The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.

seclusion

clownfoodclownfood packet pusherin the wallsRegistered User regular
edited February 2007 in Debate and/or Discourse
Recently a thought popped into my head about a situation in which if I was offered a million dollars to spend a year in seclusion, would I be able to do it. (this is based on a story i read long ago and can't remember the name of).

I figured I could if I had a few necessities provided. Books, music, food/water, bathing area and a few things for exercise. Being single and known for just up and moving to various parts of the world on a whim, I figured this would be easy for me. But I pose this to the board, could you do this. Here is what you get in your room.

Room is comparable to a studio loft ~ 1300 square feet. and there are no windows.
you have a bathroom and a stove/kitchen area
There would be lights that you would control.
There would be NO clocks, you would have nothing to tell you what time it was.
Your food would provided via a room that would be designed like an airlock. no food will come to you prepared. Basically periodically you would recieve a couple bags of groceries needed to make healthy meals. but you could recieve some sweets and the such.
Your room would actually be outside of the US or your country of origin so your million dollars would come to you tax free (based off US rules and regs (I could be wrong about this))
After entering the room, you will not be able to request more books or more music. You stock the place beforehand and you are stuck with it.
Your personal bills would be looked after while you are in seclusion. This means student loans, phone bills, rent/morgage, etc etc
Your family is on its own.
You are to make no attempt at contacting people or trying to find any information on the outside world.
You do not have a TV. For your music, you have something akin to a iPod shuffle with extended space (no LCD with time on it)

the kicker is that the door to the outside world is unlocked. You can walk out at any time. This is a voluntary action and the moment you are discovered trying to make contact with the outside world, the deal is off, you are returned to your life and you get no money for the time you are in. This doesn't mean you are not free to try, but this is a risk you take. It is an all or nothing deal. This includes trying to talk or communicate with people or trying to obtain news or information about anything outside of your walls. The moment the door closes behind you the time starts.

Could you do it? It seems easy at first, but do you think your psyche could take the isolation? How bad do you think the inability to gage time would be on your isolation? What kind of problems do you think you would have trying to readjust if you succeeded?

photo-4798.jpg?_r=1355437546
clownfood on
«13

Posts

  • 143999143999 Tellin' ya not askin' ya, not pleadin' with yaRegistered User regular
    edited February 2007
    What if something breaks?

    143999 on
    8aVThp6.png
  • ToadTheMushroomToadTheMushroom Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    A million dollars isn't a lot of money.

    Totally not worth it.

    ToadTheMushroom on
  • clownfoodclownfood packet pusher in the wallsRegistered User regular
    edited February 2007
    143999 wrote:
    What if something breaks?

    Okay, you are given tools and manuals on how to fix plumbing. You are also supplied extra light bulbs. if your stove breaks....well you know, you should play a bit more carefully with your toys.
    A million dollars isn't a lot of money.

    Totally not worth it.

    That is 20 years at my current salary. Contrary to popular belief, it is still a good bit of money for a single year. And it is tax free.

    clownfood on
    photo-4798.jpg?_r=1355437546
  • DevoutlyApatheticDevoutlyApathetic Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    A million dollars isn't a lot of money.

    Totally not worth it.

    Tax free? Invest it at 5% interest rate you make 50,000 every year. 5% for that kind of money is a stupidly low rate of return. If the above money is managed correctly you could live a middle class lifestyle for yourself, forever.

    Could I do it? I think I could though I'd expect to be very changed by the experience and I'm not certain it'd be in any kind of healthy way.

    I'm not certain I'd choose to do it or not. I would find such an idea tempting though.

    DevoutlyApathetic on
    Nod. Get treat. PSN: Quippish
  • ege02ege02 __BANNED USERS regular
    edited February 2007
    I'm a social guy. One year in seclusion would make me crazy.

    ege02 on
  • 143999143999 Tellin' ya not askin' ya, not pleadin' with yaRegistered User regular
    edited February 2007
    clownfood wrote:
    143999 wrote:
    What if something breaks?
    Okay, you are given tools and manuals on how to fix plumbing. You are also supplied extra light bulbs. if your stove breaks....well you know, you should play a bit more carefully with your toys.

    Medical supplies?

    143999 on
    8aVThp6.png
  • clownfoodclownfood packet pusher in the wallsRegistered User regular
    edited February 2007
    143999 wrote:
    clownfood wrote:
    143999 wrote:
    What if something breaks?
    Okay, you are given tools and manuals on how to fix plumbing. You are also supplied extra light bulbs. if your stove breaks....well you know, you should play a bit more carefully with your toys.

    Medical supplies?

    well stocked first aid kit and a panic button in case you fall and you can't get up. Try not to die. keep yourself clean and eat well. I will include an elipical trainer so you don't get bed sores and your legs don't suffer from atrophy.

    clownfood on
    photo-4798.jpg?_r=1355437546
  • CrayonCrayon Sleeps in the wrong bed. TejasRegistered User regular
    edited February 2007
    I'd do it. 1 year would probably drive me insane, but I'd be a rich insane man.

    Crayon on
  • Romantic UndeadRomantic Undead Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    I'd do it, provided I had a metric shit-ton of books and means with which to write.

    A computer not connected to the internet (as per the rules) would be ideal, but if it has to be a typewriter/pencil-paper, it needs to be a lot.

    Romantic Undead on
    3DS FC: 1547-5210-6531
  • clownfoodclownfood packet pusher in the wallsRegistered User regular
    edited February 2007
    I'd do it, provided I had a metric shit-ton of books and means with which to write.

    A computer not connected to the internet (as per the rules) would be ideal, but if it has to be a typewriter/pencil-paper, it needs to be a lot.

    It would probably be a typewriter with paper or a bunch of notebooks with a pen or pencil. The "no clock" part of this scenario, I believe makes it harder than anything else in the world. Not being able to gage where you are at in the term can make it feel so much longer.

    I would be curious to how your body would react to such conditions. WE all have a natural clock that tells us when to sleep and when to wake. Would you see it gradually shift or would it stay pretty constant? How long would people stay in bed trying to sleep the time away? Personally I have a hard enough time sleeping more than 6 hours at a time. I would be up and would have to deal with the next 18 hours left up to my own devices. Reading would be easy to do, but there is the fact that if I didn't move and be active, by the time the year was up, i would look like Jabba the Hut. I think I would have to have a pullup bar, a jump rope and some wieghts to try and keep myself in some sort of working order.

    clownfood on
    photo-4798.jpg?_r=1355437546
  • Safety StickSafety Stick Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    A computer/word processor would be a good thing.

    Given books (all of pratchett's stuff), music (my entire collection would fit on a 20GB drive) and a couple boxes of 15 and 28mm miniatures and paints and I would probably do it. I could sort out the backlog of unpainted stuff for sure :)

    Safety Stick on
    5075110276_cc4230e361.jpg
    My other sig sucks as well...
  • FencingsaxFencingsax It is difficult to get a man to understand, when his salary depends upon his not understanding GNU Terry PratchettRegistered User regular
    edited February 2007
    I see nowhere that says video games aren't allowed. As long as everyone knew knew I'd be back in a year, I'd totally take the mil.

    Fencingsax on
  • Romantic UndeadRomantic Undead Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    Fencingsax wrote:
    I see nowhere that says video games aren't allowed. As long as everyone knew knew I'd be back in a year, I'd totally take the mil.

    Oh man, if video games were allowed I'd hit that like vaseline on toast!

    Romantic Undead on
    3DS FC: 1547-5210-6531
  • ZoolanderZoolander Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    A million dollars is way too low.

    Zoolander on
  • clownfoodclownfood packet pusher in the wallsRegistered User regular
    edited February 2007
    Fencingsax wrote:
    I see nowhere that says video games aren't allowed. As long as everyone knew knew I'd be back in a year, I'd totally take the mil.

    Oh man, if video games were allowed I'd hit that like vaseline on toast!

    No TV....but I can see maybe a DS or a gameboy or the such.

    clownfood on
    photo-4798.jpg?_r=1355437546
  • FellhandFellhand Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    Yeah, I think I could do it, but without a clock you realize it's mental hell to whomever is inside right? Like when you can't tell the time of day or understand how much time has passed it really fucks with the human mind and body.

    Do you at least get a pen and notebooks like Old Boy?

    Fellhand on
  • clownfoodclownfood packet pusher in the wallsRegistered User regular
    edited February 2007
    Fellhand wrote:
    Yeah, I think I could do it, but without a clock you realize it's mental hell to whomever is inside right? Like when you can't tell the time of day or understand how much time has passed it really fucks with the human mind and body.

    Do you at least get a pen and notebooks like Old Boy?

    most definately. or you can have a typewriter/word processor. I would need something to write with. The fucked up thoughts that would spawn from so much time to sit and think and stew....I would have to write down. Although if you looked back on those notebooks a number of years later (if you did the time), I am sure a questioning of one's sanity would be in order.

    clownfood on
    photo-4798.jpg?_r=1355437546
  • FellhandFellhand Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    Wait, since you're outside of the US for tax purposes and possibly human rights stuff do you get drugs and alcohol? Like I definitly could do it if I had a steady supply of weed. Alcohol might be the double edged sword though.

    Fellhand on
  • Andrew_JayAndrew_Jay Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    clownfood wrote:
    (this is based on a story i read long ago and can't remember the name of)
    I'm guessing Chekhov's The Bet?

    Andrew_Jay on
  • clownfoodclownfood packet pusher in the wallsRegistered User regular
    edited February 2007
    Andrew_Jay wrote:
    clownfood wrote:
    (this is based on a story i read long ago and can't remember the name of)
    I'm guessing Chekhov's The Bet?

    That would indeed be it. I can;t imagine spending 15 years in solitary confinement. Although I do wonder what the equivillant of 2 million dollars in 1889 would be today.

    Again...15 years...that is a bit mind boggling.

    clownfood on
    photo-4798.jpg?_r=1355437546
  • FellhandFellhand Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    Yeah, this thread should really be called Solitude because that's a single person alone.

    Wikipedia also has some interesting things to say about solitude that I didn't know, such as how young people are better at adapting to it.

    Fellhand on
  • clownfoodclownfood packet pusher in the wallsRegistered User regular
    edited February 2007
    Fellhand wrote:
    Yeah, this thread should really be called Solitude because that's a single person alone.

    Wikipedia also has some interesting things to say about solitude that I didn't know, such as how young people are better at adapting to it.

    I debated on calling it "Solitary Confinement," but I chose this title for whatever reason.

    clownfood on
    photo-4798.jpg?_r=1355437546
  • MalkorMalkor Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    Id be able to do it if it wasn't for the room. I'm not exactly claustrophobic, but I'd need to be outside to run or just breathe real air at least some of the time. So half the money and on a deserted island or something and Im your man.

    Malkor on
    14271f3c-c765-4e74-92b1-49d7612675f2.jpg
  • FellhandFellhand Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    Malkor wrote:
    Id be able to do it if it wasn't for the room. I'm not exactly claustrophobic, but I'd need to be outside to run or just breathe real air at least some of the time. So half the money and on a deserted island or something and Im your man.

    But you can understand the passage of time that way.
    What about if it was like the bio dome but it worked and was self contained.
    Like The World in Morrison's X-Men run.

    Fellhand on
  • ViolentChemistryViolentChemistry __BANNED USERS regular
    edited February 2007
    I would need things not on your list. A year in seclusion would be useful, but not without more space and items you've explicitly ruled out. A year cut off from technology but not from people would be more productive, however.

    ViolentChemistry on
  • corcorigancorcorigan Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    Sounds a bit like becoming a Buddhist monk or something.

    Except you get paid. :)

    corcorigan on
    Ad Astra Per Aspera
  • LodbrokLodbrok Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    I recall that experiments done along these lines where people do not have access to clocks shows that humans when left to their own devices tend to adapt to a 28 hour cycle (can't remember the exact number, but longer than 24 hours anyway). If you are aware of this fact it should not be that difficult to keep a rought estimate of how much time has passed.

    I think I would do it. The hardest thing for me would be never seing the sky I think. That and not interacting with anyone... I think a year like that would change you in strange ways. I can imagine that if you have any latent psychological problems, you might emerge a total nutcase.....

    Lodbrok on
  • NerissaNerissa Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    12 x 26 is WAY too small for an entire year, even if I could manage the seclusion. Are the bathroom & kitchen facilities included in that? If so, once you fit them in, plus a bed and an exercise machine (assuming some sort of counter / table in the kitchen area that could double as a desk), you're looking at MAYBE 12 x 12 available space, which is about the size of my office. I'd go crazy real quick.

    My bedroom is about 12 x 20 not counting bathroom & closets, and I had a hell of a time being stuck in there for 2 weeks WITH television, computer, and human contact. Of course, I was stuck in bed the entire time, but still...

    Nerissa on
  • SamiSami Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    I would never do it, no matter the reward for one reason.

    No reward could ever compensate for things that have value but no pricetag.

    How do you judge the monetary value of falling in love?
    Making a new friend?
    Babysitting someone's new puppy?
    Hitting every green light?
    Getting way too drunk after an unlucky game of beer pong?
    Farting in a car full of friends and switching on the window lock?

    Nah, it'd never be worth it.

    Sami on
  • ElendilElendil Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    I'd need more space and more stuff, but probably. I'm already reclusive.

    Elendil on
  • ViolentChemistryViolentChemistry __BANNED USERS regular
    edited February 2007
    Sami wrote:
    I would never do it, no matter the reward for one reason.

    No reward could ever compensate for things that have value but no pricetag.

    How do you judge the monetary value of falling in love?
    Making a new friend?
    Babysitting someone's new puppy?
    Hitting every green light?
    Getting way too drunk after an unlucky game of beer pong?
    Farting in a car full of friends and switching on the window lock?

    Nah, it'd never be worth it.
    How do you judge the monetary value of mastering a dozen disciplines of your choice in only a year while being paid a million dollars to do it instead of having to pay as much out over the course of several years?

    I just say there's not enough space, nor the tools I would need.

    ViolentChemistry on
  • clownfoodclownfood packet pusher in the wallsRegistered User regular
    edited February 2007
    Sami wrote:
    I would never do it, no matter the reward for one reason.

    No reward could ever compensate for things that have value but no pricetag.

    How do you judge the monetary value of falling in love?
    Making a new friend?
    Babysitting someone's new puppy?
    Hitting every green light?
    Getting way too drunk after an unlucky game of beer pong?
    Farting in a car full of friends and switching on the window lock?

    Nah, it'd never be worth it.
    How do you judge the monetary value of mastering a dozen disciplines of your choice in only a year while being paid a million dollars to do it instead of having to pay as much out over the course of several years?

    I just say there's not enough space, nor the tools I would need.

    I would probably conceede some additional space, but I wouldn't allow a computer or a TV.

    I was judging the space on the Control center I work in. I have had some rather small bathrooms in my apartments and made due with no problems. For a kitchen, you simply need about 10 feet of counterspace and that would include the stove and sink.

    I will up the space to the size of my friend's studio loft. 1300 square feet. That is a pretty big increase.

    clownfood on
    photo-4798.jpg?_r=1355437546
  • ViolentChemistryViolentChemistry __BANNED USERS regular
    edited February 2007
    Without either a live instructor, a computer or TV I can't learn any physical disciplines, only mental ones. Not worth my time. I would also need lots of really good dank.

    ViolentChemistry on
  • clownfoodclownfood packet pusher in the wallsRegistered User regular
    edited February 2007
    Without either a live instructor, a computer or TV I can't learn any physical disciplines, only mental ones. Not worth my time. I would also need lots of really good dank.

    That adds an interesting wrinkle to the whole situation. Drug use. After so long in solitude....would drug use inspire a deeper break from reality?

    I don't think i really could learn much of anything in that situation outside from personal enlightenment. I would spend most my time reading and writing. The more and more I think about it, the less and less sure I could actually pull off such a stunt.

    clownfood on
    photo-4798.jpg?_r=1355437546
  • NoneoftheaboveNoneoftheabove Just a conforming non-conformist. Twilight ZoneRegistered User regular
    edited February 2007
    Lack of windows is the deal breaker. Without natural sunlight I think a person becomes more emotionally drained. I believe depression in some cases has been directly linked to lack of sunlight in a persons mental health.

    For that reason, I think I would avoid this challenge.

    Noneoftheabove on
  • redxredx I(x)=2(x)+1 whole numbersRegistered User regular
    edited February 2007
    sure, I could do it no problem. I'd rather have the option of having a handy person come in and fix stuff, but I guess I could manage.

    I'd also like to have something to game on, but whatever.

    or at least some up front money to pay for books.

    one of those mp3 playing cd dealies, cause I'd fill up a shuffle too quick. Like, a couple spools of cds full of mp3. That would be good. Actual speakers instead of ear bud jobbies, cause it is not like I would bug anyone rocking out.

    Writing stuff, pens papers that kinda thing. Punching bag.

    I could manage alright. I'd end up a bit more disassociate, and would need some treatment when I came out. Otherwise, I'd manage.

    redx on
    They moistly come out at night, moistly.
  • Andrew_JayAndrew_Jay Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    Yeah, throwing people's sense of time (and blocking natural light) is a little unnecessary, and the one thing most likely to lead to health (physical and mental) problems.

    I'd probably do it if that little detail was lifted. Doubly-so if I got my own deserted island - think St. Helena, but with better weather.

    Andrew_Jay on
  • redxredx I(x)=2(x)+1 whole numbersRegistered User regular
    edited February 2007
    Lodbrok wrote:
    I recall that experiments done along these lines where people do not have access to clocks shows that humans when left to their own devices tend to adapt to a 28 hour cycle (can't remember the exact number, but longer than 24 hours anyway). If you are aware of this fact it should not be that difficult to keep a rought

    25 hours actually. and it breaks down all sorts of diffrent ways, like 12/13 25/25 15/10 6.25/6.25 x 2 but it always comes out to 25 for some reason.

    redx on
    They moistly come out at night, moistly.
  • YarYar Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    My inclination is to say yes, but it is a tough call.

    The room size is pretty critical. A really small one like you describe and I might be clawing the walls with my fingernails.

    Also, I'm pretending I don't have a wife and kids. There's no way I'd voluntarily leave them for a whole year.

    A stocked bar would help immensely. I'd probably turn into an alcoholic, but it would really help ease the stress to be able to mix up a drink every few days.

    Video games I think would be the big tie-breaker. I often fantasize about having a year to myself to do nothing but play through all the games I never had time to play. Hell, I'd almost pay for that privilege. I could blow months in a flash just playing through all the old Ultimas or something.

    I might be able to replace video games with a lot of books, but that would be harder.

    So, wake up, exercise, eat, read, eat, meditate, exercise again, play games, eat, drink, play games, read, go to bed. I could do that for a year, though I probably be depressed and a little strange for it.

    I'd also have to have some sort of ironclad undoubtable guarantee that the door would open in a year. If I had already gone through about 400 sleep cycles and the door still wasn't opening, I'd start panicking in stress about whether or not I'm really just like a day or two from finishing, or its actually a big test and they are never going to open it.

    Yar on
  • FellhandFellhand Registered User regular
    edited February 2007
    I want someone to bet me this. I'd love to be able to disappear for a year or two and have someone take care of my shit and then give me some mad bank when I was done. A year or two isn't that long. 15 years would be insanely extreme and it would be too difficult to readapt.

    Fellhand on
Sign In or Register to comment.