The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.
Barebones MP3 Player Advice
DrFrylock
Registered User regular
Registered User regular
I'm looking for a portable MP3 player, but I need some advice on make/model for my specific needs.
I have: An MP3 collection of all my CDs (~20GB) on a Linux server only I can access. The MP3s are organized how I like them and have appropriate ID3 tags.
I want: To be able to connect the player to the USB port on the Linux box and sync the directory on the Linux box onto the player. Preferably the MP3 player will appear as a mountable drive. I then want the MP3 player to show me my files in a way that is similar to how they are organized on the Linux box and let me play them.
I can: Write software to do the syncing if necessary.
I don't want: To have to install the crapware that you're "supposed" to use to access the player (iTunes or the like) if I don't have to. I also don't want to have to use hacks or gray-area tools to do this.
I don't care: About video, the ability to record sound, the ability to play Ogg/FLAC, "PlaysForSure", "FairPlay", or other formats.
I would like: To use this player for a long time and so one that I will be able to replace the battery on eventually would be super.
I like: The iPod's clickwheel interface, but as far as I know you can't load stuff onto the iPod except through iTunes or using hacks.
Recommendations?
I have: An MP3 collection of all my CDs (~20GB) on a Linux server only I can access. The MP3s are organized how I like them and have appropriate ID3 tags.
I want: To be able to connect the player to the USB port on the Linux box and sync the directory on the Linux box onto the player. Preferably the MP3 player will appear as a mountable drive. I then want the MP3 player to show me my files in a way that is similar to how they are organized on the Linux box and let me play them.
I can: Write software to do the syncing if necessary.
I don't want: To have to install the crapware that you're "supposed" to use to access the player (iTunes or the like) if I don't have to. I also don't want to have to use hacks or gray-area tools to do this.
I don't care: About video, the ability to record sound, the ability to play Ogg/FLAC, "PlaysForSure", "FairPlay", or other formats.
I would like: To use this player for a long time and so one that I will be able to replace the battery on eventually would be super.
I like: The iPod's clickwheel interface, but as far as I know you can't load stuff onto the iPod except through iTunes or using hacks.
Recommendations?
DrFrylock on
0
Posts
It has a 20GB capacity, is small (smaller than a cigarette packet), mounts just like a USB hard drive (or at least it can, it's also a "playsforsure" device, you have to disable that in the player options before it'll mount), it has a monchrome screen and the battery life is pretty good.
The interface isn't quite as slick as the iPod, it organises by id3 tag, I have no idea if it will let you maintain a directory structure, and I don't know how one would go about replacing the battery.
The other option I considered was an iPod with the rockbox firmware, but iPods are expensive and I didn't want to instantly invalidate the warranty.
That's exactly what came to my mind. I remember when it first came out it was amazing how small it was for a 20GB player..it's still smaller than you would expect but not shockingly small.
It's been a while since I looked at it, but I'm pretty sure the mp3 player section will maintain directory structure.