Spoilers in Email Notifications

Willeth

Is there any feasible way to make spoilers not show up in email notifications? I just got a pretty big Bioshock spoiler simply by checking my email. Not ideal.

Tube

don't subscribe to threads you don't want spoilers for

we can't really babysit you through your entire internet experience

Willeth

I have everything set up to subscribe by default, so I don't have to trawl through the CP to find replies.

But hey! Not the point. You're right, I should have unsubscribed, but is there no way to prevent it? I can't be the only one.

Ramius

I've never used email notification for posts, though I have for PMs.

Am I correct that it simply strips all bbcode when sending it as an email? Because if the bbcode processor is invoked then fixing it should be not too hard, but if not, well, then that will be a bit trickier.

Willeth

I believe if somebody uses a quote, that doesn't turn up in the email. Otherwise, it just spits out all text in the post.

Ramius

testing:

Spoiler

test

Ramius

test again:

Spoiler

foo

Willeth

The first one didn't work. Not too sure about the second.

Ramius

neither is working yet...

Spoiler

foo foo

Ramius

Now I'm getting somewhere!

Ramius

OK, I've enabled something that I believe will strip spoilers from emails. If someone could test/verify that would be grand. If I can help with the testing somehow, let me know.

Ramius

Just to make sure I haven't broken them entirely...

Spoiler

this is spoilered text

Ramius

I just forced the daily digest notifications to send, a few hours early, in hopes it would help someone verify for me if the spoiler tag removal worked.

Ramius

quintuple-post!

Pony

C-c-c-c-combo breaker!

Spoiler

On-topic post up in here:
Currently, if you search for text that is contained in spoilertags, it does show the result in the search listing, but it removes the spoiler and puts a spoiler removed tag there instead, which can make it confusing why that post is on the search results at all.

I understand why this is (god forbid you search for something like "Deathly hallows" and then BAM HARRY POTTER SPOILER IN THE SEARCH RESULTS) but is it a setting the user could choose to enable or not? I use forum search quite a lot, rather than actually digging through topics to look for posts relevant to my interests (like Battlestar Galactica), and I'm willing to run the risk of spoilers to know what the hell the post that came up has to do with BSG (mostly because I'm a blatant BSG spoiler-whore but that's neither here nor there)

Yes/no/not feasible?

Ramius

well, to make it so that spoilers are not removed from the search results would be feasible, but to do the right thing and make it so that spoilered text isn't searched unless you want to see the spoilered text in the search results is not feasible without having everything indexed twice (our current index is pretty big, I wouldn't want to duplicate it.)

Ramius

also, thanks for helping me test that.

Dear Ramius,

Pony has just replied to a thread you have subscribed to entitled - Spoilers in Email Notifications - in the Tube's Circus Of Bug Reports and User Issues forum of Penny Arcade Forums.

This thread is located at:
http://forums.penny-arcade.com/showthread.php?t=33418&goto=newpost

Here is the message that has just been posted:
***************
C-c-c-c-combo breaker!

SPOILER REMOVED
***************


There may also be other replies, but you will not receive any more notifications until you visit the forum again.

All the best,
Penny Arcade Forums

looks like it worked.

Willeth

Awesome, that works a treat. Thanks a lot.

Janin

Ramius wrote: »

well, to make it so that spoilers are not removed from the search results would be feasible, but to do the right thing and make it so that spoilered text isn't searched unless you want to see the spoilered text in the search results is not feasible without having everything indexed twice (our current index is pretty big, I wouldn't want to duplicate it.)

I think he's asking for the spoiler removal to be made optional.