The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.

[Star Wars] actually maybe I don't want to talk about Star Wars anymore

Grey GhostGrey Ghost Registered User regular
edited August 20 in Social Entropy++
I mostly just want to talk about KOTOR, which I finally will play to completion to follow along with the A More Civilized Age podcast playing it instead of covering Star Wars shows due to the writer's and actor's strike. I just left Dantooine! It's the furthest I've ever made it in this game.

But you know, I have to say, there's some interesting stuff going on in Ahsoka. I don't know how it'll pan out, and generally I have not loved the way Dawson plays her, but there are some cool ideas in those first two episodes. And a couple of things that made my KOTOR-playing ass do the DiCaprio pointing meme at my TV

I didn't plan on being the one to make the next thread because I am generally a lot cooler on Star Wars these days than I used to be, and I think they just don't have the juice anymore, but here we are. Anyway, let's all talk about who's the worst KOTOR companion (it's Carth)

I hear tell there are actually other Star Wars games too! y'all probably played this one already:

https://youtu.be/bmj3ty-Wt48?si=bQMfUWL_wXmR_kUA

and this one is coming up and some of you sickos will probably be into it

https://youtu.be/ymcpwq1ltQc?si=hiKtgBTeniJVcKWf

Grey Ghost on
«13456715

Posts

  • MegaMan001MegaMan001 CRNA Rochester, MNRegistered User regular
    KOTOR was so special as this beautiful self contained story without having to handcuff itself to what has become a constant churn of Content.

    In the distant past. All new characters. We got Sith and Jedi, okay, great.

    Then the st

    I am in the business of saving lives.
  • Mortal SkyMortal Sky queer punk hedge witchRegistered User regular
    KotOR is one of those games that I think is super interesting to hear about but I've never quite been able to twist my own arm into playing

    But then that's true for a lot of CRPGs these days for me, I cannot get my attention span to click with that genre for some reason

  • Grey GhostGrey Ghost Registered User regular
    Ahsoka episode 2
    that was absolutely a Rakatan star map, right? It looks exactly like how they're depicted in KOTOR. Also the ship Morgan is constructing is called the Eye of Sion. As in Darth Sion?

    Also, I'm really interested in this idea that Ahsoka took Sabine as an apprentice and they aren't setting up that she's Force sensitive at all. Just training a regular person to be a Jedi. The flip side of this is that I know in the long run there will be exactly nothing about this concept that sticks around because we ultimately have to wind up in the narrative dead end that is Rise of Skywalker

  • MegaMan001MegaMan001 CRNA Rochester, MNRegistered User regular
    Mortal Sky wrote: »
    KotOR is one of those games that I think is super interesting to hear about but I've never quite been able to twist my own arm into playing

    But then that's true for a lot of CRPGs these days for me, I cannot get my attention span to click with that genre for some reason

    It's also very much a product of it's time. It was released in 2003 with all of the jank that brings looking at it twenty years later. At the time it was very special.

    I am in the business of saving lives.
  • Moth 13Moth 13 Registered User regular
    If I were to play KOTOR what is the recommended way? I hear a lot of the ports have glitches or other issues?

  • Grey GhostGrey Ghost Registered User regular
    I'm playing the Switch port and it runs great. I'm not aware of like, any new problems with it

  • MegaMan001MegaMan001 CRNA Rochester, MNRegistered User regular
    edited August 2023
    Moth 13 wrote: »
    If I were to play KOTOR what is the recommended way? I hear a lot of the ports have glitches or other issues?

    Steam and whatever fix it mod had the highest rating

    It gets discounted to like $0.99 every steam sale

    MegaMan001 on
    I am in the business of saving lives.
  • PsykomaPsykoma Registered User regular
    edited August 2023
    Ahsoka ep 1 and 2:
    I found myself kinda annoyed at parts of these two episodes. They're really pushing that Sabine had been padawan to Ahsoka, learning how to use the force.

    My big problem is that throughout all of star wars, probably (I think) the most core principle is that force users/jedi aren't made, they're born.
    We have four seasons of Sabine not only explicitly not being a force user, but also several multi episode arcs where they specifically address that she does not have that connection to the force, and she doesn't need it because she's badass enough on her own.

    Let cool characters exist outside of Jedi! Just let them fuckin exist!

    I'm hopeful that they have her back in her mando armour at the end of ep2, but give that girl back her jetpack.


    I also find rosario dawson is just so stiff. Like yeah ahsoka's been through a lot, and she would be serious when she needed to but at the core of the character she was still a positive person, and during her downtime would tend towards light-hearted moments. She shouldn't just be gloomy all the fuckin time.


    Psykoma on
  • SproutSprout Registered User regular
    Psykoma wrote: »
    Ahsoka ep 1 and 2:
    I found myself kinda annoyed at parts of these two episodes. They're really pushing that Sabine had been padawan to Ahsoka, learning how to use the force.

    My big problem is that throughout all of star wars, probably (I think) the most core principle is that force users/jedi aren't made, they're born.
    We have four seasons of Sabine not only explicitly not being a force user, but also several multi episode arcs where they specifically address that she does not have that connection to the force, and she doesn't need it because she's badass enough on her own.

    Let cool characters exist outside of Jedi! Just let them fuckin exist!

    I'm hopeful that they have her back in her mando armour at the end of ep2, but give that girl back her jetpack.


    I also find rosario dawson is just so stiff. Like yeah ahsoka's been through a lot, and she would be serious when she needed to but at the core of the character she was still a positive person, and during her downtime would tend towards light-hearted moments. She shouldn't just be gloomy all the fuckin time.


    LightsaberSmithDroid all but says that Sabine isn’t force sensitive. We still don’t know why Sabine apprenticed to Ahsoka. Possibly to feel closer to Ezra (and Kanan, but who knows if the show will acknowledge that dude)?

  • cj iwakuracj iwakura The Rhythm Regent Bears The Name FreedomRegistered User regular
    Outlaws looks like what Solo should've been.

    z48g7weaopj2.png
  • PinfeldorfPinfeldorf Yeah ZestRegistered User regular
    Shame that KOTOR remaster that was in the works seems to have finally been cancelled. I was hopeful for that one.

  • DracomicronDracomicron Registered User regular
    Grey Ghost wrote: »
    Ahsoka episode 2
    that was absolutely a Rakatan star map, right? It looks exactly like how they're depicted in KOTOR. Also the ship Morgan is constructing is called the Eye of Sion. As in Darth Sion?

    Also, I'm really interested in this idea that Ahsoka took Sabine as an apprentice and they aren't setting up that she's Force sensitive at all. Just training a regular person to be a Jedi. The flip side of this is that I know in the long run there will be exactly nothing about this concept that sticks around because we ultimately have to wind up in the narrative dead end that is Rise of Skywalker

    Eye of Scion, I think.

    As in "heir."

    You know, to perhaps some sort of national unit.

  • Grey GhostGrey Ghost Registered User regular
    Grey Ghost wrote: »
    Ahsoka episode 2
    that was absolutely a Rakatan star map, right? It looks exactly like how they're depicted in KOTOR. Also the ship Morgan is constructing is called the Eye of Sion. As in Darth Sion?

    Also, I'm really interested in this idea that Ahsoka took Sabine as an apprentice and they aren't setting up that she's Force sensitive at all. Just training a regular person to be a Jedi. The flip side of this is that I know in the long run there will be exactly nothing about this concept that sticks around because we ultimately have to wind up in the narrative dead end that is Rise of Skywalker

    Eye of Scion, I think.

    As in "heir."

    You know, to perhaps some sort of national unit.
    Subtitles spelled it Sion. could be a mistake, or could just be a little joke, I suppose

  • honoverehonovere Registered User regular
    I never played Kotor so I just thought Filoni likes the Treasure Planet.

  • ZonugalZonugal (He/Him) The Holiday Armadillo I'm Santa's representative for all the southern states. And Mexico!Registered User, Transition Team regular
    Psykoma wrote: »
    Ahsoka ep 1 and 2:
    I also find rosario dawson is just so stiff. Like yeah ahsoka's been through a lot, and she would be serious when she needed to but at the core of the character she was still a positive person, and during her downtime would tend towards light-hearted moments. She shouldn't just be gloomy all the fuckin time.

    Regarding your last point:
    I desperately need Rosario Dawson to find an engaging way to play Ahsoka.

    Because right now robotic David Tennant is bringing more energy and character to the show than the lead character.

    Although I would say this is a signature problem across most of the Disney+ Star Wars television shows. They're so in love with the idea of their lead/legacy characters being epic that they lock them into 'Stoic Badass' mode, which, isn't a choice I as an audience member find all that captivating!

    Ross-Geller-Prime-Sig-A.jpg
  • never dienever die Registered User regular
    Zonugal wrote: »
    Psykoma wrote: »
    Ahsoka ep 1 and 2:
    I also find rosario dawson is just so stiff. Like yeah ahsoka's been through a lot, and she would be serious when she needed to but at the core of the character she was still a positive person, and during her downtime would tend towards light-hearted moments. She shouldn't just be gloomy all the fuckin time.

    Regarding your last point:
    I desperately need Rosario Dawson to find an engaging way to play Ahsoka.

    Because right now robotic David Tennant is bringing more energy and character to the show than the lead character.

    Although I would say this is a signature problem across most of the Disney+ Star Wars television shows. They're so in love with the idea of their lead/legacy characters being epic that they lock them into 'Stoic Badass' mode, which, isn't a choice I as an audience member find all that captivating!
    I’ve honestly felt like she’s mostly played it as the stoic Jedi type character like the PT Jedi largely were. It feels like a directional choice. Not one I agree with, but is definitely intentional.

  • Blake TBlake T Do you have enemies then? Good. That means you’ve stood up for something, sometime in your life.Registered User regular
    Grey Ghost wrote: »

    I didn't plan on being the one to make the next thread because I am generally a lot cooler on Star Wars these days than I used to be, and I think they just don't have the juice anymore, but here we are. Anyway, let's all talk about who's the worst KOTOR companion (it's Carth)

    I played through the game several times and by far the best thing to do is romance him and go full sith and you end up scaring the shit out of him and he runs off.

  • BrainleechBrainleech 機知に富んだコメントはここにあります Registered User regular
    My complaint about Kotor the MMO is it uses the holy trinity {Tank-dps-Healer] I liked playing the bounty hunter but I wanted to play the other spec where you got the jetpack the other how does one be a healer with a big ass gun {in the case of a trooper I kept running into}

    I don't have Disney so I accidently saw two shorts on YT {and it took be to the unfun place of showing me red pill shit}
    I can understand that you are Force sensitivity but unable to use the force which brings me to an idea? That the mandalorian use a different side of the force that that they get sixth sense they can tell when it's going to go down or feel which way people will move that's why they were so good at being jedi hunters
    Why didn't Ahsoka teach Sabine how to use a light saber? There are people who had light sabers {Most of the people who touched the dark saber} And Grievous. So she could of shown her some of the different styles and see which one worked with her Mandalorian skills?

  • DracomicronDracomicron Registered User regular
    Brainleech wrote: »
    My complaint about Kotor the MMO is it uses the holy trinity {Tank-dps-Healer] I liked playing the bounty hunter but I wanted to play the other spec where you got the jetpack the other how does one be a healer with a big ass gun {in the case of a trooper I kept running into}

    I don't have Disney so I accidently saw two shorts on YT {and it took be to the unfun place of showing me red pill shit}
    I can understand that you are Force sensitivity but unable to use the force which brings me to an idea? That the mandalorian use a different side of the force that that they get sixth sense they can tell when it's going to go down or feel which way people will move that's why they were so good at being jedi hunters
    Why didn't Ahsoka teach Sabine how to use a light saber? There are people who had light sabers {Most of the people who touched the dark saber} And Grievous. So she could of shown her some of the different styles and see which one worked with her Mandalorian skills?
    Rebels
    Kanan taught Sabine how to use the Darksaber; Ahsoka wasn't permanently on the team at that point. It should be noted that the Darksaber is a unique blade and while training with it transfers to a point, it's not 100% applicable. He also mentions that she's already applying mando techniques to her form.
    Further, Ahsoka did train Sabine, but it had been a few years and she is rusty (she says as much).

  • Bloods EndBloods End Blade of Tyshalle Punch dimensionRegistered User regular
    never die wrote: »
    Zonugal wrote: »
    Psykoma wrote: »
    Ahsoka ep 1 and 2:
    I also find rosario dawson is just so stiff. Like yeah ahsoka's been through a lot, and she would be serious when she needed to but at the core of the character she was still a positive person, and during her downtime would tend towards light-hearted moments. She shouldn't just be gloomy all the fuckin time.

    Regarding your last point:
    I desperately need Rosario Dawson to find an engaging way to play Ahsoka.

    Because right now robotic David Tennant is bringing more energy and character to the show than the lead character.

    Although I would say this is a signature problem across most of the Disney+ Star Wars television shows. They're so in love with the idea of their lead/legacy characters being epic that they lock them into 'Stoic Badass' mode, which, isn't a choice I as an audience member find all that captivating!
    I’ve honestly felt like she’s mostly played it as the stoic Jedi type character like the PT Jedi largely were. It feels like a directional choice. Not one I agree with, but is definitely intentional.
    I feel.it was a choice and a choice that gets thrown out in the middle of the third episode. When ahsoka says "tell me what you need" there's a beat and a pause before she does it as she realizes that what she's been doing isn't working for her or sabine, and from then on she's a lot more engaged and dynamic

  • RaynagaRaynaga Registered User regular
    Yeah, Sabine can clearly fight. Her action scenes have been good. She just isn't force-fluent padawan good at close-range.

    Give her the jetpack!

  • Blake TBlake T Do you have enemies then? Good. That means you’ve stood up for something, sometime in your life.Registered User regular
    I mean they constantly say the force is in everything. I don’t think they are saying she is force insensitive or anything, just that by midichlorian count or whatever she wouldn’t be a Jedi.

    And I think that’s the big angle they’re making for the show. That Jedi just aren’t skywalkers and a handful of others and it’s a story line I find more interesting than I thought I would.

  • BrainleechBrainleech 機知に富んだコメントはここにあります Registered User regular
    I feel pre micichlorian the force was background noise of life itself as the dark side was able to manipulate the darker aspects of it
    I still feel if Liam Neeson played Qui gon Jinn as his character from Taken it would have made more sense why Obi-Wan believed in more of the noble and justice of the force and was unable to see why Anakin was sliding into the dark side {I know this is not how it was shown in the movies} The less savory and primal aspects

    I do make fun of how it was the WEG rpg and certain people ruined Jedi for me. coupled with how they are really trying now to give a background to the Mandalorians other than they fight good

  • BrainleechBrainleech 機知に富んだコメントはここにあります Registered User regular
    Blake T wrote: »
    I mean they constantly say the force is in everything. I don’t think they are saying she is force insensitive or anything, just that by midichlorian count or whatever she wouldn’t be a Jedi.

    And I think that’s the big angle they’re making for the show. That Jedi just aren’t skywalkers and a handful of others and it’s a story line I find more interesting than I thought I would.

    This is why I was disappointed in the Force Awakens movies as I wanted Rey to be herself not part of the Skywalkers or Any of characters to be shown the Force has Awakened

  • MegaMan001MegaMan001 CRNA Rochester, MNRegistered User regular
    Brainleech wrote: »
    Blake T wrote: »
    I mean they constantly say the force is in everything. I don’t think they are saying she is force insensitive or anything, just that by midichlorian count or whatever she wouldn’t be a Jedi.

    And I think that’s the big angle they’re making for the show. That Jedi just aren’t skywalkers and a handful of others and it’s a story line I find more interesting than I thought I would.

    This is why I was disappointed in the Force Awakens movies as I wanted Rey to be herself not part of the Skywalkers or Any of characters to be shown the Force has Awakened

    One the biggest missed opportunities of modern Star Wars has been not exploring the different ways the force can manifest in people.

    It could be real interesting to see a wide variety of skills or specialties and how some people could have minor force sensitivity.

    Instead we get Jedi or Sith with that usual suite of abilities and everyone's a Skywalker.

    I am in the business of saving lives.
  • RT800RT800 Registered User regular
    edited September 2023
    I wish I could get through KotOR2.

    For some reason the game feels much more insufferably slow and clumsy than KotOR1.

    Also a lot more bleak.

    And the only interesting character is Kreia. (Who is so very clearly NOT a Sith. Sith? What's a Sith? Never heard of 'em. MUST you label EVERYTHING?)

    RT800 on
  • CptKemzikCptKemzik Registered User regular
    edited September 2023
    Kotor 2 is the one I never got far enough with to planet-hop on the ebon hawk - I do recall the opening segment being more plodding/confusing and in some instances I think script bugs could happen where you either needed to restart from an earlier save or a new game outright.

    Kotor 1's backwater coruscant felt like a more appropriate, if generic for star wars, beginning sequence.

    Wild that it's been 20 years since the game first dropped! Still don't think the "you're exploring the galaxy as your own character" vibe that game managed to land (granted didn't play the MMO) has been matched - the trailers for those newer games just give the impression of "hey you like star wars for the running gunning jumping pew pew right?!?!"

    CptKemzik on
  • RingoRingo He/Him a distinct lack of substanceRegistered User regular
    Kotor1 has a fairly fast moving narrative to get you going - Darth Malak is the bad guy, help Carth, rescue Bastilla, form a crew, don't get dead. You survive Taris and you get to go become a Jedi and explore your personal story, building towards your backstory reveal and final Lightside/Darkside choice. Plus it really leans into the nature of a Star Wars story, something the sequel explicitly undercuts at times.

    Kotor2 starts in the survival horror genre and nothing you know from Kotor1, Star Wars in general, or anything Kreia or Atton says is going to help shed light on what is going on until you get off that station. Then you get to build a crew, all of whom are lying to you but will only reward you when you figure out how to act in line with their real goals, fight badguys and/or Jedi Masters whose goals and conflicts are only vaguely explained, have to deal with several storylines that are unfinished dead ends and pin your hopes on really enjoying Kreia's provocative thoughts on the Lightside/Darkside paradigm and its effects on the mechanics of the video game itself. And yeah, the game can be bleak as hell because even if you're trying to shepherd everyone to a Lightside happy ending, not only do you have to uncover/resolve everyone's tragic backstory, your character isn't really saving the universe so much as finishing a fight they never started, and oh by the way Kreia's always there to tell you exactly how much your good intentions are worth vis a vis unintended consequences.

    I like playing Kotor2, and I love the overall idea of it, but if you aren't picking up what it's putting down that game is a messy slog whose sole payoff may end up being Kreia simply telling you you played it wrong.

  • RingoRingo He/Him a distinct lack of substanceRegistered User regular
    TBH, I do kinda love Kreia telling you you played the game wrong. As a game with a big hanging sign flashing "Make your own narrative choices!" having the main NPC scream at you for not making the choices she deemed acceptable is such a wild flex on the player it still makes me grin

  • Munkus BeaverMunkus Beaver You don't have to attend every argument you are invited to. Philosophy: Stoicism. Politics: Democratic SocialistRegistered User, ClubPA regular
    Ringo wrote: »
    TBH, I do kinda love Kreia telling you you played the game wrong. As a game with a big hanging sign flashing "Make your own narrative choices!" having the main NPC scream at you for not making the choices she deemed acceptable is such a wild flex on the player it still makes me grin

    I respect the attempt but I feel like Kreia was more missed opportunity than anything.

    Humor can be dissected as a frog can, but dies in the process.
  • Blake TBlake T Do you have enemies then? Good. That means you’ve stood up for something, sometime in your life.Registered User regular
    Ringo wrote: »
    TBH, I do kinda love Kreia telling you you played the game wrong. As a game with a big hanging sign flashing "Make your own narrative choices!" having the main NPC scream at you for not making the choices she deemed acceptable is such a wild flex on the player it still makes me grin

    If I remember correctly kreia always tells you that you made the wrong choice. What she wants you to say is that you learned a lesson from the interaction.

  • Kane Red RobeKane Red Robe Master of Magic ArcanusRegistered User regular
    You do get to kill her at the end at least, so there's some satisfaction there. At least I think you do, the ending was pretty buggy. Plus I played that game as an early teen so mostly I remember that Visas Marr gave me feelings and not much else.

  • see317see317 Registered User regular
    You do get to kill her at the end at least, so there's some satisfaction there. At least I think you do, the ending was pretty buggy. Plus I played that game as an early teen so mostly I remember that Visas Marr gave me feelings and not much else.

    Even then, she tells you that you killed her the wrong way and she's very disappointed in your failure to learn her lessons.

  • RingoRingo He/Him a distinct lack of substanceRegistered User regular
    Blake T wrote: »
    Ringo wrote: »
    TBH, I do kinda love Kreia telling you you played the game wrong. As a game with a big hanging sign flashing "Make your own narrative choices!" having the main NPC scream at you for not making the choices she deemed acceptable is such a wild flex on the player it still makes me grin

    If I remember correctly kreia always tells you that you made the wrong choice. What she wants you to say is that you learned a lesson from the interaction.

    Oh no, I am talking about the full Darkside version of the late game scene at the Enclave on Dantooine
    If you let the Jedi Masters live, when you confront them at the Enclave they decide to knock you out and sever you from the Force. Kreia intervenes, calls them out for fearing you, telling them the things she has learned from you, and then cuts the Jedi Masters off from the Force (and the shock kills them). Kreia leaves and your companions rescue your comatose form.

    However if you killed the Jedi Masters when you fought them earlier, there's no one to face at the Enclave and eventually Kreia berates you for being a failure of a student who refused to listen and to learn from her, robbing her of a victory over the Jedi by forcing them to see she was right. She stabs herself with a lightsaber to disable you through the bond and then tells you to wait here and die with all of her dreams. Kreia then leaves and your companions rescue your comatose form.

    It's a very different scene if you played that way

  • Grey GhostGrey Ghost Registered User regular
    I have now completed Tatooine and Kashyyyk in KOTOR 1. pretty good so far! I don't think I have a lot to say about it at this point in time but it's, you know, a Bioware game from the start of what we might call their golden age, it's got some neat little stories even if everything is just a little too pat, and the light/dark dichotomy is hilariously simplistic as always.

    I'm going full light side as is my wont, but I'm in the middle of doing the Genoharadan bounty quest, which gives me dark side points even though all of my targets seem like cartoonishly evil scumbags. Oh well. Companions don't seem to react to this quest at all but I still like to bring Canderous and Juhani along for these encounters because I feel like they'd be least troubled by going to kill some mysterious shady dude just because I said so. Sometimes you gotta do some dirt

  • Grey GhostGrey Ghost Registered User regular
    edited September 2023
    I guess Ahsoka is also still happening. It's... boy, I don't know. There's like two interesting ideas here and they're wasting a lot of time refusing to explore them properly

    Grey Ghost on
  • DJ EebsDJ Eebs Moderator, Administrator admin
    extremely stupid use of de-aging technology in this show, I've heard

  • Grey GhostGrey Ghost Registered User regular
    DJ Eebs wrote: »
    extremely stupid use of de-aging technology in this show, I've heard

    Ahsoka episode 4
    it's especially stupid because Christensen was already in Obi-Wan and they didn't do it there! They just let him look like Hayden Christensen looks now and it was perfectly fine! grrrrrr

  • DJ EebsDJ Eebs Moderator, Administrator admin
    Grey Ghost wrote: »
    DJ Eebs wrote: »
    extremely stupid use of de-aging technology in this show, I've heard

    Ahsoka episode 4
    it's especially stupid because Christensen was already in Obi-Wan and they didn't do it there! They just let him look like Hayden Christensen looks now and it was perfectly fine! grrrrrr
    also very funny to build this as a big reunion with neither of the actors that played those characters when they knew each other are involved in this at all

  • DracomicronDracomicron Registered User regular
    DJ Eebs wrote: »
    Grey Ghost wrote: »
    DJ Eebs wrote: »
    extremely stupid use of de-aging technology in this show, I've heard

    Ahsoka episode 4
    it's especially stupid because Christensen was already in Obi-Wan and they didn't do it there! They just let him look like Hayden Christensen looks now and it was perfectly fine! grrrrrr
    also very funny to build this as a big reunion with neither of the actors that played those characters when they knew each other are involved in this at all

    Well I would have lost my shit if it was these two:
    0zeqiiv7rktb.jpg

Sign In or Register to comment.