This is going to be a tepid OP and for that I apologize. I think there was a thread similar to this awhile back but I can't find it anymore.
I was thinking earlier today of games that the collective gaming community seemed to gush about that I never really "got." That got me wondering about whether other people have ever had similar experiences of trying out games that are praised as genre changing masterpieces that seemed to just fall flat.
I know, I should give my own personal example, but I'm already procrastinating as it is. I'll write up the three games that I have in mind when I have another moment. Until then, what about everyone else?
edit: Oh! Also, please try to give an actual reason for not liking the game. Simply stating the title and then leaving is not and adequate argument. There should also be little "hey, you're full of shit because blah blah blah" replies. We're only allowed to hate together!
edit 2: THIS IS NOT A DEBATE THREAD.
Please don't treat it as such.