I think you dudes have a bad habit of mistaking weird behavior for mafia behavior.
I didn't base the vote on your behavior at all.
when a mafia member dies without knowing he's going to die and then breaks a tie close to vote close resulting in someone elses death, the smart thing to do is look at the other person. especially when usually the person who breaks said tie is suspicious and ties sometimes kill both people which is good for the mafia and if neither tries to defend themselves from a day 1 vote in a vanilla game, it means that neither is special which if they are both innocent the mafia can then narrow down their suspects for specials by 1 person.... so why break the tie?
I can see why the others thought it was weird that you were offering an actual reason for voting me out. I'm not going to say you're mafia because I think I'm just rationalizing a hunch rather than looking at things rationally, but I would expect the villagers to look back on this and wonder if you didn't choose to lay out a logical reason to avoid having people turn on you on Day 3. To a mafia, who of course knows I'm not mafia, this would be treated as an inevitability rather than a mere possibility. Villagers, on the other hand, generally act a bit more self-assured and less obligated to defend themselves (I imagine this is because confidence reaffirms their correctness to themselves).
There's certainly a stark contrast between your treatment of me today and how you acted in Mario Kart.
Also, as for the suspicious nature of Delmain's vote, I feel that's quite dealt with by the fact that I could have (and, as a mafia, would have been obligated to) break the tie myself.
I think you dudes have a bad habit of mistaking weird behavior for mafia behavior.
I didn't base the vote on your behavior at all.
when a mafia member dies without knowing he's going to die and then breaks a tie close to vote close resulting in someone elses death, the smart thing to do is look at the other person. especially when usually the person who breaks said tie is suspicious and ties sometimes kill both people which is good for the mafia and if neither tries to defend themselves from a day 1 vote in a vanilla game, it means that neither is special which if they are both innocent the mafia can then narrow down their suspects for specials by 1 person.... so why break the tie?
I can see why the others thought it was weird that you were offering an actual reason for voting me out. I'm not going to say you're mafia because I think I'm just rationalizing a hunch rather than looking at things rationally, but I would expect the villagers to look back on this and wonder if you didn't choose to lay out a logical reason to avoid having people turn on you on Day 3. To a mafia, who of course knows I'm not mafia, this would be treated as an inevitability rather than a mere possibility. Villagers, on the other hand, generally act a bit more self-assured and less obligated to defend themselves (I imagine this is because confidence reaffirms their correctness to themselves).
There's certainly a stark contrast between your treatment of me today and how you acted in Mario Kart.
Also, as for the suspicious nature of Delmain's vote, I feel that's quite dealt with by the fact that I could have (and, as a mafia, would have been obligated to) break the tie myself.
Alright, with less than an hour left, I think it's safe to say my fate is sealed.
Before I'm led to the gallows, I'd like to apologize if I came off as unnecessarily cross or unreasonable with you people. The truth of the matter is that I was just upset to have been found out so soon, especially given the circumstances.
Yes, the truth is that I am mafia and that Delmain did break the tie specifically to save me. The reason he did this is because I'd forgotten to do so myself and, knowing I would be gone for the remainder of the day, he felt he had no recourse but to cast a vote for Loser on my behalf. Naturally, if he'd known this would lead to my exposure on the next day, he'd have elected to let one of our teammates do the job instead. Unfortunately, things unfolded as they did, and so we find ourselves two days into the game with two players down and severely reduced odds of winning.
Foolish as I am, I thought I could talk myself into safety by misrepresenting my blunder as evidence of apathy and, consequently, innocence. In retrospect, I can see why none of you bought such an obvious fabrication. I've clearly overestimated my ability to lie and, more egregiously, underestimated your insight and cunning (particularly yours, Dunadan).
In closing, I just want to praise you all for a game well-played. It may be a bit premature to congratulate you for a total victory as well, but I'm sure that's soon to come nonetheless.
Well, I'm just trying to gracious in defeat. No need for hard feelings, especially given the tendency of hostility to carry over from one game to the next.
In the end, you just have to remember that it's about having fun, you know?
Well, I'm just trying to gracious in defeat. No need for hard feelings, especially given the tendency of hostility to carry over from one game to the next.
In the end, you just have to remember that it's about having fun, you know?
No it's not. It's about bringing as many people pain as you can.
Well, I'm just trying to gracious in defeat. No need for hard feelings, especially given the tendency of hostility to carry over from one game to the next.
In the end, you just have to remember that it's about having fun, you know?
No it's not. It's about bringing as many people pain as you can.
you are a good apprentice, one day you shall rule from my throne.
Well, I'm just trying to gracious in defeat. No need for hard feelings, especially given the tendency of hostility to carry over from one game to the next.
In the end, you just have to remember that it's about having fun, you know?
No it's not. It's about bringing as many people pain as you can.
Naw, I don't believe that. Even if we're not on the same side, it doesn't mean I can't appreciate the skill of the opposing team. Mafia or villager, win or lose, we're all just doing what we can to enrich the experience for everyone.
Well, I'm just trying to gracious in defeat. No need for hard feelings, especially given the tendency of hostility to carry over from one game to the next.
In the end, you just have to remember that it's about having fun, you know?
No it's not. It's about bringing as many people pain as you can.
Naw, I don't believe that. Even if we're not on the same side, it doesn't mean I can't appreciate the skill of the opposing team. Mafia or villager, win or lose, we're all just doing what we can to enrich the experience for everyone.
How can I resent that?
Win, lose, mafia, villager? None of that has to do with what I said! You can torment other people in all situations!
Well, I'm just trying to gracious in defeat. No need for hard feelings, especially given the tendency of hostility to carry over from one game to the next.
In the end, you just have to remember that it's about having fun, you know?
No it's not. It's about bringing as many people pain as you can.
Naw, I don't believe that. Even if we're not on the same side, it doesn't mean I can't appreciate the skill of the opposing team. Mafia or villager, win or lose, we're all just doing what we can to enrich the experience for everyone.
How can I resent that?
I apologize if my enrichment got in your hair. that happens every now and then.
Well, I'm just trying to gracious in defeat. No need for hard feelings, especially given the tendency of hostility to carry over from one game to the next.
In the end, you just have to remember that it's about having fun, you know?
No it's not. It's about bringing as many people pain as you can.
Naw, I don't believe that. Even if we're not on the same side, it doesn't mean I can't appreciate the skill of the opposing team. Mafia or villager, win or lose, we're all just doing what we can to enrich the experience for everyone.
How can I resent that?
Win, lose, mafia, villager? None of that has to do with what I said! You can torment other people in all situations!
Well, I'm just trying to gracious in defeat. No need for hard feelings, especially given the tendency of hostility to carry over from one game to the next.
In the end, you just have to remember that it's about having fun, you know?
No it's not. It's about bringing as many people pain as you can.
Naw, I don't believe that. Even if we're not on the same side, it doesn't mean I can't appreciate the skill of the opposing team. Mafia or villager, win or lose, we're all just doing what we can to enrich the experience for everyone.
How can I resent that?
I apologize if my enrichment got in your hair. that happens every now and then.
That explains the newfound shine and bounce that's made me the talk of the secretarial pool.
Well, I'm just trying to gracious in defeat. No need for hard feelings, especially given the tendency of hostility to carry over from one game to the next.
In the end, you just have to remember that it's about having fun, you know?
No it's not. It's about bringing as many people pain as you can.
Naw, I don't believe that. Even if we're not on the same side, it doesn't mean I can't appreciate the skill of the opposing team. Mafia or villager, win or lose, we're all just doing what we can to enrich the experience for everyone.
How can I resent that?
I apologize if my enrichment got in your hair. that happens every now and then.
That explains the newfound shine and bounce that's made me the talk of the secretarial pool.
Posts
I can see why the others thought it was weird that you were offering an actual reason for voting me out. I'm not going to say you're mafia because I think I'm just rationalizing a hunch rather than looking at things rationally, but I would expect the villagers to look back on this and wonder if you didn't choose to lay out a logical reason to avoid having people turn on you on Day 3. To a mafia, who of course knows I'm not mafia, this would be treated as an inevitability rather than a mere possibility. Villagers, on the other hand, generally act a bit more self-assured and less obligated to defend themselves (I imagine this is because confidence reaffirms their correctness to themselves).
There's certainly a stark contrast between your treatment of me today and how you acted in Mario Kart.
Also, as for the suspicious nature of Delmain's vote, I feel that's quite dealt with by the fact that I could have (and, as a mafia, would have been obligated to) break the tie myself.
https://twitter.com/Hooraydiation
I think you may be the anti-Dunadan.
overly wordy and always wrong.
You're on that list twice
I'm not on the list because I am perfect and kind and nice and no one ever suspects me!
MUAHAHAHAHA!
.... I feel like my two remarks here contradict themselves almost....
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Before I'm led to the gallows, I'd like to apologize if I came off as unnecessarily cross or unreasonable with you people. The truth of the matter is that I was just upset to have been found out so soon, especially given the circumstances.
Yes, the truth is that I am mafia and that Delmain did break the tie specifically to save me. The reason he did this is because I'd forgotten to do so myself and, knowing I would be gone for the remainder of the day, he felt he had no recourse but to cast a vote for Loser on my behalf. Naturally, if he'd known this would lead to my exposure on the next day, he'd have elected to let one of our teammates do the job instead. Unfortunately, things unfolded as they did, and so we find ourselves two days into the game with two players down and severely reduced odds of winning.
Foolish as I am, I thought I could talk myself into safety by misrepresenting my blunder as evidence of apathy and, consequently, innocence. In retrospect, I can see why none of you bought such an obvious fabrication. I've clearly overestimated my ability to lie and, more egregiously, underestimated your insight and cunning (particularly yours, Dunadan).
In closing, I just want to praise you all for a game well-played. It may be a bit premature to congratulate you for a total victory as well, but I'm sure that's soon to come nonetheless.
https://twitter.com/Hooraydiation
So Robos! I guess
Play better. :P
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Yeah, looks like I really dropped the ball again! At least this time it's a mistake that helped the village, though it's hurting me in the process.
https://twitter.com/Hooraydiation
I wouldn't know. :whistle:
https://twitter.com/Hooraydiation
I have 40 minutes left which means I can get in about 75 posts....
time to get crackin?
In the end, you just have to remember that it's about having fun, you know?
https://twitter.com/Hooraydiation
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
you are a good apprentice, one day you shall rule from my throne.
yeah, but he's dead tomorrow, remember?
I'm dying tonight, didn't u get the memo?
You are? pfft, no you aren't, I'm the secret guard and I'm guarding you.
But.... but that still doesn't make it jdark's fault
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Naw, I don't believe that. Even if we're not on the same side, it doesn't mean I can't appreciate the skill of the opposing team. Mafia or villager, win or lose, we're all just doing what we can to enrich the experience for everyone.
How can I resent that?
https://twitter.com/Hooraydiation
dumb guard! go guard the vig.
Win, lose, mafia, villager? None of that has to do with what I said! You can torment other people in all situations!
But I trust you, Duny!
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
I apologize if my enrichment got in your hair. that happens every now and then.
and I trust the revealed vig!
ergo.....
That explains the newfound shine and bounce that's made me the talk of the secretarial pool.
Enrichment, a new conditioner from Dunadan.
https://twitter.com/Hooraydiation
che-magnifique
You must reveal all the mafia like you do after the game ends with your mighty intuition.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
when have I done that?
I always point back to when I revealed them inthread.
and If I reveal them before vote close then that does NO good.
I aspire one day to be triple killed.