I feel popular.
But in like, the bad way.
That makes me sad.
Think of it this way!
This time you're being picked first!
0
Options
Shiny New Toyswhere am i?its dark in hereRegistered Userregular
I'm not particulary keen on the TRV vote as it seems to come about just because he was talking and trying to throw some ideas around. Which seems to be what he has done in most phallas he's played in?
The 38th bandwagon also seems stupid as it is just because they picked a funny name, well 'duh loads of people tried to pick humorous names. I also realize on day 1 we have nothing to go on. But later if TRV and/or 38th are village we should definitely look at who pushed these wagons.
0
Options
Erin The RedThe Name's Erin! Woman, Podcaster, Dungeon Master, IT nerd, Parent, Trans. AMABaton Rouge, LARegistered Userregular
I'm not particulary keen on the TRV vote as it seems to come about just because he was talking and trying to throw some ideas around. Which seems to be what he has done in most phallas he's played in?
The 38th bandwagon also seems stupid as it is just because they picked a funny name, well 'duh loads of people tried to pick humorous names. I also realize on day 1 we have nothing to go on. But later if TRV and/or 38th are village we should definitely look at who pushed these wagons.
I'm not particulary keen on the TRV vote as it seems to come about just because he was talking and trying to throw some ideas around. Which seems to be what he has done in most phallas he's played in?
The 38th bandwagon also seems stupid as it is just because they picked a funny name, well 'duh loads of people tried to pick humorous names. I also realize on day 1 we have nothing to go on. But later if TRV and/or 38th are village we should definitely look at who pushed these wagons.
WHEN we are shown to be village.
How are you so sure about 38th? eh?
0
Options
Erin The RedThe Name's Erin! Woman, Podcaster, Dungeon Master, IT nerd, Parent, Trans. AMABaton Rouge, LARegistered Userregular
He seemed like a nice enough lad. I could be wrong, but I was taught to give people the benefit of the doubt.
And if he turns up as a sith, you're still only shooting 50%, and that's a failing grade where I come from.
I'm...I'm aware. Not sure what to say here. Now its all awkward because not only are all 3 of us on the Council, and should be in on the joke...but KetBra you are also my MasterBuddy.*
"a planet conquered by the Jedi can never fall into Sith hands" is false. It can fall into Sith hands. Namely, if they bring it to 12 points in their favor. I'm sorry that I didn't interpret it the way you meant. Infidel cleared up my confusion. However, it was not "clear" that you meant what you meant, and not what I thought you meant. That's "clearly" true because I thought you meant what I thought you meant and not what you meant. Meant.
It can fall into enemy hands when it's no longer conquered by the Jedi. Not conquered. By the Jedi.
A planet conquered by the Jedi cannot be under Sith control.
I don't know how you can misinterpret that. You clearly define the exit conditions for your statements. When A is no longer true, B can be true.
In your restatement, you've changed the tense of one of your clauses, and is now in fact tautological. By definition, conquered means under the control of that party, and since these two factions are mutually exclusive and there are no Schrodinger's planets, a planet conquered by the Jedi cannot be under Sith control. However, that's not how I interpreted your original statement, nor is it the only way to reasonably do so:
1. "Conquered" is both a past participle (how you meant it) and the past tense of a verb (how I interpreted it).
2. "Can never fall" is the future, not present tense.
These two factors lends themself to an alternative interpretation of your statement: A planet conquered by the Jedi will always be under Jedi control. It can never fall into Sith hands. Once A, B can never be true. This could have been how the game was designed (first past the post type), and is a perfectly valid logical construct. It's not how this game was set up, but it's not completely out of the realm of possibility, so you'll forgive me for thinking that someone might have missed that small section in the OP.
I'll !vote for 38thDoe, though I do not have strong reasons to vote for either of the front runners.
I believe with my vote we're at 11 votes on TheRoadVirus and 9 on 38thDoe?
Actually, by my count, the vote is currently ties at 10 each for TheRoadVirus and 38th Doe. It is emminently possible that I missed a post somewhere though.
If it makes you feel any better, I'm working my way forward from page 7 again
0
Options
Erin The RedThe Name's Erin! Woman, Podcaster, Dungeon Master, IT nerd, Parent, Trans. AMABaton Rouge, LARegistered Userregular
In the case of a close vote, Jedi council edict 7:18:2813 dictates that any written votes must be hand-counted, as droids are unreliable and easily manipulated by the dark side
Erin The RedThe Name's Erin! Woman, Podcaster, Dungeon Master, IT nerd, Parent, Trans. AMABaton Rouge, LARegistered Userregular
@38thDoe , I am sorry if you die tonight (and turn up Jedi). Alls I know is that I am innocent of what I was accused of, and if you are slain, I will make sure that you are remembered for all the good you have done
I'll !vote for 38thDoe, though I do not have strong reasons to vote for either of the front runners.
I believe with my vote we're at 11 votes on TheRoadVirus and 9 on 38thDoe?
Actually, by my count, the vote is currently ties at 10 each for TheRoadVirus and 38th Doe. It is emminently possible that I missed a post somewhere though.
I'll !vote for 38thDoe, though I do not have strong reasons to vote for either of the front runners.
I believe with my vote we're at 11 votes on TheRoadVirus and 9 on 38thDoe?
Actually, by my count, the vote is currently ties at 10 each for TheRoadVirus and 38th Doe. It is emminently possible that I missed a post somewhere though.
I just re-checked. Your spreadsheet is absolutely right Blarney, I just missed vertroue's vote. I probably also did the wrong auto-complete on JABMonkey's.
Apologize for all the confusion! Can we get an updated total?
Posts
*high fives Retbrah*
3DS: 2981-5304-3227
Mostly if you strike me down, I am stricken. In a downward fashion. Probably forever.
I believe with my vote we're at 11 votes on TheRoadVirus and 9 on 38thDoe?
But in like, the bad way.
That makes me sad.
Then you've been truly deprived of my genius.
Think of it this way!
This time you're being picked first!
The 38th bandwagon also seems stupid as it is just because they picked a funny name, well 'duh loads of people tried to pick humorous names. I also realize on day 1 we have nothing to go on. But later if TRV and/or 38th are village we should definitely look at who pushed these wagons.
Allow me to live, that I may experience it for more than a day.
WHEN we are shown to be village.
How are you so sure about 38th? eh?
And if he turns up as a sith, you're still only shooting 50%, and that's a failing grade where I come from.
I am lazy and want to play videogames, not read a bunch of stuff.
Impatience leads to the dark side!
_____________________________________________
HoTS: Schmutz#1686
I'm...I'm aware. Not sure what to say here. Now its all awkward because not only are all 3 of us on the Council, and should be in on the joke...but KetBra you are also my MasterBuddy.*
* - copyright, Benubi Industries.
_____________________________________________
HoTS: Schmutz#1686
In your restatement, you've changed the tense of one of your clauses, and is now in fact tautological. By definition, conquered means under the control of that party, and since these two factions are mutually exclusive and there are no Schrodinger's planets, a planet conquered by the Jedi cannot be under Sith control. However, that's not how I interpreted your original statement, nor is it the only way to reasonably do so:
1. "Conquered" is both a past participle (how you meant it) and the past tense of a verb (how I interpreted it).
2. "Can never fall" is the future, not present tense.
These two factors lends themself to an alternative interpretation of your statement: A planet conquered by the Jedi will always be under Jedi control. It can never fall into Sith hands. Once A, B can never be true. This could have been how the game was designed (first past the post type), and is a perfectly valid logical construct. It's not how this game was set up, but it's not completely out of the realm of possibility, so you'll forgive me for thinking that someone might have missed that small section in the OP.
It's the new Rend! (Rend has played for a looooong time, and never once lied)
Also, I need a vote, so Retaba for a reason I don't remember, but I thought of it earlier
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Something something something outlet face, something something force lightning?
Actually, by my count, the vote is currently ties at 10 each for TheRoadVirus and 38th Doe. It is emminently possible that I missed a post somewhere though.
The Road Virus: 38th Doe, Cayrus, Grunt'sGhost, jdarksun, Ketbra, Kias, Cythraul, Peccavi, SaberOverEasy, The Anonymous
38th Doe: 13lasphemer69, Feckless Rogue, JABMonkey, Malkor, SeGaTai, SmooveOperator, TheRoadVirus, Infidel, tzeenchling, MrBlarney
Can someone check my work?
I'm back to "normal" now so if you need to slot me in at any time feel free
A list of things, should you be of the gifting persuasion
I have vertroue voting for TheRoadVirus and JABMonkey voting for The Anonymous, though I should probably check for re-votes...
I just re-checked. Your spreadsheet is absolutely right Blarney, I just missed vertroue's vote. I probably also did the wrong auto-complete on JABMonkey's.
Apologize for all the confusion! Can we get an updated total?
TRV (9): vertroue, The Anonymous, SaberOverEasy, jdarksun, Cayrus, Kias, Grunt's Ghost, 38thDoe, Peccavi
38thDoe (10): Malkor, FecklessRogue, I3lasphemer69, Smoove Operator, TheRoadVirus, Infidel, tzeentchling, MrBlarney, shalmelo, Ketbra
TRV (10): Cythraul, vertroue, The Anonymous, SaberOverEasy, jdarksun, Cayrus, Kias, Grunt's Ghost, 38thDoe, Peccavi
38thDoe (12): SeGaTai, Malkor, FecklessRogue, I3lasphemer69, Smoove Operator, TheRoadVirus, Infidel, tzeentchling, MrBlarney, shalmelo, Ketbra, Gaslight