Alpha Day 1.1 - 330AD - Brody(O), Psycho(R), Wildcat(P) - State stayed at A, Brody claims successful P/R conflict here. Assumes no lies from Brody.
Beta Day 2 - 1492 - EB, Kuhl, Wildcat - State switched from A --> B. Originally I was going to observe, EB supposedly locked in preserve. Wildcat was in sleepy town, so I switched to reverse right before close. Wildcat confirms P/R conflict here. If wildcat is willing to use their child as way to mask a lie here... hats off, I like the style.
Beta Day 3 - 1492 again - EB, Wildcat, Brody - All were supposed to Preserve, instead we got an anomaly. If anything, this makes me more suspicious of Brody, because the previous night was much more ripe for opportunity to screw something up for Wildcat. Instead, we have 2 nights in a row where EB and wildcat are in the same group with a different 3rd person, and the results are significantly different.
If we were going to switch out wildcat with someone else, I would prefer it not be brody if I'm being honest. Burnage is the other name on the list I feel okay about, but activity level is lower than I would prefer. This is generally the case across the board, unfortunately.
Okay, finally caught up. Egos seems like a safe bet. psychocucumber, 1977. This is really starting to feel like a make or break day. We had to be close for the mafia to start acting as blatantly as they have been.
I'm a little wary of Brody still, due to his voting being rather shrewd. Think it was day 2 when he voted for himself but downplayed his "only vote" when it was actively putting him on the team. He seems to be paying more attention than to not know that his vote is counting, and he's been on a suspicious team.
Basically, downplaying his moves to put himself on teams.
0
Options
BrodyThe WatchThe First ShoreRegistered Userregular
Alpha Day 1.1 - 330AD - Brody(O), Psycho(R), Wildcat(P) - State stayed at A, Brody claims successful P/R conflict here. Assumes no lies from Brody.
Beta Day 2 - 1492 - EB, Kuhl, Wildcat - State switched from A --> B. Originally I was going to observe, EB supposedly locked in preserve. Wildcat was in sleepy town, so I switched to reverse right before close. Wildcat confirms P/R conflict here. If wildcat is willing to use their child as way to mask a lie here... hats off, I like the style.
Beta Day 3 - 1492 again - EB, Wildcat, Brody - All were supposed to Preserve, instead we got an anomaly. If anything, this makes me more suspicious of Brody, because the previous night was much more ripe for opportunity to screw something up for Wildcat. Instead, we have 2 nights in a row where EB and wildcat are in the same group with a different 3rd person, and the results are significantly different.
If we were going to switch out wildcat with someone else, I would prefer it not be brody if I'm being honest. Burnage is the other name on the list I feel okay about, but activity level is lower than I would prefer. This is generally the case across the board, unfortunately.
If I wanted to screw up last night, why wouldn't I have waited for Wildcat to place his wrong order and leave before asking clarification in thread?
"I will write your name in the ruin of them. I will paint you across history in the color of their blood."
I'm a little wary of Brody still, due to his voting being rather shrewd. Think it was day 2 when he voted for himself but downplayed his "only vote" when it was actively putting him on the team. He seems to be paying more attention than to not know that his vote is counting, and he's been on a suspicious team.
Basically, downplaying his moves to put himself on teams.
I've only gotten on a team once via voting. Last night I was placed on the team because not enough votes were made.
I'll admit that I probably should have made a vote for the mission, and likely didn't, but then if it were important to me to end up on that mission, why wouldn't I have voted myself for the mission, guaranteeing a spot?
"I will write your name in the ruin of them. I will paint you across history in the color of their blood."
Alpha Day 1.1 - 330AD - Brody(O), Psycho(R), Wildcat(P) - State stayed at A, Brody claims successful P/R conflict here. Assumes no lies from Brody.
Beta Day 2 - 1492 - EB, Kuhl, Wildcat - State switched from A --> B. Originally I was going to observe, EB supposedly locked in preserve. Wildcat was in sleepy town, so I switched to reverse right before close. Wildcat confirms P/R conflict here. If wildcat is willing to use their child as way to mask a lie here... hats off, I like the style.
Beta Day 3 - 1492 again - EB, Wildcat, Brody - All were supposed to Preserve, instead we got an anomaly. If anything, this makes me more suspicious of Brody, because the previous night was much more ripe for opportunity to screw something up for Wildcat. Instead, we have 2 nights in a row where EB and wildcat are in the same group with a different 3rd person, and the results are significantly different.
If we were going to switch out wildcat with someone else, I would prefer it not be brody if I'm being honest. Burnage is the other name on the list I feel okay about, but activity level is lower than I would prefer. This is generally the case across the board, unfortunately.
Using these teams, it doesn't make me feel good about ebum at all. Day 2 looks like a "I'll just play along and hide" for mafia, while Day 3 looks like a "oh crap, they could win the game tonight" play.
It doesn't prove anything with Brody, but I wouldn't discount ebum's presence that quickly just because the results were different. Desperation was likely hitting the mafia last night because if we had aligned everything without that anomaly, we should have won. They HAD to do something.
Alpha Day 1.1 - 330AD - Brody(O), Psycho(R), Wildcat(P) - State stayed at A, Brody claims successful P/R conflict here. Assumes no lies from Brody.
Beta Day 2 - 1492 - EB, Kuhl, Wildcat - State switched from A --> B. Originally I was going to observe, EB supposedly locked in preserve. Wildcat was in sleepy town, so I switched to reverse right before close. Wildcat confirms P/R conflict here. If wildcat is willing to use their child as way to mask a lie here... hats off, I like the style.
Beta Day 3 - 1492 again - EB, Wildcat, Brody - All were supposed to Preserve, instead we got an anomaly. If anything, this makes me more suspicious of Brody, because the previous night was much more ripe for opportunity to screw something up for Wildcat. Instead, we have 2 nights in a row where EB and wildcat are in the same group with a different 3rd person, and the results are significantly different.
If we were going to switch out wildcat with someone else, I would prefer it not be brody if I'm being honest. Burnage is the other name on the list I feel okay about, but activity level is lower than I would prefer. This is generally the case across the board, unfortunately.
Using these teams, it doesn't make me feel good about ebum at all. Day 2 looks like a "I'll just play along and hide" for mafia, while Day 3 looks like a "oh crap, they could win the game tonight" play.
It doesn't prove anything with Brody, but I wouldn't discount ebum's presence that quickly just because the results were different. Desperation was likely hitting the mafia last night because if we had aligned everything without that anomaly, we should have won. They HAD to do something.
I also agree. There's a reason ebum wasn't on my earlier list.
PSN: the-K-flash
0
Options
BrodyThe WatchThe First ShoreRegistered Userregular
Ebum ended up on last nights team due to a single vote from Austin.
Can we get enough teams w/o using,
Egos, Ebum, Wildcat, Me, Austin?
"I will write your name in the ruin of them. I will paint you across history in the color of their blood."
Don't get me wrong, if I had a preference, I wouldn't put Brody or ebum on a team. But, we have a limited number of people who have been active past just voting each day, so I can't bring myself to vote for any of them really.
If 330 AD gets screwed up, then I feel like it'll just point to Brody as mafia, so maybe worth it to send him as a means of forced validation.
0
Options
BrodyThe WatchThe First ShoreRegistered Userregular
I guess Austin is already going anyways.
"I will write your name in the ruin of them. I will paint you across history in the color of their blood."
Don't get me wrong, if I had a preference, I wouldn't put Brody or ebum on a team. But, we have a limited number of people who have been active past just voting each day, so I can't bring myself to vote for any of them really.
If 330 AD gets screwed up, then I feel like it'll just point to Brody as mafia, so maybe worth it to send him as a means of forced validation.
Yes the lack of activity makes it tough. There's 4 or 5 people on my unknowns list have voted for teams once or never.
So either
1) The final solution is
100,000,000 - A
480 BC - B
330AD - A
1492 - ? claimed B by me
1765 - (B)
1789 - B
1861 - (B)
1939 - (A)
1959 - (A)
1977 - (B)
Or 2) there is a mafia within the set of {brody, infidel, mrpaku}
Currently deviating from this:
1765 is A/B due to anomaly and needs to be restored to B.
0
Options
BrodyThe WatchThe First ShoreRegistered Userregular
I think Kuhlmeye posted the same thing near the bottom of last page.
"I will write your name in the ruin of them. I will paint you across history in the color of their blood."
Let's see if we can still get more info though. Wildcat on gamma could identify if Wildcat is the problem amongst that group (even though it seems unlikely)
Minor announcement, due to unforeseen events Hosts will be temporarily unavailable until later tonight. I may be able to get on to announce vote ends but not team selection information. The Day's recap post will be delayed by hours.
Beta Day 2 - 1492 - EB, Kuhl, Wildcat - State switched from A --> B. Originally I was going to observe, EB supposedly locked in preserve. Wildcat was in sleepy town, so I switched to reverse right before close. Wildcat confirms P/R conflict here. If wildcat is willing to use their child as way to mask a lie here... hats off, I like the style.
I definitely locked in preserve. I think Brody is the weak link and should not be sent on teams, though obviously I understand if y'all are leery about me.
Self-righteousness is incompatible with coalition building.
Beta Day 2 - 1492 - EB, Kuhl, Wildcat - State switched from A --> B. Originally I was going to observe, EB supposedly locked in preserve. Wildcat was in sleepy town, so I switched to reverse right before close. Wildcat confirms P/R conflict here. If wildcat is willing to use their child as way to mask a lie here... hats off, I like the style.
I definitely locked in preserve. I think Brody is the weak link and should not be sent on teams, though obviously I understand if y'all are leery about me.
I dunno. First half of day one, I was on team alpha with both Brody and Wildcat. It could have been just mafia laying low, but it doesn't seem like there were any shenanigans. That makes me lean more towards ebum as the problem there. Of course, none of us are confirmed, so take it with a grain of salt. This is all just feelings and baseless speculation.
Yes, and Gamma should be safe unless there are two mafia. A single mafia cannot defeat the rest Preserving, they can only create an Anomaly, but that isn't an option in 1977.
Posts
Alpha Day 1.1 - 330AD - Brody(O), Psycho(R), Wildcat(P) - State stayed at A, Brody claims successful P/R conflict here. Assumes no lies from Brody.
Beta Day 2 - 1492 - EB, Kuhl, Wildcat - State switched from A --> B. Originally I was going to observe, EB supposedly locked in preserve. Wildcat was in sleepy town, so I switched to reverse right before close. Wildcat confirms P/R conflict here. If wildcat is willing to use their child as way to mask a lie here... hats off, I like the style.
Beta Day 3 - 1492 again - EB, Wildcat, Brody - All were supposed to Preserve, instead we got an anomaly. If anything, this makes me more suspicious of Brody, because the previous night was much more ripe for opportunity to screw something up for Wildcat. Instead, we have 2 nights in a row where EB and wildcat are in the same group with a different 3rd person, and the results are significantly different.
If we were going to switch out wildcat with someone else, I would prefer it not be brody if I'm being honest. Burnage is the other name on the list I feel okay about, but activity level is lower than I would prefer. This is generally the case across the board, unfortunately.
Basically, downplaying his moves to put himself on teams.
If I wanted to screw up last night, why wouldn't I have waited for Wildcat to place his wrong order and leave before asking clarification in thread?
The Monster Baru Cormorant - Seth Dickinson
Steam: Korvalain
I've only gotten on a team once via voting. Last night I was placed on the team because not enough votes were made.
I'll admit that I probably should have made a vote for the mission, and likely didn't, but then if it were important to me to end up on that mission, why wouldn't I have voted myself for the mission, guaranteeing a spot?
The Monster Baru Cormorant - Seth Dickinson
Steam: Korvalain
Using these teams, it doesn't make me feel good about ebum at all. Day 2 looks like a "I'll just play along and hide" for mafia, while Day 3 looks like a "oh crap, they could win the game tonight" play.
It doesn't prove anything with Brody, but I wouldn't discount ebum's presence that quickly just because the results were different. Desperation was likely hitting the mafia last night because if we had aligned everything without that anomaly, we should have won. They HAD to do something.
I also agree. There's a reason ebum wasn't on my earlier list.
Can we get enough teams w/o using,
Egos, Ebum, Wildcat, Me, Austin?
The Monster Baru Cormorant - Seth Dickinson
Steam: Korvalain
If 330 AD gets screwed up, then I feel like it'll just point to Brody as mafia, so maybe worth it to send him as a means of forced validation.
The Monster Baru Cormorant - Seth Dickinson
Steam: Korvalain
The Monster Baru Cormorant - Seth Dickinson
Steam: Korvalain
We can, it's everyone left I think?
Yes the lack of activity makes it tough. There's 4 or 5 people on my unknowns list have voted for teams once or never.
Results to be posted soon
Dunnalist includes her, AustinP0027, and mrpaku for reasons!
@AustinP0027
@Infidel
@kuhlmeye
Time 1492
Currently deviating from this:
The Monster Baru Cormorant - Seth Dickinson
Steam: Korvalain
Can we not make yet another Brody+Wildcat team? That really limits the spread of info and we don't get any info between them if something goes wrong.
Switching from Wildcat to !jdarksun
The Monster Baru Cormorant - Seth Dickinson
Steam: Korvalain
2 Brody
1 jdarksun
Wildcat
The Monster Baru Cormorant - Seth Dickinson
Steam: Korvalain
We apologize and thank you for your understanding
I'd rather have 3 people present to select preserve.
The Monster Baru Cormorant - Seth Dickinson
Steam: Korvalain
You only need one Preserve to foil one mafia.
If two mafia are on the team it doesn't matter much what people select.
Yeah, I guess I got too caught up in preserve only.
The Monster Baru Cormorant - Seth Dickinson
Steam: Korvalain
I definitely locked in preserve. I think Brody is the weak link and should not be sent on teams, though obviously I understand if y'all are leery about me.
Bedlam[/quote]
I dunno. First half of day one, I was on team alpha with both Brody and Wildcat. It could have been just mafia laying low, but it doesn't seem like there were any shenanigans. That makes me lean more towards ebum as the problem there. Of course, none of us are confirmed, so take it with a grain of salt. This is all just feelings and baseless speculation.
Penny Arcade Rockstar Social Club / This is why I despise cyclists
Gamma is setting preserve across the board, too, right?
@Brody
@38thDoe
@jdarksun
330 AD
Edit: Just caught the recent posts, Jdark not Wildcat
The Monster Baru Cormorant - Seth Dickinson
Steam: Korvalain