As was foretold, we've added advertisements to the forums! If you have questions, or if you encounter any bugs, please visit this thread: https://forums.penny-arcade.com/discussion/240191/forum-advertisement-faq-and-reports-thread/

GOTY 2017 - Nomination and eligibility thread - Nominations closed

2

Posts

  • PoochPooch Registered User regular
    edited January 2018
    I'm deleting Crash Bandicoot.

    What about Wonder Boy: The Dragon's Trap? I think that was just a reskin of an old game, but I could be off.

    Pooch on
  • RandomHajileRandomHajile Not actually a Snatcher The New KremlinRegistered User regular
    Pooch wrote: »
    I'm deleting Crash Bandicoot.

    What about Wonder Boy: The Dragon's Trap? I think that was just a reskin of an old have, but I could be off.
    Yeah, it is kind of a wild remaster art/sound-wise, but from what I understand the game is the same. You could even input old save game codes and it would load up from that.

  • SaraLunaSaraLuna Registered User regular
    I added a few mobile games to the list: Typeshift, Universal Paperclips, Pokemon Magikarp Jump, & Reigns: Her Majesty

  • PoochPooch Registered User regular
    I'm on mobile now, but a few games I see missing and I'll add later to the Google Doc:

    The Jackbox Party Pack 4
    Stranger Things: The Game
    Puzzle Fighter
    My brother ate my pudding
    Serial Cleaner
    Crazy Taxi Gazillionaire
    BYE-BYE BOXBOY!
    HQ Trivia
    Mirage: Arcane Warfare
    Crashy Cats
    Guns of Mercy
    Titanfall Assault

  • 21stCentury21stCentury Call me Pixel, or Pix for short! [They/Them]Registered User regular
    Is Shovel Knight: Spectre of Torment eligible? It's technically an expandalone, since it got its own release (Like Death of the Outsider), but it is based on an older game in part.......

  • TayaTaya Registered User regular
    Deemo also came out on Switch, assuming it’s the same game/version.

    The Sexy Brutale also came out on Switch.

  • EvilBadmanEvilBadman DO NOT TRUST THIS MAN Registered User regular
    edited January 2018
    Catching up on the thread, and I say no for SkyrimVR and FalloutVR. They are the same narrative with improved viewpoint.

    Spectre of Torment is such a weird case because it is technically an expansion, but it has its own protagonist and storyline. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

    Just to toot my own horn here, I am curating the GOTD (10-19) list (just like 00-09), so if not being able to vote on a remake/definitive edition is causing you personal peril, I'll see you in 2020.

    EvilBadman on
    FyreWulff wrote: »
    I should note that Badman is fucking awesome
    XBL- Evil Badman; Steam- EvilBadman; Twitter - EvilBadman
  • MongerMonger I got the ham stink. Dallas, TXRegistered User regular
    Is Shovel Knight: Spectre of Torment eligible? It's technically an expandalone, since it got its own release (Like Death of the Outsider), but it is based on an older game in part.......
    I forgot that got a standalone release. I'd say to add it. It's in the same situation as Assassin's Creed: Freedom Cry, which was on the list. I only argued against adding Plague of Shadows because it was part of the original game and simply released late.

  • PoochPooch Registered User regular
    EvilBadman wrote: »
    Catching up on the thread, and I say no for SkyrimVR and FalloutVR. They are the same narrative with improved viewpoint.

    Spectre of Torment is such a weird case because it is technically an expansion, but it has its own protagonist and storyline. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

    Just to toot my own horn here, I am curating the GOTD (10-19) list (just like 00-09), so if not being able to vote on a remake/definitive edition is causing you personal peril, I'll see you in 2020.

    How different are the levels in Spectre of Torment? The little bit I played seemed like an expansion pack, but definitely more complete than Plague of Shadows.

  • cooljammer00cooljammer00 Hey Small Christmas-Man!Registered User regular
    I've played a LOT of Match Land and Toy Blast in 2017. I think they both came out last year and should count? They're mobile games.

    steam_sig.png

    3DS Friend Code: 2165-6448-8348 www.Twitch.TV/cooljammer00
    Battle.Net: JohnDarc#1203 Origin/UPlay: CoolJammer00
  • Mr_GrinchMr_Grinch Registered User regular
    Thanks for the updates everyone, I'll check all the changes are reflected in the list tomorrow night.

    Steam: Sir_Grinch
    PSN: SirGrinchX
    Oculus Rift: Sir_Grinch
  • 21stCentury21stCentury Call me Pixel, or Pix for short! [They/Them]Registered User regular
    Pooch wrote: »
    EvilBadman wrote: »
    Catching up on the thread, and I say no for SkyrimVR and FalloutVR. They are the same narrative with improved viewpoint.

    Spectre of Torment is such a weird case because it is technically an expansion, but it has its own protagonist and storyline. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

    Just to toot my own horn here, I am curating the GOTD (10-19) list (just like 00-09), so if not being able to vote on a remake/definitive edition is causing you personal peril, I'll see you in 2020.

    How different are the levels in Spectre of Torment? The little bit I played seemed like an expansion pack, but definitely more complete than Plague of Shadows.

    I mean, they're like in Plague of Shadows. Remixed versions of the levels that have some of the same screen layouts with new gimmicks and mostly entirely new screens for the rest of the level.

    Like, it uses the same assets.

  • Mr_GrinchMr_Grinch Registered User regular
    List in the second post has been updated with the version in the Google Doc. I'll make sure I go through everyone's posts tomorrow though and ensure everything mentioned has been added/removed.

    Steam: Sir_Grinch
    PSN: SirGrinchX
    Oculus Rift: Sir_Grinch
  • DracilDracil Registered User regular
    Added Gorn (PCVR)

    3DS: 2105-8644-6304
    Switch: US 1651-2551-4335 JP 6310-4664-2624
    MH3U Monster Cheat Sheet / MH3U Veggie Elder Ticket Guide
  • LawndartLawndart Registered User regular
    Dracil wrote: »
    Added Gorn (PCVR)

    Still in early access, so unless the EA rules change it's not eligible.

    (Personally I'd keep the current EA rules mainly so I can vote for Subnautica next January.)

    Also, from reading reviews, it seems that L.A. Noire VR Case Files is like Skyrim and Fallout 4 in that it's a port with no real new content, unlike Doom VFR.

  • DracilDracil Registered User regular
    Oh, I'd just gone by what the Steam page had shown. That's a shame. Though I guess Space Pirate Trainer is now officially released.

    3DS: 2105-8644-6304
    Switch: US 1651-2551-4335 JP 6310-4664-2624
    MH3U Monster Cheat Sheet / MH3U Veggie Elder Ticket Guide
  • XaquinXaquin Right behind you!Registered User regular
    Subnautica is early access?!

  • LawndartLawndart Registered User regular
    Xaquin wrote: »
    Subnautica is early access?!

    Believe it or not. It's due to be out of early access this month, though.

    Also, my entry in the "pedantic shit nobody cares about" contest is that there was no PC version of Just Dance 2018.

  • ZythonZython Registered User regular
    Pooch wrote: »
    EvilBadman wrote: »
    Catching up on the thread, and I say no for SkyrimVR and FalloutVR. They are the same narrative with improved viewpoint.

    Spectre of Torment is such a weird case because it is technically an expansion, but it has its own protagonist and storyline. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

    Just to toot my own horn here, I am curating the GOTD (10-19) list (just like 00-09), so if not being able to vote on a remake/definitive edition is causing you personal peril, I'll see you in 2020.

    How different are the levels in Spectre of Torment? The little bit I played seemed like an expansion pack, but definitely more complete than Plague of Shadows.

    I mean, they're like in Plague of Shadows. Remixed versions of the levels that have some of the same screen layouts with new gimmicks and mostly entirely new screens for the rest of the level.

    Like, it uses the same assets.

    When Plague of Shadows launched in 2015, it could only be acquired by buying Shovel Knight. The ability to buy the expansions as stand-alones was added when Specter of Torment launched last year.

    Switch: SW-3245-5421-8042 | 3DS Friend Code: 4854-6465-0299 | PSN: Zaithon
    Steam: pazython
  • Mr_GrinchMr_Grinch Registered User regular
    I'm keen on getting games in when we think they're most likely to get the votes. The landscape of "Early Access" has totally changed now. I'd like to see Gorn in there because it's one of the more popular VR games at the moment - it probably won't be this time next year after it's 'official' release.

    This is a community thing though, I just chuck up a very rough games list and op and let you guys do all the work so it's up to y'all to decide :smile:

    Steam: Sir_Grinch
    PSN: SirGrinchX
    Oculus Rift: Sir_Grinch
  • eelektrikeelektrik Southern CaliforniaRegistered User regular
    edited January 2018
    Everspace. Love me some space Roguelite and will definitely be on my list.

    I removed Guild Wars 2: Path of Fire since it is an expansion pack.

    eelektrik on
    (She/Her)
  • LawndartLawndart Registered User regular
    edited January 2018
    Mr_Grinch wrote: »
    I'm keen on getting games in when we think they're most likely to get the votes. The landscape of "Early Access" has totally changed now. I'd like to see Gorn in there because it's one of the more popular VR games at the moment - it probably won't be this time next year after it's 'official' release.

    This is a community thing though, I just chuck up a very rough games list and op and let you guys do all the work so it's up to y'all to decide :smile:

    Personally I'd say no early access games, since for every GORN and PUBG there are games that are in EA but much less functionally complete. I'm pretty sure games like Astroneer and Oxygen Not Included would get more attention and votes when they're closer to being complete.

    Then there are all of the EA games that were excluded from previous GOTY lists, like Subnautica. Do they all get piled onto this year's list or just forgotten?

    The only downside is that a few games that linger in EA forever might never get on a GOTY list, but I'm not too upset about that.

    Lawndart on
  • SudsSuds Registered User regular
    I'm not sure including Early Access games is a good idea. It bucks the trend. There are still great games in Early Access that started in 2016 and are still in the program. They would have been excluded in the past, and wouldn't be included this year since they aren't 2017 games. Do we only do this going forward, include EA games that started in 2017, but any EA games that started in 2016 and before need a full release?

    camo_sig2.png
  • AshtonDragonAshtonDragon AKA The Nix Registered User regular
    Fate/Grand Order for Mobile should be added. I don't see any other glaring omissions from what I've played, but I'll take another look later.

  • sergiocornagasergiocornaga Registered User regular
    edited January 2018
    Currently adding the following games:
    100 (by everythingstaken)
    100 Free Beetles
    2000:1: A Space Felony
    After Death
    A Halo, Flaring
    air mail
    Alwa's Awakening
    and i made sure to hold your head sideways
    Atop The Witch's Tower
    Behold the Kickmen
    Bendy and the Ink Machine
    Black Room
    Blackwood Crossing
    Bonbon
    Bratavism
    Breakpoint
    Bundle Kitt
    Bury Me, My Love
    Butterfly Soup
    Caveblazers
    CAYNE
    Circle0
    Clarinette
    Cosmic Express
    Crowtel Renovations
    Dank Tomb
    Dead Horizon
    Detention
    Disco Bear
    District
    Dog Mt Frog
    DOGO
    Dominique Pamplemousse and Dominique Pamplemousse in "Combinatorial Explosion!"
    Dujanah
    EAT
    Entanglement - Chapter One
    EPISTLE 3 (by Heather Robertson)
    EPONYMOUS
    Everything is going to be OK
    Fidel Dungeon Rescue
    Finding Paradise
    Fist's Elimination Tower
    Forest Egg
    Forget-Me-Not_R
    Four Last Things
    Freeways
    Getting Over It with Bennett Foddy
    Gigantic
    Gumbo
    Gunmetal Arcadia
    Hell (by ahintoflime)
    Hidden my game by mom! 2
    Hostil
    INFRA
    Into the Dead 2
    Island Survival Simulation 2017
    It is as if you were doing work
    Kimmy
    Known Unknowns
    Last Word
    Legend of Hand
    Luna
    MACAULAY DAD 2016
    Maggie's Apartment
    Maze Minders
    Mini Ghost
    Monolith
    Morphblade
    Move On
    Muldulamulom
    Nadia Was Here
    Nakawak
    Near My Sins // Awaken Thy Blood [newline] or, Never Feel Pain X274 Captured Beast Banana Chalice (_FROGDIRECTION360 rancheros dream SHAREWARE VISION) Everlastic Legacy of Jazz
    Necrosphere
    No Bones
    Northgard
    Odysseus Kosmos and his Robot Quest
    Oikospiel
    Old Man's Journey
    Omegaland
    Omphaloskepsis
    on miniaturization
    Open Sorcery
    pak-gai
    Pipsqueak
    Rabbit Game
    READY PLAYER FUCK
    Remember, Remember
    Rex: Another Island
    ROTOR
    Rumu
    Secret Spaces
    Seven Doorways
    She Remembered Caterpillars
    Short Trip
    Sibilant Snakelikes
    Silver Grapple
    SNAKISMS
    Songbringer
    Snow Cones 2
    Son of Scoregasm
    Space Pirates And Zombies 2
    Spikes 'n' Stuff
    Splinter Zone
    stale (by Snapman)
    STATUES (by Space Backyard)
    Stories Untold
    Strikey Sisters
    Subliminal Realms: Call of Atis
    Subsurface Circular
    Super Fancy Pants Adventure
    Super Lovely Planet
    Super Skelemania
    Swappy 10
    TAROTICA VOO DOO
    TEMPRES
    The Darkside Detective
    The Dream Machine
    The Fidelio Incident
    The Last Days of Our Castle
    THE LEAGUE OF LONELY GEOLOGISTS
    The Letter
    The Low Road
    The Norwood Suite
    The Pokisfiori Museum Installation
    The Search
    The Shrouded Isle
    The Spicy Meatball Saves The Day
    The Stakes Are Too High
    The Tearoom
    The Zium Museum
    This Too Shall Pass
    Tiny Barbarian DX
    Tiny Echo
    Topsoil
    Tormentor X Punisher
    Tower 57
    TumbleSeed
    Unexplored
    Uurnog / Uurnog Uurnlimited
    Vignettes
    v r 3
    Watch Ducks Legacy
    Where They Cremate The Roadkill
    Whole
    Wikipedia: The Text Adventure
    Wilmot’s Warehouse
    Wire Wood Daughters
    WitchWay
    Worm Dungeon
    worst guest
    XCOM 2: War of the Chosen
    Yo! Noid 2: Enter the Void
    Zzzz-Zzzz-Zzzz
    救う(SHE SAVE)
    

    EDIT: Got exhausted partway through adding platforms for everything and it's past 5am, so I'm stopping. If anyone feels like helping, go ahead, and I'll fill in whatever's missing tomorrow.

    sergiocornaga on
  • PoochPooch Registered User regular
    Currently adding the following games:
    100 (by everythingstaken)
    100 Free Beetles
    2000:1: A Space Felony
    After Death
    A Halo, Flaring
    air mail
    Alwa's Awakening
    and i made sure to hold your head sideways
    Atop The Witch's Tower
    Behold the Kickmen
    Bendy and the Ink Machine
    Black Room
    Blackwood Crossing
    Bonbon
    Bratavism
    Breakpoint
    Bundle Kitt
    Bury Me, My Love
    Butterfly Soup
    Caveblazers
    CAYNE
    Circle0
    Clarinette
    Cosmic Express
    Crowtel Renovations
    Dank Tomb
    Dead Horizon
    Detention
    Disco Bear
    District
    Dog Mt Frog
    DOGO
    Dominique Pamplemousse and Dominique Pamplemousse in "Combinatorial Explosion!"
    Dujanah
    EAT
    Entanglement - Chapter One
    EPISTLE 3 (by Heather Robertson)
    EPONYMOUS
    Everything is going to be OK
    Fidel Dungeon Rescue
    Finding Paradise
    Fist's Elimination Tower
    Forest Egg
    Forget-Me-Not_R
    Four Last Things
    Freeways
    Getting Over It with Bennett Foddy
    Gigantic
    Gumbo
    Gunmetal Arcadia
    Hell (by ahintoflime)
    Hidden my game by mom! 2
    Hostil
    INFRA
    Into the Dead 2
    Island Survival Simulation 2017
    It is as if you were doing work
    Kimmy
    Known Unknowns
    Last Word
    Legend of Hand
    Luna
    MACAULAY DAD 2016
    Maggie's Apartment
    Maze Minders
    Mini Ghost
    Monolith
    Morphblade
    Move On
    Muldulamulom
    Nadia Was Here
    Nakawak
    Near My Sins // Awaken Thy Blood [newline] or, Never Feel Pain X274 Captured Beast Banana Chalice (_FROGDIRECTION360 rancheros dream SHAREWARE VISION) Everlastic Legacy of Jazz
    Necrosphere
    No Bones
    Northgard
    Odysseus Kosmos and his Robot Quest
    Oikospiel
    Old Man's Journey
    Omegaland
    Omphaloskepsis
    on miniaturization
    Open Sorcery
    pak-gai
    Pipsqueak
    Rabbit Game
    READY PLAYER FUCK
    Remember, Remember
    Rex: Another Island
    ROTOR
    Rumu
    Secret Spaces
    Seven Doorways
    She Remembered Caterpillars
    Short Trip
    Sibilant Snakelikes
    Silver Grapple
    SNAKISMS
    Songbringer
    Snow Cones 2
    Son of Scoregasm
    Space Pirates And Zombies 2
    Spikes 'n' Stuff
    Splinter Zone
    stale (by Snapman)
    STATUES (by Space Backyard)
    Stories Untold
    Strikey Sisters
    Subliminal Realms: Call of Atis
    Subsurface Circular
    Super Fancy Pants Adventure
    Super Lovely Planet
    Super Skelemania
    Swappy 10
    TAROTICA VOO DOO
    TEMPRES
    The Darkside Detective
    The Dream Machine
    The Fidelio Incident
    The Last Days of Our Castle
    THE LEAGUE OF LONELY GEOLOGISTS
    The Letter
    The Low Road
    The Norwood Suite
    The Pokisfiori Museum Installation
    The Search
    The Shrouded Isle
    The Spicy Meatball Saves The Day
    The Stakes Are Too High
    The Tearoom
    The Zium Museum
    This Too Shall Pass
    Tiny Barbarian DX
    Tiny Echo
    Topsoil
    Tormentor X Punisher
    Tower 57
    TumbleSeed
    Unexplored
    Uurnog / Uurnog Uurnlimited
    Vignettes
    v r 3
    Watch Ducks Legacy
    Where They Cremate The Roadkill
    Whole
    Wikipedia: The Text Adventure
    Wilmot’s Warehouse
    Wire Wood Daughters
    WitchWay
    Worm Dungeon
    worst guest
    XCOM 2: War of the Chosen
    Yo! Noid 2: Enter the Void
    Zzzz-Zzzz-Zzzz
    救う(SHE SAVE)
    

    EDIT: Got exhausted partway through adding platforms for everything and it's past 5am, so I'm stopping. If anyone feels like helping, go ahead, and I'll fill in whatever's missing tomorrow.

    Worm Dungeon is the best name for anything and they made a new Yo Noid game. Exciting times we live in

  • MongerMonger I got the ham stink. Dallas, TXRegistered User regular
    Currently adding the following games:
    100 (by everythingstaken)
    100 Free Beetles
    2000:1: A Space Felony
    After Death
    A Halo, Flaring
    air mail
    Alwa's Awakening
    and i made sure to hold your head sideways
    Atop The Witch's Tower
    Behold the Kickmen
    Bendy and the Ink Machine
    Black Room
    Blackwood Crossing
    Bonbon
    Bratavism
    Breakpoint
    Bundle Kitt
    Bury Me, My Love
    Butterfly Soup
    Caveblazers
    CAYNE
    Circle0
    Clarinette
    Cosmic Express
    Crowtel Renovations
    Dank Tomb
    Dead Horizon
    Detention
    Disco Bear
    District
    Dog Mt Frog
    DOGO
    Dominique Pamplemousse and Dominique Pamplemousse in "Combinatorial Explosion!"
    Dujanah
    EAT
    Entanglement - Chapter One
    EPISTLE 3 (by Heather Robertson)
    EPONYMOUS
    Everything is going to be OK
    Fidel Dungeon Rescue
    Finding Paradise
    Fist's Elimination Tower
    Forest Egg
    Forget-Me-Not_R
    Four Last Things
    Freeways
    Getting Over It with Bennett Foddy
    Gigantic
    Gumbo
    Gunmetal Arcadia
    Hell (by ahintoflime)
    Hidden my game by mom! 2
    Hostil
    INFRA
    Into the Dead 2
    Island Survival Simulation 2017
    It is as if you were doing work
    Kimmy
    Known Unknowns
    Last Word
    Legend of Hand
    Luna
    MACAULAY DAD 2016
    Maggie's Apartment
    Maze Minders
    Mini Ghost
    Monolith
    Morphblade
    Move On
    Muldulamulom
    Nadia Was Here
    Nakawak
    Near My Sins // Awaken Thy Blood [newline] or, Never Feel Pain X274 Captured Beast Banana Chalice (_FROGDIRECTION360 rancheros dream SHAREWARE VISION) Everlastic Legacy of Jazz
    Necrosphere
    No Bones
    Northgard
    Odysseus Kosmos and his Robot Quest
    Oikospiel
    Old Man's Journey
    Omegaland
    Omphaloskepsis
    on miniaturization
    Open Sorcery
    pak-gai
    Pipsqueak
    Rabbit Game
    READY PLAYER FUCK
    Remember, Remember
    Rex: Another Island
    ROTOR
    Rumu
    Secret Spaces
    Seven Doorways
    She Remembered Caterpillars
    Short Trip
    Sibilant Snakelikes
    Silver Grapple
    SNAKISMS
    Songbringer
    Snow Cones 2
    Son of Scoregasm
    Space Pirates And Zombies 2
    Spikes 'n' Stuff
    Splinter Zone
    stale (by Snapman)
    STATUES (by Space Backyard)
    Stories Untold
    Strikey Sisters
    Subliminal Realms: Call of Atis
    Subsurface Circular
    Super Fancy Pants Adventure
    Super Lovely Planet
    Super Skelemania
    Swappy 10
    TAROTICA VOO DOO
    TEMPRES
    The Darkside Detective
    The Dream Machine
    The Fidelio Incident
    The Last Days of Our Castle
    THE LEAGUE OF LONELY GEOLOGISTS
    The Letter
    The Low Road
    The Norwood Suite
    The Pokisfiori Museum Installation
    The Search
    The Shrouded Isle
    The Spicy Meatball Saves The Day
    The Stakes Are Too High
    The Tearoom
    The Zium Museum
    This Too Shall Pass
    Tiny Barbarian DX
    Tiny Echo
    Topsoil
    Tormentor X Punisher
    Tower 57
    TumbleSeed
    Unexplored
    Uurnog / Uurnog Uurnlimited
    Vignettes
    v r 3
    Watch Ducks Legacy
    Where They Cremate The Roadkill
    Whole
    Wikipedia: The Text Adventure
    Wilmot’s Warehouse
    Wire Wood Daughters
    WitchWay
    Worm Dungeon
    worst guest
    XCOM 2: War of the Chosen
    Yo! Noid 2: Enter the Void
    Zzzz-Zzzz-Zzzz
    救う(SHE SAVE)
    

    EDIT: Got exhausted partway through adding platforms for everything and it's past 5am, so I'm stopping. If anyone feels like helping, go ahead, and I'll fill in whatever's missing tomorrow.
    War of the Chosen needs to come off. That's an expansion.

  • sergiocornagasergiocornaga Registered User regular
    edited January 2018
    Monger wrote: »
    War of the Chosen needs to come off. That's an expansion.

    Whoops! That's what I get for not scrutinising the RPS GOTY list enough. Removed!

    EDIT: OK, I've added platforms for every game that was missing them! I also added Touhou Tenkuushou ~ Hidden Star in Four Seasons, which I suppose got an international release even if it wasn't an English language one.

    EDIT 2: Added Cinco Paus, Coincident Spaces, Doctor Kvorak's Obliteration Game, Don't make love, Engare, Full Speed Kiss, I Expect You To Die, Kyklos Code, Last Day of June, LOGistICAL, Lost Memories Dot Net, MOLOCH (Zero), Normal Human Face Simulator, office-zone with cat, Pigeon Game, Skate8, Super Blood Hockey, Tell Me What You See, That Blooming Feeling, we all get together to celebrate the birth of jesus christ, Witchball, and Yo! Let's UP.

    sergiocornaga on
  • PoochPooch Registered User regular
    Monger wrote: »
    War of the Chosen needs to come off. That's an expansion.

    Whoops! That's what I get for not scrutinising the RPS GOTY list enough. Removed!

    EDIT: OK, I've added platforms for every game that was missing them! I also added Touhou Tenkuushou ~ Hidden Star in Four Seasons, which I suppose got an international release even if it wasn't an English language one.

    EDIT 2: Added Cinco Paus, Coincident Spaces, Doctor Kvorak's Obliteration Game, Don't make love, Engare, Full Speed Kiss, I Expect You To Die, Kyklos Code, Last Day of June, LOGistICAL, Lost Memories Dot Net, MOLOCH (Zero), Normal Human Face Simulator, office-zone with cat, Pigeon Game, Skate8, Super Blood Hockey, Tell Me What You See, That Blooming Feeling, we all get together to celebrate the birth of jesus christ, Witchball, and Yo! Let's UP.

    I think I Expect You To Die came out in 2016... Was that on last year's list?

  • SpoitSpoit *twitch twitch* Registered User regular
    Is "Blaster Master Zero (NS, 3DS)" a new release this year?

    steam_sig.png
  • sergiocornagasergiocornaga Registered User regular
    edited January 2018
    Pooch wrote: »
    I think I Expect You To Die came out in 2016... Was that on last year's list?

    I wasn't able to check if it'd already been listed because goty.padev.net just says "Bad vhost." @Infidel?

    EDIT: Oh of course, I can check the forum thread instead. Yup, it's there. Removed from the spreadsheet now!

    sergiocornaga on
  • MongerMonger I got the ham stink. Dallas, TXRegistered User regular
    I did the Dark Deed because nobody else had.

    Removed:
    Mario Kart 8 Deluxe

    RIP Mario Kart. You were old and therefore trash.

  • Mr_GrinchMr_Grinch Registered User regular
    Pooch wrote: »
    Monger wrote: »
    War of the Chosen needs to come off. That's an expansion.

    Whoops! That's what I get for not scrutinising the RPS GOTY list enough. Removed!

    EDIT: OK, I've added platforms for every game that was missing them! I also added Touhou Tenkuushou ~ Hidden Star in Four Seasons, which I suppose got an international release even if it wasn't an English language one.

    EDIT 2: Added Cinco Paus, Coincident Spaces, Doctor Kvorak's Obliteration Game, Don't make love, Engare, Full Speed Kiss, I Expect You To Die, Kyklos Code, Last Day of June, LOGistICAL, Lost Memories Dot Net, MOLOCH (Zero), Normal Human Face Simulator, office-zone with cat, Pigeon Game, Skate8, Super Blood Hockey, Tell Me What You See, That Blooming Feeling, we all get together to celebrate the birth of jesus christ, Witchball, and Yo! Let's UP.

    I think I Expect You To Die came out in 2016... Was that on last year's list?

    I seem to recall it coming out last year in the USA and perhaps this year in the UK? It took a while to get to us.

    Yeah - December 6th. I dunno if it was on last years' list though. If it wasn't I think we can probably let it in (mostly because I'd love to vote for it, it was fantastic)

    Steam: Sir_Grinch
    PSN: SirGrinchX
    Oculus Rift: Sir_Grinch
  • DrakeDrake Edgelord Trash Below the ecliptic plane.Registered User regular
    edited January 2018
    Dominions 5: Warriors of the Faith came out of Early Access recently. That's all I can think of for the moment. Glad to see the GOTY poll back this year. I was starting to wonder if I'd see it.

    edit: I poked at the spreadsheet thingy. I think I did it wrong.

    Drake on
  • sergiocornagasergiocornaga Registered User regular
    Drake wrote: »
    edit: I poked at the spreadsheet thingy. I think I did it wrong.

    Yeah, it looks like you inadvertently deleted several games. But not to worry! Thanks to version history I was able to restore them, and Dominions 5 is in the list too!

  • LawndartLawndart Registered User regular
    Mr_Grinch wrote: »
    Pooch wrote: »
    Monger wrote: »
    War of the Chosen needs to come off. That's an expansion.

    Whoops! That's what I get for not scrutinising the RPS GOTY list enough. Removed!

    EDIT: OK, I've added platforms for every game that was missing them! I also added Touhou Tenkuushou ~ Hidden Star in Four Seasons, which I suppose got an international release even if it wasn't an English language one.

    EDIT 2: Added Cinco Paus, Coincident Spaces, Doctor Kvorak's Obliteration Game, Don't make love, Engare, Full Speed Kiss, I Expect You To Die, Kyklos Code, Last Day of June, LOGistICAL, Lost Memories Dot Net, MOLOCH (Zero), Normal Human Face Simulator, office-zone with cat, Pigeon Game, Skate8, Super Blood Hockey, Tell Me What You See, That Blooming Feeling, we all get together to celebrate the birth of jesus christ, Witchball, and Yo! Let's UP.

    I think I Expect You To Die came out in 2016... Was that on last year's list?

    I seem to recall it coming out last year in the USA and perhaps this year in the UK? It took a while to get to us.

    Yeah - December 6th. I dunno if it was on last years' list though. If it wasn't I think we can probably let it in (mostly because I'd love to vote for it, it was fantastic)

    I Expect You To Die was on the 2016 GOTY list.

    (There are downsides to listing literally every single game released during a calendar year in a GOTY nomination list, I guess.)

  • RandomHajileRandomHajile Not actually a Snatcher The New KremlinRegistered User regular
    Lawndart wrote: »
    Mr_Grinch wrote: »
    Pooch wrote: »
    Monger wrote: »
    War of the Chosen needs to come off. That's an expansion.

    Whoops! That's what I get for not scrutinising the RPS GOTY list enough. Removed!

    EDIT: OK, I've added platforms for every game that was missing them! I also added Touhou Tenkuushou ~ Hidden Star in Four Seasons, which I suppose got an international release even if it wasn't an English language one.

    EDIT 2: Added Cinco Paus, Coincident Spaces, Doctor Kvorak's Obliteration Game, Don't make love, Engare, Full Speed Kiss, I Expect You To Die, Kyklos Code, Last Day of June, LOGistICAL, Lost Memories Dot Net, MOLOCH (Zero), Normal Human Face Simulator, office-zone with cat, Pigeon Game, Skate8, Super Blood Hockey, Tell Me What You See, That Blooming Feeling, we all get together to celebrate the birth of jesus christ, Witchball, and Yo! Let's UP.

    I think I Expect You To Die came out in 2016... Was that on last year's list?

    I seem to recall it coming out last year in the USA and perhaps this year in the UK? It took a while to get to us.

    Yeah - December 6th. I dunno if it was on last years' list though. If it wasn't I think we can probably let it in (mostly because I'd love to vote for it, it was fantastic)

    I Expect You To Die was on the 2016 GOTY list.

    (There are downsides to listing literally every single game released during a calendar year in a GOTY nomination list, I guess.)
    The biggest problem is that "here's a 2017 release list from Wikipedia" doesn't take into account the fact that a game may be a port. It's a great start, and I wholeheartedly thank Grinch for managing the list, but we have to put eyes on the list to watch for this stuff.

  • LawndartLawndart Registered User regular
    Lawndart wrote: »
    Mr_Grinch wrote: »
    Pooch wrote: »
    Monger wrote: »
    War of the Chosen needs to come off. That's an expansion.

    Whoops! That's what I get for not scrutinising the RPS GOTY list enough. Removed!

    EDIT: OK, I've added platforms for every game that was missing them! I also added Touhou Tenkuushou ~ Hidden Star in Four Seasons, which I suppose got an international release even if it wasn't an English language one.

    EDIT 2: Added Cinco Paus, Coincident Spaces, Doctor Kvorak's Obliteration Game, Don't make love, Engare, Full Speed Kiss, I Expect You To Die, Kyklos Code, Last Day of June, LOGistICAL, Lost Memories Dot Net, MOLOCH (Zero), Normal Human Face Simulator, office-zone with cat, Pigeon Game, Skate8, Super Blood Hockey, Tell Me What You See, That Blooming Feeling, we all get together to celebrate the birth of jesus christ, Witchball, and Yo! Let's UP.

    I think I Expect You To Die came out in 2016... Was that on last year's list?

    I seem to recall it coming out last year in the USA and perhaps this year in the UK? It took a while to get to us.

    Yeah - December 6th. I dunno if it was on last years' list though. If it wasn't I think we can probably let it in (mostly because I'd love to vote for it, it was fantastic)

    I Expect You To Die was on the 2016 GOTY list.

    (There are downsides to listing literally every single game released during a calendar year in a GOTY nomination list, I guess.)
    The biggest problem is that "here's a 2017 release list from Wikipedia" doesn't take into account the fact that a game may be a port. It's a great start, and I wholeheartedly thank Grinch for managing the list, but we have to put eyes on the list to watch for this stuff.

    Ports always seem to get weeded out, but I feel bad for games released in January (since they get overshadowed by later releases) and December (since far fewer people get a chance to play them).

    I don't know if it's more fair to keep things as they are or let December releases sneak into the following year's poll as well.

  • RandomHajileRandomHajile Not actually a Snatcher The New KremlinRegistered User regular
    Lawndart wrote: »
    Lawndart wrote: »
    Mr_Grinch wrote: »
    Pooch wrote: »
    Monger wrote: »
    War of the Chosen needs to come off. That's an expansion.

    Whoops! That's what I get for not scrutinising the RPS GOTY list enough. Removed!

    EDIT: OK, I've added platforms for every game that was missing them! I also added Touhou Tenkuushou ~ Hidden Star in Four Seasons, which I suppose got an international release even if it wasn't an English language one.

    EDIT 2: Added Cinco Paus, Coincident Spaces, Doctor Kvorak's Obliteration Game, Don't make love, Engare, Full Speed Kiss, I Expect You To Die, Kyklos Code, Last Day of June, LOGistICAL, Lost Memories Dot Net, MOLOCH (Zero), Normal Human Face Simulator, office-zone with cat, Pigeon Game, Skate8, Super Blood Hockey, Tell Me What You See, That Blooming Feeling, we all get together to celebrate the birth of jesus christ, Witchball, and Yo! Let's UP.

    I think I Expect You To Die came out in 2016... Was that on last year's list?

    I seem to recall it coming out last year in the USA and perhaps this year in the UK? It took a while to get to us.

    Yeah - December 6th. I dunno if it was on last years' list though. If it wasn't I think we can probably let it in (mostly because I'd love to vote for it, it was fantastic)

    I Expect You To Die was on the 2016 GOTY list.

    (There are downsides to listing literally every single game released during a calendar year in a GOTY nomination list, I guess.)
    The biggest problem is that "here's a 2017 release list from Wikipedia" doesn't take into account the fact that a game may be a port. It's a great start, and I wholeheartedly thank Grinch for managing the list, but we have to put eyes on the list to watch for this stuff.

    Ports always seem to get weeded out, but I feel bad for games released in January (since they get overshadowed by later releases) and December (since far fewer people get a chance to play them).

    I don't know if it's more fair to keep things as they are or let December releases sneak into the following year's poll as well.
    Well, I mean, that's why we moved voting to late January a couple years back. We have to have a cutoff, and allowing December games in the following year just causes people to do the same thing as they do with January games and forget them; doubly so because they'll be like "that was last year, so I'm not going to look for it on the list." Of course, if we completely whiff on including a December game, I think it's fine to put it on the following year, but we need to be careful about that. Hence, the purpose of this thread. Also, with Infidel adding the ability to re-vote, people often see what other people have voted for and can go re-vote.

  • WybornWyborn GET EQUIPPED Registered User regular
    edited January 2018
    I'd like to throw in my support for getting Specter of Torment on there, since it's definitely on my list and has completely different level layouts, game structure, and mechanics compared to the other two Shovel Knight games

    That and, well, you can buy it independently of any other Shovel Knight game. It's sold separately! It's super a separate game. C'mon. C'mooooooooon.

    Wyborn on
    dN0T6ur.png
Sign In or Register to comment.