Where to buy 3rd party Pinny Arcade pins

PAX_Skeletor

Hey all, I though it might be a good idea to have a central location that records whereabouts on the interwebs one can go to buy Pinny Arcade pins. Once you have bled the Penny Arcade store dry, and scoured eBay for bargains, where to go next for those sweet 3rd party pins?

This post aims to collect all that information into one place to make it easier for pin noobs to level up their collection faster. I'll try and keep these listings as up to date as possible, if you get any leads on available pins post below!

Currently available pins

Zane and Mercy

Naughty Dog 30th Anniversary

Catbug

Clicker

Talent Pipes

Team Fortress 2 (set)

Sheriff Spoopifer

Transistor/Red

Polaris Grand Prix Seattle

Raz - Alternate storefront

2-Headed Baby - Alternate storefront

Giddy Up

Skull Fart

Chloe

Daxter

LRR Muffins

Starslip Insignia

Sprite

Baron Blade

Panda Espresso

Minecraft Diamond Block

Octopeyes

Troll

Sofia

Yosef

Drake

Sully

Elena

What Ho!

Hob Hero

Bard Rock

Bin It To Win It

Portal (set)

Troll Revere

Creepy Doll BBQ

Hockey Spoop

Destiny: The Taken King (set)

MC Frontalot Final Boss (scroll down to ephemera section)

Owlbear

Brütal Legend - Alternate storefront

Hexipal - Alternate storefront

Head Crab

Adventure Time (set)

Lovers in a Dangerous Spacetime

Thimbleweed Park

Tugger Nutts Does PAX

Sold out pins

These pins have store pages, but are currently displayed as sold out. Included on the off chance that they may be restocked, and solely for those with the most hyperactive of brain squirrels.

Ellie

Prof. Pigglesworth

The Co-optional Podcast


Good luck and happy pin hunting!

Ayefkay

perhaps this should be a sticky? seems important enough

Rayner

Wow... I ordered Catbug in the nick of time then.

fishfishmonkeyhat

Ayefkay wrote: »

perhaps this should be a sticky? seems important enough

cometpluto

FYI as of 10:55 am CST on January 26th, 2015, the Catbug pin is back in stock. Forgot to grab one at PAX South so just ordered one.

PAX_Skeletor

Thanks @cometpluto‌ , OP updated :-)

cometpluto

Huh, I bought the Cthulhu pin for $12 a couple of days ago (on the 26th) and now it is $17. Weird.

Hingo

As stated by @sudopoop in the PAX East speculation thread, Naughty Dog has a clicker pinny available for purchase right now: http://shop.naughtydog.com/clicker-pinny.html

Geometric Cube

Just bought mine.

PAX_Skeletor

OP Updated!

SmacAttack

Looks like the Adventure Time pins are in stock over at WeLoveFine!

PAX_Skeletor

Great catch, OP updated.

Senno

Oh man - I wanted that Ellie pin as well. Thought I'd wait another week...

*EDIT*

Went to purchase the remaining two pins available (Clicker and the 30 years pin) plus the hardcover 30 years book, but won't allow me to choose Australia as a country for shipping (only Canada and US options available).

Obviously, Im in Australia. What do I do?

PedroAsani

Use my place and I'll mail it on.

fishfishmonkeyhat

Oh shit I should have done that before. Fucking shopmate..

big haircut

SmacAttack wrote: »

Looks like the Adventure Time pins are in stock over at WeLoveFine!

Nice Find! Wish it wasn't $45, though!

Edit: didn't realize it came with I flooped the pig, too, my bad!

Aussie Ben

Hey Pedro, could I grab one of those Clicker pins too?

misskass

MORE NAUGHTY DOG PINS OH GOD MY MONEY IT'S ALL GONE

Ayefkay

UNCHARTED PLZ I'd love a nathan drake character pin in the style of the ellie pin, very cartoony that emphasises her personality

TheAggroCraig

Ayefkay wrote: »

UNCHARTED PLZ I'd love a nathan drake character pin in the style of the ellie pin, very cartoony that emphasises her personality

I need a Drake and/or Sully pin... like... really bad.

evil santa

I humbly suggest an action pose such as this - http://patrickbrown.deviantart.com/art/Uncharted-4-511000319

PedroAsani

Aussie Ben wrote: »

Hey Pedro, could I grab one of those Clicker pins too?

Sure.

JKwon

big haircut wrote: »

SmacAttack wrote: »

Looks like the Adventure Time pins are in stock over at WeLoveFine!

Nice Find! Wish it wasn't $45, though!

Edit: didn't realize it came with I flooped the pig, too, my bad!

Aw 45 is a bit steep, I bet I could trade my dupes for these at the next PAX, though.

Senno

JKwon wrote: »

big haircut wrote: »

SmacAttack wrote: »

Looks like the Adventure Time pins are in stock over at WeLoveFine!

Nice Find! Wish it wasn't $45, though!

Edit: didn't realize it came with I flooped the pig, too, my bad!

Aw 45 is a bit steep, I bet I could trade my dupes for these at the next PAX, though.

I think it's steep too, but seeing as there are no guarantees, I went ahead with the purchase. What's worse is that it cost me more than that due to the fact I'm in Australia and also have to deal with shipping and currency conversion. Sigh.

dmosinee

These came in today -- so I guess high marks on shipping time...

But damn, I think we have a new contender for ugliest pin ever released:


It looks even worse in person. I say this as someone who loved every second of The Last of Us, but I wish we had only gotten one of these awful pins to put in the corner of the display and forget about.

SerpicoBC

I reluctantly ordered one of these. I can't wait to pin it to my corkboard and never think about it again.

PedroAsani

You people are nuts. It's a rotting zombie with fungus sprouting from it's head. Just how adorable did you expect it to be?

Ayefkay

it can be done

fishfishmonkeyhat

☐ not rekt
☐ maybe rekt?
☑ rekt

SerpicoBC

Ayefkay wrote: »

it can be done

Well that's downright precious.

SKOoOTA

I just see this when I look at the Clicker Pin.

dmosinee

The big, pointless black oval really drags it down IMO -- plus big single fill areas like that tend to have a lot of defects. Two out of the four we ordered have issues with the fill of that black oval.

It wouldn't surprise me to learn that these were ordered alongside the Ellie pin, but came out so ugly that didn't want to put them alongside at East 2014.

PedroAsani

dmosinee wrote: »

The big, pointless black oval really drags it down IMO -- plus big single fill areas like that tend to have a lot of defects. Two out of the four we ordered have issues with the fill of that black oval.

It wouldn't surprise me to learn that these were ordered alongside the Ellie pin, but came out so ugly that didn't want to put them alongside at East 2014.

That black oval is keeping the body from getting damaged, because it would be pretty thin otherwise.

silrn

PedroAsani wrote: »

That black oval is keeping the body from getting damaged, because it would be pretty thin otherwise.

The Ellie pin was pretty skinny too, and it had really skinny extrusions in the form of that rifle barrel. I can't recall any examples being made of that one getting damaged.

Headhunter

Oh sweet, I didn't know about the non-Ellie pins from Naughty Dog!

Qumaden

Headhunter wrote: »

Oh sweet, I didn't know about the non-Ellie pins from Naughty Dog!

Don't worry, they're both terrible.

SerpicoBC

Qumaden wrote: »

Headhunter wrote: »

Oh sweet, I didn't know about the non-Ellie pins from Naughty Dog!

Don't worry, they're both terrible.

I nodded at the simple truth, laughed at the earnestness, and wept because I bought both.

PedroAsani

SerpicoBC wrote: »

Qumaden wrote: »

Headhunter wrote: »

Oh sweet, I didn't know about the non-Ellie pins from Naughty Dog!

Don't worry, they're both terrible.

I nodded at the simple truth, laughed at the earnestness, and wept because I bought both.

I don't get it. The Anniversary crest is a nice piece of simple design, and the Clicker looks like a Clicker. So what's the issue?

SerpicoBC

For the quality of the design, I thought the prices were high. The Clicker does look like a Clicker, but the black background was effortless and there needed to be more color/texture in the head.

I like the shield, but I also felt like it was $5 less pin than I bought.

Cowpuppy

For the Clicker, if they had gone with a bust view sort of like how the KI characters were done, it could be a much better pin. That black background throws it off. I understand needing some more meat to the pin with the subject's spindly arms and legs, but I think it would have been a better design choice to zoom in a bit.

In any case, there have been some skinny pins before, no? A lot of the Gabes and Tychos come to mind, as well as the Tin Man pin. If this pin had just been the Clicker without that background, I think it would be much improved.

Qumaden

PedroAsani wrote: »

SerpicoBC wrote: »

Qumaden wrote: »

Headhunter wrote: »

Oh sweet, I didn't know about the non-Ellie pins from Naughty Dog!

Don't worry, they're both terrible.

I nodded at the simple truth, laughed at the earnestness, and wept because I bought both.

I don't get it. The Anniversary crest is a nice piece of simple design, and the Clicker looks like a Clicker. So what's the issue?

Wrap meat in a tortilla and you've got yourself a taco. Some tacos are tasty and good and make you glad you had it (Ellie). Some give you diarrhea(30th Anni), and some taste like shit(clicker).

Then some tacos get shipped through Think Geek and are smashed with hammers during the packing process and fed to a hungry woodchipper before arriving on my doorstep.

Ok, so now I want a taco.