it as well. Started pretty slow but ended super strong. They also made Life Day canon so yes bring in more weird Lucas Star Wars shit.

Diplominator · November 2019

I will be interested to see how much of Filoni's prior stuff makes it in. Maybe we'll see Sabine.

Maybe we've already seen Sabine.

Elvenshae · November 2019

@thatassemblyguy

I mean ...

S1E1 spoiler:

He's a droid. They come off ... heh heh ... assembly lines. Pretty sure him or someone like him will be back.

King Riptor · November 2019

Diplominator wrote: »

I will be interested to see how much of Filoni's prior stuff makes it in. Maybe we'll see Sabine.
Maybe we've already seen Sabine.

That would be pretty boss

HappylilElf · November 2019

So I've actually liked both of the ST films so far but this I loved.

Like I've enjoyed the ST films but they haven't really felt like sequels to the OT to me. They feel more like a reboot of the OT for a new generation (which is fine).

Episode 1 of this show though? This actually feels like it's taking place after Return of the Jedi in a way that I just don't think The Force Awakens ever will for me.

And they did it in a single episode.

Capt Howdy · November 2019

ObiFett wrote: »

Doctor Detroit wrote: »

Mandalorian thoughts
So we're dealing with at least three factions.
The people who were guarding the infant.
Herzog's crew: "alive or proof of death."
Iggy's client wanted it dead.

if the baby is a good guy, then the group guarding the baby were good guys, and we just watched the mandalorian wreck a whole barracks of good guys

Thats not necessarily true,

Prisoners have people guarding them, too.

Marathon · November 2019

Can someone explain if/why

forging that slab of metal into some armor

Is significant.

Because it seems neat, but is also confusing.

ChaosHat · November 2019

Marathon wrote: »

Can someone explain if/why
forging that slab of metal into some armor
Is significant.

Because it seems neat, but is also confusing.

Seemed like a rite of passage. I'm guessing they get their armor forged out of the super precious metal as they earn it.

King Riptor · November 2019

Marathon wrote: »

Can someone explain if/why
forging that slab of metal into some armor
Is significant.

Because it seems neat, but is also confusing.

I believe

Mandos gain armor parts as sort of a right of passage so our Mandoloarian got the metal so a child could get a new peice of armor

Elvenshae · November 2019

@Marathon

Just from the show ...

When the Mando shows up in the first bar, the thugs come up to him and ask if he’s wearing “real Beskar steel” armor.

The Fallen Imp who hires him offers the ingot of Beskar as up-front payment, saying that it was stolen from his people and belongs back with them - along with all the rest of the truckload of Beskar he’d get for completing the contract. That’s enough to convince someone willing to take a 50% pay cut to not get Imperial credits to work for an Imp.

Then, of course, it gets made into a piece of armor for him and the unused portion will be enough to support multiple people.

So, big deal.

Out of show ...

Beskar is THE Mandolorian material. It’s known to be partially resistant to lightsabers. It fits kind of in the Damascus steel realm - semi-mythical, hard to make, amazing properties. I think that its creation is either spectacularly difficult or possibly lost at the moment, so that reforging is possible but nothing new can be made.

Marathon · November 2019

Elvenshae wrote: »

@Marathon

Just from the show ...
When the Mando shows up in the first bar, the thugs come up to him and ask if he’s wearing “real Beskar steel” armor.

The Fallen Imp who hires him offers the ingot of Beskar as up-front payment, saying that it was stolen from his people and belongs back with them - along with all the rest of the truckload of Beskar he’d get for completing the contract. That’s enough to convince someone willing to take a 50% pay cut to not get Imperial credits to work for an Imp.

Then, of course, it gets made into a piece of armor for him and the unused portion will be enough to support multiple people.

So, big deal.

Out of show ...
Beskar is THE Mandolorian material. It’s known to be partially resistant to lightsabers. It fits kind of in the Damascus steel realm - semi-mythical, hard to make, amazing properties. I think that its creation is either spectacularly difficult or possibly lost at the moment, so that reforging is possible but nothing new can be made.

Good to know, thank you. I missed that bit of dialogue during the show and then I didn’t know the details from the cannon.

Doctor Detroit · November 2019

One detail I would have liked: there were 3 planets in this episode and I don't think any of them were identified.

King Riptor · November 2019

Doctor Detroit wrote: »

One detail I would have liked: there were 3 planets in this episode and I don't think any of them were identified.

Hoth lite , sweaty world and Tatwoine

Doctor Detroit · November 2019

So my sister, who likes to frequent gossip sites, sends me this yesterday morning:

Again, that was sent to me before noon, before she even knew if I had watched it.

Gonna have to send the Mandalorian after her...

Ninjeff · November 2019

Doctor Detroit wrote: »

So my sister, who likes to frequent gossip sites, sends me this yesterday morning:

Again, that was sent to me before noon, before she even knew if I had watched it.

Gonna have to send the Mandalorian after her...

That is unforgivable.

MegaMan001 · November 2019

Clickbait websites goddamn man, no decency at all.

Oakey · November 2019

I liked it, looked great. Kinda concerned that there's only around 35 mins of actual show before the credits roll. You'd think with everything at Disney's disposal they could have made the episodes 45mins or even 60mins long?

At this length it kinda feels they're still stuck in that made for TV mindset and leaving room for commercial breaks.

Preacher · November 2019

I liked that it was only 40 minutes, meant the episode was lean and mean. And commercial breaks, chapter breaks, whatever are in pretty much every show, people need time to breathe.

Athenor · November 2019

Preacher wrote: »

I liked that it was only 40 minutes, meant the episode was lean and mean. And commercial breaks, chapter breaks, whatever are in pretty much every show, people need time to breathe.

It's a good idea to build it as if you were going to air it on commercially supported TV.

Preacher · November 2019

Athenor wrote: »

Preacher wrote: »

I liked that it was only 40 minutes, meant the episode was lean and mean. And commercial breaks, chapter breaks, whatever are in pretty much every show, people need time to breathe.

It's a good idea to build it as if you were going to air it on commercially supported TV.

Pretty much all the streaming shows I've seen have spots for where a traditional commercial break would be.

Doctor Detroit · November 2019

I'd rather they not try and pad out the runtime (minutes or episodes) to hit some artificial target.

Ninjeff · November 2019

Doctor Detroit wrote: »

I'd rather they not try and pad out the runtime (minutes or episodes) to hit some artificial target.

Agreed, although i wouldnt have complained about 2 or 3 additional minutes of armor stuff. A little bit more on the blacksmithing, a bit more on fitment, etc really make it a ceremonial thing.

Al_wat · November 2019

I thought at first that I would want a longer run time but honestly it felt just right. The episode didn't feel padded and didn't feel rushed. Hopefully the following episodes will be the same

Ninjeff · November 2019

I loved it so much i'm really contemplating waiting the rest of the episodes out so i can just mainline the whole season and immerse myself into the world like a kid.
I really dont want spoilers though....

mcp · November 2019

MegaMan001 wrote: »

Clickbait websites goddamn man, no decency at all.

My Google news feed on my phone had a

baby yoda

headline in the middle of the day, so I knew what was coming. Annoying.

Kana · November 2019

Apparently ep 1 is the shortest one

Igpx407 · November 2019

Is this the first we’ve seen of those tracking fabs? It seems weird there’s a personalized device to lead a bounty hunter to the general location of their bounty.

Preacher · November 2019

I was a big fan of there being humor, even humor from the protagonist in the episode. If the main character was a mostly joyless faceless person I think I'd get bored right away. But thank god that's not the case.

ChaosHat · November 2019

Igpx407 wrote: »

Is this the first we’ve seen of those tracking fabs? It seems weird there’s a personalized device to lead a bounty hunter to the general location of their bounty.

Well obviously before you commit a crime you have to register that crime with the Guild of Thieves and Scalawags and then they work with the Bounty Hunter's Guild to provide the tracking fobs. When the thief is brought to justice and the stolen goods returned to the rightful owner, another thief can steal those goods. In this way, the circle of scum continues and everyone remains employed.

ObiFett · November 2019

Igpx407 wrote: »

Is this the first we’ve seen of those tracking fabs? It seems weird there’s a personalized device to lead a bounty hunter to the general location of their bounty.

Yeah, that was the one piece of tech I was disappointed in. I wanted to have scenes of him tracking his bounty. Hopefully they explain it at some point, because it seems odd that it can even exist, tbh.

Preacher · November 2019

The initial bounties were bail jumpers I thought? So the tracking fobs would be something they agreed to have when they accepted bail and when they ran could then be tracked.

ObiFett · November 2019

Re: Tracking Fobs

I'm guessing they've decided to split up the tracking part of being a bounty hunter to a separate role within the guild. I'm guessing it goes like this:

- Someone puts a bounty on a person's head
- Guild sends a tracker who finds them and places a tracking device on them
- The tracking fob is sent back to the guild at which point the puck becomes available for hunting.

ObiFett · November 2019

Preacher wrote: »

The initial bounties were bail jumpers I thought? So the tracking fobs would be something they agreed to have when they accepted bail and when they ran could then be tracked.

The baby Yoda jumped bail?

Preacher · November 2019

ObiFett wrote: »

Preacher wrote: »

The initial bounties were bail jumpers I thought? So the tracking fobs would be something they agreed to have when they accepted bail and when they ran could then be tracked.

The baby Yoda jumped bail?

You don't know maybe it did Obi. MAYBE IT DID!

Capt Howdy · November 2019

ObiFett wrote: »

Preacher wrote: »

The initial bounties were bail jumpers I thought? So the tracking fobs would be something they agreed to have when they accepted bail and when they ran could then be tracked.

The baby Yoda jumped bail?

50 year olds can't jump bail? 50 isn't that old, Obi.

Penny Arcade

Quick Links

The good, the bad and [The Mandalorian] OPEN SPOILERS

Posts