Let me explain better. I'm a huge gamer(not literally), and I've played an enormous amount of games. However, I've never found my game. Most people I know or have talked to, have that game. The game that they lavish incredible amounts of time into, trying to be the best, getting the most out of it, etc. For my brother, its WoW(and EQ previously). Best friend, MGS. Other good friend, CS. Halo for one, etc etc. I don't have this game. My general path with games is getting them, playing until I'm quite good at it, and then quitting. Maybe I have gamer ADD, but once I know I can beat ~80% of people I play in a game, I see little reason to keep at it. The games I can't get that good at, I usually don't enjoy, not because I lose, but because I don't enjoy the time spent getting good at it.
So, this comes down to you, G&T. I cross my fingers, hoping you can help me find some game I didn't know about, or casually passed by, when it could be, in fact, my game. I have idea's on what this game should be like, for the most part.
-Multiplayer(though PvE is ok along with a multiplayer aspect)
-Rewards over time. Not talking about getting a higher rank, or things like that. Some form of leveling or at least gear gathering/purchasing/whatnot.
-Huge replayability.
If I ended the post here, people would shower me with MMO's. The only problem is, I've played quite a few of them, and most bored me to tears. WoW, EQ, DAoC, etc, the combat was simply boring to the point that I regularly had to force myself to stay awake. EVE, while a lot funner in combat, had too much traveling and time wasted doing nothing, along with me not liking the leveling system. I have enjoyed a couple "mmo's", like WWIIOL and Planetside, but I rarely felt rewarded enough for my efforts. After the first few ranks in WWIIOL, you get no real benefit from ranking up. Planetside, after hitting level six, anything else was just to give you more options at one time, but nothing new really.
Now, I'm not too worried about genre. A shooter, action, RPG, or strategy would all be fine, if they fit those categories well. A few games I assume will be brought up, that I can already shoot down:
1. Diablo 2 - Great game, love it, but the endgame is just endless farming and grinding. The replayability just isn't there for me to play it on a regular basis.
2. Mythos - Similar to D2, but felt too slow paced.
3. Hellgate london - Another good game, and I loved it in normal, but once you get to nightmare, you just grind and grind, nothing feels like an upgrade, and its just not fun anymore.
4. Age of Conan - I actually want to try this out, but its expensive(being new still), plus monthly fee's, and I hear some bad things along with the good... I'm holding out for a free trial
5. Call of Duty 4 - This is actually a great example of what I'd like, in terms of replayability, rewards, etc. The only problem is, I already hit level 55
One last thing, though I assume(and would prefer) this to be a PC game, I have pretty much every console and handheld except for the PS3.
TL;DR : Sorry for the long post, but really, I can't condense it much. Just skim it.
Posts
I played MH2 on the PSP
I really wanted to slit my wrists after a half hour of it. I can't even explain why I hated it to much, I just did.
3ds friend code: 2981-6032-4118
Have you tried the Rainbow Six: Vegas series?
A little bit. I played a good amount of the single player on the 360, and a little MP on the PS3. It was fun, but definitely not the game
3ds friend code: 2981-6032-4118
As for Dwarf Fortress, I actually did try it for a little bit before. I like roguelikes, and DF wasn't bad(I wasn't playing adventure mode, to preempt that question), but its too slow paced for me, the rewards aren't much, and no multiplayer.
Great suggestions all, but I turn to the forums when I've scratched my brain of every ounce of information. I rarely have easy questions.
3ds friend code: 2981-6032-4118
I've never really been able to get into browser based games though. Pretty much any game I play that forces me to wait real time before I can do more stuff, leads to me less and less frequently checking it, and eventually forgetting about them.
Not to mention they aren't terribly exciting.
3ds friend code: 2981-6032-4118
I am a difficult man to please, and I need one of you, manly st... wait, this isn't SE++.
I played a good bit of MGO at my friends house, who has the PS3. Its fun, no doubt, but as someone who's played just about every popular FPS out there, its simply mediocre to some of the better offerings out there.
3ds friend code: 2981-6032-4118
Have you tried Natural Selection? It is a RTS/FPS hybrid mod for Half-Life.
@gamefacts - Totally and utterly true gaming facts on the regular!
Will- I don't need one game to play, but I would like to find that game that really clicks for me. I currently have nothing I want to play, which makes me a sad panda. As for gamefly, I've looked through its selection, and few of the games looked that interesting to me. I have fairly picky tastes in games in general.
3ds friend code: 2981-6032-4118
which brings me onto my only advice for you: I'd maybe leave Age of Conan for a while and try it in a month or two. I bought it at release and while it is enjoyable to a point, and looks fantastic if you have the machine for it, there's just too much unfinished and unpolished.
You know when you play a game and it just 'feels' right and the controls and gameplay elements are intuitive and cleverly designed? There's a real feeling of satisfaction there and it makes the game seem almost effortlessly fun. Age of Conan, as it stands currently, is basically something of the opposite: nothing works quite as well as it should, and everything lacks polish.
It borders on depressing to play because there are so many good ideas but they're just poorly executed. It's like watching a really great, exciting film which is ruined by an inexplicably poor script.
That's my 2p.
(note, games I AM enjoying at the moment are COD4, which I'm revisiting since it errored and reset my rank to 0; and the PA game which is just refreshing and fun.)
It even focuses on PvP over PvE in the endgame, which if done correctly can lead to a much lengthier period of fun than limited PvE content. It also has extensive rewards system for PvP combat. Might want to keep your eye on that.
Well the good thing about Gamefly is that it doesn't matter if the game is crap or not - you can just fire it back and get another one if you don't like it. It might be that something you never considered really works for you. And then you can do a Let's Play on it and we'll all be like 'oh'.
@gamefacts - Totally and utterly true gaming facts on the regular!
Well, the thing is, I don't really like spending my time playing crap games.
Shit, if I just wanted to play random games I have no real desire to play, I'll try escape from monkey island, Company of Heroes, Thief, or any of the other apparently awesome games I own but haven't played, simply because they don't seem interesting to me.
3ds friend code: 2981-6032-4118
@gamefacts - Totally and utterly true gaming facts on the regular!
/ducks
EDIT: seriously, you kinda sound like someone who's a bit burnt out on gaming. I've been there, and as I get older I find myself pressed for time and feeling guilty when I sit down for more than a casual session once in a while.
3ds friend code: 2981-6032-4118
Only ever been through a game 3 times before RE4 came along.
Multiplayer wise? Advance Wars: Days of Ruin
The Transformers Fandom: Consistantly bitching about something or another since 1984.
http://www.nuklearpower.com/2009/03/28/warbot_001/ - "WARBOT In Accounting"
And I've always been a huge advance wars fan. I generally play it any time a good opportunity comes up with friends who want to play it also. Sadly, that's not all that often.
3ds friend code: 2981-6032-4118
For example, my game is Spider-Man 2. Probably not the first on any "you've GOT to play this" list.
Yeah, the good thing bout Days of Ruin is you can play online on Wifi against random people.
Some people drop out when they losin, some people keep playing a good game.
The Transformers Fandom: Consistantly bitching about something or another since 1984.
http://www.nuklearpower.com/2009/03/28/warbot_001/ - "WARBOT In Accounting"
Aw man I love Spider-man 2...but then again I'm a whore for pretty much any Spider-man game so maybe I shouldn't talk.
Because I don't really have anything to play at the moment.
Re: Advance wars, I dunno, it just seems wierd playing it online
3ds friend code: 2981-6032-4118
Not exactly competitive, but you get massive bragging rights.
I'd personally go for the virtua fighter, guilty gear and king of fighters series. Maybe street fighter.
This is what happened to me.
However, I've been able to enjoy
Team Fortress 2
Battlefield 2 if you can find a good server
And Mass Effect was an awesome game, but I'm not sure I like it enough to play through three or four times like others.
GM: Rusty Chains (DH Ongoing)
Medic was updated, Pyro update came out yesterday. Achivements, new weapons, new maps. It's competative multiplayer with a sense of accomplishment.
360 : ThePmoney
Battle.net: Pmoney.thereal
Im kind of the same in that I would buy a game play it, then never pick it up or look at it again, there are some games though that I have played through a number of times like the FF games, GTA games and of course HL/portal, I wouldn't really classify any of them as "The game" though just as games I really enjoyed playing. I know you are looking for a PC game but if you like rhythem games I would highly recommend gitaroo man, this is one game that really took me by suprise, hadn't heard anything about it and bought it out of shear bordem, I find the best games are the random ones you pick up or have no idea what they are so have no preconceptions about them
ps how the hell do you own games you haven't played? seems un-natural to me :P
Steam ID : rwb36, Twitter : Werezompire,
Hmmm, perhaps that is not the game for you then.
Maybe you could try out that new Tom Clancy game EndWar when it comes out. It's headed to PC and the next gen consoles, and I think it's in beta now.