The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.

Laptop won't recognize external HD

-Spitfire--Spitfire- Registered User regular
edited January 2008 in Help / Advice Forum
OK, so I've had this desktop computer for quite a few years, and a couple of weeks ago it just... died. It says "please insert system disk" and when I insert the disk, it says "please insert system disk". So, whatever. A few months prior I had purchased a laptop (which is about twice as good as the desktop was) so I'm not without a computer, but I am without all the files I need from my old compy.

So I thought to myself that there had to be a way to make the old harddrive into what amounts to an external drive for the laptop. I described my situation to the gentleman at the computer store, who sold me a housing unit. I got it all assembled and so forth, but when I connect it to the laptop, it doesn't appear on the list of "drives" on my menu. My device manager lists it as a "USB Mass Storage Device" so the computer obviously knows there's "a big thing with lots of stuff" connected to it, but it won't let me in. It is also listed under "Disk Drives" with a location of "0". They also all say "this device is working properly".

Obviously I am doing something wrong, or possibly off completely in left field with the whole idea (always a possibility!)

I'm running Windows XP Pro.

-Spitfire- on

Posts

  • yotesyotes Registered User regular
    edited January 2008
    That kind of sounds like the old HD died (causing the "system disk" error), and then you put the dead drive in an external enclosure. And it's still dead.

    Have you tried a different HD in the same enclosure yet?

    yotes on
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • -Spitfire--Spitfire- Registered User regular
    edited January 2008
    I thought it died as in "the OS doesn't work but the data is still retrievable", not "it died and you're screwed".

    ... is there a difference?

    It died one day while I was surfing my own website - froze and stopped responding. It gave me the error when I rebooted.

    Can I get the data back?

    -Spitfire- on
  • Shark_MegaByteShark_MegaByte Registered User regular
    edited January 2008
    Laptops frequently have trouble running external drives, because the drive can't pull as much power from USB on a laptop as it can from a desktop. Your description seems to fit this problem, and the same thing happens when I plug my Maxtor external hd into my laptop on a single USB port.

    The answer is to use two USB ports.

    Some external drives/enclosures come with a special USB cable to address this problem - it has one USB connector for the drive, and two for the PC - a way of making sure it gets enough power. You just need to find one of those and it should work.

    Shark_MegaByte on
  • -Spitfire--Spitfire- Registered User regular
    edited January 2008
    The enclosure in question has its own power cord which it won't run without. I didn't think it was pulling any power through the USB, or am I misunderstanding?

    I also heard that it can take some time for the drive to register, but it's been overnight and still nothing.

    EDIT: to a previous reply - I haven't tried another HD in the enclosure yet, simply because I don't have extra ones lying around. I haven't tried connecting it to another computer either, for the same reason.

    -Spitfire- on
  • yotesyotes Registered User regular
    edited January 2008
    3.5" externals aren't powered by USB anyways, so that shouldn't be the problem.

    First, see if there's chipset or USB drivers for your laptop on your manufacturer's website, and install those. Occasionally, that can be the issue.
    If that doesn't help, put the drive back into the desktop it was previously in, and boot off a Knoppix LiveCD (set the CD/DVD drive as the first boot device in your BIOS). If you can't access the HD that way, it's probably dead.

    Does the desktop's BIOS recognize the old drive?

    yotes on
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
Sign In or Register to comment.