A part of me feels like H3K and GG may both be mafia. They are barely interacting with each other (I went through each other's posts where one mentions the other), even now with both of them leading 1st and 2nd in bandwagons, which is weird to me. Neither really putting any logic forward against the other, except a comment by H3K a couple of days (?) ago (or maybe it was today) asking why he is suspicious and not GG. Then Locus shows up talking about making it not a close vote. Misdirection? I dunno.
Switch: SW-7690-2320-9238Steam/PSN/Xbox: Drezdar
0
Options
MamaWolfThe wolf pack guides all to safetyRegistered Userregular
Day 6 is over. Votes closed.
"May the moon watch over you and keep you safe through the night, 'till the morning comes and MamaWolf can protect you through the day"
A part of me feels like H3K and GG may both be mafia. They are barely interacting with each other (I went through each other's posts where one mentions the other), even now with both of them leading 1st and 2nd in bandwagons, which is weird to me. Neither really putting any logic forward against the other, except a comment by H3K a couple of days (?) ago (or maybe it was today) asking why he is suspicious and not GG. Then Locus shows up talking about making it not a close vote. Misdirection? I dunno.
This has a bunch of errors.
I made that post today. The first two votes against me were LN and Obi, on the basis that I had voted for Obi rather than jdark the previous day. Yet they (or at least Obi) accepted GG's reasoning as innocent for why he had also voted Obi the previous day. But they were the same reasons I had given in the thread, so I was challenging the logic of voting against me.
I repeatedly mentioned that GG has been low activity in the thread so far, and that plus self-preservation are why I ended up voting against him.
GG originally said they didn't like the wagon against me, then joined it out of self-preservation, then switched to finger Erin when it became a lost cause.
OK sorry I did search specifically for "Grunt's Ghosts" and not "GG" which is an abbreviation I see you using here, so I may have missed something there. Apologies.
As for whose side I'm on, I'm on the side of the Truth.
Switch: SW-7690-2320-9238Steam/PSN/Xbox: Drezdar
0
Options
ObiFettUse the ForceAs You WishRegistered Userregular
For the record, H3, I voted for you because of where you were on the obi train yesterday and the nature of your posts. They were much more suspicious than GG
MamaWolfThe wolf pack guides all to safetyRegistered Userregular
Day 7: Death of a courageous coward!
After a week of nearly no progress on rooting out Imhotep and his followers, one the undead at last slips up. A particularly inebriated Jonathan Carnahan (OBIFETT) stumbled into what he believed was his own tent, only to come face-to-face with a mummified horror. The monster quickly moved to silence Jonathan, but with his dying breath the man was able to call for help. A mob quickly surrounded the mummy priest (GRUNT'S GHOST) and with an impressive volley of gunfire and scimitar swings, managed to put down the undead for good. Morale now at a high point for the first time in days, the desiccated remains of the mummy were paraded through the camp.
The deceased: Jonathan Carnahan (OBIFETT) - Death by death (GRUNT'S GHOST)- Brutal force
"May the moon watch over you and keep you safe through the night, 'till the morning comes and MamaWolf can protect you through the day"
+1
Options
H3KnucklesBut we decide which is rightand which is an illusion.Registered Userregular
Our two day curse people still aren’t dead. Does anyone claim curing Drez or Erin?
For the record GG store my cure two nights ago after I told Erin I had it. They confessed to it yesterday though which had me leaning village for them because why would the mafia confess to that? Unless it was because I immediately started to suspect Erin
LostNinja on
+1
Options
H3KnucklesBut we decide which is rightand which is an illusion.Registered Userregular
Actually, scratch that. I'm expendable, someone stole the only thing important I had.
Heads up everyone! Stealing one of the items gave me a curse, Obi thinks each of the items are what curse people, so the mafia can track their movements.
Erin the Red (2) - LostNinja (2nd), kime (9th), Grunt's Ghosts (19th)
Auralynx (1) - premium (5th)
Drez (0) - Bluecyan (1st)
LostNinja (0) - Erin the Red (3rd)
premium (0) - H3Knuckles (10th)
Huh, weird how it worked out so that all three players who had all votes against them redacted are in both alphabetical order, and order of when the vote against them was made.
So, given Erin's placement in voting for GG, I'm leaning towards her having been village, but not being dead makes me fear she's been converted, unless someone cured her (PM me instead of publicly announcing it).
H3KnucklesBut we decide which is rightand which is an illusion.Registered Userregular
edited December 2019
Just to reiterate, I'm still cursed (2nd day now), my PM says I haven't got much time if it isn't cured. If you want to cure me, that would be very much appreciated, but other people might be a higher priority than me (since I'm now empty-handed). Still, I suppose I could be cured tonight, and them tomorrow night, since it takes a few days for the effects to kick in.
We need a network head, but since we don't seem to have reliable guards, I'm not sure how to work that out.
I'll come out and say that I've got day 2 of a plague there isnt a day 3 for and that I've got no powers and am a villager. My voting hasn't been the best, so I'm not a super reliable source of insight
I'll come out and say that I've got day 2 of a plague there isnt a day 3 for and that I've got no powers and am a villager. My voting hasn't been the best, so I'm not a super reliable source of insight
Erin, why aren’t you dead?
Frankly I'm as surprised as you are. I guess GG saying that I WAS gonna get cured but not after I voted for him was enough to get someone to use a cure on me?
Shit I hope they're not rare. I'd say they should have saved it for a special but we kinda need all hands on deck, eh?
ANYWAY my vote today is for H3 mostly because GG vouched for you and then y'all both kinda jumped on each other immediately and that felt weird to me? Most of this has been gut feels but frankly at this point you all seem suspicious as hell to me.
I'm surprised kime is still alive and bluecyan still feels off to me for reasons I can't put my finger on.
I'm not feeling especially swayed by any of the vote targets so far today, so a preliminary vote for Bluecyan again. I'm still finding him very suspicious.
I'll come out and say that I've got day 2 of a plague there isnt a day 3 for and that I've got no powers and am a villager. My voting hasn't been the best, so I'm not a super reliable source of insight
Erin, why aren’t you dead?
Frankly I'm as surprised as you are. I guess GG saying that I WAS gonna get cured but not after I voted for him was enough to get someone to use a cure on me?
Shit I hope they're not rare. I'd say they should have saved it for a special but we kinda need all hands on deck, eh?
ANYWAY my vote today is for H3 mostly because GG vouched for you and then y'all both kinda jumped on each other immediately and that felt weird to me? Most of this has been gut feels but frankly at this point you all seem suspicious as hell to me.
I'm surprised kime is still alive and bluecyan still feels off to me for reasons I can't put my finger on.
So, I think it's time that people start publicly sharing their thoughts on each other and what they have been up to.
We're limited on people, and no seer means no one is confirmed. I'd like to think that my starting of the GG wagon puts me in a good place to at least have earned a small amount of trust here.
Erin - Need to understand why you aren't dead. That's a pretty big red flag
Kime - You've been really quite, and vote record is a little all over the place (mostly seeming to avoid wagons)
Drez - the word I'd use with most of your actions seems to be random. That is a little troubling, if I'm being honest.
Auralynx - I'm not sure, honestly. Nothing too suspicious jumps out, which in itself seems a little suspicious.
BlueCyan - not sure why people are jumping all over Blue, so far he's reading villager and pretty active
H3 - Replacement, but I'm getting the villager H3 vibe from the detailed analysis and basically the fact that he's resigned to death today without a cure
LostNinja - Not too sure. I need to look at votes more, but started off really quiet and has gotten louder as the game goes on (not necessarily a bad thing)
premium - super quiet. I don't have a read at all, honestly.
Locus - Hi Mummy dude.
I'd encourage everyone else to start dropping info and discussing, or even refuting my stuff above, but we need some real convos going here now that the game is getting close to the potential end.
Hey, I have the key. If anyone has either book (life preferred) please let me know so I can give it to you.
I would ask if anyone is planning on stealing run it by me so that we don't end up getting these things separated again.
Erin/Drez - May be a conversion or the curses are a bit of a red herring, but probably best to find out what is going on there.
Kime - Been very much on the sideline, voting early then letting things play out. Seemed suspicious early on but kept the routine during the last few nights.
Auralynx - Has been very active with the whole key/book hunt, though the jump from Jdark to Obi is still weird
Bluecyan - seems very suspicious, maybe not mafia but we should probably kill them anyways
H3 - Same list of suspicious that GG had, the sudden bandwagoning of GG might have been a mafia call to not look suspicious. Though the cursed thing may take precedence depending.
LostNinja - Very responsible for the Jdark kill, seems legit, has tried to cure people
premium - Wait, they're in this game? Very quiet...
Burnage - Either they lied about being cursed or they are village. Strikes me as vilalge
Austin - Also a cured cursed person, very active in the key/book realm
There, that's every living person, didn't miss anyone important.
Auralynx - 100% grade-A mafia.
Austin - Definitely mafia.
Bluecyan - Oh, they're a mafia alright.
Burnage - On a scale of 1 to 10, 1 being village and 10 being mafia, they are a 10.
Drez - In the history of phalla, has there ever been a player more likely to be mafia? I say to thee, "No."
Erin - Mafia AF.
H3Knuckles - They're my MVM (Most Valuable Mummy).
kime - Villager.
LostNinja - If you looked up "mafia" in the dictionary, you would probably get a definition having absolutely nothing to do with phalla. BUT, if we had our own phalla dictionary, and if you looked up "mafia" in THAT dictionary, you would find a picture of LostNinja.
premium - That's So Mafia.
I've been going through the thread and I actually want to point some suspicion on Premium.
First point: He's been very, very quiet this game. Plenty of us have commented that it's been difficult to get a read on him because of this.
Second point: He tried to subtly encourage us to vote for Locus again. I think that at this point we can be pretty confident that Locus is immortal until we finish fucking around with the book and the key, so this feels like the sort of push a mafia member might give.
Third point: Literally a last minute vote on jdark, the kind that a mafioso might give when they want to bump up their voting record and know they can't change the bandwagon.
None of these are a slam dunk, but they do add up to being suspicious as hell. We're clawing things back but we still can't afford for a mafioso barely skirting inactivity to slip under our rader.
I've been going through the thread and I actually want to point some suspicion on Premium.
Second point: He tried to subtly encourage us to vote for Locus again. I think that at this point we can be pretty confident that Locus is immortal until we finish fucking around with the book and the key, so this feels like the sort of push a mafia member might give.
To be fair, I did this too. I just want to have that out in the open. But yeah, he's been real quiet.
I wish I had more reasoning or info for y'all on my end of stuff. Someone saved me from dying. Hooray? Guess I'll die for it today probably but yeah I agree it's suspicious as hell. Sorry for living? I guess?
Posts
This has a bunch of errors.
I made that post today. The first two votes against me were LN and Obi, on the basis that I had voted for Obi rather than jdark the previous day. Yet they (or at least Obi) accepted GG's reasoning as innocent for why he had also voted Obi the previous day. But they were the same reasons I had given in the thread, so I was challenging the logic of voting against me.
I repeatedly mentioned that GG has been low activity in the thread so far, and that plus self-preservation are why I ended up voting against him.
GG originally said they didn't like the wagon against me, then joined it out of self-preservation, then switched to finger Erin when it became a lost cause.
Locus said exactly the opposite:
Whose side are you on, Drez?
As for whose side I'm on, I'm on the side of the Truth.
After a week of nearly no progress on rooting out Imhotep and his followers, one the undead at last slips up. A particularly inebriated Jonathan Carnahan (OBIFETT) stumbled into what he believed was his own tent, only to come face-to-face with a mummified horror. The monster quickly moved to silence Jonathan, but with his dying breath the man was able to call for help. A mob quickly surrounded the mummy priest (GRUNT'S GHOST) and with an impressive volley of gunfire and scimitar swings, managed to put down the undead for good. Morale now at a high point for the first time in days, the desiccated remains of the mummy were paraded through the camp.
The deceased:
Jonathan Carnahan (OBIFETT) - Death by death
(GRUNT'S GHOST)- Brutal force
Please, please, please someone have a cure for me.
For the record GG store my cure two nights ago after I told Erin I had it. They confessed to it yesterday though which had me leaning village for them because why would the mafia confess to that? Unless it was because I immediately started to suspect Erin
Heads up everyone! Stealing one of the items gave me a curse, Obi thinks each of the items are what curse people, so the mafia can track their movements.
So, given Erin's placement in voting for GG, I'm leaning towards her having been village, but not being dead makes me fear she's been converted, unless someone cured her (PM me instead of publicly announcing it).
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
We need a network head, but since we don't seem to have reliable guards, I'm not sure how to work that out.
Drez
Austin
Bluecyan
Auralynx
Locus
Lostninja
premium
Erin
Burnage
That's not a vote for Locus, I just didn't want anyone to forget that he's an evil mummy while I posted a list for reference.
It seems like a safe bet he has at least one more minion of some kind.
E: And I forgot to close the tag properly, to cap it off, so it really doesn't count.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Erin, why aren’t you dead?
Frankly I'm as surprised as you are. I guess GG saying that I WAS gonna get cured but not after I voted for him was enough to get someone to use a cure on me?
Shit I hope they're not rare. I'd say they should have saved it for a special but we kinda need all hands on deck, eh?
ANYWAY my vote today is for H3 mostly because GG vouched for you and then y'all both kinda jumped on each other immediately and that felt weird to me? Most of this has been gut feels but frankly at this point you all seem suspicious as hell to me.
I'm surprised kime is still alive and bluecyan still feels off to me for reasons I can't put my finger on.
Real proud moment for me there. I blame trying not to disturb my wife.
I get that a lot, even outside if phallas too...
We're limited on people, and no seer means no one is confirmed. I'd like to think that my starting of the GG wagon puts me in a good place to at least have earned a small amount of trust here.
Erin - Need to understand why you aren't dead. That's a pretty big red flag
Kime - You've been really quite, and vote record is a little all over the place (mostly seeming to avoid wagons)
Drez - the word I'd use with most of your actions seems to be random. That is a little troubling, if I'm being honest.
Auralynx - I'm not sure, honestly. Nothing too suspicious jumps out, which in itself seems a little suspicious.
BlueCyan - not sure why people are jumping all over Blue, so far he's reading villager and pretty active
H3 - Replacement, but I'm getting the villager H3 vibe from the detailed analysis and basically the fact that he's resigned to death today without a cure
LostNinja - Not too sure. I need to look at votes more, but started off really quiet and has gotten louder as the game goes on (not necessarily a bad thing)
premium - super quiet. I don't have a read at all, honestly.
Locus - Hi Mummy dude.
I'd encourage everyone else to start dropping info and discussing, or even refuting my stuff above, but we need some real convos going here now that the game is getting close to the potential end.
Poor @Burnage!
I would ask if anyone is planning on stealing run it by me so that we don't end up getting these things separated again.
Erin/Drez - May be a conversion or the curses are a bit of a red herring, but probably best to find out what is going on there.
Kime - Been very much on the sideline, voting early then letting things play out. Seemed suspicious early on but kept the routine during the last few nights.
Auralynx - Has been very active with the whole key/book hunt, though the jump from Jdark to Obi is still weird
Bluecyan - seems very suspicious, maybe not mafia but we should probably kill them anyways
H3 - Same list of suspicious that GG had, the sudden bandwagoning of GG might have been a mafia call to not look suspicious. Though the cursed thing may take precedence depending.
LostNinja - Very responsible for the Jdark kill, seems legit, has tried to cure people
premium - Wait, they're in this game? Very quiet...
Burnage - Either they lied about being cursed or they are village. Strikes me as vilalge
Austin - Also a cured cursed person, very active in the key/book realm
There, that's every living person, didn't miss anyone important.
Locus - Mafia, obvi.
Auralynx - 100% grade-A mafia.
Austin - Definitely mafia.
Bluecyan - Oh, they're a mafia alright.
Burnage - On a scale of 1 to 10, 1 being village and 10 being mafia, they are a 10.
Drez - In the history of phalla, has there ever been a player more likely to be mafia? I say to thee, "No."
Erin - Mafia AF.
H3Knuckles - They're my MVM (Most Valuable Mummy).
kime - Villager.
LostNinja - If you looked up "mafia" in the dictionary, you would probably get a definition having absolutely nothing to do with phalla. BUT, if we had our own phalla dictionary, and if you looked up "mafia" in THAT dictionary, you would find a picture of LostNinja.
premium - That's So Mafia.
Oh damnit all. I was staring at the list above when I typed mine out so I really have no idea how I missed someone.
Burnage - don’t have a ton here. Seems like decent vote records but not getting much outside that
First point: He's been very, very quiet this game. Plenty of us have commented that it's been difficult to get a read on him because of this.
Second point: He tried to subtly encourage us to vote for Locus again. I think that at this point we can be pretty confident that Locus is immortal until we finish fucking around with the book and the key, so this feels like the sort of push a mafia member might give.
Third point: Literally a last minute vote on jdark, the kind that a mafioso might give when they want to bump up their voting record and know they can't change the bandwagon.
None of these are a slam dunk, but they do add up to being suspicious as hell. We're clawing things back but we still can't afford for a mafioso barely skirting inactivity to slip under our rader.
Erin - 2
H3 - 2
premium - 1
Drez - 1
Need to know if curse is conversation, BS, or maybe you were just lying.
I had a curse, I was cured, now I don't! It's simple ancient Egyptian science.
To be fair, I did this too. I just want to have that out in the open. But yeah, he's been real quiet.
I wish I had more reasoning or info for y'all on my end of stuff. Someone saved me from dying. Hooray? Guess I'll die for it today probably but yeah I agree it's suspicious as hell. Sorry for living? I guess?
So, if you cured Erin, speak up. There's only a limited number of us left, so it should be pretty simple for someone to claim the cure.
Not me!
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
I'm going with Erin for a) yesterday's reason of being mostly quiet, and also being alive today :P
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile