As was foretold, we've added advertisements to the forums! If you have questions, or if you encounter any bugs, please visit this thread: https://forums.penny-arcade.com/discussion/240191/forum-advertisement-faq-and-reports-thread/

Trash, Trade Up, and Treasure

HingoHingo Minneapolis, MNRegistered User regular
edited October 2015 in Pinny Arcade
In the spirit of "kill, bang, marry", I bring you the pin edition. The rules are simple: You have 2 fodder pins to trade. You are also allowed to take one of the pins from the table and throw it directly into the garbage. Which pin do you trash? Which pin do you trade up for based purely on value? Which pin do you trade for as your favorite of the pins available to treasure forever?

Table 1
INvMUZP.jpg

Pins for trade!
2015 PAX Prime Omeganaut (I will forever hate Katamari)
Hingo on
evanephrine
«1

Posts

  • HingoHingo Minneapolis, MNRegistered User regular
    My picks for Table 1:
    Trash: Moon - I've never really cared for T&C, and that is my least favorite pin of the set.
    Trade up: Ben Kuchera Staff head
    Treasure: Sprite - I loved the shit out of Hob, and Matt Uelmen and Max Schaefer are awesome to talk to

    Pins for trade!
    2015 PAX Prime Omeganaut (I will forever hate Katamari)
    evanephrine
  • TheAggroCraigTheAggroCraig Ultimate Lucky Douchebag MassachusettsRegistered User regular
    Ooooh fun.

    Trash: Tyche. Not a fan of the art style for Gabbie either tbh.
    Trade Up: Sprite. Always keep the next PAX in mind!
    Treasure: Castle Guy, because 17 isn't enough.

  • misskassmisskass Melbourne, AustraliaRegistered User regular
    Trash: Castle Guy. DIE, CASTLE GUY.
    Trade Up: Iced Coffee Kemper, everyone loves Kempers.
    Treasure: Probably the Cardinal, in an attempt to broaden my collection horizon of older pins, I'm looking into obtaining some of The Behemoth's cuter offerings.

    https://www.pinnypals.com/pals/misskass
    Attended: Aus 2013, Aus 2014, East 2015, Aus 2015

    Aus 2016
    [x] GUESS WHO JUST REALISED IT'S FINALLY THIS YEAR
    evanephrine
  • AyefkayAyefkay Queensland, AustraliaRegistered User regular
    trash: Beker Staff head, if I've got that many surely I can spare to throw one out :P, seriously though probably any of the staff 2 set, I'm getting kind of sick of all the orange...

    Trade: Something from lookouts, that'll get me something good in a trade for sure

    keep: project spark, best design on the table

    My PinnyPals Digital Lanyard: Now Up to date! https://pinnypals.com/pals/Ayefkay

    8fuuo_RK.png
  • LazorzLazorz Tokyo, JPRegistered User regular
    edited October 2015
    Trash: Binwin Bronzebottom. I really don't like the design of the AI set, and there are a lot of Binwins on that table.
    Trade up: Sprite. Its design is fantastic; I'm sure someone will be looking for it at South or East.
    Treasure: Pumpkin Fucker. There's just something about a robot fucking a pumpkin that really resonates with me, y'know?

    Lazorz on
    Gethevanephrine
  • TheAggroCraigTheAggroCraig Ultimate Lucky Douchebag MassachusettsRegistered User regular
    misskass wrote: »
    Trash: Castle Guy. DIE, CASTLE GUY.


    YOU TAKE THAT BACK

  • evanephrineevanephrine ev-an-eff-rinn Seattle, WARegistered User regular
    Trash: MC Frontalot because euuugh that design.
    Trade up: Probably the Iron Guard Stance, I might be biased though since East '14 was my first PAX.
    Treasure: Cardinal because I have spent countless hours playing Castle Crashers. Looooove that game :D

  • MetricalSkyMetricalSky Vancouver, BCRegistered User regular
    Trash: Sophia Hex. I'm not a fan of Behemoth's pins in general.
    Trade: Probably the Ben Kuchera staff head.
    Treasure: Sprite. I just really like the design.

    ItrVoTt.png
  • misskassmisskass Melbourne, AustraliaRegistered User regular
    misskass wrote: »
    Trash: Castle Guy. DIE, CASTLE GUY.


    YOU TAKE THAT BACK
    dfeemb3xbs26.png

    https://www.pinnypals.com/pals/misskass
    Attended: Aus 2013, Aus 2014, East 2015, Aus 2015

    Aus 2016
    [x] GUESS WHO JUST REALISED IT'S FINALLY THIS YEAR
    HingoQumadenfishfishmonkeyhat
  • SolelronSolelron Wandering Gamer Cornelius, ORRegistered User regular
    Trash: Moon
    Upgrade: Sunset OD
    Treasure: Sprite

  • orthancstoneorthancstone TexasRegistered User regular
    edited October 2015
    Trash: Any staff head/bust save Ben. Sorry guys, one of each is enough for me.
    Trade up: Second Sons
    Treasure: Sprite

    orthancstone on
    PAX South 2018 - Jan 12-14!
    Pins!
  • callmegarcallmegar Registered User regular
    edited October 2015
    Trash: where do I start, the ugly core 2 grey toaster or whatever.
    Trade up: Dunkin Kemper, because kemper is the source of unexpected trades.
    Treasure: Cardinal, a buy pin and and old one.

    callmegar on
    00trpy9qu6xq.jpg
  • bravesaturnbravesaturn World's Best Entry Level Employee Registered User regular
    Trash: Sophia hex. I love Behemoth, but most of their hex pins are unappealing to me.
    Trade up: Sprite
    Treasure: Iced coffee Kemper

  • dmosineedmosinee Davenport, IARegistered User regular
    Trash: Football head lookout kid
    Trade Up: Infamous Second Son
    Treasure: Sunset Overdrive (Fizzy)

    Digital Lanyard, I love trades - https://www.pinnypals.com/pals/dmosinee
    http://pinmash.info - Two pins enter, one pins leaves... then the other pin leaves with a lower Elo rating
  • JuicesirJuicesir The Boy with the D&D Tattoo Registered User regular
    Tresure the Project Spark pin, it's one of my favorites regardless.
    Trade up for the Coffee Kemper cus Kemper pins always in style.
    Trash the Ben Kuchera pin just cus. ^_^

    callmegar
  • agentcooperagentcooper Brisbane, AustraliaRegistered User regular
    Trash: Sophia Hex
    Trade Up: Sunset Overdrive (Fizzy)
    Treasure: Helmet Tycho

    Let's trade: https://www.pinnypals.com/pals/agentcooper
    "Damn fine pins!"
    bravesaturn
  • MaxxsenseMaxxsense N. Ridgeville OhioRegistered User regular
    Just a heads up the MC Frontalot pin is no longer available at PAX. Frontalot posted on Twitter that the last ones sold out during PAX Prime.

    Check out my Virtual Pin Lanyard: https://www.pinnypals.com/pals/Maxx_Sense
    Juicesirfishfishmonkeyhatbravesaturn
  • silrnsilrn Fairfax, VARegistered User regular
    Trash: Merch 1.0 (The less there are, the more valuable mine is right?!?)
    Trade: Iced Coffee Kemper (Cause Kemper)
    Treasure: Kitsapp (Bye Moonrise, we never got to know the real you!)

    Hingo
  • HingoHingo Minneapolis, MNRegistered User regular
    silrn wrote: »
    Trash: Merch 1.0 (The less there are, the more valuable mine is right?!?)

    Devious...

    Pins for trade!
    2015 PAX Prime Omeganaut (I will forever hate Katamari)
  • HingoHingo Minneapolis, MNRegistered User regular
    New table time!
    Table 2:
    4v81leem15za.jpg

    Trash: Balloon Man
    Trade Up: Next Level
    Treasure: PNW Kemper

    Pins for trade!
    2015 PAX Prime Omeganaut (I will forever hate Katamari)
  • orthancstoneorthancstone TexasRegistered User regular
    edited October 2015
    Trash: PAX 15 Logo
    Trade up: PAX AUS 14 Logo
    Treasure: Riptor

    orthancstone on
    PAX South 2018 - Jan 12-14!
    Pins!
  • evanephrineevanephrine ev-an-eff-rinn Seattle, WARegistered User regular
    Trash: Balloon Man, still not big on the T&C set.
    Trade Up: Dropbear in the case, sneaky little bugger!
    Treasure: Witch Annarchy that's hiding on its side, still adorable.

  • SolelronSolelron Wandering Gamer Cornelius, ORRegistered User regular
    Trash: 2015 Logo
    Trade Up: Atoi
    Treasure: Aus Logo

    Geth
  • ArcticLancerArcticLancer Best served chilled. Registered User regular
    I still haven't seen the PNW Kemper in the photo, but yeah, assuming we get free reign on the case (which as a game, we almost certainly cannot) ...
    Trash: Balloon Man
    Trade Up: Riptor
    Treasure: Riptor

    I love the KI pins and think it's one of the best.

  • TheAggroCraigTheAggroCraig Ultimate Lucky Douchebag MassachusettsRegistered User regular
    Trash: Balloon Man
    Trade Up: Riptor
    Treasure: Jerkimides

    (Of course the latter 2 are assuming I could pick from the dice roll box)

  • HingoHingo Minneapolis, MNRegistered User regular
    I still haven't seen the PNW Kemper in the photo, but yeah, assuming we get free reign on the case (which as a game, we almost certainly cannot) ...
    Trash: Balloon Man
    Trade Up: Riptor
    Treasure: Riptor

    I love the KI pins and think it's one of the best.

    Lower right hand corner.

    Pins for trade!
    2015 PAX Prime Omeganaut (I will forever hate Katamari)
  • misskassmisskass Melbourne, AustraliaRegistered User regular
    Trash: the Gavin Bust (too many Gavins)
    Trade up: Riptor
    Treasure: Hobby Kenneth (the gummy bear, because someone nice traded me one at East and I like to treasure my trades)

    https://www.pinnypals.com/pals/misskass
    Attended: Aus 2013, Aus 2014, East 2015, Aus 2015

    Aus 2016
    [x] GUESS WHO JUST REALISED IT'S FINALLY THIS YEAR
  • dmosineedmosinee Davenport, IARegistered User regular
    Trash: Catsby
    Trade Up: CTS Gabe
    Treasure: Sexy Nurse Gabe (that's one of my favorite PA strips)

    WILDCARD: There is a Naughty Dog pin face down near Brian's right elbow, if that is Ellie then it is def the new Treasure -- Ellie is probably my favorite pin of all.

    Digital Lanyard, I love trades - https://www.pinnypals.com/pals/dmosinee
    http://pinmash.info - Two pins enter, one pins leaves... then the other pin leaves with a lower Elo rating
  • silrnsilrn Fairfax, VARegistered User regular
    Trash: Next Level (Same as before, if there's less of them, mine is worth more!)
    Trade Up: Riptor
    Treasure: Baby Gabe

    Also, that PNW Kemper... IS NOT ON THE TABLE!! That's pretty clearly in someone's personal little bag.

    Additionally, Gavin is totally chomping on the Japanese sour grape treats that I gave him!

  • HingoHingo Minneapolis, MNRegistered User regular
    edited October 2015
    silrn wrote: »
    Also, that PNW Kemper... IS NOT ON THE TABLE!! That's pretty clearly in someone's personal little bag.

    I don't care it still counts!
    @dmosinee Brian used random card backs to put pins on for his upside-down trading game. I got a Valentine's Day pin by using the strategy of "pick the backing with the barcode on it". Agreed though on Ellie, definitely in my top 2 favorite pins!

    Hingo on
    Pins for trade!
    2015 PAX Prime Omeganaut (I will forever hate Katamari)
  • bravesaturnbravesaturn World's Best Entry Level Employee Registered User regular
    Trash: one of the sketch pins
    Trade Up: Riptor
    Treasure: I would choose PNW Kemper if he was on the table, but he looks like he's in a bag that someone is holding. Therefore, I have to choose...FF from the core 1.0 set

  • JuicesirJuicesir The Boy with the D&D Tattoo Registered User regular
    Trash that smug looking Lookout scout. I can't even. He just reeks of Draco Malfoyness.
    Trade up the Tyche, cus holla at dat fan art.
    Treasure the Cardboard Tube Samurai. Always treasure him. Always.

  • calamityjamiecalamityjamie Corgi Wrangler Seattle, WARegistered User staff
    Ayefkay wrote: »
    seriously though probably any of the staff 2 set, I'm getting kind of sick of all the orange...

    ... with the staff 2 orange forum avatar :P

    Juicesir
  • calamityjamiecalamityjamie Corgi Wrangler Seattle, WARegistered User staff
    silrn wrote: »
    Additionally, Gavin is totally chomping on the Japanese sour grape treats that I gave him!

    Those treats were so goooooooooood

  • fishfishmonkeyhatfishfishmonkeyhat Freelance Pin Man Newcastle, AustraliaRegistered User regular
    Is this where you wanted the staff table pics @Hingo?

    ALL RIGHT BACK UP THE TRUCK!

    Q0Lq0aet.jpg Z2tLsOSt.jpg h1kKBwSt.jpg IGWgH1Rt.jpg 0NIry8yt.jpg

  • HingoHingo Minneapolis, MNRegistered User regular
    That works, @fishfishmonkeyhat . We'll start with this guy first:
    Q0Lq0ae.jpg
    Trash: Div 2.0 - they took that "be fruitful and multiply" statement way too seriously
    Trade Up: Snorkel Kemper - because Kemper
    Treasure: Kemperoo - one of my favorite pins, and Kemper is so happy!

    Pins for trade!
    2015 PAX Prime Omeganaut (I will forever hate Katamari)
  • SolelronSolelron Wandering Gamer Cornelius, ORRegistered User regular
    Trash, : Merch (either)
    Trade up: Kemper snorkel
    Treasure: sunset overdrive.

  • bravesaturnbravesaturn World's Best Entry Level Employee Registered User regular
    Trash: moon
    Trade up: snorkel kemper
    Treasure: kemperoo

  • TheAggroCraigTheAggroCraig Ultimate Lucky Douchebag MassachusettsRegistered User regular
    Trash: Moon
    Trade Up: Snorkel Kemper
    Treasure: A different Snorkel Kemper

    Hingoevanephrine
  • drusus82drusus82 Narara, NSW, AURegistered User regular
    Trash: deep crow
    Trade up: lookout leader
    Treasure: lookout symbol.

    Actual treasure for me from this table on the day was a cardboard tube samurai gabe.

Sign In or Register to comment.