Excellent brain candy, terrible, TERRIBLE ending to the series, awkward transition to film only made fun by the gigantic CG budget and the well-funded casting of pretty much every adult character in the movie.
I enjoyed the series somewhat, but the ending... man.
Oogmar that part was cheesy but come on Harry always was really REALLY cheesy
The entire second half of the last book was entirely cheesy, as well as terrible, poorly built, and contradictory to almost every single rule and plot point Rowling had built into her own world. Cheesy is fine, but that shit was abysmal.
Juuust sayin'.
Edit: I suppose I shouldn't crap all over the "EEE HARRY POTTER" thread just because I'm a disenchanted former fan (as in I read the books, not as in I wrote in my notebooks about marrying one of the Weasley twins or owned any Harry Potter item besides the books)(those obsessive fans were the reason I put off reading them for so long). Incredibly, incredibly disappointed in that last one.
I wouldn't call it abysmal but I'm not sure she had everything planned out. It reads as though she was trying to tie everything up as she went along, which I'm fine with. I would rather have a bumpy ride that is an actual conclusion than a smooth ride that explains nothing at all
Although that's probably because if I had read the last book and not had closure I would have flipped out
zimfan on
0
Options
KlykaDO you have anySPARE BATTERIES?Registered Userregular
Fair enough on the closure bit, but I'm too big a fan of authors who follow through with hard promises: When a character dies, they are dead. Even if it's the main character. I know from experience that killing a character you've grown attached to writing is really, really hard, but to shrug what could have been a solid ending to opt for a happy one that wouldn't break the kiddies hearts was, in my opinion, irresponsible authoring.
The assumption that everybody married their high school sweethearts was painful.
But man, Prisoner of Azkaban. Great re-read for those days when brain-think isn't necessary. And Gary O. ruled in the movie, so I have no bones about that installment. I will never knock Rowling's ability to put together a great mental image with very simple tools, which is something largely missing in children/young adult fiction.
Matthew Woodring Stover:
In fact, I’d like to go the other way entirely, and say that every fantasy writer living today should get down on hands and knees to kiss J.K. Rowling’s, er, feet. She not only has managed to write fantasy that adults don’t mind being seen reading on the bus, she has also created millions of new fantasy readers out there. Ten years from now, a lot of those kids will be buying my books.
May the gods rain blessings upon Harry Potter.
As far as influences—well, everything influences me. Every time I come across a neat bit of storytelling, I file it away. I steal from everybody.
Bloods End on
0
Options
Raneadospolice apologistyou shouldn't have been there, obviouslyRegistered Userregular
edited August 2010
oogmar your love of harry potter has made you catch a severe case of the vapors
Rane, you were rejected from Hogwarts as a child, weren't you?
I never applied to hogwarts
as it is fictional
Funny, that sounds exactly like something that a Hogwarts rejectee would say. o_O
no no I have the letter right here
Dear Raneados
As Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry is fictional, we must deny your application. You would have better luck at a real school, and not one that obviously doesn't exist, as we don't.
All the best
Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry
see even they say they're fictional
and that's the only reason i am not there, obviously
Rane, you were rejected from Hogwarts as a child, weren't you?
I never applied to hogwarts
as it is fictional
Funny, that sounds exactly like something that a Hogwarts rejectee would say. o_O
no no I have the letter right here
Dear Raneados
As Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry is fictional, we must deny your application. You would have better luck at a real school, and not one that obviously doesn't exist, as we don't.
All the best
Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry
see even they say they're fictional
and that's the only reason i am not there, obviously
If you never applied, how do you have a rejection letter?
Posts
Secret Satan 2013 Wishlist
The years haven't been too kind to Mr. Weasely.
though emma watson continues to become finer than ever
well that explains it then
I never realised that Daniel Radcliffe had such spooky eyes
At least the books are good, unlike a certain other series.
I bet being a famous hot lady would suck. Everyone trying so hard to screw you.
Yes, yes it would :winky:
Rane, you were rejected from Hogwarts as a child, weren't you?
I enjoyed the series somewhat, but the ending... man.
The entire second half of the last book was entirely cheesy, as well as terrible, poorly built, and contradictory to almost every single rule and plot point Rowling had built into her own world. Cheesy is fine, but that shit was abysmal.
Juuust sayin'.
Edit: I suppose I shouldn't crap all over the "EEE HARRY POTTER" thread just because I'm a disenchanted former fan (as in I read the books, not as in I wrote in my notebooks about marrying one of the Weasley twins or owned any Harry Potter item besides the books)(those obsessive fans were the reason I put off reading them for so long). Incredibly, incredibly disappointed in that last one.
Although that's probably because if I had read the last book and not had closure I would have flipped out
The assumption that everybody married their high school sweethearts was painful.
But man, Prisoner of Azkaban. Great re-read for those days when brain-think isn't necessary. And Gary O. ruled in the movie, so I have no bones about that installment. I will never knock Rowling's ability to put together a great mental image with very simple tools, which is something largely missing in children/young adult fiction.
Still love the series though. It was a huge part of my childhood and I can't wait to watch the Part 2 of Deathly Hallows while at "Hogwarts".
I also like several of the Star Wars EU books, and I thought The Chocolate War was the worst piece of shit that was ever pooped out of a butt.
My literary tastes are decidedly elitist.
Rane, you never answered my question.
I never applied to hogwarts
as it is fictional
It will sell 20 million copies.
Secret Satan 2013 Wishlist
Funny, that sounds exactly like something that a Hogwarts rejectee would say. o_O
boo bloo blah whining
IT'S REAL TO ME DAMMIT!
i dont care about harry potter either but that video is good
and not all that related
no no I have the letter right here
see even they say they're fictional
and that's the only reason i am not there, obviously
Things That The British Have Not Managed To Beat America At Yet:
[strike]Tea.
Crumpets.
Comedy.[/strike]
Hamburgers.
Underage pop stars.
If you never applied, how do you have a rejection letter?
they just fucking tell you
I don't even like harry potter and I know that
you are all the worst fans ever