The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.
Good Credit but still cant get an auto loan
AbsoluteZero
The new film by Quentin KoopantinoRegistered User regular
The new film by Quentin KoopantinoRegistered User regular
So I've found a nice used car and gotten a purchase agreement for it, a pretty good deal too. The dealer has agreed to hang on to the vehicle for a while until I secure a loan (probably a week at best). I need a loan of about $8700.
I've so far applied at two places: US Bank and Wells Fargo.
Despite the fact that my FICO is 713 and my credit is spotless, both places have turned me down. The reason they give: I haven't had an auto loan before.
So despite that the fact that I have been making around $400/mo payments on my numerous student loans for probably 2 years now and the fact that I have paid in full my credit cards every single month for 4 years and have never, ever gone past due on anything.... it seems they don't think I could handle repaying a $8700 secured debt.
The only remedy I can think of is to get a co-signer... but there is literally no one who would co-sign for me that has decent credit. None that I can think of, anyways.
I really need/want this car, and I'm running out of time. Any thoughts? Anyone know of a lender that would be more friendly to my needs?
I've so far applied at two places: US Bank and Wells Fargo.
Despite the fact that my FICO is 713 and my credit is spotless, both places have turned me down. The reason they give: I haven't had an auto loan before.
So despite that the fact that I have been making around $400/mo payments on my numerous student loans for probably 2 years now and the fact that I have paid in full my credit cards every single month for 4 years and have never, ever gone past due on anything.... it seems they don't think I could handle repaying a $8700 secured debt.
The only remedy I can think of is to get a co-signer... but there is literally no one who would co-sign for me that has decent credit. None that I can think of, anyways.
I really need/want this car, and I'm running out of time. Any thoughts? Anyone know of a lender that would be more friendly to my needs?
AbsoluteZero on
0
This discussion has been closed.
Posts
For example, with my wife's car, we had her and my credit scores in hand (771 and 750 respectively) and told our dealer that our bank offered us 6% and we wanted to see what the dealer could do. He had to "talk to his boss" and got us a 5.5% loan.
I'm not an expert on car dealers by any means, but it worked for us.
xbl - HowYouGetAnts
steam - WeAreAllGeth
Or even talk to the bank manager! I mean you work there.
Satans..... hints.....
Most credit unions are vastly superior to banks. Their rates are usually much better and they actually like to have you come in. It's a completely different atmosphere than a bank.
What city are you in?
I switched to a credit union (Boeing Employees Credit Union, available to all residents of Washington state, despite the name) and they gave me a loan right away.
Credit unions suck less than banks, use them if you can.
I did about a month ago get my TransUnion credit report (though I didn't get my FICO because for whatever reason that costs money) and saw absolutely nothing wrong with it. Never have had a single missed/late payment in my life and my credit reflects that.
It truly seems to be that I can not get an auto loan for the simple fact that I have never had an auto loan before.
I will try some more places and give credit unions a go, but I believe I'm going to have to face very real probability that I wont get this figured out in time to buy the car in question. At least perhaps I can get pre-approved somewhere and go car shopping.
Or on the other hand I could just hope the clunker I have now keeps running and save up to purchase with cash.
If you're not carrying a high balance with your bank, you don't have your current loans with them, and you've never had an auto loan with them, I can see where they might be reticent to give you a secured loan.
Is this where you're getting the 713 fico score from? I ask because I believe Transunion uses a different scale that would put your actual fico somewhere in the 600s. When I bought my car last year, my fico was something like 780 but Transunion said 820-something.
Most places give a loan based on the average or middle score. When I bought a car a year and a half ago, I just went to the dealer and told them I had X amount for a down payment, I didn't want to pay more than Y amount per month, and test drove the car I wanted to purchase. Twenty-four hours later, I went back and signed the paperwork and had a new car.
If this is a small dealership, you probably won't have much luck through the dealer there, but if all else fails, hit up the finance department at one or more of the big new-car dealerships. They may look at you funny for not buying one of their cars, but they should be able to find you a loan. They usually have multiple sources for loans they can check at once.
PSN: Beltaine-77 | Steam: beltane77 | Battle.net BadHaggis#1433
But yes, credit unions tend to be fairly decent on their loan rates, savings rates, etc. I've never had a problem with Navy Federal Credit Union, but I've heard some people complain about small local type credit unions.
I ended up getting a co-signer, and it worked out great. Now I was able to get a home loan on my own credit.
Exactly. Not all financial institutions are the same on this particular issue. Some banks are more willing to give a particular type of loan than other banks. My local credit union loves to give car loans. Just call around.
the "no true scotch man" fallacy.
The banker I worked with let me see my FICO right after he pulled it, that's where I got the 713 score.
I have however officially given up and let the car go. I'm going to save up a couple thousand more dollars, hunt around for a co-signer, and try again in a couple months. Suppose I should try to get pre-approved before I go car shopping again.
Thanks again for the advice, everybody
Your employer may not want to tell you that's the reason, though.