Is there someone out there with more stable internet than I have right now that would mind quoting/analyzing Exarch's posts, that would be helpful.
Not a whole lot to work with, unfortunately. He made a grand total of four posts in this thread, and that's including his sign-up post. Two votes: Chamberlain on day 1, Trueneverborn yesterday, and a late day 1 post saying something like "lots of activity for a day 1, could be useful later". About all I think we can take from his body of work is that TNB is _probably_ village-aligned. (still being dumb, though)
Hum. Still not feeling strongly about anyone just yet, gonna go with Trueneverborn for lack of better ideas.
Not a lot of content to those posts. Basically only have the vote history to look at. He was the only one to vote for Chamberlain on day 1 and Chamberlain died to the mafia that night. He joined the TrueNeverborn wagon on day 2. Other players who joined that bandwagon:
Anialos
Bluecyan
enlightenedbum
Megafrost (<-- I know that person!)
romanqwerty
Smoove Operator
There has been lots of speculation on Anialos already. Not sure what to think of Bluecyan and enlightenedbum. I voted TrueNeverborn primarily in protest to the Retaba vote, take that as you will. Romanqwerty and Smoove Operator have been consistently voting for TrueNeverborn each day. Doing this on day 1 isn't too weird, but days 2 & 3 they have continued to vote for him with the only explanation being that they did so the previous day.
0
Options
38thDoelets never be stupid againwait lets always be stupid foreverRegistered Userregular
Its been a while since I've seen defenestration in a phalla.
Where did sportz try and infiltrate the network?? In a pm?
I'm just sitting here shaking my head as villagers insist on wasting their vote. Oh well!
To be fair, yov are also talking abovt shaking yovr head. This is an additional thing. It mvst be covnted. Everything mvst be covnted.
(I typed an e-mail at work today and withovt even thinking, swapped the v into words. Help me)
I'm just going to throw out that my secret, which turned out to be a vig kill, was wasted on someone the mafia killed. If I was mafia, I wouldn't have done that.
I'm going with Anialos based on the analysis provided by spool.
I'm just sitting here shaking my head as villagers insist on wasting their vote. Oh well!
Anialos. Give us an impassioned defense.
Or post less frequently so I can eat you.
Nah, no impassioned defense. Just point out that spool's analysis of me missed a post, and let it go. My power was used to give us a Kime overlord, my work is done. If the village wants me dead, so be it.
I agree with you Mr.T, but the next two highest voted options are Mill, who is in a similar predicament as Anialos and the other is me, who is me. Do you have some reason for picking Lucedes?
I'm just going to throw out that my secret, which turned out to be a vig kill, was wasted on someone the mafia killed. If I was mafia, I wouldn't have done that.
I'm going with Anialos based on the analysis provided by spool.
I don't think that is necessarily true. The mafia could very well have used that as a safe way to test out the mechanic itself.
All you would have needed was some kind of clarification about the order of actions or that the mafia kill could stack with powers.
We cannot gain any insight into your mafia-ness from that action.
I do however mostly agree with you that it would not be an ideal mafia play... You are less on my watch list than others are.
Mafia wouldn't use one-shot powers blindly.
Mafia also wouldn't use a public seering on a green.
=> Anialos is a bad vote.
This isn't necessarily true. It is unlikely that ANYONE would have known that the public seer would also reveal the person who used the secret. That could have been an unwelcomed surprise for the mafia.
I'm not saying anialos is mafia or not (i'm frankly on the fence about it.... i think others are more suspicious and a better vote). Just don't get into such a black and white way of thinking as to what the mafia might think is a good idea.
I agree with you Mr.T, but the next two highest voted options are Mill, who is in a similar predicament as Anialos and the other is me, who is me. Do you have some reason for picking Lucedes?
Lucedes vote is because they posted 3 nonsenses posts in a row, one of which was a vote without reasoning... right after we were talking about how we should give reasoning for our votes.
I took it to be more of an ironic/silly post than something that was seriously suspicious. But you know... my vote is still on you... so... kinda awkward because I still think votes on you are way better than any other alternative right now...
I agree with you Mr.T, but the next two highest voted options are Mill, who is in a similar predicament as Anialos and the other is me, who is me. Do you have some reason for picking Lucedes?
Lucedes vote is because they posted 3 nonsenses posts in a row, one of which was a vote without reasoning... right after we were talking about how we should give reasoning for our votes.
I took it to be more of an ironic/silly post than something that was seriously suspicious. But you know... my vote is still on you... so... kinda awkward because I still think votes on you are way better than any other alternative right now...
Hey, no worries, I've had orange soda on me before, it stains a little but I'll survive. At least you have have a valid reason for your vote.
Its been a while since I've seen defenestration in a phalla.
Where did sportz try and infiltrate the network?? In a pm?
This was in relation to an exchange that was occurring very early in the day with kime where he subtly added a "me too" into it after kime asked Infidel to get in touch. It was subtle, but I took it as his way of saying "let me in the network" without his being confirmed. Will quote shortly...
I don't like the anialos vote at all either. The reasons for voting for him at the moment are silly. If we are all insisting that we must pick from that short list of players involved in that specific time frame of the bandwagon, my choice from the list is going to be Mill. Yes, Mill already used up the fancy secret power and it happened to hit on a target the mafia were already killing. Mill's defense was that if he was mafia he wouldn't have wasted his secret on a target he knew was dying, but I can see where testing the secret that way could be beneficial. We had no way of knowing what those secrets would do Day 1, and testing it on somebody who would be shortly removed could be useful over testing it on someone and have the chance they'd still be around as a link back to you.
"The psychedelic mind is a higher dimensional mind, it is not fit for three dimensional space time."
- Terence McKenna
Posts
// Switch: SW-5306-0651-6424 //
Trying this again. I believe there's at least one mafia in that three-person Infidel wagon.
// Switch: SW-5306-0651-6424 //
Henri Emmanuel Gratien St Pierre in Where No Man Has Gone Before
Lord Augustus Cumberbatch in Eclipse Phase
Not a whole lot to work with, unfortunately. He made a grand total of four posts in this thread, and that's including his sign-up post. Two votes: Chamberlain on day 1, Trueneverborn yesterday, and a late day 1 post saying something like "lots of activity for a day 1, could be useful later". About all I think we can take from his body of work is that TNB is _probably_ village-aligned. (still being dumb, though)
Not a lot of content to those posts. Basically only have the vote history to look at. He was the only one to vote for Chamberlain on day 1 and Chamberlain died to the mafia that night. He joined the TrueNeverborn wagon on day 2. Other players who joined that bandwagon:
Anialos
Bluecyan
enlightenedbum
Megafrost (<-- I know that person!)
romanqwerty
Smoove Operator
There has been lots of speculation on Anialos already. Not sure what to think of Bluecyan and enlightenedbum. I voted TrueNeverborn primarily in protest to the Retaba vote, take that as you will. Romanqwerty and Smoove Operator have been consistently voting for TrueNeverborn each day. Doing this on day 1 isn't too weird, but days 2 & 3 they have continued to vote for him with the only explanation being that they did so the previous day.
Where did sportz try and infiltrate the network?? In a pm?
Perhaps someone sent him a link to the proboards and he pvt in an application?
anyhow i'm going to change my vote now for Warban
Steam
- Terence McKenna
No, I haven't done that.
TylerJ on League of Legends (it's free and fun!)
Indeed.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
the specialest!?
To be fair, yov are also talking abovt shaking yovr head. This is an additional thing. It mvst be covnted. Everything mvst be covnted.
(I typed an e-mail at work today and withovt even thinking, swapped the v into words. Help me)
I'm going with Anialos based on the analysis provided by spool.
battletag: Millin#1360
Nice chart to figure out how honest a news source is.
Anialos. Give us an impassioned defense.
Or post less frequently so I can eat you.
TylerJ on League of Legends (it's free and fun!)
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Nah, no impassioned defense. Just point out that spool's analysis of me missed a post, and let it go. My power was used to give us a Kime overlord, my work is done. If the village wants me dead, so be it.
I don't think I've voted.
Lucedes
Mafia wouldn't use one-shot powers blindly.
Mafia also wouldn't use a public seering on a green.
=> Anialos is a bad vote.
Sorry, wouldn't normally, but I need to make sure I vote. And, honestly, it's a bit early. And my vote will have too much influence.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
They may, to see what happens. Especially when he didn't know it would be a public seering.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Is this a network call?
Yes Spool, I am very proud of you. You are among my favoritest of people right now.
I don't think that is necessarily true. The mafia could very well have used that as a safe way to test out the mechanic itself.
All you would have needed was some kind of clarification about the order of actions or that the mafia kill could stack with powers.
We cannot gain any insight into your mafia-ness from that action.
I do however mostly agree with you that it would not be an ideal mafia play... You are less on my watch list than others are.
This isn't necessarily true. It is unlikely that ANYONE would have known that the public seer would also reveal the person who used the secret. That could have been an unwelcomed surprise for the mafia.
I'm not saying anialos is mafia or not (i'm frankly on the fence about it.... i think others are more suspicious and a better vote). Just don't get into such a black and white way of thinking as to what the mafia might think is a good idea.
I loved that BW.
Lucedes
The Black Hole of Cygnus X-1
Especially when they can use the abilities to prohibit them from village use later when the village is more organized.
It's just not happening.
I have no real reasoning on Lucedes except that I saw a few votes on her (?)
Lucedes vote is because they posted 3 nonsenses posts in a row, one of which was a vote without reasoning... right after we were talking about how we should give reasoning for our votes.
I took it to be more of an ironic/silly post than something that was seriously suspicious. But you know... my vote is still on you... so... kinda awkward because I still think votes on you are way better than any other alternative right now...
No more, I searched through my PMs. You all suck at reminding me of things though.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
The Black Hole of Cygnus X-1
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Hey, no worries, I've had orange soda on me before, it stains a little but I'll survive. At least you have have a valid reason for your vote.
This was in relation to an exchange that was occurring very early in the day with kime where he subtly added a "me too" into it after kime asked Infidel to get in touch. It was subtle, but I took it as his way of saying "let me in the network" without his being confirmed. Will quote shortly...
- Terence McKenna