The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
Please vote in the Forum Structure Poll. Polling will close at 2PM EST on January 21, 2025.

Abortion help

KrautKraut Registered User regular
edited February 2011 in Help / Advice Forum
The Situation:

I am an Australian dude and met an Indonesian girl studying here. We became friends (as in, just friends. Nothing more than that). She eventually moved back to Indonesia and then a little less than two months ago I got the opportunity to travel there and naturally decided to meet up with her there.

Stupid inc: During this holiday one thing led to another and we ended up having spontaneous unplanned unprotected sex. I'm aware how stupid this was. But she tells me a few days later that she had her period, and I breathe a sigh of relief.

Then yesterday she told me she was lying because she didn't know how I'd react. She's now a bit less than two months pregnant with no really visible signs yet.

Now, here's the complicated part. She believes abortion is murder and is morally against it. She has done the procedure once, just last year, out of necessity (from another guy) and she couldn't bear the guilt and sorrow from that. She said recently she won't able to live with herself if she does it again, but then implied today that she'd consider it ONLY if there's basically no chance she'd go barren from it.

Even if such a procedure existed, she certainly can't get it in Indonesia (it's illegal). She can't come to Australia because it would require a Visa with the endorsement of her father and employer, which would lead to all kinds of questions. I've tried to look in the Southeast Asia region for options but only really came up with Singapore which restricts the procedure to Singaporean citizens only.

I've only turned 24 recently. She hasn't even turned 25 yet. I haven't even finished my undergraduate study and there's just no way I can drop my life in Australia to go live in Indonesia and raise a child. And I'm starting to feel like the worst kind of monster to do this to someone.

How can I live with myself if
a) she goes through raising a child with just herself and her family
or
b) she somehow finds some abortion procedure somewhere (which I'm running out of hope I can find) where she can actually go, and then becomes barren and can never realise her most cherished dream of having children?

The only alternative is c, that I end my life, my dreams, my job, my family, everything to fix a stupid mistake of two young fools.

What the hell can I do?

tldr version:
* I am an Australian citizen. I live in Australia. I am there now.
* I knocked up an Indonesian citizen. She lives in Indonesia. She is there now.
* ohgodhowdoweabortthissafely

Kraut on
«1

Posts

  • SpacemilkSpacemilk Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    Has she been to a doctor and had the pregnancy confirmed? Pregnancy tests are not 100% and missed periods do not guarantee pregnancy.

    Have you guys considered adoption? (note: I don't even know if that's a "thing" in Indonesia =/ )

    Have you looked into what legal options are available for her in Australia considering how she is the father of your child? Would she consider moving there and eventually obtaining citizenship? Would the child have Aussie citizenship automatically?

    Have you considered letting her keep the baby but providing child support in the form of money and, occasionally, visits? (I have no idea how things work in Australia but that's the norm in the U.S. between a couple that has a child but isn't married and doesn't want to be in a relationship with each other) In my opinion, doing so is not the same as "letting her raise it with just her and her family"... you are still there to support her and the child.

    Your biggest mistake right now (besides not using protection, obvi) is thinking that this just HAS to end your life, your dreams, etc. It doesn't. There are many other options besides the ones you listed.

    Spacemilk on
  • MushroomStickMushroomStick Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    I apologize in advance if I sound terrible for asking these but... Are you sure its your kid? Are you sure she's actually pregnant? I just worry about the off chance that someone is jumping on the opportunity for an elaborate con.

    MushroomStick on
  • VisionOfClarityVisionOfClarity Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    VisionOfClarity on
  • Pure DinPure Din Boston-areaRegistered User regular
    edited February 2011
    I apologize in advance if I sound terrible for asking these but... Are you sure its your kid? Are you sure she's actually pregnant? I just worry about the off chance that someone is jumping on the opportunity for an elaborate con.

    I second this advice...

    Also if you are going to get a visa and fly her out of the country do it fast, because generally abortions are more difficult and expensive the longer you wait (though I don't know if Australia has specific laws about this or waiting periods, etc, like we see in the US)

    Pure Din on
  • Inquisitor77Inquisitor77 2 x Penny Arcade Fight Club Champion A fixed point in space and timeRegistered User regular
    edited February 2011
    I'd recommend contacting your Department of Immigration and Citizenship and asking them if they have any additional insight. This is not a cut-and-dry situation, and you have a lot of options and outcomes to consider. I'm sure they deal with this type of thing all the time, and can at least let you know your legal avenues, from an immigration/citizenship perspective.

    Also, you'll probably want to get a lawyer. Seriously.


    PS - This is definitely not the end of the world. Stay in communication and under no circumstances should you assume that the child is actually yours. Do not make any promises with regards to support or future plans until you can clear up the issue of parentage.

    Inquisitor77 on
  • MushroomStickMushroomStick Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    How long is it before you can get a paternity test? I ask because the results would greatly affect how I would handle such a situation if it were me.

    MushroomStick on
  • ceresceres When the last moon is cast over the last star of morning And the future has past without even a last desperate warningRegistered User, Moderator Mod Emeritus
    edited February 2011
    Regardless, if she doesn't want to do it she doesn't and you can't make her and should never, ever try. It's unlikely if she found a safe, legal clinic she'd lose her fertility, but nothing in this crazy world is certain, and it doesn't sound like that's her only qualm.

    The only thing you can decide (assuming paternity test comes back yours) is how involved you want to be as a parent, if at all, if she decides to keep it. The decision to have or not have an abortion MUST come from her. Don't be that guy. Don't pressure her.

    ceres on
    And it seems like all is dying, and would leave the world to mourn
  • KistraKistra Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    Kraut wrote: »
    Now, here's the complicated part. She believes abortion is murder and is morally against it. She has done the procedure once, just last year, out of necessity (from another guy) and she couldn't bear the guilt and sorrow from that. She said recently she won't able to live with herself if she does it again, but then implied today that she'd consider it ONLY if there's basically no chance she'd go barren from it.

    The only alternative is c, that I end my life, my dreams, my job, my family, everything to fix a stupid mistake of two young fools.
    The two bolded parts make her sound really conflicted and confused about abortion. Is she religious? Do you have any organizations like this: http://rcrc.org/ where she could talk to clergy members about abortion without being judged so that she can clarify her values around abortion and fertility?

    This needs to be her decision. You can (and ideally should) be there to help her find information, help her access advice or values clarification, and help her access providers if she decides that is what she wants. However, you can't make this decision for her and you shouldn't try. Having said that, there are international aid organizations that will help women get access to medication abortions in countries where it is illegal, but only through 9 weeks, so you might try to find her some non-judgemental values clarification ASAP so that she can make an informed decision while all of her options are still open.

    On a second, related note, if she does decide to continue the pregnancy, having a child does not magically end your life. You guys can raise a child together (ie both as parents) even at a distance and not in a relationship. People finish school, chase dream jobs, and enjoy good relationships with their family even after having children in less than ideal circumstances.

    I also don't know if adoption is a "thing" in Indonesia, but it may be something to consider since it sounds like she is against abortion but isn't interested in raising a child either.

    Kistra on
    Animal Crossing: City Folk Lissa in Filmore 3179-9580-0076
  • KrautKraut Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    Hi, guys. Thanks for the advice so far. I've spoken to an anonymous hotline who told me some things, some of which were similar to some suggestions posted here. A very nice woman on the line told me a number of things:

    - She might be lying about the pregnancy altogether (in which case I should wait another three months to call her bluff. The problem with this is of course that makes it too late for safe abortion if its true which I really do think it is). She told me to hold off on seeking legal advice, or doing anything really, at this point.

    - She might be lying about it being MY baby. There's no way to really prove that until it's born. However, I have known this girl for a while as a friend and I'm inclined to believe her when she says she hasn't been involved with anyone else. However, the woman on the hotline told me I have to wary about this and my logic agrees with her.

    - She might be using me to try and obtain Australian citizenship. That's what it appears, and I know why from an outside perspective this situation looks like one of those classic con stories. The woman on the hotline asked me if I'd ever met her family or visited her house. Truthfully I haven't, but I have seen her house via skype video, driven in her car (she has her own Mercedes so she's hardly poor) and I'm also friends with a few other friends of hers who live in Australia (some of who are Australian).

    Additionally she's said she wants nothing from me. No money, no obligation. However, she's unstable and unpredictable and what she says one day changes the next. Last night she offered to sign legal papers absolving me from any responsibility, but today she's demanding I be there for her and offer emotional support (despite my "support" being someone for her to abuse and tell how much she hates me).

    - She (the hotline woman) pointed out the dangers of abortion and told me under no circumstances should I be too directly involved in assisting with that (in the form of organising visas or travelling) as that could land me into all kinds of other trouble. I still think I should be trying to help her find options, of course, and will. The problem is it's really hard and dangerous to do that kind of thing in Indonesia. It could land her in jail if busted. She told me recently that she found out about some massage abortion technique that she wanted to look into. I told her I'd look into it.

    She (the hotline woman) recommended I take a break from her, tell her to get back to me in three months with an ultrasound proving her pregnancy, and to just turn off my phone after that. I've done that but I told her I wasn't just cutting her loose, that I needed some time to think and get my shit together and approach this logically. On the other hand I realise time is very much of the essence and I can't afford to take too long if we still want options open.

    I feel terrible about turning my phone off, but I can't think straight when she's keeping me up all night and stressing me to the point where I had to take the day off work and see a doctor, and I think one of us needs to be thinking straight.
    The two bolded parts make her sound really conflicted and confused about abortion. Is she religious? Do you have any organizations like this: http://rcrc.org/ where she could talk to clergy members about abortion without being judged so that she can clarify her values around abortion and fertility?

    This needs to be her decision. You can (and ideally should) be there to help her find information, help her access advice or values clarification, and help her access providers if she decides that is what she wants. However, you can't make this decision for her and you shouldn't try. Having said that, there are international aid organizations that will help women get access to medication abortions in countries where it is illegal, but only through 9 weeks, so you might try to find her some non-judgemental values clarification ASAP so that she can make an informed decision while all of her options are still open.

    On a second, related note, if she does decide to continue the pregnancy, having a child does not magically end your life. You guys can raise a child together (ie both as parents) even at a distance and not in a relationship. People finish school, chase dream jobs, and enjoy good relationships with their family even after having children in less than ideal circumstances.

    I also don't know if adoption is a "thing" in Indonesia, but it may be something to consider since it sounds like she is against abortion but isn't interested in raising a child either.

    Yes, she is conflicted and even said so that one day she'll say one thing and say another thing the next. That's part of why she's so unstable.

    She's a muslim, but to me she's never seemed like a serious one. I've never seen her wear a veil or anything and she dresses like Western women. She appreciates jokes about religion and even reads atheist books like The God Delusion out of curiosity.

    I completely accept that it's 100% her decision to abort or not and would never try to force her (however, I do strongly, strongly tell her to think things through). The problem is that she believes it's killing a baby and I don't, and that's the kind of argument that's pointless to even begin. I'll never be able to convince her that abortion isn't murder and I don't intend to try.

    I have suggested adoption and she's against it because she wants to raise it. She's very much into the idea of raising children. Unfortunately, I'm very much against it (yes, I should have thought of that before not using a condom. I'm a fucking idiot). I really honestly don't want anything to do with raising a child. It might sound cowardly but the thought makes me sick to my stomach.

    Quite possibly, but it requires certain documentation regarding finances that I believe her employer and possibly father (who I should mention is a frankly scary serious muslim) would have to provide. If he found out about this (and he will soon enough, I guess), the entire situation would get a lot more complicated, fast.

    Kraut on
  • ImprovoloneImprovolone Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    Separate emotion from the equation, pay attention to the logic of the situation. Want to get through this? Stop thinking with irrational emotions.
    Fishy things smell fishy. Follow up on them. If that insults her? Who fucking cares. You have rights to these answers.

    Also, having a kid doesn't have to ruin your life. Start thinking about what you'd be comfortable with in terms of how involved you are with this potential child.

    Improvolone on
    Voice actor for hire. My time is free if your project is!
  • RikushixRikushix VancouverRegistered User regular
    edited February 2011
    I'm not sure if you mentioned this explicitly earlier but I didn't read anything to this effect: assuming this is all real (she's really pregnant, you're really the father, etc) has she explicitly said that you need to come to indonesia and raise the child with her, or has that just been implied in the general panic since she told you she was pregnant?

    Rikushix on
    StKbT.jpg
  • CelestialBadgerCelestialBadger Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    What is this hotline you called? The advice sounds dubious to me. Waiting 3 months would make it very hard to get an abortion, even in Australia. Abortion is not particularly dangerous (in a country where it is legal, like Australia - obviously in Indonesia it is dangerous), so why did your Australian hotline lady say it was so dangerous? Was it an anti-abortion hotline (some of them say they are impartial but are actually funded by anti-abortion charities.) Go to a real family planning clinic on your own as soon as possible and get them to answer your questions properly.

    CelestialBadger on
  • MonoxideMonoxide Registered User, ClubPA regular
    edited February 2011
    She has done the procedure once, just last year, out of necessity (from another guy) and she couldn't bear the guilt and sorrow from that. She said recently she won't able to live with herself if she does it again, but then implied today that she'd consider it ONLY if there's basically no chance she'd go barren from it.

    Even if such a procedure existed, she certainly can't get it in Indonesia (it's illegal).

    I'm confused. She had an abortion once last year but is now unable to find a place to have one done and it's illegal in Indonesia?

    Did the law change in the past 12 months or what's the deal here

    Monoxide on
  • VisionOfClarityVisionOfClarity Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    It sounds like she had one back alley abortion and would prefer not to do something so incredibly risky again & you can't blame her for that.

    VisionOfClarity on
  • OnTheLastCastleOnTheLastCastle let's keep it haimish for the peripatetic Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    Yeah, like VoC said it has been illegal for there for quite a while. Very conservative society. There are still lots of abortions going on though because... that's how the world works.

    OnTheLastCastle on
  • CelestialBadgerCelestialBadger Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    Maybe she could arrive on a tourist visa and get a safe abortion in Australia. You'd probably need real legal advice before doing this, though, as it might be illegal in any number of ways.

    CelestialBadger on
  • SneakertSneakert Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    When I read all of this I don't trust her one bit. She allready HAD an abortion and felt so super guilty so she went and had unprotected sex AGAIN?

    Either way: DONT HELP HER GET AN ABORTION.

    Sneakert on
  • VisionOfClarityVisionOfClarity Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    Maybe she could arrive on a tourist visa and get a safe abortion in Australia. You'd probably need real legal advice before doing this, though, as it might be illegal in any number of ways.

    It would be completely illegal. She would have to get the medical visa I posted earlier.

    VisionOfClarity on
  • dzenithdzenith Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    Send her a coat hanger.

    dzenith on
  • KistraKistra Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    I'm very confused by the hotline lady. Some of the points she brought up are valid and other ones are just really weird - and I agree it kinda sounds like you got tricked into calling a crisis pregnancy center type of hotline.

    If you want proof that the girl is pregnant, why not ask for an ultrasound now, why wait for 3 months? Waiting that long eliminates the option that you are hoping for.

    I really don't know the laws in your part of the world, but if Australia has a medical visa why would it be dangerous for you to help her get it?

    The girl sounds scared, panicky and seriously unsure of how she feels. Do you know if she has contacted the indonesian branch of planned parenthood? I know the US and Canadian ones have trained people that can do values clarification over the phone and that might help her feel more comfortable and more confidant with whatever decision she makes.

    Kistra on
    Animal Crossing: City Folk Lissa in Filmore 3179-9580-0076
  • VisionOfClarityVisionOfClarity Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    It sounds like this girl is really not comfortable with an abortion. She just wants to be not pregnant and goes back and forth about the procedure. The op should not keep pressuring her about an abortion. If anything he should give her the info on the medical visa and leave it at that.

    VisionOfClarity on
  • CelestialBadgerCelestialBadger Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    Kistra wrote: »
    Do you know if she has contacted the indonesian branch of planned parenthood?

    Abortion is illegal in Indonesia, so there would be no local equivalent of Planned Parenthood. This is the cause of the pickle that these two people are currently in. She is afraid to go to a backstreet abortionist because of the risk.

    Perhaps she could call the Australian equivalent of Planned Parenthood (what is it?) and get advice on medical visas.

    CelestialBadger on
  • KistraKistra Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    Kistra wrote: »
    Do you know if she has contacted the indonesian branch of planned parenthood?

    Abortion is illegal in Indonesia, so there would be no local equivalent of Planned Parenthood. This is the cause of the pickle that these two people are currently in. She is afraid to go to a backstreet abortionist because of the risk.

    Perhaps she could call the Australian equivalent of Planned Parenthood (what is it?) and get advice on medical visas.

    That is incorrect. There is an Indonesian branch of Planned Parenthood, they do a lot more than just abortions everywhere that they exist and therefore they are still useful and still exist in places where abortion is illegal.

    http://www.ippf.org/en/Where/id.htm

    Kistra on
    Animal Crossing: City Folk Lissa in Filmore 3179-9580-0076
  • The CatThe Cat Registered User, ClubPA regular
    edited February 2011
    What is this hotline you called? The advice sounds dubious to me. Waiting 3 months would make it very hard to get an abortion, even in Australia. Abortion is not particularly dangerous (in a country where it is legal, like Australia - obviously in Indonesia it is dangerous), so why did your Australian hotline lady say it was so dangerous? Was it an anti-abortion hotline (some of them say they are impartial but are actually funded by anti-abortion charities.) Go to a real family planning clinic on your own as soon as possible and get them to answer your questions properly.

    There's only one family planning hotline in Aus, and its government funded, so it should be impartial, but our conservative party pulled some backroom funding shenanigans that mean its almost entirely staffed by religious groups at present. If that's the line the OP called, there's a good chance he was indeed lied to.

    OP, just FYI a safe, legal abortion in a developed-world medical system is actually several orders of magnitude safer than continuing the pregnancy. In Indonesia, its lucky she didn't die from a perforated uterus the first time around D:

    The medical visa posted earlier may get her into the country, provided she can demonstrate she has the money. However, I'm not sure if foreign nationals can actually get abortions here. Possibly in Victoria, maybe in New South Wales, almost certainly not in Queensland. If she can, it'll be full price, because she's not a citizen and therefore can't make a Medicare claim. You'll need to check your state legislation.

    But yeah, do what the people here have said and figure out exactly how much you're really connected to this before you explore further options.

    The Cat on
    tmsig.jpg
  • KrautKraut Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    I've just got off the phone to her after collecting some options so I could state them in a factual manner. I stayed calm throughout the call, ignoring her emotional baiting, and told her about the medical visa linked here, the Indonesian Planned Parency Association, and to stay away from dodgy massage abortion as it sounds traumatic, painful, and unsafe.

    Throughout the call she was "telling me what I want to hear", that she's just a slut who blackmails guys and I shouldn't worry because she'll just find another guy this week and tell him it's his. This is because I said earlier that I was advised anonymously that I couldn't accept what she said as truth. I ignored this and told her if she had any questions concerning the options I gave her she can contact me by email and I'd call her. I also told her I'd continue to look for more options. She wanted to continue abusing me at this point so I hung up and turned off my phone again.

    To answer some questions -

    The hotline I called earlier was Pregnancy Counselling Australia - http://www.pregnancycounselling.com.au/
    They also recommended I call the Men's Line Australia - http://www.menslineaus.org.au/ though I haven't called them yet. I may do so soon.

    Regarding her previous abortion, that was done while she was studying here in Australia. She got proper surgery at a real clinic.

    It's worth noting that she's now EXTREMELY upset that I questioned the fact the baby is mine. She now insists I called her a blackmailing prostitute and wants me to apologise. In fact, her exact email sent a few minutes ago after I called her:

    "i dont want anything. i just wanna hear u say sorry. for calling me prostitute. thats it. and what i do with my life is my own business. i wont ask u to take the responsibily"

    The problem is,
    - While SHE might not ask me to take responsibility, her father (who scares the shit out of me) sure as hell might have something to say about it. Also, she herself said she changes her mind all the time. So what's to say she won't ask later?
    - This girl was my friend. Before all this shit happened, a really good friend who I cared about a lot. I don't want her to fuck up her life (especially on account of something I had a part in causing).

    I'm not really sure what to do at this point. I'm just leaving my phone off (though I let her know she can contact me if she has something to say to me that isn't abuse) and I guess the ball is in her park. Is there anything else I could/should do?

    Kraut on
  • SneakertSneakert Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    - Buy condoms and make sure you always have one on your person.
    - Get checked out for STD's
    - Stop contacting her, don't agree to anything and don't give her money.

    Sneakert on
  • ceresceres When the last moon is cast over the last star of morning And the future has past without even a last desperate warningRegistered User, Moderator Mod Emeritus
    edited February 2011
    If she was that good a friend and you knew her well before this, that's information that would have been good for us to have. You kind of played her off as someone you don't know that well. That's going to change the nature of the advice you get. :/

    Of course she's going to be hurt. If she is pregnant and it is yours and she really liked you, this is going to be terrible for her, and to hear you say those things... if it were me, you certainly wouldn't have to worry about future contact, or coming anywhere near a baby of mine. If this is all the case, think about it from her perspective. I really wouldn't say she's abusing you, here. You've decided you don't trust her; perhaps rightly so, or perhaps you let your fear of the situation cloud your previous certainty that she was a nice girl. What's she supposed to do? You had the sex too, this is only about 50% her fault.

    You've made it pretty clear that you want nothing to do with a baby or her. Painfully clear. You've given her the information you wanted to give her, and since that's all you're planning to do you should leave her alone, and let her move on.

    ceres on
    And it seems like all is dying, and would leave the world to mourn
  • KrautKraut Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    ceres wrote: »
    If she was that good a friend and you knew her well before this, that's information that would have been good for us to have. You kind of played her off as someone you don't know that well. That's going to change the nature of the advice you get. :/

    Of course she's going to be hurt. If she is pregnant and it is yours and she really liked you, this is going to be terrible for her, and to hear you say those things... if it were me, you certainly wouldn't have to worry about future contact, or coming anywhere near a baby of mine. If this is all the case, think about it from her perspective. I really wouldn't say she's abusing you, here. You've decided you don't trust her; perhaps rightly so, or perhaps you let your fear of the situation cloud your previous certainty that she was a nice girl. What's she supposed to do? You had the sex too, this is only about 50% her fault.

    You've made it pretty clear that you want nothing to do with a baby or her. Painfully clear. You've given her the information you wanted to give her, and since that's all you're planning to do you should leave her alone, and let her move on.

    Sorry, didn't mean to be unclear. To be precise, I met her about late August 2010. We only met in person in Australia a couple of times (friend of a friend), then she moved back to Indonesia and we just chatted online after that and developed what I would describe as a close friend relationship.

    What happened with me questioning the baby's paternity was a direct result of me doing what the hotline told me to do because I'm scared and don't know what to do. I don't personally believe someone else is the father (and have told her that).

    It's not really that I don't (didn't) want anything to do with her, it's just that a baby at this point is just something I can't cope with. I realise that may sound weak, but I have to be honest here. I don't want kids.

    Just to be totally clear: Yes, I am an idiot. I have no goddamn clue what I'm doing and am totally out of my league with dealing with this kind of situation and I'm just doing the best I know how to.

    Kraut on
  • AvicusAvicus Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    I agree with Ceres. You have hurt her. I recommend that you don't talk to her for a little while, let her calm down, and let yourself calm down as well.

    You have made it clear that she does not want an abortion. She is morally opposed and worries about the physical consequences as well. She most likely changes her mind on occasion because she feels overwhelming pressure pushing her towards it. If someone is morally opposed to abortion, you have no right to "convince" them otherwise.

    From what I can see, she must feel like an absolute wreck at the moment. First she is pregnant and it is messing with her hormones. Secondly the father of the child has made it painfully obvious that he considers abortion to be the number 1 option where it is the last for her. Thirdly the father has also questioned if he is even the father. Not only does she have to deal with this but she wouldn't even have the support of her family because of her religious father. She is all alone with some very difficult choices to make.

    One of my exes (who I still talk to) recently got an abortion when she found out she was pregnant two weeks after the relationship ended. She is against abortion but allowed herself to be pressured into it because she didn't want to 'ruin the father's life'. Now, 3 months later, she is suffering from severe depression. She believes it was one of the biggest mistakes of her life.

    Avicus on
    stephen_coop.gifkim_coop.gifscott_guitar.gif
  • ceresceres When the last moon is cast over the last star of morning And the future has past without even a last desperate warningRegistered User, Moderator Mod Emeritus
    edited February 2011
    Now you're shifting blame for your words to this hotline. I know you're scared. I know you don't want kids. But you did the thing you did and now there quite probably is one, so I suggest you work it out. I guarantee you that your life is not looking nearly as screwed up as hers is right now, so at the very least you should consider putting away your cross.

    You have two choices here, assuming you trust her: never talk to her again, or reopen the lines of communication, apologize for being insensitive, and try to find out what she wants from you. Be up-front about the amount of involvement you want, even if that's none at all. If this is real, you need communicate and turning off your phone and saying "talk to the hand" is not really an acceptable way to deal with it.

    ceres on
    And it seems like all is dying, and would leave the world to mourn
  • Judge Joe BrownJudge Joe Brown Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    Ceres, I don't think he's shifting blame. He's here asking for advice. He's rationalizing his actions based on the limited resources he has. I would have done similar in his situation. Saying that he's made it "painfully obvious" that he doesn't want anything to do with the baby is a very vindictive statement, and I'm disappointed that you see his situation as so black and white.

    Telling him that shutting down the lines of communication is unacceptable, having gotten that advice directly from his only real line of support (recall that he is walking a legal minefield, where inaction is absolutely appropriate and recommended thus far), seems judgmental at best and condescending at worst.

    Judge Joe Brown on
  • MushroomStickMushroomStick Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    Did I miss a part where it was determined that the girl is definitely pregnant? Otherwise, a little bit of googling came up with the Thai girlfriend pregnancy scam.

    MushroomStick on
  • ceresceres When the last moon is cast over the last star of morning And the future has past without even a last desperate warningRegistered User, Moderator Mod Emeritus
    edited February 2011
    Well, operating under the assumption that the OP actually does know this girl well enough to trust her (and my posts have several qualifiers to that effect), repeating dispassionately the things they told him and then deciding when she gets emotional about it that she's just being "abusive" and cutting her off is actually a pretty nasty way to respond. Doing so AND THEN saying "oh but the hotline told me to" with no real indication that he plans to apologize for hurting a friend's feelings is very much shifting blame for his words. The issue I take with the whole thing is not the fear but the seeming lack of interest in taking responsibility for his actions or behavior. From the sound of it he said some very nasty things. Trying to work out ways to pressure a girl who thinks abortion is wrong into having one? I would say painfully obvious.

    On the other hand, my post does actually contain advice, and yours does not, nor have you given any in this thread. You might want to pick a different high horse on which to ride into these things.

    ceres on
    And it seems like all is dying, and would leave the world to mourn
  • Judge Joe BrownJudge Joe Brown Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    I'm just sitting here reading a thread where I expected the OP to get flamed into the ground, but he has actually done far more than what most individuals would have done. He is dealing with someone who seems borderline psychotic (justifiably so, some might say).

    If you want the subtext here (read: advice), then here it is: I don't think that it's as simple as just ignore her completely and move on or go back to her and apologize for x. He should be upfront, as you said, but I don't see anywhere here where he hasn't been (if he has been completely honest with us). He tried the advice he's given, and he's still hitting a brick wall communicating properly with this girl.

    I can't imagine that he would be able to just call her up, tell her he understands her concerns Dr. Phil style, and everything will be peaches. Doesn't ring true based on the information thus far.

    Judge Joe Brown on
  • SarcastroSarcastro Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    Step 1: Do something stupid with lifelong consequences.
    Step 2: Refuse to man up, and insist your pregnant ladyfriend is a lying, blackmailing slut.
    Step 3: ????
    Step 4: Abortion!

    Wow. Just... wow. The fuck happened up in here, guys?

    K, so like step one is done. Congratulations, that was pretty dumb. And yes, some of the stupid things one does can affect the rest of your life. I left my copy of What to Expect While You're the Father of an Love-Child in Indonesia on the plane, but basically, it goes something like this:

    Grow a pair. Yes, it's scary, and horrifying and it's traumatic and shit's all blowed up. Fucking breathe, already. All that fear and uncertainty? Ya, that's going on for two people about now. So who are you going to play in the movie of your life? Are you going to be the panicky private who charges in early and bungles everything up, or the guy who takes a while to form an actual plan with an actual strategy while adapting to the situation at hand?

    So here's what you'll want to do; apologize for losing your shit. Denial is one of the first five stages, and you hit that shit up with a vengence. Soon you'll hit anger (sounds like you have) then bargaining, then depression, then acceptance. Sound familiar? Ya, its the five stages of loss. Because you just lost your old life.

    That guy five days ago? Ya, that guy died. Freak accident, totally preventable, very sad. Now the funny thing about that guy, is that he doesn't really get he's dead yet. He's still screaming in the carfire of his life, trying to hang onto what he had. The thrashing about will continue, until he finally succumbs to the situation, and just gives in.

    Fortunately for you, it's not actually your body, it's just an old way of being. Now, you'll have a new way of being. The differences may not be all that much, or maybe the new you will be substantially different. either way, you can't fight change. Well, you can, but you're going to lose. And the interesting thing about taking on that fight any way, is that the more you fight, the worse the position you'll be in when you are finally forced to accept it.

    All this bullshit up in the past few pages? You know, where you had some bad news, panicked like a little girl and made everything way, way worse? That's you being in an even worse position by failing to adapt to change appropriately. It's not your fault, you only have the tools you're given, but still. Worse. It's time to stop, drop, and roll, is what I'm getting at here.

    So what to do? The first is to take it on faith that your situation is occuring. Yes, indeed, the car is on fire. It's not some psuedo-fire, it's not a trick to get you buy a new car; all that shit is entirely irrelevant. Deal with the here and now. You have: One friend in trouble. One possible life-long obligation. One social role to pick and perform.

    And that's it. You don't have to move anywhere, or quit school, or drop everything and start sending cheques, get married, anything. That shit is optional. All kinds of people including yourself will tell you what you should or shouldn't do. It's all just an opinion, and none of it really matters. In the end, you'll get to choose who you want to be. Your reaction is in your hands. It always is.

    So after apologizing for being a hurtful dumbass, discuss what you need to do in the next month. 1 month. Are you going to be there for phone calls? Can she talk to you about how goddamn terrifying this whole thing is? What role do you want to play? Its going to be give and take, options explored, and she's going to have her own ideas as well.

    I suppose at this time, it's prudent to mention the possibility of fakery. It's not impossible, but it is not very likely. Assume true until proven otherwise. That's the high road. Taking people at face value, especially friends is an important part of being a positive social creature. Yes, there are people out there who will fuck you over and try to scam you, but they are in a very small minority, and the odds say that she is what she says she is. All you have to lose at this moment in time is moral support, and if someone is going through these kinds of unbeleiveable lengths just to get a hug and a shoulder pat, fucking just give them a hug already.

    When the month ends, there will be new things for the next month. Doctor's visits, family issues, etc. Take each thing one step at a time, and remember that you always have the power to choose. Because of the distance, you have a lot more power over the situation than she does. Keep that in mind- she has no other alternative than to weather out the situation, while you have all kinds of ways to opt out. Respect that, and try to see it from her point of view.

    So- in short. Quit panicking. Different does not mean bad, it just means different. For fucks sake, apologize already. Decide what role you will play for the next four weeks, and stick to that. Clean as you go, deal as it comes. It'll all get much clearer as time goes on. You'll adjust, you'll adapt, and you'll find your life just keeps on ticking. It always does.

    Sarcastro on
  • BowenBowen Sup? Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    Did I miss a part where it was determined that the girl is definitely pregnant? Otherwise, a little bit of googling came up with the Thai girlfriend pregnancy scam.

    Wow I'm having a hard time believing this website.

    Is it impossible to locate this girl to have her tested and then have the baby, when/if delivered, tested for paternity? I'd be less than enthused about sending money internationally with something I can't confirm face to face, I'd be skeptical as well. Though all the slut shaming and bashing her are not helpful.

    Bowen on
  • CelestialBadgerCelestialBadger Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    I'm just sitting here reading a thread where I expected the OP to get flamed into the ground, but he has actually done far more than what most individuals would have done. He is dealing with someone who seems borderline psychotic (justifiably so, some might say).

    She sounds more crazy panicking than psychotic. Who wouldn't be? She just screwed up her life. She didn't even get pregnant with a local guy who could be made to pay child support - she is utterly dependent on the OP's good will to help her. It also sounds as if she has a very traditional father who might make her life a misery for "being a slut." Panicking like hell in that situation is a response only to be expected, and almost rational. This is not a little mistake. She just made the biggest mistake of her life. You can bet she is yelling and panicking. Let's not judge her for that.

    I say the OP has a moral duty to help her out financially with the baby - he should get a DNA test if he is doubtful that he is the father. She might even get thrown out of the house if her parents are as traditional as he says. The OP's life is not ruined. He is not going to suffer shame for being pregnant out of wedlock in a traditional society. He does not risk being kicked out his house. I doubt that he can be made to pay child support unless he wants to, due to being in a different country. He needs to be the cool head, because he is not in such a hellish situation as the mother. His situation is bad but not dire. Hers is dire.

    CelestialBadger on
  • DisrupterDisrupter Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    It sounds like neither you or her really want this baby to be happening. Understandably so. But chances are it is, so...really you have an obligation to do the right thing and not leave a baby and woman without the father involved at all.

    However, the abortion angle still confuses me. I think you are confused to. No, you should not convince her to have an abortion. However if shes had one before, it seems to me that chances are she isnt against them, or even her having one, but more shes scared to do a risky proceedure again. So, perhaps when both of you get your act together and get to talking again instead of her being stupid and taking your "are we sure its mine?" as an insult and cutting off communication, and you stop taking her rashness as an excuse to wash your hands of the situation you can figure out exactly why she doesnt want to have one and go from there.

    Beyond that, adoption may be an option too. I personally see no reason a baby should be born and raised into a situation where nobody wants it. But thats something she and you need to figure out.

    I dont have advice for confirming its yours, but I do feel thats important. I mean, yes she can be defensive and be all "your calling me a slut!" but you have every right to know for sure its yours. Thats a delicate issue, that maybe you need to hold off on discussing until you just talk to her, are there for her, and help her figure out what shes going to do next.

    Disrupter on
    616610-1.png
  • witch_iewitch_ie Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    One thing to note about really difficult situations like this - yes it's important to be honest, but that does not mean that you have to tell her every little thing that crosses your mind about this situation...when you do start communicating with her again, try to put a constructive filter on what you say and what you do. Learn from your mistakes (and there have been many) in this situation and try to forecast the consequences before acting or speaking.

    How did you expect her to react when dropping the not-so-subtle hint that she could be lying about it being your baby or being pregnant? Really - think about it. What was the purpose of bringing that up at all if you believe she's telling the truth?

    You've also provided her with a lot of options for how she could have an abortion when while she's conflicted about what to do, she's stated pretty clearly that she doesn't really want to have one for any number of reasons. Have you also provided her with information regarding her options if she choses to keep the baby? Including but not limited to adoption, raising it on her own, raising it with differing levels of support for you?

    Have you taken the time to just listen and let her talk this out with you? I don't mean, listening to what she says and trying to respond with a solution or options, but just listening. Echoing Sarcastro's excellent post, it sounds like she's just looking for some moral support right now. Is there any reason you can't or shouldn't give that to her?

    witch_ie on
  • KrautKraut Registered User regular
    edited February 2011
    One thing to note about really difficult situations like this - yes it's important to be honest, but that does not mean that you have to tell her every little thing that crosses your mind about this situation...when you do start communicating with her again, try to put a constructive filter on what you say and what you do. Learn from your mistakes (and there have been many) in this situation and try to forecast the consequences before acting or speaking.

    How did you expect her to react when dropping the not-so-subtle hint that she could be lying about it being your baby or being pregnant? Really - think about it. What was the purpose of bringing that up at all if you believe she's telling the truth?

    Yeah, that was pretty dumb. I was in shock and saying what the hotline told me to say without thinking of how it would make her feel. I've apologised profusely for that.
    You've also provided her with a lot of options for how she could have an abortion when while she's conflicted about what to do, she's stated pretty clearly that she doesn't really want to have one for any number of reasons. Have you also provided her with information regarding her options if she choses to keep the baby? Including but not limited to adoption, raising it on her own, raising it with differing levels of support for you?

    I have. Actually, what I'm working on now is trying to get her to decide on what option she wants to pursue (that is, abortion or keeping) because at the moment she's only 60-40 in favour of keeping. I told her we'd try and raise that higher so she can feel she's making the right decision in keeping it. She is emphatically opposed to putting the baby up for adoption, however and would prefer to raise it herself.

    Then she asks me what I would do if she kept it. It breaks my heart that I have to tell her the truth, that I don't want to be directly or financially involved with raising a child. I know it hurts her so much to hear me say that. Am I wrong for saying as much? Should I be telling her I'll be there with her, that I'll send money (despite the fact I'm a student with a work experience job living with my parents), that I'll be involved somehow?

    If she does keep it she wants me to be there (as in physically present) when she gives birth. The main part of that that worries me is that her fundamentalist muslim father will likely try to murder me if he sees me. That's not hyperbole. I'm completely serious when I say the man scares the shit out of me (he also owns a revolver). I've heard enough about him to know he'll want revenge (she even agrees with me on that point), and he's extremely (EXTREMELY) protective of his daughter. With good reason, I suppose, in retrospect.
    Have you taken the time to just listen and let her talk this out with you? I don't mean, listening to what she says and trying to respond with a solution or options, but just listening. Echoing Sarcastro's excellent post, it sounds like she's just looking for some moral support right now. Is there any reason you can't or shouldn't give that to her?

    No reason at all, and I'm now doing so the best I can. We've both calmed down a lot, and we can talk somewhat rationally about things.

    Regarding abortion: Safe, clinical abortion is decidedly impossible. The two problems with abortion in Australia is
    a) that she'd need to take at least two weeks off her (still new) job, which wouldn't be possible without sacrificing the job. She isn't willing to sacrifice this job.
    b) She'd need to prove she has the finances to back the surgery, the cost of living, and the plane ticket(probably in the vicinity of 3-4 grand AUD). Neither of us have that kind of money (we're both poor. Her father is rich by Indonesian standards, but he can't know about this yet) though I am being paid soon which should barely cover that. Doesn't help problem a, though.

    She said she's taking some period regulation pills called EM Kapsul. She doesn't expect it to work, but she'll know in about a week. If that doesn't work she's set on trying the massage thing if she decides to go the abortion route.
    I say the OP has a moral duty to help her out financially with the baby - he should get a DNA test if he is doubtful that he is the father. She might even get thrown out of the house if her parents are as traditional as he says. The OP's life is not ruined. He is not going to suffer shame for being pregnant out of wedlock in a traditional society. He does not risk being kicked out his house. I doubt that he can be made to pay child support unless he wants to, due to being in a different country. He needs to be the cool head, because he is not in such a hellish situation as the mother. His situation is bad but not dire. Hers is dire.

    I've asked her what would (will) happen when her father finds out. Her father is traditionalist, but he's also extremely protective of her and she says he would help her raise it. It's out of the question that she'd be thrown out, her father loves her too fiercely for that. It's more likely he'd find her a quick arranged husband to be the replacement father for it.
    So after apologizing for being a hurtful dumbass, discuss what you need to do in the next month. 1 month. Are you going to be there for phone calls? Can she talk to you about how goddamn terrifying this whole thing is? What role do you want to play? Its going to be give and take, options explored, and she's going to have her own ideas as well.

    I have indeed apologised for being a hurtful dumbass. In those exact words, actually, and in many others. I have told her I'm here always for her phone calls and for emotional support.

    What I need to know is if I'm a terrible person if I refuse to offer financial or upbringing support of any kind.
    I have trouble paying the upkeep of my car and studies, let alone child support. I suppose this is where I need to seek legal advice if things continue. The moral duty is what's tearing me up inside.

    The other problem is my own parents. They're fairly fundamentalist catholics themselves (I'm atheist) and they would flip their shit if they found out about this. Is it even possible to keep this a secret from them forever?

    What's clear to me is that I need professional help. What kind of professional should I be looking for, a psychologist? Psychiatrist? Or some other kind of counsellor? Can anyone recommend me someone I can talk to as some kind of lifeline? I feel like I'm all alone and desperately need someone in person I can talk to about this.

    Kraut on
Sign In or Register to comment.