My guess is: everyone submits an order of some kind. Hunter picks a target. The target(s?) the hunter picks gets the action performed on them.
So maybe we say seer and hunter picks "everyone" but mafia has ability to change seer to vig and then...
My guess is: everyone submits an order of some kind. Hunter picks a target. The target(s?) the hunter picks gets the action performed on them.
So maybe we say seer and hunter picks "everyone" but mafia has ability to change seer to vig and then...
You are assuming that the hunter is a person and not just a mechanic. I think that we should be very specific with the order that we send in for the hunter, that they should include the target and the action, and that our choices should be announced publicly.
You are assuming that the hunter is a person and not just a mechanic. I think that we should be very specific with the order that we send in for the hunter, that they should include the target and the action, and that our choices should be announced publicly.
If we are specific with a seer target - wouldn't the mafia just off that target?
Gizzy on
Switch Animal Crossing Friend Code: SW-5107-9276-1030
Island Name: Felinefine
You are assuming that the hunter is a person and not just a mechanic. I think that we should be very specific with the order that we send in for the hunter, that they should include the target and the action, and that our choices should be announced publicly.
If we are specific with a seer target - wouldn't the mafia just off that target?
I see your point, as I assume the result of the hunter's actions will be announced publicly.
You are assuming that the hunter is a person and not just a mechanic. I think that we should be very specific with the order that we send in for the hunter, that they should include the target and the action, and that our choices should be announced publicly.
If we are specific with a seer target - wouldn't the mafia just off that target?
I see your point, as I assume the result of the hunter's actions will be announced publicly.
You are assuming that the hunter is a person and not just a mechanic. I think that we should be very specific with the order that we send in for the hunter, that they should include the target and the action, and that our choices should be announced publicly.
If we are specific with a seer target - wouldn't the mafia just off that target?
I see your point, as I assume the result of the hunter's actions will be announced publicly.
Why?
Because the regular vote results are posted in the thread. This is just another vote.
We could test this theory. Do you volunteer?
+1
Options
MamaWolfThe wolf pack guides all to safetyRegistered Userregular
Notice he didn't actually say no to bringing people back to life, just refused to clarify. Not sure it's worth risking a full vote to find out though, especially since that won't be helpful until lots of people are dead.
Grudge vote on H3Knuckles for his repeated attempts to kill me last game.
You are assuming that the hunter is a person and not just a mechanic. I think that we should be very specific with the order that we send in for the hunter, that they should include the target and the action, and that our choices should be announced publicly.
If we are specific with a seer target - wouldn't the mafia just off that target?
I see your point, as I assume the result of the hunter's actions will be announced publicly.
Why?
Because the regular vote results are posted in the thread. This is just another vote.
We could test this theory. Do you volunteer?
This is specifically a private vote that determines a special's action. Special actions are normally not public. I see no evidence why this would be.
Are we talking public as in, would appear in the narration?
I don't see why it'd appear there unless it was a kill. If we all vote seer, the Hunter should get the results privately and then it's up to them to share with the crowd.
You are assuming that the hunter is a person and not just a mechanic. I think that we should be very specific with the order that we send in for the hunter, that they should include the target and the action, and that our choices should be announced publicly.
If we are specific with a seer target - wouldn't the mafia just off that target?
I see your point, as I assume the result of the hunter's actions will be announced publicly.
Why?
Because the regular vote results are posted in the thread. This is just another vote.
We could test this theory. Do you volunteer?
I do! Feel free to aim the Hunter at me so we can find out what happens as far as targeting.
Good morning guys. Just getting my bearings here. Gonna put out a provisional vote for !Preda, since I'm still harboring a grudge. I reserve the right to change my mind.
Yeah it'd be super helpful to know whether the hunter is a player, because it changes how we word our power vote (as in do we also need to specify a target).
I'm going to vote public seer. Same as normal seer but the target is revealed in the narrative rather than via PM. Seems a fair comprimise over Kime's omniseer idea and normal seer.
How flexible are you with aggregating action votes?
Say A votes for "self-sacrificing guard," B votes for "guard," C votes for "normal guard," D votes for "perfect guard (even protects from vote)," E votes for "guard who can guard two people each night," and F votes for "guard who automatically targets the mafia kill target." What would be the vote counts in this case?
Hmmmm, the only grudge I can think of is Preda from the Bloodborne PBP game. Good enough for Day 1.
I like the public seer idea, and I like JDark's suggestion of publicly stating what you're voting for. So for now I'm going to vote Public Seer (results revealed in narration) for the hunter.
I'm not sure how I feel about Aura offering to be the target. That kind of thing usually is frowned upon due to the abundance of shenanigans possible (bus drivers for example).
Some other cool power ideas: Find out how many mafia voted for the vote winner (or second place or whatever). Find out how many mafia received votes that day... stuff like that.
Also, just got a CD on the question about death/narration results being reliable so.... yeah.
0
Options
AuralynxDarkness is a perspectiveWatching the ego workRegistered Userregular
Hmmmm, the only grudge I can think of is Preda from the Bloodborne PBP game. Good enough for Day 1.
I like the public seer idea, and I like JDark's suggestion of publicly stating what you're voting for. So for now I'm going to vote Public Seer (results revealed in narration) for the hunter.
I'm not sure how I feel about Aura offering to be the target. That kind of thing usually is frowned upon due to the abundance of shenanigans possible (bus drivers for example).
Some other cool power ideas: Find out how many mafia voted for the vote winner (or second place or whatever). Find out how many mafia received votes that day... stuff like that.
Also, just got a CD on the question about death/narration results being reliable so.... yeah.
It's my assumption that it won't end up mattering if I volunteered or not, to be honest, but if we decide we want a public target I'm game to be that guy.
How flexible are you with aggregating action votes?
Say A votes for "self-sacrificing guard," B votes for "guard," C votes for "normal guard," D votes for "perfect guard (even protects from vote)," E votes for "guard who can guard two people each night," and F votes for "guard who automatically targets the mafia kill target." What would be the vote counts in this case?
Posts
That's a double trust thing isn't it? We trust you aren't mafia, and the Hunter themselves has to trust it too?
So maybe we say seer and hunter picks "everyone" but mafia has ability to change seer to vig and then...
Island Name: Felinefine
Discrider
Island Name: Felinefine
You are assuming that the hunter is a person and not just a mechanic. I think that we should be very specific with the order that we send in for the hunter, that they should include the target and the action, and that our choices should be announced publicly.
If possible, we should do some sort of seering power. Like the second place red vote gets revealed if they're mafia.
Penny Arcade Rockstar Social Club / This is why I despise cyclists
If we are specific with a seer target - wouldn't the mafia just off that target?
Island Name: Felinefine
I see your point, as I assume the result of the hunter's actions will be announced publicly.
Why?
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Because the regular vote results are posted in the thread. This is just another vote.
We could test this theory. Do you volunteer?
Awww, I think we could get along fine Gizzy
Doe said to assume nothing.
The Monster Baru Cormorant - Seth Dickinson
Steam: Korvalain
Grudge vote on H3Knuckles for his repeated attempts to kill me last game.
premium then
This is specifically a private vote that determines a special's action. Special actions are normally not public. I see no evidence why this would be.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
I don't see why it'd appear there unless it was a kill. If we all vote seer, the Hunter should get the results privately and then it's up to them to share with the crowd.
This is an excellent proposal.
Is the hunter a player role?
I do! Feel free to aim the Hunter at me so we can find out what happens as far as targeting.
Also AHAVAAAAAA
Confusion will be my epitaph
Good question. I've been assuming it was, so I wasn't assuming they would share any results.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Awww, I think we could get along fine Gizzy
Or is everyone just doing Seer day 1?
Also, Kime as revenge for the last Phalla.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
So the mafia must be... Wolves.
mamawolf, the evidence is overwhelming.
3DS: 1289-8447-4695
Say A votes for "self-sacrificing guard," B votes for "guard," C votes for "normal guard," D votes for "perfect guard (even protects from vote)," E votes for "guard who can guard two people each night," and F votes for "guard who automatically targets the mafia kill target." What would be the vote counts in this case?
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
I like the public seer idea, and I like JDark's suggestion of publicly stating what you're voting for. So for now I'm going to vote Public Seer (results revealed in narration) for the hunter.
I'm not sure how I feel about Aura offering to be the target. That kind of thing usually is frowned upon due to the abundance of shenanigans possible (bus drivers for example).
Some other cool power ideas: Find out how many mafia voted for the vote winner (or second place or whatever). Find out how many mafia received votes that day... stuff like that.
Also, just got a CD on the question about death/narration results being reliable so.... yeah.
It's my assumption that it won't end up mattering if I volunteered or not, to be honest, but if we decide we want a public target I'm game to be that guy.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Clarification Denied.
I'm going to say it depends and then CD followups.
I will do my best to be flexible. CD.
Expecting me to read pffft
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
You admitted to reading the OP. We're on to you.