The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.
So many amazing details with every comic, but I can't get over Malachi's smug smile at the end. You know he's thinking: "Good thing -I- stepped in to save everyone today!"
This was a LOT of talking! I wonder if he was starting to stutter again at the end just because of the sheer volume of talking he'd done, or because the knife reminds him of old times, or because asking for his knife back made him nervous, or if stuttering is just something that never goes away, or if he doesn't stutter around Malachi and Seventeen because he's so comfortable around them...it might seem like a small detail, but Katie and Adam are geniuses, so I imagine there's a precise reason for it happening at that moment.
I may be late to the party for this, but I noticed that Purdy seems to be the only camper who didn't get her shoes stolen. That implies to me that she's camp royalty. Or that she scares the bejeezus out of the shoe thief.
That 4th panel the blonde guy rubbing his neck, that was my exact reaction every time someone started crying as a kid. Little details like how those three each react differently but realistically to the situation is just another reason to absolutely love this comic.
Purdy isn't the only one who still has shoes. Malachi lost his but got them back early in the strip, could be partly just that he's still (I think) the most recently arrived camper. Linus (the librarian) also still has shoes. Being one of the oldest (and largest) campers may be the reason. I'm not certain that those three are the only ones.
Still, if civilization collapses and we all end up like these campers, in three generations there will only be one person left with boots. That will be Purdy's granddaughter.
Stutterers are often portrayed as losing their stutter or stammer under emotional stress, as here. (Robert Penn Warren does the same thing with Sugar Boy in "All the King's Men") In this case, the return of Brian's stutter shows his return to normality, in an otherwise emotionally-charged moment as he confronts Randall and politely asks for his knife back. We are all back to where we started.
Stammering is a poorly-understood medical condition. The best insight I had into it was from reading John Glenn's memoir. One night, with a couple of other Mercury 7 astronauts and their wives at his home, Glenn (flush with LIFE magazine money) showed off some of his new electronics, including a speech repeater that put a half-second delay into what everybody spoke into the microphone. Everybody broke up over how they all fumbled it. Except for Glenn's wife, Annie, whose stammer is now well-known (thanks, Tom Wolfe). Her speech came out clear and without a break. The delay somehow eliminated her stammer completely. I don't know that anybody has researched this phenomenon further. No help for Brian in any case.
As someone who was reading this whole week at once, I desperately needed that Panel 5 Malachi to help bring me back from the end of the previous comic. Thank you, Katie and Adam, for continuing this heart-wrenching and belly-busting rollercoaster ride.
@Peter Rogan That type of audio feedback device is actually used for people who stutter. I don't remember how exactly it is supposed to work (or whether they know exactly how it works), but that is something that some stutterers use.
Also, I stutter, but mine gets worse under emotional stress (or excitement- any time I get worked up basically). The guy I knew with the feedback device, whose stutter was much worse than mine, did say that he became much more fluent when he was angry. I get way *less* fluent, which is extremely frustrating if I'm having an emotionally charged conversation with someone and I can't get my words out.
I just realized... Brian had shoes in the previous comic... He doesn't have them now... WHO DARES TAKE BRIAN'S SHOES?! PROTOKID?! Well, maybe he felt sorry for Protokid and gave them up willingly...
@Android 21 3/7 - Brian had shoes in the flashback. That was before he got to camp. Maybe protokid took them while he was asleep. Or Brian could be like me: I only wear shoes when I absolutely have to. (Note my avatar... and username.) ;-}}
(Aside: I would consider this one of my favorite comics regardless, but it's a definite plus for me that almost all the characters are barefoot all the time.)
Before this arc, did we know Brian stutters? I guess that's why he's quiet
No. Outside of the early comics, Brian almost never spoke.
The only times I really can think he said anything after the early ones (Pootopia, I think is his biggest speech) is telling Seventeen "We do," and his ventriloquist act. There's probably more, but that's all that's coming to mind.
Purdy is the only one is camp that has shoes, a jacket and a gun. She's one of the older campers (though not the oldest) and she lives in a treehouse. Therefore I proclaim her to be Princess Purdy, Countess of the county of Ropes Course and Lady Sheriff of the town of Treehouses. Long Live King Brian! Huzzah!
Purdy is the only one is camp that has shoes, a jacket and a gun. She's one of the older campers (though not the oldest) and she lives in a treehouse. Therefore I proclaim her to be Princess Purdy, Countess of the county of Ropes Course and Lady Sheriff of the town of Treehouses. Long Live King Brian! Huzzah!
I think of Purdy as Generalissimo of the Ropes Course.
Posts
This was a LOT of talking! I wonder if he was starting to stutter again at the end just because of the sheer volume of talking he'd done, or because the knife reminds him of old times, or because asking for his knife back made him nervous, or if stuttering is just something that never goes away, or if he doesn't stutter around Malachi and Seventeen because he's so comfortable around them...it might seem like a small detail, but Katie and Adam are geniuses, so I imagine there's a precise reason for it happening at that moment.
This was a nice conclusion o this arc.
PS: Purdy has a great git rekt face.
Still, if civilization collapses and we all end up like these campers, in three generations there will only be one person left with boots. That will be Purdy's granddaughter.
Stammering is a poorly-understood medical condition. The best insight I had into it was from reading John Glenn's memoir. One night, with a couple of other Mercury 7 astronauts and their wives at his home, Glenn (flush with LIFE magazine money) showed off some of his new electronics, including a speech repeater that put a half-second delay into what everybody spoke into the microphone. Everybody broke up over how they all fumbled it. Except for Glenn's wife, Annie, whose stammer is now well-known (thanks, Tom Wolfe). Her speech came out clear and without a break. The delay somehow eliminated her stammer completely. I don't know that anybody has researched this phenomenon further. No help for Brian in any case.
It was a very unethical and monstrous stutter study done on orphan children.
That happens because the camp is a magical place. Brian, why do you hate magic?
How can I enjoy my comics with such logical inconsistencies? This is worse than when I found out Garfield has no reason to hate Monday!
Also, I stutter, but mine gets worse under emotional stress (or excitement- any time I get worked up basically). The guy I knew with the feedback device, whose stutter was much worse than mine, did say that he became much more fluent when he was angry. I get way *less* fluent, which is extremely frustrating if I'm having an emotionally charged conversation with someone and I can't get my words out.
The only thing that took a beating, was my heart . Brian is legit becoming one of my favourite all time fictional characters...
(Aside: I would consider this one of my favorite comics regardless, but it's a definite plus for me that almost all the characters are barefoot all the time.)
No. Outside of the early comics, Brian almost never spoke.
The only times I really can think he said anything after the early ones (Pootopia, I think is his biggest speech) is telling Seventeen "We do," and his ventriloquist act. There's probably more, but that's all that's coming to mind.
I think of Purdy as Generalissimo of the Ropes Course.