Woahhh I changed the title, wooooooo heres a painting
wooooo critque me please
Might as well post some stuff since I got myself in this situation anyways, <insert hateful word> you tycho and your Strange Attractor game that you had to post about and make me go to these forums
I wouldn't mind but I made these a year ago, although I can see most of the mistakes in them myself already, it was just some stuff I did real fast with the Pen tool in photoshop, like the banana has a stiff back near the mouth, the pumpkins mouth is strangely bent, ect ect
Edit: Which was like... my first year of doing serious art /wrist, I would show my crap, but its crap, although I suppose I can show some of my recent works I just NEED to get mah camera set up I'M NOT READY YET NOOOOOOO
Loomdun on
splat
0
Options
NappuccinoSurveyor of Things and StuffRegistered Userregular
edited September 2008
Well, the more "crap" you put up, the better critique you can get from us.
Well, the more "crap" you put up, the better critique you can get from us.
Wellll if I wanted critique I would probably ask for it,I'll probably make a new topic in a few minutes and post actual stuff and ask about it I've always been curious as to what the vicious world of the interwebz has to say about it, just gotta figure out how to rotate :<
Loomdun on
splat
0
Options
NappuccinoSurveyor of Things and StuffRegistered Userregular
edited September 2008
Word to the wise: keep all your stuff you think is thread worthy in this thread- Doodles should go in the doodle thread. No need creating another thread for your stuff, this one will do just fine.
You can change the topic to let us know when you update by editing it in your first post.
Well then i'm a moron, alright let me figure out how to open up these pictures them from my camera and i'll give 2 paintings that you may viciously rip me apart for creating real fast then
Loomdun on
splat
0
Options
NappuccinoSurveyor of Things and StuffRegistered Userregular
edited September 2008
I actually like the first one quite a lot. The shapeless shapes that appear in the sky and the water are really interesting to look at. The use of color is pretty well done and balanced as well. However, the mountains (hills?) bug me quite a bit... the white on the middle doesn't seem to belong to a mountain/hill. The white itself works well with the rest of the picture, but it doesn't quite work in relation to what it's painted on (imo)
The second one is... well... blurry and a little dull. There isn't that contrast of color that lets it pop like your first one.
oh thank you, Personally I love the color blue, I basically used Blue white and Black to make the entire thing, then I added some brown to the stones, I was going for a glistening look on the mountain with small packs of visible snow, but personally its just cause I like white on black
And meh do you mean blurry as in I failed to take a proper picture of it?
Edit: I suppose I could take the Moonlight in the forest and add it a slight ray going diagonally throughout it in order to get cut off view, The contrast from the moonlight and the night time shades should allow it to pop up enough if I plan it, not sure if I WANT to do it though I would show more stuff but I dont think nude drawings are allowed in these forums
I do have another painting but its incomplete. These are all my first ever paintings, (I learn REALLY fast) but I cant paint much right now because I have 3 college art classes which don't involve painting, Human anatomy, Freehanding and 2-d design (the 2 basics and 1 recommended for majoring class due to pre-requisite) I cant take a painting class until I get those 2 done meh.
BUT ONCE I DO which will be 16 weeks i'll probably come here and be like "hay can you look at my stuffz" and hopefully i'll get better at using my camera then
Loomdun on
splat
0
Options
NappuccinoSurveyor of Things and StuffRegistered Userregular
oh thank you, Personally I love the color blue, I basically used Blue white and Black to make the entire thing, then I added some brown to the stones, I was going for a glistening look on the mountain with small packs of visible snow, but personally its just cause I like white on black
And I'd certainly agree- 1/2 my clothes have blue on them somewhere lol. I think that, because the mountains are so rounded they don't quite look like mountians.
And meh do you mean blurry as in I failed to take a proper picture of it?
I'm not sure, but I'm leaning towards the photo itself is blurry with a slight dash of a painting with little contrast.
Edit: I suppose I could take the Moonlight in the forest and add it a slight ray going diagonally throughout it in order to get cut off view, The contrast from the moonlight and the night time shades should allow it to pop up enough if I plan it, not sure if I WANT to do it though I would show more stuff but I dont think nude drawings are allowed in these forums
I think that moonlight could add a lot to it, but you should probably get a second opinion before you take mine. I do my best, but i'm proven wrong often enough.
Also, nude drawings are allowed, just make sure the thread title includes NSFW (not suitible for work) if you decide to post them.
Oh wait, it isn't a double post, eh I stand with the rest of what I said, But when I first reposted it with my art, I was curious as to the opinions of those who I would show my artwork to, I know this may sound strange but I wasn't hoping to receive positive comments, I dont know where I'm going with what I can do and I wish to continue exceeding even though I dont know where i'm going with it, I feel as to what I can do right now is very small and insignificant there are still lots of people who excel far more then me. So really perhaps was hoping if people would look more and be more harsh with me please. To anyone who i've shown let it be teacher professor or family, they have only been positive. which isn't what was what should be right?
People should be trying to help with less compliments and more judgement. To say whether something is nice is fine, and to throw in a compliment is fine as well. But theres to much of that IRL and I dont want to think that I am capable because I know I am not, so if night dragon could kindly come back and tell me that its crap I would very much appreciate it
Loomdun on
splat
0
Options
MustangArbiter of Unpopular OpinionsRegistered Userregular
edited September 2008
Okay, you suck! Feel better?
I have a hard time critiquing traditional art because I'm a total lost cause when using it myself.
However, I think you could stand to work on your values, especially with your landscapes. Everything has the same contrast/colours from foreground to back ground. Your contrast needs to die off as the painting aproaches the horizon (depending on the amount of particles in the air/time of day), and eventually dissapearing into the sky.
It's actually a common thing I see with traditional artists, so I'm assuming that it's a prick of a thing to try and portray with paint.
Maybe bring out the colours a little more with some higher contrasts to draw the viewer in. At the moment, (could be the photo doing this) the colours look a little dull and washed out.
In this one, high contrasts in the flames would work well with the dark background.
I could be wrong as i dont really understand how colour works, but yeah, thats about all i find wrong with your work.
I did work on the painting more, I'll bring a less blurry image of it in a few minutes along to update what it looks like
I have never taken photos before so its new to me I've found that all my pictures looked like this because I took them while standing, which makes everything blurry because the pressure on hitting the button causes the camera to slightly move.
anywho i'll re-take my other two sooner or later. this is what that painting looks like unblurred and updated
Posts
You're from 4chan, aren't you.
I wouldn't mind but I made these a year ago, although I can see most of the mistakes in them myself already, it was just some stuff I did real fast with the Pen tool in photoshop, like the banana has a stiff back near the mouth, the pumpkins mouth is strangely bent, ect ect
Edit: Which was like... my first year of doing serious art /wrist, I would show my crap, but its crap, although I suppose I can show some of my recent works I just NEED to get mah camera set up I'M NOT READY YET NOOOOOOO
Wellll if I wanted critique I would probably ask for it,I'll probably make a new topic in a few minutes and post actual stuff and ask about it I've always been curious as to what the vicious world of the interwebz has to say about it, just gotta figure out how to rotate :<
You can change the topic to let us know when you update by editing it in your first post.
Also, you should expect every piece you post here to be critiqued. That's why people post here, not for asspats or anything else.
The second one is... well... blurry and a little dull. There isn't that contrast of color that lets it pop like your first one.
And meh do you mean blurry as in I failed to take a proper picture of it?
Edit: I suppose I could take the Moonlight in the forest and add it a slight ray going diagonally throughout it in order to get cut off view, The contrast from the moonlight and the night time shades should allow it to pop up enough if I plan it, not sure if I WANT to do it though I would show more stuff but I dont think nude drawings are allowed in these forums
I do have another painting but its incomplete. These are all my first ever paintings, (I learn REALLY fast) but I cant paint much right now because I have 3 college art classes which don't involve painting, Human anatomy, Freehanding and 2-d design (the 2 basics and 1 recommended for majoring class due to pre-requisite) I cant take a painting class until I get those 2 done meh.
BUT ONCE I DO which will be 16 weeks i'll probably come here and be like "hay can you look at my stuffz" and hopefully i'll get better at using my camera then
And I'd certainly agree- 1/2 my clothes have blue on them somewhere lol. I think that, because the mountains are so rounded they don't quite look like mountians.
I'm not sure, but I'm leaning towards the photo itself is blurry with a slight dash of a painting with little contrast.
I think that moonlight could add a lot to it, but you should probably get a second opinion before you take mine. I do my best, but i'm proven wrong often enough.
Also, nude drawings are allowed, just make sure the thread title includes NSFW (not suitible for work) if you decide to post them.
Here is a sneakpeek of what will be done though, like I said I probably wont work on it until a few weeks though
Am I the only one that sees a dolphin in the top left?
Oh good someone finally caught on, Hint hint those 2 paintings also contain a dog, and a lizard
Actually, that was the first thing that I saw when I looked at the picture- it took me a second to realize that it wasn't underwater.
Yep I saw that straight away and then realised it wasn't a dolphin at all.
People should be trying to help with less compliments and more judgement. To say whether something is nice is fine, and to throw in a compliment is fine as well. But theres to much of that IRL and I dont want to think that I am capable because I know I am not, so if night dragon could kindly come back and tell me that its crap I would very much appreciate it
I have a hard time critiquing traditional art because I'm a total lost cause when using it myself.
However, I think you could stand to work on your values, especially with your landscapes. Everything has the same contrast/colours from foreground to back ground. Your contrast needs to die off as the painting aproaches the horizon (depending on the amount of particles in the air/time of day), and eventually dissapearing into the sky.
It's actually a common thing I see with traditional artists, so I'm assuming that it's a prick of a thing to try and portray with paint.
In this one, high contrasts in the flames would work well with the dark background.
I could be wrong as i dont really understand how colour works, but yeah, thats about all i find wrong with your work.
*BTW i suck at painting*
I have never taken photos before so its new to me I've found that all my pictures looked like this because I took them while standing, which makes everything blurry because the pressure on hitting the button causes the camera to slightly move.
anywho i'll re-take my other two sooner or later. this is what that painting looks like unblurred and updated