So, by my count, there are four reds.
I'd be highly suspect of that one guy who revealed red and then passed to the guy who wanted to stab that one guy.
It was either stab you and figure out who was on what team between you and obi, or stab obi hoping he wasn't on my team, or stab kirindal and hope he wasn't the berzerker. If I wanted to be stabbed, I could have gotten that in the first turn
Right.
Because it's not like the Inquisitor wouldn't show one and then stab the guy who will let him reveal the next red token, in the hopes of assassinating everyone by being assassinated.
Why do you assume that I wanted you to stab me? There were two people with no information showing. The person who declared they wanted to stab me and the person who just did stab me. There was also one other unknown from my perspective. I figured if you were on my team then at least I wouldn't just get insta-stabbed back
Fishing for more information as the Inquisitor is far more appealing than simply stabbing the blue dudes and forcing them to use a power.
Whereas a true Rose would be stabbing Kirindal and making the Beast's position more tenuous by making them reveal and/or make them use powers.
What? Kirindal is B? thus 7/8/9 and almost certainly not their leader (unless they drew only 7/8/9s and he's the zerker). We could draw out the power yeah, but only 9 has a power they don't want to use earlyish and even then, in this small of a game an early 9 isn't so bad. So, you've traded getting more information on their team composition for activating a power they either want out or don't care about using
Well that's the thing. Once curses are out there are only two winners (barring elder/quill shenanigans). If the inquisitor put the curse on a leader, then that team cannot win the game anymore, so they lose nothing by allowing the inquisitor to help them get the other team. If the inquisitor has cursed the wrong person, then the inquisitor cannot win, and so the same team also loses nothing by letting him help
That would involve the Inquisitor revealing who they put a pox on. And then you only protect the 'lose if they win' team from a berserker attack, whilst assuming that that team (and the Inquisitor to a certain extent) has perfect knowledge about their own roles and so can determine that giving the dagger to the Inquisitor is the preferable over intervening shenanigans.
Maybe you'd like to @ those who you think are on your team, @jdarksun?
I think we'll have to tweak intervention rules a bit after this game, because we're getting situations where everyone is waiting for someone else to make a move.
Posts
Penny Arcade Rockstar Social Club / This is why I despise cyclists
What do you bleed, @discrider?
From the mists of time, seven vampires came together to compete in a poker tournament like none before.
Blood was pumping - and the stakes were high.
In front of the players were the following revealed tokens:
discrider
ObiFett -
Kirindal -
Preda -
Phyphor -
jdarksun
JPants -
discrider
ObiFett - ?
Kirindal - B?
Preda - ?
Phyphor - R
jdarksun
JPants - ?
I feel like me stabbing you Phyphor is exactly what you want. Unless Obifett.
So with that in mind:
!pass
(stab Kirindal, lose a Blue ability).
I'd be highly suspect of that one guy who revealed red and then passed to the guy who wanted to stab that one guy.
Because it's not like the Inquisitor wouldn't show one and then stab the guy who will let him reveal the next red token, in the hopes of assassinating everyone by being assassinated.
Whereas a true Rose would be stabbing Kirindal and making the Beast's position more tenuous by making them reveal and/or make them use powers.
Technically the post was edited, but we'll let it pass... this time. =P
Hi @Preda, any targets that you'd like to stab?
!STAB @jdarksun
Penny Arcade Rockstar Social Club / This is why I despise cyclists
Maybe you'd like to @ those who you think are on your team, @jdarksun?
I think we'll have to tweak intervention rules a bit after this game, because we're getting situations where everyone is waiting for someone else to make a move.
A classic deadlock.
Penny Arcade Rockstar Social Club / This is why I despise cyclists
!STAB @Phyphor
Penny Arcade Rockstar Social Club / This is why I despise cyclists
* Time travelling note: This includes Preda's actions in two posts
The tension is so thick, you could cut it with a sharpened stake knife. Oh ho ho ho ho.
discrider -
ObiFett -
Kirindal -
Preda -
Phyphor -
jdarksun -
JPants -
discrider - 6 Green sword
ObiFett - ?
Kirindal - B?
Preda - 8? Green shield, Staff
Phyphor - R Staff
jdarksun - B
JPants - ?
Than !STAB @jdarksun again
Drat! I forgot! Sorry - editing it in now
Edit: Also added in Preda's 8 + staff
Penny Arcade Rockstar Social Club / This is why I despise cyclists
GIVE @Kirindal
Penny Arcade Rockstar Social Club / This is why I despise cyclists
Hey, JPants! Catch!
!Stab @JPants
No thanks inquisitor! I'll reveal ?
And pass the dagger to @Preda
Now go stab Obi with it!
He is most likely the Inquisitor.
Both Phyphor and Obifett are the Inquisitors.