The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.
I watched Le Samourai and Blade Runner (which are, admittedly, not traditional noir as far as I know) and got really interested. Can anybody recommend me some good examples of film noir? Less traditional examples are welcomed too.
Well, Brick (from 2005) is really good, and stars Joseph Gordon-Levitt from Ten Things I Hate About You, 500 Days of Summer, and Inception. It's basically hardboiled detective drama...in a high school setting. Hardboiled and Noir are very similar genres.
Anyway, I was damned impressed with Brick. I'll leave it to others to offer other suggestions.
Dark City - make sure to get the director's cut, or turn the sound off until Kiefer Sutherland appears, because the studio added a stupid speech that explains the entire premise for the cinematic cut.
It's from 1998 and firmly in the neo-noir camp, sci-fi premise or not.
Veronica Mars. Has a noir sensibility disguised as a high school drama.
The idea that your vote is a moral statement about you or who you vote for is some backwards ass libertarian nonsense. Your vote is about society. Vote to protect the vulnerable.
0
EshTending bar. FFXIV. Motorcycles.Portland, ORRegistered Userregular
edited July 2011
Authors: Jim Thompson, Dashiell Hammett, David Goodis, Chester Himes. Anything by those four is going to be great.
Movies:
Sunset Boulevard (Absolutely essential. Also, there's a funeral for a monkey in the first 15 minutes)
Kiss Me Deadly (just got an amazing Criterion release)
Kiss, Kiss, Bang, Bang (Modern. Robert Downey Jr. Amazing.)
The Thin Man, After The Thin Man, Shadow Of The Thin Man (Slightly comic, but essential. Also, Myrna Loy. Rawr Rawr.)
The Third Man
Rififi (French)
Bob le Flambeur (Bob The Gambler, French)
Night And The City
Pickup On South Street
Veronica Mars. Has a noir sensibility disguised as a high school drama.
If I knew how to lime this, I would.
Also, once you become familiar with the tropes of noir, watch The Big Lebowski. The Coens have stated that it's their take on Raymond Chandler. Speaking of which, the 70s version of The Long Goodbye with Elliot Gould is a bit underrated
Veronica Mars. Has a noir sensibility disguised as a high school drama.
If I knew how to lime this, I would.
Also, once you become familiar with the tropes of noir, watch The Big Lebowski. The Coens have stated that it's their take on Raymond Chandler. Speaking of which, the 70s version of The Long Goodbye with Elliot Gould is a bit underrated
I forgot about The Long Goodbye, which is rather well-rated and definitely worth catching. It's got Sterling Hayden in it too. Classic noir actor. Also, a VERY early appearance by Arnold Schwarzenegger.
Speaking of the Coen Brothers, The Man Who Wasn't There is a great example of neo-noir.
Don't know why the obvious ones haven't been mentioned, not that I'm an expert, but I feel that Casablanca, The Maltese Falcon, and The Third Man are the biggest film examples.
Don't know why the obvious ones haven't been mentioned, not that I'm an expert, but I feel that Casablanca, The Maltese Falcon, and The Third Man are the biggest film examples.
Falcon and The Third Man have both been mentioned. Some might not consider Casablanca noir.
Oh yeah, just remembered another book: Bone Song by John Meaney.
It's the only book of his that I've read, but it feels like he's intentionally going nuts with the silly stuff just for fun. It's a crime noir story in a 1940s-lookalike alternate world where instead of nuclear reactors they have necrotic reactors fueled by energy harvested from the bones of the dead. Instead of elevators they have empty shafts with spirits lifting you to the floor you want. Oh, and the protagonist's boss is a zombie.
Lots of silly stuff, but I found it to be a quick and enjoyable read.
If you're looking for novels and not just movies, I'd recommend both James Ellroy and Walter Mosley.
For James Ellroy, it's tempting to start with L.A. Confidential, but be warned the opening chapter sorta spoils one of his previous "L.A. Quartet" novels, The Big Nowhere. I'd start with the first of that series, The Black Dahlia and then work your way forward if you dig that one.
Also, avoid the movie version of The Black Dahlia since it's pretty terrible. The movie version of L.A. Confidential is excellent.
For Walter Mosley, check out Devil In A Blue Dress, especially as a nice counter-perspective to the often overwhelming racism depicted in Ellroy's L.A. novels.
Edit: More, older movie suggestions: D.O.A. (the original, not the remake), Force Of Evil, Double Indemnity, and Detour are all worth seeing.
i've read lots of hammett and chandler, but i think james m. cain's got them both beat. he writes roman noir in which the protagonists are usually murderers themselves and his novels chronicle their downward spirals in feverish and visceral prose. his books are hard to find in places like B&N and Borders, but you can go look anyway. i know Mildred Pierce is being published again because some tv series came out based on the novel, but it's not his best. try calling different used bookstores around your area.
read A Postman Always Rings Twice and then Double Indemnity after that. both are some of the best noir fiction out there.
Tons of fantastic recommendations in here, so I'll just chime in with some much more obscure, but still wonderful, suggestions. Two books: Motherless Brooklyn and Gun, With Occasional Music. One movie, Assassination of a High School President. These are all less traditional noir, although Motherless Brooklyn isn't too far from the classics.
0
EshTending bar. FFXIV. Motorcycles.Portland, ORRegistered Userregular
Tons of fantastic recommendations in here, so I'll just chime in with some much more obscure, but still wonderful, suggestions. Two books: Motherless Brooklyn and Gun, With Occasional Music. One movie, Assassination of a High School President. These are all less traditional noir, although Motherless Brooklyn isn't too far from the classics.
Jonathan Lethem! I forgot about that book. Motherless Brooklyn that is. The protagonist has tourettes. It's a great read.
EDIT: I'm really surprised no one has mentioned Cowboy Bebop yet. Futuristic noir.
Mentioned already, but near and dear to me as a noir fanatic, are both Brick and Kiss Kiss, Bang Bang. The later pretty much gave Downey his career back, pre Ironman. It's hilarious, and dark, and just a good story - Val Kilmer also makes that movie shine alot in my mind.
Also, in classic noir, I'm a huge fan of The Big Sleep. It's a bit darker, but Bogart really knocks it out of the park.
0
EshTending bar. FFXIV. Motorcycles.Portland, ORRegistered Userregular
Mentioned already, but near and dear to me as a noir fanatic, are both Brick and Kiss Kiss, Bang Bang. The later pretty much gave Downey his career back, pre Ironman. It's hilarious, and dark, and just a good story - Val Kilmer also makes that movie shine alot in my mind.
Also, in classic noir, I'm a huge fan of The Big Sleep. It's a bit darker, but Bogart really knocks it out of the park.
When I saw Brick in the theater, they gave me a little booklet that translated all the 40s slang in the movie. I still have it somewhere.
Also, Michelle Monaghan in Kiss Kiss Bang Bang. Rawr.
The Long Goodbye, in my opinion, is the perfect noir novel.
I can't decide if I like the movie or the book ending better.
One book that I hated that they watered down the film version ending for was The Getaway. I won't spoil anything, but man could it have been darker had they stuck to the original ending.
Reminds me of how the remake of Spoorloos (The Vanishing in America) gutted the ending of the original story.
Brick - Set in a modern high school, but film noir in style, storyline and dialogue. Very, very good
Discworld Noir - An adventure game. Part noir, part noir parody. Pretty fun
Another one I forgot- Winter's Bone. Both the book and movie are really, really good. The movie is actually really close to the book, so I would recommend reading the book first.
The Long Goodbye is my favorite novel. The first time I saw the Gould movie I really didn't like it, because it's really different, but some rewatchings have made me reconsider my opinion.
Also, another book is The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night Time. It doesn't fully stick the landing, but I think it's worth reading. It's told through the POV of a kid with autism, and the writer really handles it well.
The Long Goodbye is such a good book. The ending leaves you with the most perfect hollow feeling. I don't understand why according to some it's not considered one of Chandler's best novels.
Jeff Vandermeer's Finch is a wonderful mashup of noir detective stylings and steampunk fantasy. It's got a harsh style that may take some time to get used to, but it's a great read.
If you grab DOA, make sure you get the original version (interestingly, available legally on the internet, as its copyright was never renewed) and not the 80s remake, which sucked.
The Lady from Shanghai is a classic example of the genre (omg Rita Hayworth).
Roman de Gare is a french flick from '07 that's very noir-ish.
Several people have recommended Brick, but if you're just getting into the genre, I would hold off until you've seen some of the classics. It will make the structure, character archetypes and dialogue more readily identifiable and understandable. It will also probably make the film seem more clever.
Looks like everyone has the movies covered though I will throw another recommendation for The Third Man out there.
For books I saw Dashiell Hammett and Raymond Chandler mentioned and I can't endorse them enough. I've read everything Hammett wrote and it's all awesome. His novels are great, but the majority of his work is short stories. Check out The Continental Op, The Big Knockover and Nightmare Town for short story collections, The Maltese Falcon, Red Harvest, and The Thin Man for books, but I'd recommend reading The Continental Op and The Big Knockover before Red Harvest, just to establish the character better.
I'd also recommend the works of James M. Cain. The Postman Always Rings Twice is an awesome little piece of noir fiction and his other stuff is also worth checking as well.
Not quite noir, but close enough I'd recommend The Chinatown Death Cloud Peril by Paul Malmont which is a pulp/noir hybrid story about the writers of the old pulp characters The Shadow and Doc Savage going on their own adventure. If you liked Blade Runner, get Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep by Philip K. Dick, it's what Blade Runner is based off of and really shows a much more detailed and complex story.
There's also a lot of Old Time Radio Dramas dealing with detectives and noir settings that are available as podcasts. I know for a fact you can get a bunch of The Adventures of Philip Marlowe episodes on iTunes for free that are all pretty good. I'd also try and find some episodes of The Whistler if you can, you might have to hunt for those; however, they are worth it. They're the only major thing in entertainment I'm aware of that is told entirely in the second person and are noir to the core.
Wait, have we gone this long without mentioning Chinatown?
Also, with the advent of ebooks, there are tons of great, pulpy reads that you can get for really cheap. Yeah, it's sort of hard to find the good ones vs the trash, but twitter has been awesome in introducing me a bunch of new writers.
Somebody mentioned the Asphalt Jungle ... I recently stumbled over it on IMDB. That and Stanley Kubrick's "The Killing" ... would the Killing be also a good recommendation for film noir?
And covering the "whateverthefuck" part of the thread title ... Games. LA Noire.
Yeah, it's sort of hard to find the good ones vs the trash, but twitter has been awesome in introducing me a bunch of new writers.
Can you give an example or two?
Sure.
Anthony Neil Smith(docnoir) This is the first writer that I found and from there I started adding others he followed and talked to. He has a whole series bunch of books out on Kindle, most .99-2.99. They're fun, filthy, dark books.
Matthew McBride(matthewjmcbride) He has one book, Frank Sinatra in a Blender. His protagonist is an alcoholic, pill popping ex cop who's trying to quit smoking.
Jarret Rush(Jarrettrush) His book, Chasing Filthy Lucre, is a bit Blade Runner/Snow Crash, but not bad.
Also, other random writers;
Brubaker-Another one that should have been mentioned sooner. If you haven't, check out his comic book work. Sleeper is my personal favorite, but Criminal, and Incognito are also really fun and definitely are noir/have some of the tendencies.
Dwayne Swierczynski- Just this month he released I believe three books all at once, all pulpy, noir/thrillers.
Charlie Huston- If you don't mind a bit of Supernatural with your noir, his Joe Pitt series, about a vampire living in NYC is really good stuff. If you want something more normal, check out his Caught Stealing Trilogy, and my fave- The Mystic Arts of Erasing all Signs of Death.
Simon R. Green- Again, supernatural/noir, but his Darkside books are fun reads that don't take themselves too seriously.
Oh! On the tv side check out Justified. It's not full blown noir, but it's based of Elmore Leonard Stuff. Also, if it ever comes out on DVD, Terriers, a short live FX show
Thanks guys. I got Brick, Taxi Driver, Reservoir Dogs and Point Blank for now. I'll be sure to check out some of the novels too.
Pretty wobbly (as in WAY skewed towards the more recent) representation, honestly. You should delve back a little further. Brick isn't going to resonate near as much until you watch some of the stuff from the 40s.
Yeah, I thought about that too, but as it is it's kinda hard for me to get legit copies of the older ones. Still, I'm not really going to watch the ones I have any time soon due to a lack of time, so I think I'll be able to get some of the older stuff before I watch any of the ones I have anyway.
Posts
Anyway, I was damned impressed with Brick. I'll leave it to others to offer other suggestions.
Dark City - make sure to get the director's cut, or turn the sound off until Kiefer Sutherland appears, because the studio added a stupid speech that explains the entire premise for the cinematic cut.
It's from 1998 and firmly in the neo-noir camp, sci-fi premise or not.
LA Confidential
Payback
Insomnia
Heat *
Ronin *
Momento *
A History of Violence *
Road to Perdition
Reservoir Dogs *
Serpico
Taxi Driver *
Point Blank
Get Carter
The Getaway (The Steve McQueen one) *
The Driver *
Mean Streets
The Big Sleep
The Maltese Falcon
Touch of Evil
The Asphalt Jungle
* some might argue that these aren't quite noir.
Twitter
Movies:
Sunset Boulevard (Absolutely essential. Also, there's a funeral for a monkey in the first 15 minutes)
Kiss Me Deadly (just got an amazing Criterion release)
Kiss, Kiss, Bang, Bang (Modern. Robert Downey Jr. Amazing.)
The Thin Man, After The Thin Man, Shadow Of The Thin Man (Slightly comic, but essential. Also, Myrna Loy. Rawr Rawr.)
The Third Man
Rififi (French)
Bob le Flambeur (Bob The Gambler, French)
Night And The City
Pickup On South Street
I could go on for a long time. On Amazon, there are several sets called "The Film Noir Classic Collection". They're really cheap and there's some amazing stuff in them. The first one is " http://www.amazon.com/Classic-Collection-Asphalt-Jungle-Murder/dp/B000244F2S/ref=sr_1_5?ie=UTF8&qid=1310860139&sr=8-5 " Anything you see in those collections is going to be worth watching.
EDIT: Oh, and if you haven't seen Ghost Dog by Jim Jarmusch, rent it. It was HEAVILY inspired by Le Samourai.
EDIT 2: And if you like Brick (which you should definitely watch), rent The Lookout. It's noirish and also has Joseph Gordon Levitt.
If I knew how to lime this, I would.
Also, once you become familiar with the tropes of noir, watch The Big Lebowski. The Coens have stated that it's their take on Raymond Chandler. Speaking of which, the 70s version of The Long Goodbye with Elliot Gould is a bit underrated
I forgot about The Long Goodbye, which is rather well-rated and definitely worth catching. It's got Sterling Hayden in it too. Classic noir actor. Also, a VERY early appearance by Arnold Schwarzenegger.
Speaking of the Coen Brothers, The Man Who Wasn't There is a great example of neo-noir.
I never got around to seeing blood simple but it looks good.
Falcon and The Third Man have both been mentioned. Some might not consider Casablanca noir.
It's the only book of his that I've read, but it feels like he's intentionally going nuts with the silly stuff just for fun. It's a crime noir story in a 1940s-lookalike alternate world where instead of nuclear reactors they have necrotic reactors fueled by energy harvested from the bones of the dead. Instead of elevators they have empty shafts with spirits lifting you to the floor you want. Oh, and the protagonist's boss is a zombie.
Lots of silly stuff, but I found it to be a quick and enjoyable read.
For James Ellroy, it's tempting to start with L.A. Confidential, but be warned the opening chapter sorta spoils one of his previous "L.A. Quartet" novels, The Big Nowhere. I'd start with the first of that series, The Black Dahlia and then work your way forward if you dig that one.
Also, avoid the movie version of The Black Dahlia since it's pretty terrible. The movie version of L.A. Confidential is excellent.
For Walter Mosley, check out Devil In A Blue Dress, especially as a nice counter-perspective to the often overwhelming racism depicted in Ellroy's L.A. novels.
Edit: More, older movie suggestions: D.O.A. (the original, not the remake), Force Of Evil, Double Indemnity, and Detour are all worth seeing.
read A Postman Always Rings Twice and then Double Indemnity after that. both are some of the best noir fiction out there.
this is another hard-to-find novel, but absolutely worth reading if you can
They Shoot Horses, Don't They by Horace McCoy
Jonathan Lethem! I forgot about that book. Motherless Brooklyn that is. The protagonist has tourettes. It's a great read.
EDIT: I'm really surprised no one has mentioned Cowboy Bebop yet. Futuristic noir.
Also, in classic noir, I'm a huge fan of The Big Sleep. It's a bit darker, but Bogart really knocks it out of the park.
When I saw Brick in the theater, they gave me a little booklet that translated all the 40s slang in the movie. I still have it somewhere.
Also, Michelle Monaghan in Kiss Kiss Bang Bang. Rawr.
I can't decide if I like the movie or the book ending better.
One book that I hated that they watered down the film version ending for was The Getaway. I won't spoil anything, but man could it have been darker had they stuck to the original ending.
Reminds me of how the remake of Spoorloos (The Vanishing in America) gutted the ending of the original story.
Discworld Noir - An adventure game. Part noir, part noir parody. Pretty fun
The Long Goodbye is my favorite novel. The first time I saw the Gould movie I really didn't like it, because it's really different, but some rewatchings have made me reconsider my opinion.
Also, another book is The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night Time. It doesn't fully stick the landing, but I think it's worth reading. It's told through the POV of a kid with autism, and the writer really handles it well.
Anyone want to beta read a paranormal mystery novella? Here's your chance.
stream
The Lady from Shanghai is a classic example of the genre (omg Rita Hayworth).
Roman de Gare is a french flick from '07 that's very noir-ish.
Several people have recommended Brick, but if you're just getting into the genre, I would hold off until you've seen some of the classics. It will make the structure, character archetypes and dialogue more readily identifiable and understandable. It will also probably make the film seem more clever.
For books I saw Dashiell Hammett and Raymond Chandler mentioned and I can't endorse them enough. I've read everything Hammett wrote and it's all awesome. His novels are great, but the majority of his work is short stories. Check out The Continental Op, The Big Knockover and Nightmare Town for short story collections, The Maltese Falcon, Red Harvest, and The Thin Man for books, but I'd recommend reading The Continental Op and The Big Knockover before Red Harvest, just to establish the character better.
I'd also recommend the works of James M. Cain. The Postman Always Rings Twice is an awesome little piece of noir fiction and his other stuff is also worth checking as well.
Not quite noir, but close enough I'd recommend The Chinatown Death Cloud Peril by Paul Malmont which is a pulp/noir hybrid story about the writers of the old pulp characters The Shadow and Doc Savage going on their own adventure. If you liked Blade Runner, get Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep by Philip K. Dick, it's what Blade Runner is based off of and really shows a much more detailed and complex story.
There's also a lot of Old Time Radio Dramas dealing with detectives and noir settings that are available as podcasts. I know for a fact you can get a bunch of The Adventures of Philip Marlowe episodes on iTunes for free that are all pretty good. I'd also try and find some episodes of The Whistler if you can, you might have to hunt for those; however, they are worth it. They're the only major thing in entertainment I'm aware of that is told entirely in the second person and are noir to the core.
Also, with the advent of ebooks, there are tons of great, pulpy reads that you can get for really cheap. Yeah, it's sort of hard to find the good ones vs the trash, but twitter has been awesome in introducing me a bunch of new writers.
And covering the "whateverthefuck" part of the thread title ... Games. LA Noire.
Can you give an example or two?
Sure.
Anthony Neil Smith(docnoir) This is the first writer that I found and from there I started adding others he followed and talked to. He has a whole series bunch of books out on Kindle, most .99-2.99. They're fun, filthy, dark books.
Matthew McBride(matthewjmcbride) He has one book, Frank Sinatra in a Blender. His protagonist is an alcoholic, pill popping ex cop who's trying to quit smoking.
Jarret Rush(Jarrettrush) His book, Chasing Filthy Lucre, is a bit Blade Runner/Snow Crash, but not bad.
Also, other random writers;
Brubaker-Another one that should have been mentioned sooner. If you haven't, check out his comic book work. Sleeper is my personal favorite, but Criminal, and Incognito are also really fun and definitely are noir/have some of the tendencies.
Dwayne Swierczynski- Just this month he released I believe three books all at once, all pulpy, noir/thrillers.
Charlie Huston- If you don't mind a bit of Supernatural with your noir, his Joe Pitt series, about a vampire living in NYC is really good stuff. If you want something more normal, check out his Caught Stealing Trilogy, and my fave- The Mystic Arts of Erasing all Signs of Death.
Simon R. Green- Again, supernatural/noir, but his Darkside books are fun reads that don't take themselves too seriously.
Oh! On the tv side check out Justified. It's not full blown noir, but it's based of Elmore Leonard Stuff. Also, if it ever comes out on DVD, Terriers, a short live FX show
Okay, I'm going to stop now.
Pretty wobbly (as in WAY skewed towards the more recent) representation, honestly. You should delve back a little further. Brick isn't going to resonate near as much until you watch some of the stuff from the 40s.