The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.
Ok my step dad just came in and said he's going to scrape the paint off the asbestos on the front porch of our house and repaint it himself.
I said that he should get professionals to do it but he “Doesn’t want to pay the moneyâ€. I told him that fucking professionals charge so much because it’s a pro job and the stuff is super dangerous. He’s not listening. I called my mum and she talked to him and let it go through pretty much because “He seems set on doing it†and she can’t do anything atm because she’s in another city.
He has masks that say “For asbestos removal†and a sort of throw away suit. It just rained and he’ll water down the area once he’s done. Is that the right gear and procedure?
Am I overreacting? I mean the stuff is highly dangerous.
There’s no reason to do the job anyway and if he wants it done I think not endangering the family and letting pros do it would be worth the money.
I’ve told my brother not to go anywhere near the porch and stay out of the living room (which is adjacent to the porch). Anything else I should do?
This is what I took away from my environmental chemistry class. Asbestos is safe as long as you're not fooling with it. Messing with it is a really bad idea and he needs to get a professional. Asbestos gets into your lungs and causes scarring as well as cancer.
One topic I do know really well is lung scarring. My father ruined his lungs with pesticides, he has it bad. Scar tissue on lungs never goes away, you have permanently damaged lungs. I really suggest not letting your dad do this. Sure it seems like people are always overreacting about chemicals and such but it only takes one time, as my father found out (we told him not to spray above his head), to hurt yourself so bad you have to be on O2 the rest of your life. He seems to have aged about 10 years in the last 3.
Walter on
0
Blake TDo you have enemies then?Good. That means you’ve stood up for something, sometime in your life.Registered Userregular
edited December 2006
Most councils do not allow people to remove asbestos (in australia at least) similar rules may apply there. If you really want to check with you local council and tell your father that you are going to call the cops if he does. Additionally in australia you can't dump asbestos into a land fill so ask him what he's going to do with it once he's done, lisenced removalists know how to get rid of it.
If you really don't want to bother and he's deadset in going through with it, try soaking the roof beforehand to ensure at least the small airborne pieces are weighed down enough so they don't float around. That's me just applying logic to the situation I have no idea if that will actually work and really I recomend getting in the profesionals.
Also point out to him it doesn't take much at all to kill him.
EDIT: on the throw away suit, that needs to be marked for asbestos use also. Really most removalists now days have full face masks.
Also in terms of protecting your brother I'd also tape up the entry ways and windows on the porch with masking tape and then vaccuum serval times once finsihed while still wearing the equipment.
He's already started. Just to clarify, this is in Australia and he isn't removing it, he's repainting it. It's just in a small part of the roo on the outside of the he's scratching off the paint and then repainting it.
He's so dead set on doing it, I really don't give a flying fuck whether his lungs collapse or scar or whatever. He'd totally deserve it.
I'm just wondering what me and my brother should do. Is staying away from the area for a few days enough? If he repaints it and the paint drys will it be safe again?
How long will it take for the stuff to be taken away by the wind?
If scraping off the paint and repainting it is endangering our household I'd consider calling the cops but it's a big step and I don't want to do it if he's only endangering himself.
People don't like to listen to heresay and anecdotes. Use google scholar to look up asbetos dangers, find actual articles written by doctors that say "Hey! This is a stupid idea!" My big sister came down with lupus and wouldn't stop drinking diet drinks until I had printed out 3 articles describing how aspartame aggravates lupus. She would only hear what she wanted to hear. http://intl-ajrcmb.atsjournals.org/cgi/content/abstract/16/4/479
Heres one, you don't have to understand it all but just get the gist of the articles and show your dad.
Just saw your last post. I don't know what scrapping it would do. Just keep away I guess. Maybe call the professionals and ask them about it. They could tell you over the phone if you need to keep away.
Just saw your last post. I don't know what scrapping it would do. Just keep away I guess. Maybe call the professionals and ask them about it. They could tell you over the phone if you need to keep away.
Hm that's a good idea I'll do that now (hope they're still at work) and post what they said here, just incase you guys find yourself in a similar situation sometime (ie have an idiot running your houshold...).
Well, goddamn it. My stupid uncle did something similar to some flooring tiles in two rooms in the house - one which is HUGE (used to be an art studio for my grandfather)...he tore up everything without any protective gear, and when I asked him about asbestos (because I live in that house, he does not, he lives in Canada 2000 miles away) he was all like, "oh, I'll juet wet it down". I just read a few articles on the stuff - he pretty much did 1 out of every 2 things you're not supposed to do. God, I hate that. I hope I don't get lung cancer.
Anyway. It's recommended that you don't vacuum an area where you think asbestos would be - it makes the particles airborne. It would be a good idea, I think, to limit the methods the asbestos (if it exists on the porch) can get into the livingroom. Make sure the windows are securely shut, that your father's not wearing the same shoes in the house that he did on the porch, and I'd try to get him to change his clothes in an entryway or something, if he can.
Man, that sucks. I know exactly how you feel (even about the same subject, though different family member!) I hope it works out for ya. Pleading with him and trying to get him to understand how worried you are MAY help, especially if you've got printed proof from reliable sources that what he's doing is potentially extremely hazardous. Good luck!
Ok I called up a guy. he said that if the surface of the asbestos is disturbed (ie by scratching it with a metal object) then the fibres are released. He said that he needs to keep the area wet, if he's going to do it and didn't seem to think it would spread into the lounge.
He also said he thinks "It's probably not the best idea". Understatement of the year.
He hosed it down and had a shower after doing the job. So I guess that's pretty much the end of this little episode. I should probably go and find his shoes and clothes put them in a plastic bag.
Anyway words can't describe how much respect I've lost for the guy.
Anyway words can't describe how much respect I've lost for the guy.
Doing this in an environment with kids sickens me. I actually work with the asbestos inspectors for our city. I wish to hell this were happening here, because i could have them at your location within a couple of hours.
I don't know enough personally to talk about the direct risk from what you describe. I would make sure to bag and avoid any clothes items & tools (especially brushes) present on the job.
Theungry on
Unfortunately, western cultures frown upon arranged marriages, so the vast majority of people have to take risks in order to get into relationships.
On the other hand, the major problems with asbestos come from repeat exposure, not a one-time exposure. It's still not the best thing to do, but the reason that professionals charge so much and wear so much protective gear is because they're exposed to the stuff constantly.
A homeowner who scrapes a patch and repaints it once in 10 years isn't at nearly the same level of risk.
If it was outside, you don't have to worry about it getting inside; any outside wind will carry away any friable fibers and make them essentially meaningless. If your step-dad wetted down the area well, he likely captured 80 to 90% of the asbestos fibers, if not more, and it sounds like he took enough precautions to safely do a one-time job.
We had linoleum floors in our new old house and we were very worried about the pad underneath containing asbestos, and we also had popcorn ceilings that I wanted to take down which can also contain asbestos, so my wife and I did a lot of research into asbestos removal and containment, as well as potential health risks. Yes, it's dangerous, but the level of risk is so low for a one time exposure that it's really not a problem.
My dad works in construction and he essentially said the same thing -- if you're constantly exposed, you're in major problems. Extremely occasional exposure is a) inevitable and b) not really a problem. If he just started hacking at it, he may have reduced lung capacity in 40 years. It would be extremely unlikely that he would develop lung cancer or a serious disease from even that sort of one-time exposure. You guys should be fine if he wetted it down and disposed of it wet.
On the other hand, the major problems with asbestos come from repeat exposure, not a one-time exposure. It's still not the best thing to do, but the reason that professionals charge so much and wear so much protective gear is because they're exposed to the stuff constantly.
A homeowner who scrapes a patch and repaints it once in 10 years isn't at nearly the same level of risk.
If it was outside, you don't have to worry about it getting inside; any outside wind will carry away any friable fibers and make them essentially meaningless. If your step-dad wetted down the area well, he likely captured 80 to 90% of the asbestos fibers, if not more, and it sounds like he took enough precautions to safely do a one-time job.
We had linoleum floors in our new old house and we were very worried about the pad underneath containing asbestos, and we also had popcorn ceilings that I wanted to take down which can also contain asbestos, so my wife and I did a lot of research into asbestos removal and containment, as well as potential health risks. Yes, it's dangerous, but the level of risk is so low for a one time exposure that it's really not a problem.
My dad works in construction and he essentially said the same thing -- if you're constantly exposed, you're in major problems. Extremely occasional exposure is a) inevitable and b) not really a problem. If he just started hacking at it, he may have reduced lung capacity in 40 years. It would be extremely unlikely that he would develop lung cancer or a serious disease from even that sort of one-time exposure. You guys should be fine if he wetted it down and disposed of it wet.
I have slate asbestos tiles on the outside of a house I just bought. Both inspectors I have had look at it have told me the same thing that EggyToast just mentioned. Be careful when removing it but it's not a deal-breaker.
Posts
One topic I do know really well is lung scarring. My father ruined his lungs with pesticides, he has it bad. Scar tissue on lungs never goes away, you have permanently damaged lungs. I really suggest not letting your dad do this. Sure it seems like people are always overreacting about chemicals and such but it only takes one time, as my father found out (we told him not to spray above his head), to hurt yourself so bad you have to be on O2 the rest of your life. He seems to have aged about 10 years in the last 3.
If you really don't want to bother and he's deadset in going through with it, try soaking the roof beforehand to ensure at least the small airborne pieces are weighed down enough so they don't float around. That's me just applying logic to the situation I have no idea if that will actually work and really I recomend getting in the profesionals.
Also point out to him it doesn't take much at all to kill him.
EDIT: on the throw away suit, that needs to be marked for asbestos use also. Really most removalists now days have full face masks.
Also in terms of protecting your brother I'd also tape up the entry ways and windows on the porch with masking tape and then vaccuum serval times once finsihed while still wearing the equipment.
Satans..... hints.....
He's so dead set on doing it, I really don't give a flying fuck whether his lungs collapse or scar or whatever. He'd totally deserve it.
I'm just wondering what me and my brother should do. Is staying away from the area for a few days enough? If he repaints it and the paint drys will it be safe again?
How long will it take for the stuff to be taken away by the wind?
If scraping off the paint and repainting it is endangering our household I'd consider calling the cops but it's a big step and I don't want to do it if he's only endangering himself.
http://intl-ajrcmb.atsjournals.org/cgi/content/abstract/16/4/479
Heres one, you don't have to understand it all but just get the gist of the articles and show your dad.
Just saw your last post. I don't know what scrapping it would do. Just keep away I guess. Maybe call the professionals and ask them about it. They could tell you over the phone if you need to keep away.
Hm that's a good idea I'll do that now (hope they're still at work) and post what they said here, just incase you guys find yourself in a similar situation sometime (ie have an idiot running your houshold...).
Anyway. It's recommended that you don't vacuum an area where you think asbestos would be - it makes the particles airborne. It would be a good idea, I think, to limit the methods the asbestos (if it exists on the porch) can get into the livingroom. Make sure the windows are securely shut, that your father's not wearing the same shoes in the house that he did on the porch, and I'd try to get him to change his clothes in an entryway or something, if he can.
Man, that sucks. I know exactly how you feel (even about the same subject, though different family member!) I hope it works out for ya. Pleading with him and trying to get him to understand how worried you are MAY help, especially if you've got printed proof from reliable sources that what he's doing is potentially extremely hazardous. Good luck!
And maybe sell their house to an emo.
He also said he thinks "It's probably not the best idea". Understatement of the year.
He hosed it down and had a shower after doing the job. So I guess that's pretty much the end of this little episode. I should probably go and find his shoes and clothes put them in a plastic bag.
Anyway words can't describe how much respect I've lost for the guy.
Doing this in an environment with kids sickens me. I actually work with the asbestos inspectors for our city. I wish to hell this were happening here, because i could have them at your location within a couple of hours.
I don't know enough personally to talk about the direct risk from what you describe. I would make sure to bag and avoid any clothes items & tools (especially brushes) present on the job.
A homeowner who scrapes a patch and repaints it once in 10 years isn't at nearly the same level of risk.
If it was outside, you don't have to worry about it getting inside; any outside wind will carry away any friable fibers and make them essentially meaningless. If your step-dad wetted down the area well, he likely captured 80 to 90% of the asbestos fibers, if not more, and it sounds like he took enough precautions to safely do a one-time job.
We had linoleum floors in our new old house and we were very worried about the pad underneath containing asbestos, and we also had popcorn ceilings that I wanted to take down which can also contain asbestos, so my wife and I did a lot of research into asbestos removal and containment, as well as potential health risks. Yes, it's dangerous, but the level of risk is so low for a one time exposure that it's really not a problem.
My dad works in construction and he essentially said the same thing -- if you're constantly exposed, you're in major problems. Extremely occasional exposure is a) inevitable and b) not really a problem. If he just started hacking at it, he may have reduced lung capacity in 40 years. It would be extremely unlikely that he would develop lung cancer or a serious disease from even that sort of one-time exposure. You guys should be fine if he wetted it down and disposed of it wet.
I have slate asbestos tiles on the outside of a house I just bought. Both inspectors I have had look at it have told me the same thing that EggyToast just mentioned. Be careful when removing it but it's not a deal-breaker.