I'm sad I didn't get to replace Lucedes (curse you for forgetting about me kime!!!!!1), I would have been 2 for 2 on replacing Lucedes and winning gloriously.
Liked that the villagers had a important function beyond the vote (the point allocation mechanic)
Liked that the mafia had a choice between one super kill and using their variety of upgradable abilities, the high number of potential guards made this a very important choice each day
Enjoyed the "choose your own role" nature of the specials
Liked that it wasn't immediately apparent what abilities you'd get for investing in a your personal pools
Loved the ability to give special abilities to other players (helps keep the 'vanilla' players in the mix)
Not sure about the miller/thrall. That could end very badly combined with the ability to grant abilities to other players. Since it didn't come up, can't say whether it's really a bad thing or not.
Flavor feedback
Good background fluff
Narration was usually up super fast, which is always appreciated
It was cool having a host for each side, with them sparring in the narration and occasionally during the day
I think the minigames were a nice addition, and the reward were well balanced
Posts
It's okay though, because this was tons of fun to watch.
Also, I totally pwn you all at Music Catch:
I used to be pretty obsessed with those games
You're darn lucky that the vote went first, because if your goosery had lead to a mafia, or even host, victory. Grudged for life.
Confusion will be my epitaph
Is that a challenge?
now I have to start playing again
let's be tag-team partners
seriously
even when you're rawkking badguy
Liked that the villagers had a important function beyond the vote (the point allocation mechanic)
Liked that the mafia had a choice between one super kill and using their variety of upgradable abilities, the high number of potential guards made this a very important choice each day
Enjoyed the "choose your own role" nature of the specials
Liked that it wasn't immediately apparent what abilities you'd get for investing in a your personal pools
Loved the ability to give special abilities to other players (helps keep the 'vanilla' players in the mix)
Not sure about the miller/thrall. That could end very badly combined with the ability to grant abilities to other players. Since it didn't come up, can't say whether it's really a bad thing or not.
Flavor feedback
Good background fluff
Narration was usually up super fast, which is always appreciated
It was cool having a host for each side, with them sparring in the narration and occasionally during the day
I think the minigames were a nice addition, and the reward were well balanced
The Black Hole of Cygnus X-1