The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
Please vote in the Forum Structure Poll. Polling will close at 2PM EST on January 21, 2025.
[PA Comic] Wednesday, September 18, 2013 - The Tithe, Part Six
Geth
LegionPerseus VeilRegistered User, Moderator, Penny Arcade Staff, Vanilla Staff vanilla
LegionPerseus VeilRegistered User, Moderator, Penny Arcade Staff, Vanilla Staff vanilla
Posts
Gamer Dater - My Video Game Dating Website full of Faygo
Strip Search Wastebasket of Broken Dreams App I made
Gamer Dater - My Video Game Dating Website full of Faygo
Strip Search Wastebasket of Broken Dreams App I made
"I...I need an adult?"
"I am an adult."
"What the fuck... are you even talking about, man?! I got goddamn flowers budding from my scalp!"
No?
Everything he says gives the impression that he holds the Daughters in high regard. I doubt he would say all that stuff attempting to comfort her, and then kill her.
Feeling pretty bad about my comments on the last strip right now. This is ace.
She's literally flowering.
And I think I agree with @davidhbrown - I've been looking for what the Tithe is, and some form of payment to the forest fits.
For what it's worth, I for one did get the point you were making, and it was a worthy thing to be concerned over. I just wasn't worried about the implications for women in literature because I knew this was coming; more so when Jerry commented that the Daughters know about the Thornwatch and how to summon them, but aren't privvy to the same aggressive propaganda telling them why they shouldn't do it.
If every girl in Hanna's position has the necessary time and knowledge to call on the Thornwatch, and the Thornwatch are actually willing and able to intervene, then the only plant-ladies that exist must be from the girls that freak out so much that they don't call on the Thornwatch until it's too late, or the ones that for whatever reason don't freak out at all about the flower buds growing out of their skull.
But no. She gets a curt "sorry, out of our jurisdiction, nothing we can do" and some words of dubious comfort, and that's all they have for her.
only dreams now
I had said the dude with the staff was my favorite, I think I've been vindicated.
The way the story and art come together is magical.
I would love to see you do a major project around the Eyrewood trio - please say it will be so, pretty please?
I got more of a sense of bewilderment.
Kind of like, "What's this guy on about?"
This is not the Thornwatch refusing to help her because of their 'ideology' or 'mystical crap,' there is actual mystical stuff going on they have no control over.
Did you miss the voice that called her to her 'walk in the woods' in the middle of the night? Did you miss the forest nymph she met? Did you miss the plants growing out of her head?
In previous Lookouts comics the titular group sent little boys out into the woods to get killed by basilisks for no apparent reason, if you want to talk about horrifying stuff done for ideology.
Disclaimer: I haven't read the Cryptozoic Lookouts comics or any other stuff that is accessible outside of PA comics and their newsposts regarding the universe of the Eyrewood, so this is merely my conjecture based on what I've seen in the comic series (Lookouts, Thornwatch intro, and now the Tithe).
Yeah, it seems like the Thornwatch views what is happening to Hanna as the natural order of things - while you can perhaps delay the call, the forest chooses who it will and there is no turning back once it has happened. Is it wrong to us, that a girl is scared and confused about what's happening to her and the people she has turned to in desperation only have "well, deal with it" (although perhaps in kinder tones) to say? Probably. I would guess that in the Eyrewood, though, the people have the preconception that while they may sometimes be at odds with the forest and its inhabitants, the Daughters are a deeply integrated part of the wood and it's only natural to see some confusion or inner conflict as a girl comes to terms with her "calling".
She can't go back to her old life anymore than a woman can go back to being a girl.
The point that the Thornwatch are making is that she *is* home: she's a "Daughter of the Eyrewood in the heart of the forest".
pffff
it's been two weeks
on the contrary, people have been bitching about the comic since the beginning, so
seems like we're right on track
(Major spoilers for issue six!)
Unlike Hanna, Elith did not run into the woods in the middle of the night, and her parents had been clipping the flowers from her hair in an attempt to hide what she's become (it hurts, and they always grow back). After a while a very old Hag of the Eyrewood comes to the village in the middle of the night and tries to take her into the Eyrewood by force.
There is literally nothing they can do to help her, and I think the Greenheart is kind of like a druid (?) and probably sees her connection to the forest as a blessing, or something to be celebrated.
I have no idea.
I mean the art is nice. But i dont see what this has to do with gaming. Is this based off a fantasy RPG or something? I mean it appears to be a comic....PA is a web comic at least....but i'm not seeing the punch line or the comedy factor. I don't get the message the comic is trying to send at all. It feels very random.
The news post for part 1 doesn't help much either.
"This fills out the middle part of the Lookouts as a setting, with Thornwatch being the third. "
??? What are looksout? Thornwatch? Is this a WOW reference? There are no hyper links or anything for these terms. Are we just supposed to know what these refer to?
I look at some of the older comics and most are pretty clear what they are talking about. Like this one : http://art.penny-arcade.com/photos/i-pnZkpTF/0/950x10000/i-pnZkpTF-950x10000.jpg. Its a splinter cell comic. Its obvious. There's a joke and a punch line. I don't get what this series is about, it just looks like a girl hallucinating voices, playing in a forest and some aragorn look alikes pretending to be all deep and mysterious.
Word from Mike, if I recall correctly, was that while in prior side projects they've always felt obligated to not spend too long on the side project because they felt they were taking the main strip away from us by doing that (you saw that with Sand), in this instance they'll be taking as long as they feel they need to take to do the story properly. They look to have built up a week's worth of lead time, and I figure when they have things wrapped up on their end, they'll give us a heads-up. By the end, I'm sure we'll get what's going on, but for now we're learning right along with Hanna.
Um, are you new here? They don't always write about video games. They depict stories like these from time to time. Remember Sand? Automata? Jim Darkmagic? Cardboard Tube Samurai? I don't understand the confusion here. I'm guessing you weren't here for the other two Lookouts comics that took over the main updates years ago.
Personally, I hope they'll take as long as they need to for this particular storyline. It's always disappointing to see a project get rushed.
Thank you.
I've been waiting to use that bro? button properly.
I read through the archive and saw a lot of other comics that i dont understand. The cardboard tube samurai one felt like it was mocking megatokyo or just weaboos in general though.
I have no idea what these comics are supposed to mean. Or were they drawn/written under the influence of substantial amounts of alcohol? They don't make any sense to me, it's like coming into a movie half way and theres these bunch of characters doing SOMETHING....but you have no idea who they are, what they are doing or why they are doing it.
So... there is a news page associated with nearly all of the archive (the very beginning doesn't have it because they didn't keep archives of the news posts when they first started out). So if you don't understand a comic when you're going through the archive, there's a handy newspost available for you to read to get some context.
In this instance, this series is a continued exploration of the world of the Lookouts, a fantasy setting dreamed up by Gabe and Tycho. Here is a link to the original concept comic and you can click the newspost link from there to get a little additional context.
http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2009/06/10
And because I already found them with the handy search function of the archive, here's the next comic in that series, done by a guest artist: http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2009/7/1
And the first comic in the series after that: http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2010/04/26
And here is the first of the three comics introducing the Thornwatch: http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2012/10/17
Enjoy, and be bewildered no more!
I thought they said somewhere this one was a 10 parter.