The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.

We're breaking the habit tonight! (Cat Thread)

JadedJaded Registered User regular
edited October 2008 in Help / Advice Forum
Hey guys... I have a problem of the feline variety, allow me to start with back story.

May of this year I accepted a job 2 hours away from where my girlfriend and I lived, so I moved out this way to start my job while my lovely lady sold our old home. With her was my cat (Alias) who is 6 years old. Alias has always been a... emotional... kitty. Hates kids, loves adults, can go from friendly to frustrated in about half a second.

In August my girlfriend got a job out here and she moved out to where I was staying (with family) until we could find our own home, however where we were staying there was a black lab pup, so I asked my parents to watch over Alias until we found our own place, which they happily agreed to do.

The place in which my girlfriend and I owned before we moved had no fence, so we never let the cat out in fear that she would run away, get hit by a car, etc etc... mom and dad however had a fully enclosed back yard. When my mom and dad get up in the morning (0430 - 0500) they would brew a pot of coffee and go sit on their patio, read the paper, watch the birds, whatever it is that mom and dads do at that ungodly hour. Now, of course the cat was up so they started taking her out in the yard with them, which she apparently loved.

So, in new city my girlfriend and I found a place finally that we moved into on September 15th. The cat was leery around the new place for the first 3 weeks or so, getting her bearings, learning all the places she can hide and finding all the sun beams were her first priorities.

Now however, that she is comfortable she is up every morning at 0400 and jumping up on my bed begging to be let outside (This has been going on for about 4 days now). Day 1, I let her out and stayed up, but man... I go to bed at midnight, 4 hours sleep kills me for work. Nights 2 - 4 I have gently nudged her off the bed, but she keeps coming back every 10 minutes or so. I closed the bedroom door on night number 2 after the third time that the cat came back (lol?) and laid back down. Now... I sleep with ear plugs in (airport nearby and a fire hall down the street) so I don't hear much while I snooze... however, the unearthly, mournful wail that my cat let out from the other end of the house by the back door easily penetrated my 35 decibel earplugs. So I got up, went and let her out and brewed a pot of coffee.

Day 3 and 4 I have got out of bed, closed the bedroom door and crashed on the couch as I didn't want her meowing(?) to wake the girlfriend.

Long story short, cat wakes me every morning at 0400 and whines to be let out, is there a way to break this habitual behaviour?

Cat facts:
- female
- spayed
- has all claws
- 6 years old
- short hair
- likes munching on grass
- likes eating dragonflies
- hates other cats
- whines if she doesn't get her way

I don't want to take to spritzing her with a water bottle as she's finally (in the last year) really warmed up to my girlfriend and I and lets us nuzzle and pet her.
Save me! Save my sleep... H/A forums... your my only hope...

I can't think of anything clever.
Jaded on

Posts

  • LPDustinLPDustin Registered User regular
    edited October 2008
    Well I dont like cats so my help may not help, but I would take the Eric Cartman route and "smack it on da head, and say Thats a bad kitty!"

    Really I have found cats to be REALLY stubborn and thats because they see themselves as the boss in any owner-cat relationship, which is why I dont like them...

    LPDustin on
  • JadedJaded Registered User regular
    edited October 2008
    LPDustin wrote: »
    but I would take the Eric Cartman route and "smack it on da head, and say Thats a bad kitty!"

    If I'm not about to spritz her I certainly am not going to smack / bonk / slap her on the noggin... it's just not in my nature.

    I love cats, the sheer attitude they have over dogs (I've had 2 dogs and this is my first cat) the independence. I find them far more entertaining and cuddly then either of my dogs (Toy poodle and a Bishon / Shitzu) were.

    Jaded on
    I can't think of anything clever.
  • SpherickSpherick Registered User regular
    edited October 2008
    As a cat owner, the only thing I can suggest is to spritz them or ignore it until the cat understands that it is a bad behavoir. Unfortunately, cats are vastly different from dogs in the training aspect.

    Either that or lock the cat out of your room at nights.

    Spherick on
  • LPDustinLPDustin Registered User regular
    edited October 2008
    Yeah, definately the greatest things about cats are their independance and how cuddly there are, I have a Bichon-shitzu (weird eh?) and he takes the role of a cat very well but without all the shedding :P

    As for training cats with spritzing, I dont know if its just me, but it depends on the cat, some might just think your playing with them depending on their personality.

    LPDustin on
  • EggyToastEggyToast Jersey CityRegistered User regular
    edited October 2008
    She's doing this because you're letting her. She figures "making loud noise" gets you up and lets her outside. Why would she change?

    For her to get over it, you need to not let her outside. At all. Ever. Especially not at 4am. Don't play with her, don't interact with her at all. Ignore her at 4. You're beat already, so tonight, go to bed at 8 or 9 or something, so when she wakes you up at 4 you can get to all the things you didn't do last night -- read the internet, do the dishes, play video games, whatever. Then go into work. Do NOT interact with her (unless she comes up to you to be petted, etc.). And definitely do not let her outside anymore, or else she'll keep doing the same thing.

    EggyToast on
    || Flickr — || PSN: EggyToast
  • YamiNoSenshiYamiNoSenshi A point called Z In the complex planeRegistered User regular
    edited October 2008
    LPDustin wrote: »
    Well I dont like cats so my help may not help, but I would take the Eric Cartman route and "smack it on da head, and say Thats a bad kitty!"

    Terrible idea. Cats don't respond well to physical punishment. Scaring them is the best way, so a water bottle or even a very sudden and loud "BAD!" can deter behavior. Other than that, it's a bit like raising a small child. Ignore the behavior and DO. NOT. GIVE. IN. Just like a kid, you'll teach the cat that whining and yowling are effective methods for getting her way.

    EDIT: Physical punishment is bad for cats because not only does it not work, it deters a different behavior: being friends with you. Hitting a cat just makes it afraid of you, not the behavior you want stopped.

    YamiNoSenshi on
  • LPDustinLPDustin Registered User regular
    edited October 2008
    I was gonna say try scaring it, but figured that would seem crueler then a bonk on the head, oh well lol

    LPDustin on
  • edited October 2008
    This content has been removed.

  • JadedJaded Registered User regular
    edited October 2008
    EggyToast wrote: »
    She's doing this because you're letting her. She figures "making loud noise" gets you up and lets her outside. Why would she change?

    For her to get over it, you need to not let her outside. At all. Ever. Especially not at 4am. Don't play with her, don't interact with her at all. Ignore her at 4. You're beat already, so tonight, go to bed at 8 or 9 or something, so when she wakes you up at 4 you can get to all the things you didn't do last night -- read the internet, do the dishes, play video games, whatever. Then go into work. Do NOT interact with her (unless she comes up to you to be petted, etc.). And definitely do not let her outside anymore, or else she'll keep doing the same thing.

    In regards to this. Would she not be, I suppose for lack of a better word, conditioned to realize she can not go out until people are awake and doing their routine? As I said, the last couple days I have just crashed on the couch after the wake-up call and she seems to be placated until the alarm clock goes off. I don't want to limit her physical activity (which she gets tonnes of outside)... I just want her to realize that we don't all cat nap.

    =^.^=

    Jaded on
    I can't think of anything clever.
  • EggyToastEggyToast Jersey CityRegistered User regular
    edited October 2008
    Yeah, the only way to really train cats to stop doing something (that involves you) is the silent treatment. My wife and I switched our cats from twice daily feeding to only once at night, and it took about a week or so, but now at 9pm every night the cats get their food. And if we forget, at 9:15 our wet/raw food addict is meowing like crazy. But the only way we did it is by sticking with it, and not giving in when he was meowing in the morning.

    EggyToast on
    || Flickr — || PSN: EggyToast
  • EggyToastEggyToast Jersey CityRegistered User regular
    edited October 2008
    Jaded wrote: »
    EggyToast wrote: »
    She's doing this because you're letting her. She figures "making loud noise" gets you up and lets her outside. Why would she change?

    For her to get over it, you need to not let her outside. At all. Ever. Especially not at 4am. Don't play with her, don't interact with her at all. Ignore her at 4. You're beat already, so tonight, go to bed at 8 or 9 or something, so when she wakes you up at 4 you can get to all the things you didn't do last night -- read the internet, do the dishes, play video games, whatever. Then go into work. Do NOT interact with her (unless she comes up to you to be petted, etc.). And definitely do not let her outside anymore, or else she'll keep doing the same thing.

    In regards to this. Would she not be, I suppose for lack of a better word, conditioned to realize she can not go out until people are awake and doing their routine? As I said, the last couple days I have just crashed on the couch after the wake-up call and she seems to be placated until the alarm clock goes off. I don't want to limit her physical activity (which she gets tonnes of outside)... I just want her to realize that we don't all cat nap.

    =^.^=

    If she never goes outside, she'll stop trying to wake you up in order to let her out. She may still want you awake, but that's why you shouldn't interact with her. Most cats don't care if you're awake or asleep, as long as you're around a space on a schedule, but she's not waking you up to play with YOU -- she's going outside, and then you're crashing on the couch. You can play with her at night, so that she's tired, and "expects" to play with you at night -- not in the morning.

    EggyToast on
    || Flickr — || PSN: EggyToast
  • EvilkittenEvilkitten Registered User new member
    edited October 2008
    Just got one thing to say to you Jaded...

    told you so!

    love,
    me

    Evilkitten on
  • JadedJaded Registered User regular
    edited October 2008
    We'll settle this when we get home... :x

    Jaded on
    I can't think of anything clever.
  • TrowizillaTrowizilla Registered User regular
    edited October 2008
    Stop letting your cat out at all. It's really dangerous for them (outside cats live, on average, only half as long as inside cats) and it's terrible for the local ecosystem. She'll make a big fuss for awhile and then get over it.

    If she really likes eating grass, you could get her one of those little cat-grass trays.

    Trowizilla on
  • JadedJaded Registered User regular
    edited October 2008
    Stop letting your cat out at all. It's really dangerous for them (outside cats live, on average, only half as long as inside cats) and it's terrible for the local ecosystem.

    Even if it's just in a fenced in back yard?
    I know she "could" get over the fence if she tried, but she seems quite content to just veg outside.

    Jaded on
    I can't think of anything clever.
  • BetelguesePDXBetelguesePDX Registered User regular
    edited October 2008
    Kinda stating the obvious but have you considered installing a pet door?

    BetelguesePDX on
  • JadedJaded Registered User regular
    edited October 2008
    Kinda stating the obvious but have you considered installing a pet door?

    If I had any kind of mechanical apptitude I would look into something like that. how do they work in regards to having 2 doors though? We have a storm door on the outside and a wooden door on the inside. I imagine the Storm Door would have to come out?o_O

    Jaded on
    I can't think of anything clever.
  • stratslingerstratslinger Registered User regular
    edited October 2008
    Trowizilla wrote: »
    Stop letting your cat out at all...

    outside cats live, on average, only half as long as inside cats

    This. Especially this. The amount of diseases that an outdoor or partially outdoor cat is exposed to drsatically reduces their life expectancy. If other cats happen by, or even have been through the yard recently, you're talking potential exposure to Feline Leukemia, FIV (basically, kitty AIDS), and any number of other things. Any mosquito out there could potentially be carrying heartorm larvae - if your cat is infected, it's fatal (it's treatable in dogs - but that very treatment is fatal to cats' systems).

    If you want to continue to let Alias out, just make certain she's 100% up to date on her shots and taking a monthly dose of heartguard or similar.

    As for behavior adjustment, the silent treatment is one o fthe best. Another - and this takes a small commitment on you or your girlfriend's part - is to try to exhaust the kitty at bedtime. One of ours used to play all hours of the night when my wife and I moved in together. The worst part was he'd play in the bedroom - usually running right over us both several times throughout the night. We found that playing with him before bedtime until HE lost interest eliminated the problem. We used to toss around little toy mice, he'd actually fetch them and bring them back for us to toss again. Any kind of active toy should do the trick.

    stratslinger on
  • AurinAurin Registered User regular
    edited October 2008
    Jaded wrote: »
    Kinda stating the obvious but have you considered installing a pet door?

    If I had any kind of mechanical apptitude I would look into something like that. how do they work in regards to having 2 doors though? We have a storm door on the outside and a wooden door on the inside. I imagine the Storm Door would have to come out?o_O

    You can actually put them in the wall near the door as well. My house has one leading to the yard since all we have are sliding glass doors. And, they have little plates you can put over them as well if you ever change your mind on letting her out.

    Personally, I don't let my cats outside because I don't like the whole get hit by a car thing... and the cat next door would constantly want to beat them up. :P

    Aurin on
  • SheepSheep Registered User, __BANNED USERS regular
    edited October 2008
    Never ever give in to a cat. If a cat does something and sees that it gets results, it will repeat it. From now on, just ignore the cat or perform negative reinforcement. When she starts howling at 4AM, get up and lock her in the bathroom or someplace similar until you get up. She'll start to realize that if she does this, then she'll be locked up instead of let out.

    Sheep on
  • TrowizillaTrowizilla Registered User regular
    edited October 2008
    Jaded wrote: »
    Stop letting your cat out at all. It's really dangerous for them (outside cats live, on average, only half as long as inside cats) and it's terrible for the local ecosystem.

    Even if it's just in a fenced in back yard?
    I know she "could" get over the fence if she tried, but she seems quite content to just veg outside.

    Other cats can and do get over the fence, exposing your cat to highly contagious and often deadly feline diseases. Plus, you never know when your cat will get a wild hair up her butt and leave your fenced yard; you don't even know if she's doing it now, because you're letting her out when you're not right there to watch her.

    Plus, birds and other small animals do come in and out of your yard freely, and your cat is very likely eating them. This is a bad thing both for the bird population and for your cat, since she can get all sorts of nasty parasites that way.

    Just keep her inside.

    Trowizilla on
  • edited October 2008
    This content has been removed.

Sign In or Register to comment.