This stone representation of me did not always weep, no.
Perhaps there is something to be gained in figvring out why?
Most likely not.
Your stone was crying yesterday, though yeah?
Time flows differently for me than it does for yov. This game has been going on for months here. I believe sometime yesterday for yov, my visage changed. Most likely dvring my confrontation with my... estranged friend. I feel that only his death will bring me peace. Then may I rest.
This particular game is what we lovingly call “vanilla. With a twist”. There will be your standard roles present in this game Seer, Guard, Vigilante, Mafia, Masons There may be one or two random other roles, but that I will keep a secret. There are no Thralls, Millers, Conversions, or other obnoxious roles present. Why not? Because I dislike playing in games with them present so I’m not going to run a game with them present.
Someone being able to change the narration to show someone as a different alignment would make that a thrall/miller, yes?
Therefore, that is not a mechanic that would exist. If words can be inserted, that is one thing. People cannot change the color of another player on a whim.
I was gonna vote for someone else. But re-reading the thread Anialos seems way too overeager to find someone better to vote after his stupid Infidel vote.
I was gonna vote for someone else. But re-reading the thread Anialos seems way too overeager to find someone better to vote after his stupid Infidel vote.
I was wondering earlier if he'd hoped using his secret would result in something less pleasant than 'confirmed village' happening to kime...
0
Options
AnialosCollies are love, Collies are life!Shadowbrook ColliesRegistered Userregular
I was gonna vote for someone else. But re-reading the thread Anialos seems way too overeager to find someone better to vote after his stupid Infidel vote.
I was wondering earlier if he'd hoped using his secret would result in something less pleasant than 'confirmed village' happening to kime...
Ahaha, you guys are funny. Yes, I was looking to change my joke vote. Why wouldn't I be?
I was gonna vote for someone else. But re-reading the thread Anialos seems way too overeager to find someone better to vote after his stupid Infidel vote.
I was wondering earlier if he'd hoped using his secret would result in something less pleasant than 'confirmed village' happening to kime...
I was gonna vote for someone else. But re-reading the thread Anialos seems way too overeager to find someone better to vote after his stupid Infidel vote.
I was wondering earlier if he'd hoped using his secret would result in something less pleasant than 'confirmed village' happening to kime...
What makes you think this?
None of us had any idea what the secrets would do until someone pulled the trigger Day 1.
Day 1 trigger pulls were aimed at:
Guy who also got mafia killed.
Prominent player with a solid win-loss record.
Did he fear kime was mafia? Reasonable.
Did he know kime was village and hope to impede us? Also reasonable.
spool32 on
0
Options
AnialosCollies are love, Collies are life!Shadowbrook ColliesRegistered Userregular
I was gonna vote for someone else. But re-reading the thread Anialos seems way too overeager to find someone better to vote after his stupid Infidel vote.
I was wondering earlier if he'd hoped using his secret would result in something less pleasant than 'confirmed village' happening to kime...
What makes you think this?
None of us had any idea what the secrets would do until someone pulled the trigger Day 1.
Day 1 trigger pulls were aimed at:
Guy who also got mafia killed.
Prominent player with a solid win-loss record.
Did he fear kime was mafia? Reasonable.
Did he know kime was village and hope to impede us? Also reasonable.
Did he see the person whose secret he had tied for the vote lead and decide to use it just in case that somehow effected it? A'yup.
Did he pick Kime because he is either the best mafia to have dead/revealed, or the most charismatic/best nethead to have? A'yup.
I thought I posted this, but maybe not. If you have a secret that would fit into "A Secret Agenda," let me know please. Even if you already told me once.
Just for the record, Langly wasted someone else's power, which is the travesty. (And a little broken design, but still the result of villager lazyness.)
The whole "look at the tie" thing is silly, but doesn't look like anyone is caught pushing that. Oh well!
If you think there is shenanigans, you do it right and vote for me. If I come up mafia ever, then you follow up on the tie. Until then, there is nothing really interesting or rational about the two wagons.
And voting for me you probably want some reason to think I'm mafia other than "he voted for a villager" or "it's Infidel." I could at least somewhat accept "it's Infidel and it is now day 4" but we're not there yet are we. :P
Saying that anyone who starts a bandwagon on a villager is mafia is bad, but I hope stever didn't mean that.
The Langly vote was legit, in my opinion. He made a mistake, but the mistake made him look evil, so them's the breaks. So just be careful about how much we analyze people going for langly yesterday.
Just for the record, Langly wasted someone else's power, which is the travesty. (And a little broken design, but still the result of villager lazyness.)
The whole "look at the tie" thing is silly, but doesn't look like anyone is caught pushing that. Oh well!
If you think there is shenanigans, you do it right and vote for me. If I come up mafia ever, then you follow up on the tie. Until then, there is nothing really interesting or rational about the two wagons.
And voting for me you probably want some reason to think I'm mafia other than "he voted for a villager" or "it's Infidel." I could at least somewhat accept "it's Infidel and it is now day 4" but we're not there yet are we. :P
Saying that anyone who starts a bandwagon on a villager is mafia is bad, but I hope stever didn't mean that.
I read that as him meaning the reason why the Langly wagon took off while there was a close vote going on. Which doesn't seem weird to me considering Langly admitted that he had nullified his secret by accident. So it seems less likely the wagon was mafia-started to get it off of a possible mafia.
Oh also: mafia can almost assuredly use secrets. After all, secret-users are revealed in the narration! Would be silly for them to be denied that.
Why?
And if they can use secrets, how would that work? All of our secrets are one time use. So they each can only use their powers once a game like us?
Just don't see it.
If they can't use secrets, then using a secret is like a public seering. That's possibly, like, 5 publicly confirmed villagers each night? Ehhh, I doubt it.
And they probably have secrets in addition to regular mafia abilities?
Oh also: mafia can almost assuredly use secrets. After all, secret-users are revealed in the narration! Would be silly for them to be denied that.
Why?
And if they can use secrets, how would that work? All of our secrets are one time use. So they each can only use their powers once a game like us?
Just don't see it.
Every player submitted a secret before the game started. Everyone received a secret from another player
this includes the mafias
they probably still have separate mafia powers in addition to that secret
0
Options
ObiFettUse the ForceAs You WishRegistered Userregular
edited July 2012
Although, second thought on that.
What if they can gain access to the secrets of people who have been removed but haven't used their secrets? This would give them their renewable pool of secrets to use.
It might be good just to be safe and reveal your secret when its obvious you are gonna get voted out. Like the last ten minutes or so, to make sure the mafia can't get any use out of it.
But then again, that might be a bad idea if the mafia need to figure out everyone's secrets to perform some of their powers.
What if they can gain access to the secrets of people who have been removed but haven't used their secrets? This would give them their renewable pool of secrets to use.
It might be good just to be safe and reveal your secret when its obvious you are gonna get voted out. Like the last ten minutes or so, to make sure the mafia can't get any use out of it.
But then again, that might be a bad idea if the mafia need to figure out everyone's secrets to perform some of their powers.
I assume voided secrets won't be shared in the narration.
Edit: And hopefully I'll have given out orders and had them followed through before 10 minutes to close. :P
Posts
Your stone was crying yesterday, though yeah?
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Time flows differently for me than it does for yov. This game has been going on for months here. I believe sometime yesterday for yov, my visage changed. Most likely dvring my confrontation with my... estranged friend. I feel that only his death will bring me peace. Then may I rest.
FTFY
It's not really metagaming if it's in the OP.
Someone being able to change the narration to show someone as a different alignment would make that a thrall/miller, yes?
Therefore, that is not a mechanic that would exist. If words can be inserted, that is one thing. People cannot change the color of another player on a whim.
BAAAAAAUGH
-Not a vote-
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Any reasoning behind yovr vote, or jvst a gvt instinct thing?
I was wondering earlier if he'd hoped using his secret would result in something less pleasant than 'confirmed village' happening to kime...
Ahaha, you guys are funny. Yes, I was looking to change my joke vote. Why wouldn't I be?
What makes you think this?
None of us had any idea what the secrets would do until someone pulled the trigger Day 1.
Day 1 trigger pulls were aimed at:
Guy who also got mafia killed.
Prominent player with a solid win-loss record.
Did he fear kime was mafia? Reasonable.
Did he know kime was village and hope to impede us? Also reasonable.
Did he see the person whose secret he had tied for the vote lead and decide to use it just in case that somehow effected it? A'yup.
Did he pick Kime because he is either the best mafia to have dead/revealed, or the most charismatic/best nethead to have? A'yup.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
I thought it was Invincible?
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
These are newbie rules :rotate:
Witness.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
My vote tonight goes on stever777 for this terrible Game Theory.
Saying that anyone who starts a bandwagon on a villager is mafia is bad, but I hope stever didn't mean that.
oh :oops:
wait
(I still think a mafias would take into account what most sane people would assume or think rather than my twisted mind)
Anialos
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
I read that as him meaning the reason why the Langly wagon took off while there was a close vote going on. Which doesn't seem weird to me considering Langly admitted that he had nullified his secret by accident. So it seems less likely the wagon was mafia-started to get it off of a possible mafia.
i'd vote trv again but a grudge vote at this point is dumb, if I could kill him though I would!
Steam
don't tell anyone
Why?
And if they can use secrets, how would that work? All of our secrets are one time use. So they each can only use their powers once a game like us?
Just don't see it.
Steam
If they can't use secrets, then using a secret is like a public seering. That's possibly, like, 5 publicly confirmed villagers each night? Ehhh, I doubt it.
And they probably have secrets in addition to regular mafia abilities?
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Every player submitted a secret before the game started. Everyone received a secret from another player
this includes the mafias
they probably still have separate mafia powers in addition to that secret
What if they can gain access to the secrets of people who have been removed but haven't used their secrets? This would give them their renewable pool of secrets to use.
It might be good just to be safe and reveal your secret when its obvious you are gonna get voted out. Like the last ten minutes or so, to make sure the mafia can't get any use out of it.
But then again, that might be a bad idea if the mafia need to figure out everyone's secrets to perform some of their powers.
Also kime mentioned that we have true specials, so presumably the mafia has their kills as well.
Edit: And hopefully I'll have given out orders and had them followed through before 10 minutes to close. :P
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile