The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.
Well, I beat CoD4 a while ago on my 360, and it was good, and I'm still enjoying the hell outta multiplayer, but I've still got the urge to kill some folks in service of my country (or, well, any country really). So I need some recommendations for good military fps's on the 360, preferably with a decent single player campaign.
I've played the first hour or so of R6:Vegas and liked it, so it's definitely on the list. I've heard both GRAW games are good (but should I get the first one first or skip straight to the second?), but after that I'm kind of at a loss. Looking around I see that their are a lot of military-esqe fps's on the 360, and I was wondering if anyone had any first hand experience with any others and could recommend either picking them up or skipping, stuff like MOH: Airbourne, that new Soldier of Fortune, or that America's Army game, or anything else.
Battlefield 2 or 2142 are good. I like 2142. I am the only person on these forums who does, but I never played BF2 so I don't get the whole "It's just BF2 all over again".
Are you looking for just straight modern military realistic shooters or are you good with sci-fi or anything of that sort? Because beyond the CoD games and the Clancy games I really can't think of anything good. From what I've heard MoH Airbourne is a steaming tird but if you're one of those people who still like WWII shooters I'd wait out for the new Brothers In Arms. Or you could just pick up CoD2 if your in the mood for some nazi killing. Avoid CoD3 though, that game just isn't worth it.
Battlefield 2 or 2142 are good. I like 2142. I am the only person on these forums who does, but I never played BF2 so I don't get the whole "It's just BF2 all over again".
Americas Army on the 360 is exactly like GRAW 2. Seriously everything about it is the same except that it doesnt have as much customisation, there isnt as much polish, and AA is just a giant recruitment ad.
I'm just judging off of the demo so feel free to correct me.
MOH: Airborne is one of my favorites in that series, but it's not a very realistic game. It's much more arcadey and fast paced than you may be looking for. Think the Arcade Mode in COD4.
Both of the GRAW games are fantastic. The second one immediately follows the plot of the first, so if you start with number two the plot may feel a little underwhelming.
ArmA on the PC is the successor to the Operation Flashpoint games, and it's pretty neat, if PC gaming is your thing.
Avoid the new Soldier of Fortune. It's a lame game made on the slightly creaky Call of Duty 2 Engine, literally of the "Kill Guys, Find Key, Open Door, Kill Boss" variety. It has bosses that look like normal enemies but just have a massive amount of hit points. That sounds kind of cool in a weird way, but it really isn't at all. I made the mistake of buying it, and although I had fun with it for a couple hours, it just wasn't worth it in the end.
brynstar on
Xbox Live: Xander51
PSN ID : Xander51 Steam ID : Xander51
I'm in the same boat as the OP. I used to hate FPSs on consoles, as I was a strict PC gamer. After college though, I know play ONLY consoles and own a Mac.
I'm pretty interested in GRAW, GRAW2, and R6: Vegas. But I never even looked at Flashpoint. I'll be staying tuned to this thread.
Oh god, Operation Flashpoint. I remember buying the PC version on a whim back when it came out, and it's pretty much the most realistic military FPS game I've ever played.
Now when I say "realistic", I say that from the perspective of an old, out-of-shape dude who's never even picked up a gun, let alone served in the military.
Playing Operation Flashpoint gave me an idea of what it'd be like if I got plunked down in the middle of a war zone: Long bouts of slow trudging through the woods that mixed fear and boredom, punctuated by panicked, wildly-inaccurate attempts at trying to shoot at something in the distance, followed almost immediately by me having my head blown open.
Wait a sec...I played Flashpoint on my PC years ago. I agree that it can be avoided.
I guess it's not for everyone. It's not an action game, it's not what you could call a First Person shooter. It's pretty much as much a soldier sim as you're likely to get. Combat is often brutal and punishingly unfair on one side or another depending on how you do things, and just plain on how things go.
But when you get into it, it's really loads of fun.
For the 360, don't forget backwards compatible Oxbox games. I'll Recommend Ghost Recon 2 Summit Strike. My friends and I had a blast playing multiplayer against the computer.
I'm not sure on Operation Flashpoint 2, with a different developer I fear it may lose the realism but, if it doesn't I'll be happy! If only ArmA worked well...
I remember going to buy Flashpoint when it came out, and the guy at ebgames or whatever it was asked me if I was sure that I wanted it because it was "complicated".
If you don't mind it being on the PC, I too would recommend Operation: Flashpoint. It is old and extremely ugly at this point, but it's still the best mixed unit military simulation out there. It manages to be a realistic infantry simulation, tank simulation (not to mention all the other wheeled vehicles you can drive), and helicopter simulation, and throw them all into the game in a convincing and compelling manner.
It is by no means an exciting game, though. The missions often throw you into combat, but the combat tends to be led up to by slow and boring patrols or long rides to the combat zone in an APC with nothing to do and no interesting dialogue to listen to like you might find in a modern set piece oriented game. Op:Flash doesn't try to present you with incredible set pieces or exciting battles or non-stop action. It doesn't even expect you to always succeed in a mission.
And then there's a great mod community which I believe is still active so when you've finished with the main campaign, there's a butt load of available scenarios and campaigns for you to download, many of them of extremely high quality.
And if you want, you can get into it yourself. It's surprisingly easy to learn and the utilities the game comes with are very accessible and easy to use and the scripts that drive the scenarios and cutscenes are both simple and very versatile and you can do some really impressive things with very little experience and practice.
If you really want something more modern and better looking and also on the 360, you can't go wrong with the GRAW games either. They aren't perfect (coming back to them, I always, always hate the controls) and they're short, but they are good military themed games. They're a lot more exciting than Op:Flash too. And start with the first one. The two play almost identically and it helps to be familiar with the story from the first.
Posts
I like 2142 as well, don't worry.
Those games range from mediocre to bad. Try to find a copy of Operation Flashpoint. Or hold out for the sequel.
I'm just judging off of the demo so feel free to correct me.
Both of the GRAW games are fantastic. The second one immediately follows the plot of the first, so if you start with number two the plot may feel a little underwhelming.
ArmA on the PC is the successor to the Operation Flashpoint games, and it's pretty neat, if PC gaming is your thing.
Avoid the new Soldier of Fortune. It's a lame game made on the slightly creaky Call of Duty 2 Engine, literally of the "Kill Guys, Find Key, Open Door, Kill Boss" variety. It has bosses that look like normal enemies but just have a massive amount of hit points. That sounds kind of cool in a weird way, but it really isn't at all. I made the mistake of buying it, and although I had fun with it for a couple hours, it just wasn't worth it in the end.
PSN ID : Xander51 Steam ID : Xander51
Using the headset to do the voice commands usually works really well.
EDIT: Oh. 360 games. Nevermind.
Wii: 1056 1549 1957 0345
Part Time Gamer.com | My Game Collection | Flickr: Video Game Photo Mode | Flickr: Game Rooms
I'm pretty interested in GRAW, GRAW2, and R6: Vegas. But I never even looked at Flashpoint. I'll be staying tuned to this thread.
Now when I say "realistic", I say that from the perspective of an old, out-of-shape dude who's never even picked up a gun, let alone served in the military.
Playing Operation Flashpoint gave me an idea of what it'd be like if I got plunked down in the middle of a war zone: Long bouts of slow trudging through the woods that mixed fear and boredom, punctuated by panicked, wildly-inaccurate attempts at trying to shoot at something in the distance, followed almost immediately by me having my head blown open.
RB6 = Not quite as good but still a lot of fun. I have it on PS3 and the online quality sucks balls, I'm told it's better on 360 though.
I fucking loved Operation Flashpoint. I will fucking love Operation Flashpoint 2.
I guess it's not for everyone. It's not an action game, it's not what you could call a First Person shooter. It's pretty much as much a soldier sim as you're likely to get. Combat is often brutal and punishingly unfair on one side or another depending on how you do things, and just plain on how things go.
But when you get into it, it's really loads of fun.
Buy some useless stuff at my Cafepress site!
It is by no means an exciting game, though. The missions often throw you into combat, but the combat tends to be led up to by slow and boring patrols or long rides to the combat zone in an APC with nothing to do and no interesting dialogue to listen to like you might find in a modern set piece oriented game. Op:Flash doesn't try to present you with incredible set pieces or exciting battles or non-stop action. It doesn't even expect you to always succeed in a mission.
And then there's a great mod community which I believe is still active so when you've finished with the main campaign, there's a butt load of available scenarios and campaigns for you to download, many of them of extremely high quality.
And if you want, you can get into it yourself. It's surprisingly easy to learn and the utilities the game comes with are very accessible and easy to use and the scripts that drive the scenarios and cutscenes are both simple and very versatile and you can do some really impressive things with very little experience and practice.
If you really want something more modern and better looking and also on the 360, you can't go wrong with the GRAW games either. They aren't perfect (coming back to them, I always, always hate the controls) and they're short, but they are good military themed games. They're a lot more exciting than Op:Flash too. And start with the first one. The two play almost identically and it helps to be familiar with the story from the first.