So a quick overview of how things worked before I go to bed.
There were 12 divisions, the three powers a division could have was either seering, guarding or vigilante. There were 4 divisions of each power. So each day 3 divisions were called, so one had the seer power, one had guardian and one had vigilante.
The normal actual specials were the ryoka;
Ichigo Kurosaki = vigilante
Yourichi = seer
Orihime Inoue = guardian
Uryu Ishida = mason
Ganju Shiba = mason
Yastora Sado = mason
Kukaku Shiba = vigilante (except captains were immune)
There were 12 bad guys, 3 captains, 3 lieutenants and 6 normal badguys, there was one bad guy in each division. So the bad guys had some control of the division powers.
When he kept doing all the big posts and seemed to try and keep things on track at the beginning of the days, I was pretty sure jdark was evil. Of course, by that point I was dead, so it didn't really matter.
Is the game over? Because some people are going to go on my shit list.
Everyone needs a grudge list like mine.
Well, I'm not talking about grudges here. I'm talking about major characters who are bloody inactive. It's lovely being a no-name guard for Rukia when Rukia can't even be bothered to play the game.
Also, you guys should have figured out that Durax was a badguy since I died on day 2.
I will also say that it was so sad to see both the vigilantes and outspoken players get killed in one night, then one baddie takes over the network and completely decimates the village the next day.
Especially since it happened right when I thought the village might be able to pull through.
When he kept doing all the big posts and seemed to try and keep things on track at the beginning of the days, I was pretty sure jdark was evil. Of course, by that point I was dead, so it didn't really matter.
With the vacuum of power/loss of a village voice (ardor) it did seem like an opportune time for an evil to step up to the plate ; especially if they hadn't taken drastic losses (which it didn't seem like they did).
Egos on
0
Options
cj iwakuraThe Rhythm RegentBears The Name FreedomRegistered Userregular
The only person I ever trusted was Law, which was why I didn't forward any of his info on to anyone.
Thanks for running this Sabs.
I think in the future, giving the bad guys so much control over kills plus killing off inactives makes the game severely imbalanced against the larger faction, that being the good guys. I mean, how many captains were evil? The seer who could deceive people (Jdark) and whatever power Ventroue had, that meant they had a power every other night unless someone killed them.
EDIT: 3 evil captains. 3 powers which was roughly one per night as long as they lived and as one of the two good guy vigs, I couldn't even kill them? Heh.
The only person I ever trusted was Law, which was why I didn't forward any of his info on to anyone.
Thanks for running this Sabs.
I think in the future, giving the bad guys so much control over kills plus killing off inactives makes the game severely imbalanced against the larger faction, that being the good guys. I mean, how many captains were evil? The seer who could deceive people (Jdark) and whatever power Ventroue had, that meant they had a power every other night unless someone killed them.
There were 3 evil captains. If half the specials weren't inactive it would have been a closer game. And I was close to killing off a badguy or two from inactivity but they started posting soooo.
There was something in the voting patterns I saw that the goodguys could have found most of the badguys (it worked far better than I even realized when I noticed, I thought it would only turn up 2 or so rather than the bulk of them), but no one caught on to it. I'm reluctant to mention what it was, since I don't want badguy groups to be wise to it for the future. The other badguy group in the FMA phalla made the same mistake and we wiped them out largely due to it.
I didn't trust you jdarksun because nobody could verify anyone else.
Dude, anyone could have been evil. Law was the only person killing bad guys. I gave a lot of info to law I didn't give to you.
Just because you could seer didn't make you good. We had nobody we could trust. He wanted to keep the captains alive because they were following his order but we had been killing good guys the whole game, which is why I pushed to kill Vertroue, having failed an attack on her before.
I do take some satisfaction that my final list with percentage chances were only wrong due to thinking Verr was ok due to having 3 dead division 2 guys already probably meant we weren't going to find a 4th. All my other guesses weren't half bad.
I just wish people used the resources available to them is all.
Also, like I was saying you really shouldn't have trusted captains. Given the source material it was almost given that some of them were going to be badguys.
The only person I ever trusted was Law, which was why I didn't forward any of his info on to anyone.
Thanks for running this Sabs.
I think in the future, giving the bad guys so much control over kills plus killing off inactives makes the game severely imbalanced against the larger faction, that being the good guys. I mean, how many captains were evil? The seer who could deceive people (Jdark) and whatever power Ventroue had, that meant they had a power every other night unless someone killed them.
There were 3 evil captains. If half the specials weren't inactive it would have been a closer game. And I was close to killing off a badguy or two from inactivity but they started posting soooo.
Basically there were no guardians in this game.
What powers did they control though? Seering was one. Did they also have a guard and a vigilante?
The old rule of thumb I heard about long ago was 15% bad guys and for every kill the village has, add another bad guy.
So if the bad guys had control over the same powers as the village plus their 2 kills as a large masoned group, how exactly where the odds with us?
I mean, one can state there were 2 vigs, 2 bad guys kills, vote and like 3 division kills a night, but if the bad guys controlled a division, it was 3 bad guy kills and 4 good guy kills plus the vote.
I didn't trust you jdarksun because nobody could verify anyone else.
Dude, anyone could have been evil. Law was the only person killing bad guys. I gave a lot of info to law I didn't give to you.
I'm a little shocked, actually. Between you and Law, I had the keys to the cookie factory. You guys set me up to take over after you died, and even gave me the info on when was best to kill you.
Then everyone told me who they were. The only holdouts were folk not on your list, whom we promptly slaughtered while pointing the village at the innocents.
I don't think I did anything other than give you a day or two of my kills. You knew who I was, so I really didn't have a choice to give you some information because I had nothing to hide. I have to imagine your seering showed you I wasn't in a division, which meant I was a good guy special.
Ardor on
0
Options
cj iwakuraThe Rhythm RegentBears The Name FreedomRegistered Userregular
There was something in the voting patterns I saw that the goodguys could have found most of the badguys (it worked far better than I even realized when I noticed, I thought it would only turn up 2 or so rather than the bulk of them), but no one caught on to it. I'm reluctant to mention what it was, since I don't want badguy groups to be wise to it for the future. The other badguy group in the FMA phalla made the same mistake and we wiped them out largely due to it.
If it's "let's kill everyone who's not us online at vote close" levels of meta, then yes, you should let the entire class know.
Oh, it definitely isn't something meta. No more meta than looking at people's votes.
I didn't trust you jdarksun because nobody could verify anyone else.
Dude, anyone could have been evil. Law was the only person killing bad guys. I gave a lot of info to law I didn't give to you.
I'm a little shocked, actually. Between you and Law, I had the keys to the cookie factory. You guys set me up to take over after you died, and even gave me the info on when was best to kill you.
Then everyone told me who they were. The only holdouts were folk not on your list, whom we promptly slaughtered while pointing the village at the innocents.
I don't think I did anything other than give you a day or two of my kills. You knew who I was, so I really didn't have a choice to give you some information because I had nothing to hide. I have to imagine your seering showed you I wasn't in a division, which meant I was a good guy special.
In his defense, you never told him to guard you and you heavily implied that you had a dedicated guard elsewhere.
No I didn't. Also this just in, when it's your turn to do some kind of special thing, respond to PMs, or even if I haven't sent you one, send me one. Maximus took a day off, bum.
I didn't trust you jdarksun because nobody could verify anyone else.
Dude, anyone could have been evil. Law was the only person killing bad guys. I gave a lot of info to law I didn't give to you.
I'm a little shocked, actually. Between you and Law, I had the keys to the cookie factory. You guys set me up to take over after you died, and even gave me the info on when was best to kill you.
Then everyone told me who they were. The only holdouts were folk not on your list, whom we promptly slaughtered while pointing the village at the innocents.
I don't think I did anything other than give you a day or two of my kills. You knew who I was, so I really didn't have a choice to give you some information because I had nothing to hide. I have to imagine your seering showed you I wasn't in a division, which meant I was a good guy special.
Like "rukia's guard #2"
All I know about jdark is that he identified my role when he contacted me and claimed to be our seer. Not much I can do to defend against that. The seering allowed them to hammer us to the ground.
I apologize that I'm a bit frustrated and it's showing. I do think I helped make a positive difference for my team though and that's what I enjoy out of these. However, being the only or last loud mouthed villager in the thread isn't much fun either I guess.
Ardor on
0
Options
duraxWho watches the watchdogs?Registered Userregular
Posts
[size=+1]Ichigo is a Twat![/size]
(Obbi will unlock the boards when he is available.)
Arch,
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t_goGR39m2k
naknaknaknaknak
Very fun guys, thanks.
I'll be interested in seeing who actually killed me.
There were 12 divisions, the three powers a division could have was either seering, guarding or vigilante. There were 4 divisions of each power. So each day 3 divisions were called, so one had the seer power, one had guardian and one had vigilante.
The normal actual specials were the ryoka;
Ichigo Kurosaki = vigilante
Yourichi = seer
Orihime Inoue = guardian
Uryu Ishida = mason
Ganju Shiba = mason
Yastora Sado = mason
Kukaku Shiba = vigilante (except captains were immune)
There were 12 bad guys, 3 captains, 3 lieutenants and 6 normal badguys, there was one bad guy in each division. So the bad guys had some control of the division powers.
3DS: 2852-6809-9411
When he kept doing all the big posts and seemed to try and keep things on track at the beginning of the days, I was pretty sure jdark was evil. Of course, by that point I was dead, so it didn't really matter.
I'll be there, waiting.
I was suspicious of Obbi for a while too, but I had no reason for it and my instincts are usually terrible in Phalla.
Well, I'm not talking about grudges here. I'm talking about major characters who are bloody inactive. It's lovely being a no-name guard for Rukia when Rukia can't even be bothered to play the game.
Also, you guys should have figured out that Durax was a badguy since I died on day 2.
Especially since it happened right when I thought the village might be able to pull through.
3DS: 2852-6809-9411
With the vacuum of power/loss of a village voice (ardor) it did seem like an opportune time for an evil to step up to the plate ; especially if they hadn't taken drastic losses (which it didn't seem like they did).
Thanks for running this Sabs.
I think in the future, giving the bad guys so much control over kills plus killing off inactives makes the game severely imbalanced against the larger faction, that being the good guys. I mean, how many captains were evil? The seer who could deceive people (Jdark) and whatever power Ventroue had, that meant they had a power every other night unless someone killed them.
EDIT: 3 evil captains. 3 powers which was roughly one per night as long as they lived and as one of the two good guy vigs, I couldn't even kill them? Heh.
Strangely enough, I have only even been a seer 3 times throughout my phalla-career.
There were 3 evil captains. If half the specials weren't inactive it would have been a closer game. And I was close to killing off a badguy or two from inactivity but they started posting soooo.
Basically there were no guardians in this game.
3DS: 2852-6809-9411
Hindsight is 20/20.
Perhaps if things had been different then someone else would have been right. Confirmation bias is what I am saying!
Even on the suspected target list, there were better odds to hit a villager than mafia.
Dude, anyone could have been evil. Law was the only person killing bad guys. I gave a lot of info to law I didn't give to you.
Just because you could seer didn't make you good. We had nobody we could trust. He wanted to keep the captains alive because they were following his order but we had been killing good guys the whole game, which is why I pushed to kill Vertroue, having failed an attack on her before.
I do take some satisfaction that my final list with percentage chances were only wrong due to thinking Verr was ok due to having 3 dead division 2 guys already probably meant we weren't going to find a 4th. All my other guesses weren't half bad.
I just wish people used the resources available to them is all.
That was Skid's trick in the Soviet Phalla, wasn't it?
What powers did they control though? Seering was one. Did they also have a guard and a vigilante?
The old rule of thumb I heard about long ago was 15% bad guys and for every kill the village has, add another bad guy.
So if the bad guys had control over the same powers as the village plus their 2 kills as a large masoned group, how exactly where the odds with us?
I mean, one can state there were 2 vigs, 2 bad guys kills, vote and like 3 division kills a night, but if the bad guys controlled a division, it was 3 bad guy kills and 4 good guy kills plus the vote.
I must've missed it, but what did you do in the public thread to help us out? I know you called me an idiot, but I missed the first 2 days otherwise.
I blame the entire game on Abotkin.
I don't think I did anything other than give you a day or two of my kills. You knew who I was, so I really didn't have a choice to give you some information because I had nothing to hide. I have to imagine your seering showed you I wasn't in a division, which meant I was a good guy special.
Oh, it definitely isn't something meta. No more meta than looking at people's votes.
Frost Mist and I were going to rock out, but he was killed.
Then JT and I were going to rock out, but we were both killed.
Like "rukia's guard #2"
No I didn't. Also this just in, when it's your turn to do some kind of special thing, respond to PMs, or even if I haven't sent you one, send me one. Maximus took a day off, bum.
All I know about jdark is that he identified my role when he contacted me and claimed to be our seer. Not much I can do to defend against that. The seering allowed them to hammer us to the ground.
I apologize that I'm a bit frustrated and it's showing. I do think I helped make a positive difference for my team though and that's what I enjoy out of these. However, being the only or last loud mouthed villager in the thread isn't much fun either I guess.