The person I suspect as a demon was not seer'd but some information came up indicating they might be one, also while I wanted them killed, I wasn't exactly positive I had enough vigs in the first place so their lack of death isn't that surprising. PrecisionK and I are talking and hopefully something will come of it
0
Options
The AnonymousUh, uh, uhhhhhh...Uh, uh.Registered Userregular
The person I suspect as a demon was not seer'd but some information came up indicating they might be one, also while I wanted them killed, I wasn't exactly positive I had enough vigs in the first place so their lack of death isn't that surprising. PrecisionK and I are talking and hopefully something will come of it
Why are you hiding the identity of who you think is a demon? And the reasons you think they're a demon?
The person I suspect as a demon was not seer'd but some information came up indicating they might be one, also while I wanted them killed, I wasn't exactly positive I had enough vigs in the first place so their lack of death isn't that surprising. PrecisionK and I are talking and hopefully something will come of it
Why are you hiding the identity of who you think is a demon? And the reasons you think they're a demon?
Uh maybe so he can gather evidence and or have them vigged? You don't kill all mafia with a vote, and furthermore it would be too early in the day to call a vote.
You never reveal/call a vote until late in the day, otherwise you've wasted the day.
Networks don't tell everything they know to the public. that's why they are a network. If you tell the thread, you have told the mafia.
There are plenty of reasons not to trust these seers at the moment, but the constant gotcha-ing going on is silly. There are a million reasons not to go public with your info as a seer, and they're all good.
Revelations: vagrant winds is a gibbering pile of dead heads. SCARY. The voice toldme this, told me in dark places I couldn't see. SCARY. It told me to search and search again.
Pillar is from Baator, home to bad-things. Must be bad. I ONLY DO AS IM TOLD. WE NEED MANY SWORDS TO KILL MANY HEADS!!!
It tells untruths of it's being to deceive, do not listen to its vile poisonous words, you may die! Poison is bad for you!!
If Vagrant Winds is actually the Pillar of Skulls...
That's worth a lynchin' rope, I think.
Ropes. Lots of ropes. For lots of... skulls? Maybe we should switch to lynching hammers for this one. IfVagrant WInds is the Pillar of Skulls then it needs to die (given that in the lore that makes it a traitorous Geographical goddamn Feature of the home plane of the Devils (or Demons, can't remember which).
Of course, the "evidence" for VW being the Pillar of Skulls is this:
One person can see me, this is a good sign, yes, we've got this, if that one person never ever dies and continues to answer me for eternity then I can be absolutely assured of the fact that I exist.
A man wanders the planes for many years
Telling many lies; they are egregious sins.
I now call for his head on a spear,
The Pile of Skulls, vagrant_winds
So... it might not be worth much. Hells, maybe we should be voting for RR based on craaaazy.
I need a coffee.
Uh maybe so he can gather evidence and or have them vigged? You don't kill all mafia with a vote, and furthermore it would be too early in the day to call a vote.
You never reveal/call a vote until late in the day, otherwise you've wasted the day.
Networks don't tell everything they know to the public. that's why they are a network. If you tell the thread, you have told the mafia.
I guess I don't see the point of saying "I know something about someone, I think. But I'm not going to tell you who. Or what. And we may have tried to vig whoever it was but apparently it didn't work." How is that useful to us?
Yeah right now vagrant_winds seems like a good choice. Also Grimmy vagrant admitted to being the skulls, it's not the only evidence.
Well he said "why would you want to kill the merchant" to rysk after his crazy tirade.
Ah. Was that towards the end of the old thread? I missed it. Aaaaanyway, I've been burned once by someone (ahem, Arivia) claiming neutrality this game. Not falling for that again.
Even if this time it happens to be true. Now I remember why I quit phalla.
0
Options
The AnonymousUh, uh, uhhhhhh...Uh, uh.Registered Userregular
I'd rather wait and see what Retaba and PK have for us today.
...you do have something for us today, right? Right?
Yeah right now vagrant_winds seems like a good choice. Also Grimmy vagrant admitted to being the skulls, it's not the only evidence.
Well he said "why would you want to kill the merchant" to rysk after his crazy tirade.
Ah. Was that towards the end of the old thread? I missed it. Aaaaanyway, I've been burned once by someone (ahem, Arivia) claiming neutrality this game. Not falling for that again.
Even if this time it happens to be true. Now I remember why I quit phalla.
(Only need one green post per day, per player brosef)
Also, vagrant_winds sounds like a good enough target. Good enough for me to poop on.
Uh maybe so he can gather evidence and or have them vigged? You don't kill all mafia with a vote, and furthermore it would be too early in the day to call a vote.
You never reveal/call a vote until late in the day, otherwise you've wasted the day.
Networks don't tell everything they know to the public. that's why they are a network. If you tell the thread, you have told the mafia.
I guess I don't see the point of saying "I know something about someone, I think. But I'm not going to tell you who. Or what. And we may have tried to vig whoever it was but apparently it didn't work." How is that useful to us?
he never said he wouldn't tell us, he just didn't tell us at that point. Like I said, you don't call a vote or reveal something early. It's not good.
Also, the point of relaying that information is really just a nice thing to do. It's not just silence from the network, it's nice to say "hey we've got a solid lead, still working on it"
Grimmy it was on the first page. it's like, the fourth post
You're the fourth post. Hmm. Well, I'm not sure that vw's post there counts as an admission to being the PoS(kulls). That said, I've voted for him and that stands.
P.S. Sorry, I totally missed that post when I was catching up on the new thread.
EDIT: Thanks for the clarification, Squish. That's a relief.
Grimmy it was on the first page. it's like, the fourth post
You're the fourth post. Hmm. Well, I'm not sure that vw's post there counts as an admission to being the PoS(kulls). That said, I've voted for him and that stands.
P.S. Sorry, I totally missed that post when I was catching up on the new thread.
EDIT: Thanks for the clarification, Squish. That's a relief.
it wouldn't be if the next post he made (in response to "was that a reveal??") hadn't been "I don't care who knows who I am, I am not out to kill anyone and lack the ability"
I guess I don't see the point of saying "I know something about someone, I think. But I'm not going to tell you who. Or what. And we may have tried to vig whoever it was but apparently it didn't work." How is that useful to us?
You are redeemed for your kime-analyzing ways. I have to actually disagree with Langly on this one. Once you say you have a solid lead, it becomes known that a sheep vote is incoming, and mafia can vote however they want. The vote record is ruined as soon as you say you have a target.
Also, is the pillar of skulls a merchant? How does saying that you're a merchant imply that he's the pillar of skulls?
Yea totally missed that reveal there, though not completely convinced to kill him if he is just a merchant-not really sure what demons/devils get for buying weapons and how they pay for it-guessing life based on what Infy said-maybe not terrible if they weaken themselves and kill each other. Though now that I just said that that does really sound like a bad idea-vagrant winds
So the person I had attacked last night and is suspect of being a demon is Jdarksun, if anyone has any information that can confirm/deny I guess now would be the time to tell me or tell us all, otherwise Jdarksun
As for this Vwinds, thing? Its up to you guys if you want to vote him out tonight or tomorrow.
It was suggested by someone (precisionk? Infidel? Retaba?) in the old thread that there are merchants that only sell to mafia in the game.
If that is the case, and vagrant is such a merchant, then we should be cutting the mafia off from a source of desired gods by voting out vagrant. If he's simply lying, and the Pillar of Skulls is mafia-aligned, then a should vote out vagrant.
Either way, I'm content with my vote's usefulness for the village.
Edit: apparently my phone thinks that merchanrd is a word.
I never advocated for silence, I advocated for the seers not telling the village everything, because that is the entire point of a network. Villagers are unconnected and could be told anything by anybody, like jdark's thing there. What proof is there? None but his word. A network is seeing much more than the village sees, and can make better decisions than the village can.
A silent village is one that is doomed to lose, but that doesn't mean the network should be an open thing, that's stupid.
0
Options
The AnonymousUh, uh, uhhhhhh...Uh, uh.Registered Userregular
Fine, let's see how deep this rabbit hole goes. Baidol
Posts
and that's where we are at this point in time.
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
Also colors, I love surprises.
Steam
You're evil because you want to goat. And goats are demony.
Steam
Steam
Wait a second... didn't Retaba say that he had tried to kill a mafia/demon/devil, and didn't succeed or something?
there's all kinds of talk about betrayal and betraying demons and things.
and I remember clearly how much you love to backstab your way to badassness.
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
HollowerFollower for staying below my radar - looking through the player list, I don't actually recall you!
* not patented
That's worth a lynchin' rope, I think.
Twitch Stream
Pfft I am totally not planning on betraying anyone or anythings today.
Steam
Why are you hiding the identity of who you think is a demon? And the reasons you think they're a demon?
(yeah, I am half a page late, but whatevers)
Uh maybe so he can gather evidence and or have them vigged? You don't kill all mafia with a vote, and furthermore it would be too early in the day to call a vote.
You never reveal/call a vote until late in the day, otherwise you've wasted the day.
Networks don't tell everything they know to the public. that's why they are a network. If you tell the thread, you have told the mafia.
Pillar is from Baator, home to bad-things. Must be bad. I ONLY DO AS IM TOLD. WE NEED MANY SWORDS TO KILL MANY HEADS!!!
It tells untruths of it's being to deceive, do not listen to its vile poisonous words, you may die! Poison is bad for you!!
Ropes. Lots of ropes. For lots of... skulls? Maybe we should switch to lynching hammers for this one. If Vagrant WInds is the Pillar of Skulls then it needs to die (given that in the lore that makes it a traitorous Geographical goddamn Feature of the home plane of the Devils (or Demons, can't remember which).
Of course, the "evidence" for VW being the Pillar of Skulls is this:
So... it might not be worth much. Hells, maybe we should be voting for RR based on craaaazy.
I need a coffee.
The Pillar of Skulls would make some sense for a devil seer. Do we have any confirmation that a "merchant" faction exists apart from player claims?
Well he said "why would you want to kill the merchant" to rysk after his crazy tirade.
I guess I don't see the point of saying "I know something about someone, I think. But I'm not going to tell you who. Or what. And we may have tried to vig whoever it was but apparently it didn't work." How is that useful to us?
Ah. Was that towards the end of the old thread? I missed it. Aaaaanyway, I've been burned once by someone (ahem, Arivia) claiming neutrality this game. Not falling for that again.
...you do have something for us today, right? Right?
Implying I wasn't going to tell you when I never said such a thing is not very kind.
(Only need one green post per day, per player brosef)
Also, vagrant_winds sounds like a good enough target. Good enough for me to poop on.
he never said he wouldn't tell us, he just didn't tell us at that point. Like I said, you don't call a vote or reveal something early. It's not good.
Also, the point of relaying that information is really just a nice thing to do. It's not just silence from the network, it's nice to say "hey we've got a solid lead, still working on it"
You're the fourth post. Hmm. Well, I'm not sure that vw's post there counts as an admission to being the PoS(kulls). That said, I've voted for him and that stands.
P.S. Sorry, I totally missed that post when I was catching up on the new thread.
EDIT: Thanks for the clarification, Squish. That's a relief.
it wouldn't be if the next post he made (in response to "was that a reveal??") hadn't been "I don't care who knows who I am, I am not out to kill anyone and lack the ability"
You are redeemed for your kime-analyzing ways. I have to actually disagree with Langly on this one. Once you say you have a solid lead, it becomes known that a sheep vote is incoming, and mafia can vote however they want. The vote record is ruined as soon as you say you have a target.
Also, is the pillar of skulls a merchant? How does saying that you're a merchant imply that he's the pillar of skulls?
As for this Vwinds, thing? Its up to you guys if you want to vote him out tonight or tomorrow.
If that is the case, and vagrant is such a merchant, then we should be cutting the mafia off from a source of desired gods by voting out vagrant. If he's simply lying, and the Pillar of Skulls is mafia-aligned, then a should vote out vagrant.
Either way, I'm content with my vote's usefulness for the village.
Edit: apparently my phone thinks that merchanrd is a word.
A silent village is one that is doomed to lose, but that doesn't mean the network should be an open thing, that's stupid.