The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.

Low-Feature, Durable Cell Phone for older adult.

PriestPriest Registered User regular
edited April 2015 in Help / Advice Forum
Greetings all,

My parents have used these flip-phones for years now. My mother recently had her first grandchild, however, and with her flip-phone dying, wants something that handles pictures better. She's not looking for the new blinged-out phones, just something durable that she can reliably make phone calls on (which smartphones seems to be getting worse and worse at).

I've had a lot of trouble finding any examples of phones like this, wondering if anyone has any recommendations / advice. I'm seeking a non-data reliant smartphone for my Mom, key features would be:

- Small to Medium sized, no larger than 4.5" Screen.
- High-Resolution Color Screen (IE: Not like a Flip-Phone Screen)
- Hardware and Software keyboards are acceptable (IE: Slider phones)
- Wi-Fi & 4G Capable. (3G is an acceptable fallback, No 2G)
- Android Preferred, other OS acceptable, prefer no Apple devices.
- High durability
- High call-quality
- Battery life 48 hours + (This is hard to find, but not impossible in smaller phones)
- T-Mobile - Must be GSM network + SIM card friendly.
- Off-Contract


I'm willing to pay a higher price for a smaller phone like this ($200-$300) to gain durability and battery life at the expense of size, brand-name, and high-processing power. Because she'll solely be using it for Phone Calls, Texting, Pictures, and Wi-Fi email, all other features are irrelevant.

Thanks in advance, folks

Priest on

Posts

  • knitdanknitdan Registered User regular
    https://www.greatcall.com/lp/simple-cell-phones-for-seniors.aspx

    This might fit the bill, I'm not sure about durability but their selling point is they are designed with seniors in mind.

    “I was quick when I came in here, I’m twice as quick now”
    -Indiana Solo, runner of blades
  • SmokeStacksSmokeStacks Registered User regular
    edited April 2015
    Smartphones and 48+ hour battery life don't really jive that well.

    Some of the older people I know or work with hate charging their phones because it sucks. Fumbling around with a tiny ass latch to open the tiny ass port to plug in a tiny ass USB charging cable backwards so you can flip it around and try again only to realize that you had it right the first time is a pain for anyone, let alone an older person who might have poor eyesight and arthritis, so I'd recommend seeing if you can find a phone that has an aftermarket dock that is easy to use so your folks can simply place it in a dock to charge.

    Alternately, if the main reason they want nicer phones is for pictures, what about using simpler phones that they are used to and grabbing something like a cheap android tablet? They could use phones they are already comfortable with for making calls, but have a separate device that is easy to use for sharing pictures or Facebooking/keeping in touch with grandchildren or whatever it is that they want to do.

    SmokeStacks on
  • BarrakkethBarrakketh Registered User regular
    Smartphones and 48+ hour battery life don't really jive that well.
    That depends on how much you're actively using them. A couple of days ago I noticed that my phone (a Galaxy Note 4) managed 33 hours before I had to charge it, and that was with a little over seven hours of the screen being on, and WiFi being active the whole time. Primary usage was Youtube + heavy web browsing.

    @Priest Have you considered looking for phones that have aftermarket batteries available for them? They add thickness to the phone (which might be nice for some people...I'm not a fan of super thin phones because the grip on them feels poor) but can easily triple the stock battery life.

    Rollers are red, chargers are blue....omae wa mou shindeiru
  • November FifthNovember Fifth Registered User regular
    I am going to second SmokeStack's recommendation of getting her another flip phone plus a tablet to share pictures and maybe video chat.

    You could also consider getting her a battery extender/wireless charging system for a smartphone.

  • BlindZenDriverBlindZenDriver Registered User regular
    Not sure of anything regarding prices and contracts since I'm in Europe, but taking a look at Nokia/Microsoft Lumia phones as they may be the way to go.

    Here is why:
    • Durable
    • Good battery life (My Lumia 920 is 2½ years now if I don't go Skype and Netflix crazy on it going 2-3 days between charging is a given. Longest time is 133 hours, but that was with little use(was traveling and thus mainly used a work phone).
    • Wireless charging is found with several of the Nokia/Microsoft phones and it is so convenient I'd call it a must.
    • The Windows OS brings some familiarity with PC Windows 8 and more down the line when we all move to Windows 10 (and even older Lumia phones will get Windows 10). Also the integration of calendar, OneNote and so on is a good thing in it all being build in.
    • Good sound quality.

    Bones heal, glory is forever.
  • JuliusJulius Captain of Serenity on my shipRegistered User regular
    I got a Samsung something mini. The line is pretty durable though I think the battery life might be too low.

    Also I second BlindZenDriver.

  • SanderJKSanderJK Crocodylus Pontifex Sinterklasicus Madrid, 3000 ADRegistered User regular
    Samsung phones with removable backsides often have aftermarket larger batteries available that replace the battery and backside. Up to an including crazy 10000mAh monstrosities. (That's 5x the charging power). Of course you pay in bulk and weight, approx 50g per 2000mAh. In general the changeable batteries help a lot about 18 months down the stretch when the battery inevitably deteriorates.

    Configuring a smartphone properly to not use much energy can also help a lot.

    Steam: SanderJK Origin: SanderJK
  • hsuhsu Registered User regular
    Just as a note, once my parents got grandkids (via siblings), video chat became their goto app.
    It started out on a tablet that my siblings and I got them, but it has since migrated to their computer and smartphones.
    I'd have sworn my parents were technophobes, but once they found video chat, that was all she wrote.
    Their single biggest requirement of their phone? It had to video chat. Which is why they upgraded to a smartphone.

    iTNdmYl.png
  • IrukaIruka Registered User, Moderator Mod Emeritus
    edited April 2015
    I have sometimes found the reduced feature phones to be harder to use than newer Iphones/android phones. I have a few less technical relatives, and they have an unusable flip phone and a useless smart phone that is 5 or six generations behind. Eventually they ended up with a kindle fire for reading, and that suddenly became the go to device for emails and everything else, because it worked well. We are probably going to get them an Ipad.

    Assuming the galaxy S5 mini is exactly the same as the S5, my phone has been thrown on the floor/concrete a million times and is no worse for the wear ( I dont use a case, either). Its also water proof to a certain point, which is helpful.

    Call quality is so so, but that may be my network in my area (verizon). wifi calling has helped. The galaxy has an "ultra power saving mode" that turns the phone black and white and keeps it alive for days. I use it while traveling and at conventions, calls and texts still come through but it turns off all the crap. I think at 50% battery when you turn it to powersaving it gives you 7 days.

    If shes technically inclined enough to switch between the modes, its not a terrible option. That plus an aftermarket battery, I'd imagine, would really make it ridiculous. She'd have to remember to switch back and forth when she wants to take pictures and look at stuff in color, which is probably a deal breaker, but better to know its an option.

    Iruka on
  • ResIpsaLoquiturResIpsaLoquitur Not a grammar nazi, just alt-write. Registered User regular
    The Moto G is dirt cheap, GSM based, just a little larger than your target, and is pretty close to stock android. For 180 bucks, give or take, it'd be my recommendation. My wife went from a feature phone to a smartphone recently, with similar requests. We ended up spending a little more and getting the G3 Vigor, but the Moto G was the only phone I found that ticked most all of the "entry level" boxes while still being a current-gen phone.

    League of Legends: MichaelDominick; Blizzard(NA): MichaelD#11402; Steam ID: MichaelDominick
    PwH4Ipj.jpg
  • PriestPriest Registered User regular
    Hey all,

    Throwing an update here. So Slider phones are stupidly expensive, considering what smart phones cost. Also, nobody except for smartphone makers are putting decent screens in their phones.

    Turns out the LG Optimus is a reasonably sized phone that only cost $125. I'm happy with that. Took two nights, but got her trained on using it and getting used to touch-keyboards. Been a gauntlet getting through that, but thankfully her mother (my grandmother) and her sisters have been texting her non-stop to force her to practice using the phone. Humorous day that my Grandma is more tech-savvy than my mother. It wasn't Phablet sized, had a removable battery, and wasn't too terrible on the vendor-OS.

    I forwent flashing Cryanogen on it, just due to the fact that Cryanogen isn't 100% stable on phones, and I don't want my Mom to have to deal with it. I purged most of the apps, especially the LG built in apps, cleaned her home screen, basically made the phone as user friendly as possible for her. Apparently Android doesn't require you to sign in with Google anymore, which is a boon, as she didn't want Gmail (she uses Yahoo, I could care less what people use).

    The LG Optimus has fantastic call quality - best I've heard on a smartphone. Highly recommend it for people looking for low-end smartphones. Decent speed, not flashy. Bundled LG and T-Mo software is a sloth though, and must be purged with fire and hatred.

Sign In or Register to comment.