The image size limit has been raised to 1mb! Anything larger than that should be linked to. This is a HARD limit, please do not abuse it.
Our new Indie Games subforum is now open for business in G&T. Go and check it out, you might land a code for a free game. If you're developing an indie game and want to post about it, follow these directions. If you don't, he'll break your legs! Hahaha! Seriously though.
Our rules have been updated and given their own forum. Go and look at them! They are nice, and there may be new ones that you didn't know about! Hooray for rules! Hooray for The System! Hooray for Conforming!

True Dungeon Demo Thoughts

ahstoddardahstoddard President-kidnapping NinjaHouston-ishRegistered User regular
Personally I ended up enjoying the whole thing a lot more than I thought I would, so I'm wondering what everyone else's opinions on it happened to be.
Would you want it to come back? Would you be willing to pay extra for the "full" experience or would you want it to maybe be a little smaller and stay free like the rest of PAX?

Also, if anyone else has gone through it at GenCon and did it at South, are the puzzles usually that simple?

abQ40DK.png

Posts

  • AthexAthex Registered User new member
    I havent done another true dungeon, I assume the puzzles cant be too difficult as they need to move people through. I don't think i would be up for paying extra for it though at pax, I suspect they will need to bake it into the ticket price when it comes back as a full thing. I wouldnt want pax to start going down the route of charging extra for certain things anyway, its a slippery slope. Next you will get charges for the vr freeplay or some other area.

    abQ40DK.png
  • BekerBeker Child's Play Guy and PAX VR Freeplay Manager SeattleRegistered User, Penny Arcade Staff regular
    Charging is a tricky thing. We have built PAX on the all inclusive badge, and try not to nickle and dime attendees at the show. However I'm not sure its fair to raise everyone's badge price for an experience only a small portion of attendees will be able to experience. Its something we are still considering, and have not made decisions on it yet.

    Personally I really enjoyed my experience with True Dungeon, and very much hope the full experience can be at a future PAXen. As the OP asked, love to hear what others of you thought about the experience.

    -Beker/Erick
    NDoOjUb.png
  • PreacherChePreacherChe Houston, TXRegistered User regular
    I agree, upping the PAX badge cost doesn't seem fair. Given what I saw at the sample this year and from what I hear about the full experience, I'd be willing to pay separately for True Dungeon. In 2016, it looks like the entry for True Dungeon was running $54 - not cheap, but heck I end up spending a lot more than that while inside the con (I think one convention center lunch ran almost that much for me and kids, this year).

    uv2FoQs.png
  • Christopher HuffChristopher Huff Registered User regular
    While I don't know all the logistics done behind the scenes since I'm not obviously part of the crew, do you think that since PAX South is growing fast enough in terms of attendees that would allow for the full version of True Dungeon without intentionally raising the badge prices for everyone solely because of it?

    While I personally wouldn't mind about paying separately for a full version (PAX is a vacation to me and I allocate money to spend around it -- Pre-PAX, food, merch, etc.) I completely agree that it would be a unfair practice baking charges into the badge price for the "upgrade". It doesn't have to be True Dungeon, it can be any other event as well that people want upgraded and the same terms apply. This kind of relates to why PC will always reign supreme to me because I really, really, really hate the pay to play online concept. I already paid you a good amount of money for the game itself and now you want to charge me to play online? No thanks. I'll rather have game companies give you the option to host your own server or the ability to purchase a dedicated one (and of course give yourself admin privileges and a reserved slot in the process) rather than them to complain that a paid membership is necessary for good online play.

    But I wouldn't like a convention where everything is pay to play. Imagine if a amusement park charged you for admission AND rides rather than one or the other? I highly doubt that a vast majority of people would like that. Touchy subject indeed, but the "easiest" solution without severely turning off people would be to increase attendance to allow for more wiggle room in the budget but obviously that is something the higher up's have little control over. While I do enjoy that I don't have to stalk the interwebs for South passes, it does come at the cost of a smaller budget for the development/planning/coordinating teams.

    kZjgojP.png
  • ahstoddardahstoddard President-kidnapping Ninja Houston-ishRegistered User regular
    I almost wonder if, in order to keep to the "free" nature of PAX, that True Dungeon would need to be PAX-adjacent.
    Something along the lines of: PAX expands to take up a larger portion of the SA Convention Center, then True Dungeon squats in another section. PAX attendees are given first shot at buying tickets and signing up for times, but it is technically open to the good people of San Antonio to also purchase tickets.

    They said they needed something along the lines of 200 volunteers to run the whole thing, and did the demo with just 7, so it is certainly a large undertaking (especially with South this year lacking a full number of Enforcers from what I hear)
    Athex wrote: »
    I havent done another true dungeon, I assume the puzzles cant be too difficult as they need to move people through.
    I think they said in the full version you get double the time in each room, so I would hope the puzzles would at least have more steps, if not also being slightly difficult.

    abQ40DK.png
  • japesterjapester Registered User regular
    I can appreciate PAX's dilemma about offering something with a separate charge, but from what I saw it would be justified. PAX is huge and has been around a long time. There's no danger of a slippery slope or suddenly charging for everything. TD is a wholly unique experience, not some incremental upgrade with a charge tacked on to test the waters.

    I was both impressed and unimpressed by the experience. Bringing the big rock worm animatronic and the lava room was pretty nifty As were the character reference sheets (hinting at the cool stuff we wouldn't actually be doing). But I was less impressed by the lack of info going in. For example, our whole group was stressing while reading the character sheets, thinking we'd need to memorize things and actually play the game. All of that could have been alleviated if the people seating us had taken 30 seconds to explain things better. Likewise, while I appreciate how labor-intensive breakdown must have been on the last day, shutting it down before noon without warning was quite a disappointment. And mishandling of the tokens that morning only added to the negative experience (they could have given one away per person walking up and being turned away, but instead they gave armloads of them to the last few groups just to get rid of them). These kinds of issues were unique to a first year/demo situation like this one and likely wouldn't be repeated, but they do speak to the lack of organization and customer experience awareness.

  • YoungFreyYoungFrey Registered User regular
    One thing that would be awesome is if True Dungeon at PAX was themed to PAX in some way. I know Acquisitions Incorporated might be out because of Wizards, but there is also the Eyrewood. That would make a shorter experience feel a lot less like True-Dungeon Lite and more like True Dungeon PAX.

  • ahstoddardahstoddard President-kidnapping Ninja Houston-ishRegistered User regular
    YoungFrey wrote: »
    One thing that would be awesome is if True Dungeon at PAX was themed to PAX in some way. I know Acquisitions Incorporated might be out because of Wizards, but there is also the Eyrewood. That would make a shorter experience feel a lot less like True-Dungeon Lite and more like True Dungeon PAX.

    I know for GenCon this year everything will be set within the world of Pat Rothfuss' books, so something PAX related would not be out of the question, especially if they were planning on setting up at multiple PAXen.

    abQ40DK.png
  • YoungFreyYoungFrey Registered User regular
    An Automata one might even make more sense. Easier to craft rooms inside than a forest. Plus, solving puzzles is possibly more adaptable to robots than elves.

    ahstoddard
  • GundabadGundabad PAX East & Unplugged Tabletop Manager NJRegistered User regular
    I would definitely like to see True Dungeon remain free, but I would also like to see the hours extended into late night. As a morning shift Enforcer, there was simply no way I was going to get up there.

Sign In or Register to comment.