Blaming Tony for everything is getting pretty old. I mean, the Invasion would've happened regardless of what he did, and Janet was probably going to die no matter what.
he woke up to find his wife dead
that captain america is dead
you think the dude is going to be objective about this?
No, he's in grief and he's going to want to blame someone. Tony Stark is the easiest target for that.
I mean, I sort of blame Tony for Cap's death, even though I objectively know it's really the Skull's doing. People aren't rational IRL, I don't expect them to be rational in fiction.
Really, Cap's death was so simply pulled off it could've been done at pretty much any time, even if CW had never happened. He didn't have his shield at the time, that was pretty much the only effect it had on the situation.
Scooter on
0
Options
JacobkoshGamble a stamp.I can show you how to be a real man!Moderatormod
Interviews with Ron Moore say otherwise - they had no idea where they were going with the show, or if it would even be renewed, post "Kobol part 2".
Note that I'm not saying this is a bad thing - in my mind, it's a good thing for storylines to be fluid. I just think it's sort of silly for folks to jump on the BND Spider-Man creators for 'not having a plan', when you wouldn't really hold those standards to anything else.
I hold the Galactica dudes to that standard, since I feel like their not having a plan has really hurt the show. Plot hints and mysterious prophecies stop being tantalizing when you look behind the curtain and realize that the dudes writing the story are straight-up winging it.
I think that the lack of a plan has also held back a lot of otherwise-good monthly comics. Writers back in the day used to think six or eight or sometimes even twelve issues in advance, and it made the stories more compelling and resonant. Now it's remarkable for a writer to even last on a title that long.
Blaming Tony for everything is getting pretty old. I mean, the Invasion would've happened regardless of what he did, and Janet was probably going to die no matter what.
he woke up to find his wife dead
that captain america is dead
you think the dude is going to be objective about this?
No, he's in grief and he's going to want to blame someone. Tony Stark is the easiest target for that.
I mean, I sort of blame Tony for Cap's death, even though I objectively know it's really the Skull's doing. People aren't rational IRL, I don't expect them to be rational in fiction.
speaking of which, did he ever say that he would have supported the registration act?
Really, Cap's death was so simply pulled off it could've been done at pretty much any time, even if CW had never happened. He didn't have his shield at the time, that was pretty much the only effect it had on the situation.
His Shield wouldn't have saved him because it wasn't the sniper shot that killed him
Posts
that captain america is dead
you think the dude is going to be objective about this?
No, he's in grief and he's going to want to blame someone. Tony Stark is the easiest target for that.
I mean, I sort of blame Tony for Cap's death, even though I objectively know it's really the Skull's doing. People aren't rational IRL, I don't expect them to be rational in fiction.
I hold the Galactica dudes to that standard, since I feel like their not having a plan has really hurt the show. Plot hints and mysterious prophecies stop being tantalizing when you look behind the curtain and realize that the dudes writing the story are straight-up winging it.
I think that the lack of a plan has also held back a lot of otherwise-good monthly comics. Writers back in the day used to think six or eight or sometimes even twelve issues in advance, and it made the stories more compelling and resonant. Now it's remarkable for a writer to even last on a title that long.
speaking of which, did he ever say that he would have supported the registration act?
His Shield wouldn't have saved him because it wasn't the sniper shot that killed him
Being shot point blank two or three times by