The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.
[PA Comic] Friday, September 13, 2013 - The Tithe, Part Four
I don't know if it's significant, but I have some speculation about some imagery.
Cherry Blossoms (which are falling all over in this) are used to symbolize the samurai because (unlike most flowers) the don't fade on the branch. So they symbolize dying at your prime in battle. I don't think it makes sense for them to symbolize the death of tree ladies because it makes sense they'd become old and wither like trees do. Also Jerry was talking about his fascination with the Triple Goddess so that imples a crone stage in addition to the Maiden and Mother we've seen so far.
My guess is the blossoms we see now symbolize the Lookouts. The daughters are the (at least symbolic) mothers of them and the rain of petals is the men living their lives and dying in the forrest. Just an idea.
I don't know if it's significant, but I have some speculation about some imagery.
Cherry Blossoms (which are falling all over in this) are used to symbolize the samurai because (unlike most flowers) the don't fade on the branch. So they symbolize dying at your prime in battle. I don't think it makes sense for them to symbolize the death of tree ladies because it makes sense they'd become old and wither like trees do. Also Jerry was talking about his fascination with the Triple Goddess so that imples a crone stage in addition to the Maiden and Mother we've seen so far.
My guess is the blossoms we see now symbolize the Lookouts. The daughters are the (at least symbolic) mothers of them and the rain of petals is the men living their lives and dying in the forrest. Just an idea.
I don't know if it's significant, but I have some speculation about some imagery.
Cherry Blossoms (which are falling all over in this) are used to symbolize the samurai because (unlike most flowers) the don't fade on the branch. So they symbolize dying at your prime in battle. I don't think it makes sense for them to symbolize the death of tree ladies because it makes sense they'd become old and wither like trees do. Also Jerry was talking about his fascination with the Triple Goddess so that imples a crone stage in addition to the Maiden and Mother we've seen so far.
My guess is the blossoms we see now symbolize the Lookouts. The daughters are the (at least symbolic) mothers of them and the rain of petals is the men living their lives and dying in the forrest. Just an idea.
Cardboard Tube Samurai / Lookouts crossover?
Only if it ties into their Dragon Age PA Presents too. Some serious tree magic in that.
There's been at least one all-star panel in every page of this so far. Panel 5 today keeps it up.
Also, I wonder how old the girl is. At first I was thinking 9-10, but based on her thinking the mother was called yesterday she might be younger. 5-6ish?
-Redtube
-A goat staring back without blinking
-Jerry
-Sannakji
-Al Gore
-Duke Nukem Forever
-live dolphin birth
-Oprah's afro
-John Madden eating a turducken
I don't know if it's significant, but I have some speculation about some imagery.
Cherry Blossoms (which are falling all over in this) are used to symbolize the samurai because (unlike most flowers) the don't fade on the branch. So they symbolize dying at your prime in battle. I don't think it makes sense for them to symbolize the death of tree ladies because it makes sense they'd become old and wither like trees do. Also Jerry was talking about his fascination with the Triple Goddess so that imples a crone stage in addition to the Maiden and Mother we've seen so far.
My guess is the blossoms we see now symbolize the Lookouts. The daughters are the (at least symbolic) mothers of them and the rain of petals is the men living their lives and dying in the forrest. Just an idea.
Forest Crone is exactly what this lady is in the Cryptozoic Lookouts comic:
Mild plot spoiler:
She has come to collect the aspiring Daughter as her parents are trying to escape her destiny.
4th panel made me tear up and I'm not even sure why.
damn fine series they have going on here.
4th panel is exactly the way my parents looked at me when I told them my wife is pregnant. I'm in my 30s and we've been together for 10 years, and we still get that look of remembered naïveté. It's some serious nostalgic heartbreaking shit 8->
Sceptre: Penny Arcade, where you get starcraft AND marriage advice.
3clipse: The key to any successful marriage is a good mid-game transition.
+2
Arithon32Member of the PinquisitionRegistered Userregular
Oh man, I suck at this observation stuff. I feel particularly stupid after reading Jerry's post and seeing how abundantly obvious the final 2 panels are. :oops:
Also, this continues to be the most amazing art Mike has ever done. Seriously, amazing work!
NNID: Rehab0
0
CambiataCommander ShepardThe likes of which even GAWD has never seenRegistered Userregular
edited September 2013
Theorycrafting is nice, but I think the reason it's cherry blossoms is because cherry blossoms are pretty and also look amazing falling all around like snow.
Cambiata on
"excuse my French
But fuck you — no, fuck y'all, that's as blunt as it gets"
- Kendrick Lamar, "The Blacker the Berry"
+3
KalTorakOne way or another, they all end up inthe Undercity.Registered Userregular
personally i'd like a wallpaper of Panel 5
0
Arithon32Member of the PinquisitionRegistered Userregular
I'd like a wallpaper of every panel in this strip, but if I had to pick one, it'd be four. The look on her face is perfect.
There's been at least one all-star panel in every page of this so far. Panel 5 today keeps it up.
Also, I wonder how old the girl is. At first I was thinking 9-10, but based on her thinking the mother was called yesterday she might be younger. 5-6ish?
Spoilers for The Lookouts Issue 6:
It's a good question. The girl in the lookouts comic looked very young when the hag came to take her. Like, 5 or 6. Maybe younger, she looked really small in her father's arms. The hag also implied that they had been pruning her flowers for some time. When she's with the lookouts, she appears to be a bit older, maybe 8-10. But it would seem odd for that much time to pass between her killing the Hag and them sending her off with Samson. I suppose in the Eyrewood it may take some time to send messages and travel, but still...
As for Hannah, I think she looks too tall to be in either of the age groups you mentioned. To me she looks to be around 11 or 12. If she's any younger, she's seriously tall. Not that this is impossible, my niece is pretty tall, but she's the exception.
Also, if I were going just off The Tithe, I would be inclined to think of the flowers budding and being called as an analogue to the onset of puberty. Such a thing is hardly unprecedented in stories like this. But that doesn't really add up with
Eli's
apparent age in lookouts.
Still, based on her build, I'd be sorta surprised if Hannah was younger than 10.
Theorycrafting is nice, but I think the reason it's cherry blossoms is because cherry blossoms are pretty and also look amazing falling all around like snow.
It seems rather unlikely that they don't mean something, at least to Mike and Jerry, given this paragraph from today's news post:
But the notion of them as actual plants? That didn’t occur to me until later, and once it had there was simply no other way to think of them. Like a Winterfresh mouth, it is much, much cooler. And it has the added benefit of you being able to choose your flower, something that matters to you. And it’s scary for people to just look and be able to see your secret self. For me, at least, it’s a big part of what I like about Daughters of the Eyrewood.
Also, I wonder how old the girl is. At first I was thinking 9-10, but based on her thinking the mother was called yesterday she might be younger. 5-6ish?
I don't see the connection that makes you think she's ~5.
+1
CambiataCommander ShepardThe likes of which even GAWD has never seenRegistered Userregular
Theorycrafting is nice, but I think the reason it's cherry blossoms is because cherry blossoms are pretty and also look amazing falling all around like snow.
It seems rather unlikely that they don't mean something, at least to Mike and Jerry, given this paragraph from today's news post:
But the notion of them as actual plants? That didn’t occur to me until later, and once it had there was simply no other way to think of them. Like a Winterfresh mouth, it is much, much cooler. And it has the added benefit of you being able to choose your flower, something that matters to you. And it’s scary for people to just look and be able to see your secret self. For me, at least, it’s a big part of what I like about Daughters of the Eyrewood.
That just makes it sound like the girls themselves are choosing the flowers somehow, which is an interesting concept, but doesn't tie into "they are secretly samurai!" in any way that satisfies.
Cambiata on
"excuse my French
But fuck you — no, fuck y'all, that's as blunt as it gets"
- Kendrick Lamar, "The Blacker the Berry"
I truly, deeply love stories - but I love stories most when those infinite, intangible parts somehow fall together, and that happened here for me with "You're becoming! Look; the stream will show you."
0
KalTorakOne way or another, they all end up inthe Undercity.Registered Userregular
Theorycrafting is nice, but I think the reason it's cherry blossoms is because cherry blossoms are pretty and also look amazing falling all around like snow.
It seems rather unlikely that they don't mean something, at least to Mike and Jerry, given this paragraph from today's news post:
But the notion of them as actual plants? That didn’t occur to me until later, and once it had there was simply no other way to think of them. Like a Winterfresh mouth, it is much, much cooler. And it has the added benefit of you being able to choose your flower, something that matters to you. And it’s scary for people to just look and be able to see your secret self. For me, at least, it’s a big part of what I like about Daughters of the Eyrewood.
That just makes it sound like the girls themselves are choosing the flowers somehow, which is an interesting concept, but doesn't tie into "they are secretly samurai!" in any way that satisfies.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not buying into the specific samurai reference made earlier. All I mean to say is that he makes it sound like the flower tied with a Daughter says something about her.
I'm not flower expert, so I don't know what they were, but the Hag had a very thorny, briar like flower in her hair in Lookouts, which seemed to fit her disposition.
0
ceresWhen the last moon is cast over the last star of morningAnd the future has past without even a last desperate warningRegistered User, ModeratorMod Emeritus
A panel from the second part is my tablet's home screen, and a panel from the third part is my lock screen.
And it seems like all is dying, and would leave the world to mourn
I really like this story arc! Beautiful artwork, too.
I'm beginning to wonder how the Lookouts village manages to keep a functioning population though, what with all the boys dying in the forest and the girls running off to be living tree-ladies :P
These short stories of girls in the woods, cowboys in space, rangers that don't range... it's not your trade. Can I grin and bear it? Sure but they're virtually back to back these days. Weeks, in fact, seem to yawn between my once regular fixes of angry gamer humor. Come back to us, boys.
These short stories of girls in the woods, cowboys in space, rangers that don't range... it's not your trade. Can I grin and bear it? Sure but they're virtually back to back these days. Weeks, in fact, seem to yawn between my once regular fixes of angry gamer humor. Come back to us, boys.
Well, you are entitled to your opinion and I respect it. However...
1. Mine and Jerry clearly like doing these side projects and it's unlikely they're going to stop unless they run out of ideas.
1a. It is unlikely they will run out of ideas.
2. You are going to be overwhelmingly in the minority in your opinion of these side projects.
3. Mike and Jerry rarely read the forums (Jerry has never appeared that I can recall since I've been here), so chances are they are not going to see your opinion.
I don't know if it's significant, but I have some speculation about some imagery.
Cherry Blossoms (which are falling all over in this) are used to symbolize the samurai because (unlike most flowers) the don't fade on the branch. So they symbolize dying at your prime in battle. I don't think it makes sense for them to symbolize the death of tree ladies because it makes sense they'd become old and wither like trees do. Also Jerry was talking about his fascination with the Triple Goddess so that imples a crone stage in addition to the Maiden and Mother we've seen so far.
My guess is the blossoms we see now symbolize the Lookouts. The daughters are the (at least symbolic) mothers of them and the rain of petals is the men living their lives and dying in the forrest. Just an idea.
Back way way way before we were going to get a DOTE comic because they hadn't hit the stretch goal, I did some doofy fanart of an older mother and Mike tweeted me back that there was indeed a third stage, at the time he was calling it The Crone. It makes it sound a bit singular (as if there's only one), but I dunno! That was quite a while ago so some things in the story might have changed since then. Personally I'm hoping there's lots and lots of Crones (like the Forest Crone from the Lookouts comic), because I love the Mothers/Crones aesthetic a lot.
I was genuinely surprised when I saw the flowers were a part of the girls, something that grew. It makes me a bit uneasy but ahh it's kind of whimsical and charming too... I am so excited for new pages, everything about this arc hits me just the right way.
Posts
the art keeps on getting better and better
Gamer Dater - My Video Game Dating Website full of Faygo
Strip Search Wastebasket of Broken Dreams App I made
Should've had this as an 8th panel:
I'm originally from the year 8,000 and only in this time due to a bad time travel accident. To me you're all dirty contemptuous primitive screwheads.
My guess is the blossoms we see now symbolize the Lookouts. The daughters are the (at least symbolic) mothers of them and the rain of petals is the men living their lives and dying in the forrest. Just an idea.
Also, I wonder how old the girl is. At first I was thinking 9-10, but based on her thinking the mother was called yesterday she might be younger. 5-6ish?
Come for the scenery.
Stay because you were torn to shreds by a basilisk
-Redtube
-A goat staring back without blinking
-Jerry
-Sannakji
-Al Gore
-Duke Nukem Forever
-live dolphin birth
-Oprah's afro
-John Madden eating a turducken
damn fine series they have going on here.
Forest Crone is exactly what this lady is in the Cryptozoic Lookouts comic:
Mild plot spoiler:
4th panel is exactly the way my parents looked at me when I told them my wife is pregnant. I'm in my 30s and we've been together for 10 years, and we still get that look of remembered naïveté. It's some serious nostalgic heartbreaking shit 8->
3clipse: The key to any successful marriage is a good mid-game transition.
Heavy is the head that births the Rock Pikmin.
Also, this continues to be the most amazing art Mike has ever done. Seriously, amazing work!
But fuck you — no, fuck y'all, that's as blunt as it gets"
- Kendrick Lamar, "The Blacker the Berry"
As for Hannah, I think she looks too tall to be in either of the age groups you mentioned. To me she looks to be around 11 or 12. If she's any younger, she's seriously tall. Not that this is impossible, my niece is pretty tall, but she's the exception.
Also, if I were going just off The Tithe, I would be inclined to think of the flowers budding and being called as an analogue to the onset of puberty. Such a thing is hardly unprecedented in stories like this. But that doesn't really add up with
Still, based on her build, I'd be sorta surprised if Hannah was younger than 10.
It seems rather unlikely that they don't mean something, at least to Mike and Jerry, given this paragraph from today's news post:
I don't see the connection that makes you think she's ~5.
That just makes it sound like the girls themselves are choosing the flowers somehow, which is an interesting concept, but doesn't tie into "they are secretly samurai!" in any way that satisfies.
But fuck you — no, fuck y'all, that's as blunt as it gets"
- Kendrick Lamar, "The Blacker the Berry"
Don't get me wrong, I'm not buying into the specific samurai reference made earlier. All I mean to say is that he makes it sound like the flower tied with a Daughter says something about her.
I'm not flower expert, so I don't know what they were, but the Hag had a very thorny, briar like flower in her hair in Lookouts, which seemed to fit her disposition.
I'm beginning to wonder how the Lookouts village manages to keep a functioning population though, what with all the boys dying in the forest and the girls running off to be living tree-ladies :P
These short stories of girls in the woods, cowboys in space, rangers that don't range... it's not your trade. Can I grin and bear it? Sure but they're virtually back to back these days. Weeks, in fact, seem to yawn between my once regular fixes of angry gamer humor. Come back to us, boys.
Well, you are entitled to your opinion and I respect it. However...
1. Mine and Jerry clearly like doing these side projects and it's unlikely they're going to stop unless they run out of ideas.
1a. It is unlikely they will run out of ideas.
2. You are going to be overwhelmingly in the minority in your opinion of these side projects.
3. Mike and Jerry rarely read the forums (Jerry has never appeared that I can recall since I've been here), so chances are they are not going to see your opinion.
I was genuinely surprised when I saw the flowers were a part of the girls, something that grew. It makes me a bit uneasy but ahh it's kind of whimsical and charming too... I am so excited for new pages, everything about this arc hits me just the right way.