What? The Anonymous isn't even claiming that I'm mafia, he just wanted to have everyone put a placeholder vote on me. I'm assuming this is because he doesn't know what I am, which is because I'm an aquacadet. There can't possibly be any confirming evidence for me to be mafia or to not be mafia unless I got seered, which I obviously didn't or else they wouldn't be putting a "placeholder" vote on me.
I wasn't talking about what they know about me, because they can't know anything about me, I was talking about what they know in general that The Anonymous is apparently going to come back and guide the village to the mafia tonight.
And while I understand sometimes the villagehead has a good lead and we should follow it, if its a good lead, what's the problem with telling us - conversely, if it isn't a good lead, then... whats the point in focusing us on it?
It's very possible that The Anonymous has some information we don't, but if he does I'd love to hear it. .
Since Anon was so strongly proven in the narration, it is very likely that village specials, villagers, etc. contacted him after that first night (like they should have). By now, several nights later, Anon is almost guaranteed to have more information than us. Which means that even if he's blind guessing, he's going to be doing it better than you. What he shouldn't do, though, is ALWAYS tell you every reason. Because that could put him in a trap:
Say the village is looking suspiciously at Alex and Bob. Little do we know, Alex and Bob are both known to Anon to be the village guard and seer. Well, he can't come right out and say that, nor can he come and say "I don't want Alex or Bob to die," because then that puts two more easy kills in the mafias' hands. So he'll be forced to come say something like "I think Calvin is a good bet." Unfortunately for us, that may lead us to bandwagoning a villager thinking he's been seered, but we don't have many options. Anon has been about as solidly publicly confirmed as it gets in these games, we kind of have to put faith in him.
That being said, he'd do better to let the village speculate some before saying "hey everyone vote for <insert name>, and I may come back and direct you somewhere else later." That'll lead to a boring village, yes, and a lot less ideas being tossed around.
This game has conversions. I began the game as evil (I was supposed to help the mafia win, but wasn't in contact with the mafia) but was converted one day 1. My converter can only convert every other day. Unfortunately, the target for conversion last night was godmode. We fear that the mafia may have such a conversion as well.
Honestly, i think i agree with dunadan on this one.
Winky that was a very mafiaesque post. I wasn't really on board because fuck TA if he hasn't gotten an actual seer target, but i think you've dug yourself a grave....
He's a shy overambitious dog-catcher on the wrong side of the law. She's an orphaned psychic mercenary with the power to bend men's minds. They fight crime!
Hmmm... conversions, huh. Vagrant_Winds. If someone was to be converted in this game, someone like Vagrant would be a nice addiction to any group, mafia or not. Of course, this is just me being me. And I don't feel like voting Winky until I know why to vote for Winky.
I know from past games that people who show activity and guile are usually big targets for conversion, so keeping a close eye on whether Dunadan remains helpful is probably worthwhile.
Sir FabulousMalevolent Squid GodRegistered Userregular
edited September 2010
Psssst. Perhaps someone should Re-Seer T_A. His alignment could have changed since you last confirmed him. Not saying he's definitely evil. Just saying a confirmed vig would make and awesome addition to a mafia team.
I guess that's not surprising to anyone. But screw Dunadan's argument that was retarded, if that's how you guys knew I was mafia then it was pure coincidence that you actually got me :P.
Anyway, certain individuals may find it in their best interests to PM me.
She was hanging off the chopper. It seemed like nothing would stop her. Handle bar standing and flying over canyons were mere child’s play to Danger Woman, or as some called her, romanqwerty. It seems, in the end, if that’s what Space Monster “M” wants, that’s what Space Monster “M” gets, and he wants Danger Woman. Not alive, of course. He killed her. Well, not him exactly, but he might as well have.
The Phantom Highlander, The Songbird Avenger, Danger Woman is no more.
The good guys got him back, though. In an almost unanimous decision, Mr. Evil McEvilson, or as everyone but me knows him, Winky was taken down by the power of democracy.
However…The good guys lost someone very near and dear to the Aquabats. Professor Monty Corndog, affectionately called Sir Fabulous by those in his inner circle, was struck down by his good friend Crash McLarson. Why would Crash do such a thing? Was he confused? Was he misinformed? Did he miss his daily dose of Cracklin’ Oat Bran? Is his head simply occupied by some of his 250 lbs of pure muscle? Or did the Professor’s fate come down to the mere flip of a coin? We may never know! But he killed him. Killed him dead, he did.
I hope your happy, Crash! Pizza Day is ruined!
The Fallen Winky - Henchman - Vote Sir Fabulous - Professor Monty Corndog - Punk Rock Super Fist romanqwerty - Danger Woman - Forces of Evil
Notch on
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
0
Options
The AnonymousUh, uh, uhhhhhh...Uh, uh.Registered Userregular
edited September 2010
The Anonymous on
0
Options
The AnonymousUh, uh, uhhhhhh...Uh, uh.Registered Userregular
edited September 2010
To clarify, Sir Fab never got in touch with me, and his reaction towards the Winky vote convinced us (the network) he was mafia. So, serves you fucking right for not trusting the confirmed vig.
Posts
I wasn't talking about what they know about me, because they can't know anything about me, I was talking about what they know in general that The Anonymous is apparently going to come back and guide the village to the mafia tonight.
Since Anon was so strongly proven in the narration, it is very likely that village specials, villagers, etc. contacted him after that first night (like they should have). By now, several nights later, Anon is almost guaranteed to have more information than us. Which means that even if he's blind guessing, he's going to be doing it better than you. What he shouldn't do, though, is ALWAYS tell you every reason. Because that could put him in a trap:
Say the village is looking suspiciously at Alex and Bob. Little do we know, Alex and Bob are both known to Anon to be the village guard and seer. Well, he can't come right out and say that, nor can he come and say "I don't want Alex or Bob to die," because then that puts two more easy kills in the mafias' hands. So he'll be forced to come say something like "I think Calvin is a good bet." Unfortunately for us, that may lead us to bandwagoning a villager thinking he's been seered, but we don't have many options. Anon has been about as solidly publicly confirmed as it gets in these games, we kind of have to put faith in him.
That being said, he'd do better to let the village speculate some before saying "hey everyone vote for <insert name>, and I may come back and direct you somewhere else later." That'll lead to a boring village, yes, and a lot less ideas being tossed around.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
I hate being the sacrificial lamb, though.
This game has conversions. I began the game as evil (I was supposed to help the mafia win, but wasn't in contact with the mafia) but was converted one day 1. My converter can only convert every other day. Unfortunately, the target for conversion last night was godmode. We fear that the mafia may have such a conversion as well.
Winky that was a very mafiaesque post. I wasn't really on board because fuck TA if he hasn't gotten an actual seer target, but i think you've dug yourself a grave....
Now to check if hell is still warm...
wait a second
there may be conversions?
SERIOUSLY? WHAT?
Yes.
Winky as the directed placeholder, and because he is evilllllll!
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
This is entirely true. Entirely!
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Game suddenly became a lot more... curious.
fix'd.
Can I be the black sheep?
// Switch: SW-5306-0651-6424 //
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
Someone else make a better argument so I can actually feel like I died for a reason.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
I sure hope so!
Why because I lost internets last night.
Winky
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
I guess that's not surprising to anyone. But screw Dunadan's argument that was retarded, if that's how you guys knew I was mafia then it was pure coincidence that you actually got me :P.
Anyway, certain individuals may find it in their best interests to PM me.
She was hanging off the chopper. It seemed like nothing would stop her. Handle bar standing and flying over canyons were mere child’s play to Danger Woman, or as some called her, romanqwerty. It seems, in the end, if that’s what Space Monster “M” wants, that’s what Space Monster “M” gets, and he wants Danger Woman. Not alive, of course. He killed her. Well, not him exactly, but he might as well have.
The Phantom Highlander, The Songbird Avenger, Danger Woman is no more.
The good guys got him back, though. In an almost unanimous decision, Mr. Evil McEvilson, or as everyone but me knows him, Winky was taken down by the power of democracy.
However…The good guys lost someone very near and dear to the Aquabats. Professor Monty Corndog, affectionately called Sir Fabulous by those in his inner circle, was struck down by his good friend Crash McLarson. Why would Crash do such a thing? Was he confused? Was he misinformed? Did he miss his daily dose of Cracklin’ Oat Bran? Is his head simply occupied by some of his 250 lbs of pure muscle? Or did the Professor’s fate come down to the mere flip of a coin? We may never know! But he killed him. Killed him dead, he did.
I hope your happy, Crash! Pizza Day is ruined!
The Fallen
Winky - Henchman - Vote
Sir Fabulous - Professor Monty Corndog - Punk Rock Super Fist
romanqwerty - Danger Woman - Forces of Evil