Did we clear Garick? I'm still not comfortable with his role. A vig contacted him, he called a kill that was a villager and a vig died by mafia hands. I don't think he's mafia, although the possibility exists in my mind. My un-coffee processed thought is that he' a neutral with his own goals.
Did we clear Garick? I'm still not comfortable with his role. A vig contacted him, he called a kill that was a villager and a vig died by mafia hands. I don't think he's mafia, although the possibility exists in my mind. My un-coffee processed thought is that he' a neutral with his own goals.
You might be right, but my suspicions are on roman first right now. Moving into second place would probably be phyphor at this juncture (unless he's the unluckiest guard ever at this point). Garick would probably be #3, tied with a few others.
Doesn't really matter, as I'm probably next on the block if my suspicions are right around Roman (since a lot of others who've suspected him have been mafia'd).
You might be right, but my suspicions are on roman first right now. Moving into second place would probably be phyphor at this juncture (unless he's the unluckiest guard ever at this point). Garick would probably be #3, tied with a few others.
Doesn't really matter, as I'm probably next on the block if my suspicions are right around Roman (since a lot of others who've suspected him have been mafia'd).
Agreed. I'm still on romanqwerty for now. I think phyphor will probably be my vote tomorrow unless something is unearthed tonight.
"The only way to get rid of a temptation is to give into it." - Oscar Wilde
"We believe in the people and their 'wisdom' as if there was some special secret entrance to knowledge that barred to anyone who had ever learned anything." - Friedrich Nietzsche
1) It's somewhat unlikely for a bandwagon to switch from one village special to another (though the list of village specials is growing, we're at like 7 now)
2) Two guards is also somewhat unlikely
3) I got roleblocked and the other guard wasn't on to protect the seer
He claimed he was a guard two days ago and later claimed that he was role blocked (which is why kellie, our seer died). However, last night's kills show that Tipsy was a guard, and multiple guards are not common in vanilla games.
Whether Garick is mafia or not, town drunk's posting obviously showed he supported Garick's plan and then this happened before vote close-
OK... at least 1 vig got in contact with me. I will be calling his kill after vote close. If the other vig who did not contact me could chose someone else to target so they don't waste their kill, that would be great.
/face palm
So, this is just as likely what led to losing our vig as the possibility that Garick is mafia baiting new players.
It seems we have a case of the good, the bad and the ugly, the problem is who is which. Phyphor, Romanqwerty, or Garick.
Here's the thing. There are good reasons for why phyphor and garick are suspicious. But me? I haven't done or claimed anything? The troubling thing is that I think the mafia is keeping me at the forefront in order to have an easy bandwagon when one of my picks dies a villager.
tldr; Villagers, if you're voting me you're the biggest geese.
He claimed he was a guard two days ago and later claimed that he was role blocked (which is why kellie, our seer died). However, last night's kills show that Tipsy was a guard, and multiple guards are not common in vanilla games.
Whether Garick is mafia or not, town drunk's posting obviously showed he supported Garick's plan and then this happened before vote close-
OK... at least 1 vig got in contact with me. I will be calling his kill after vote close. If the other vig who did not contact me could chose someone else to target so they don't waste their kill, that would be great.
/face palm
So, this is just as likely what led to losing our vig as the possibility that Garick is mafia baiting new players.
Unless Garick calls a kill again tonight (or something else surfaces), i'm voting him out tomorrow.
It seems we have a case of the good, the bad and the ugly, the problem is who is which. Phyphor, Romanqwerty, or Garick.
Here's the thing. There are good reasons for why phyphor and garick are suspicious. But me? I haven't done or claimed anything? The troubling thing is that I think the mafia is keeping me at the forefront in order to have an easy bandwagon when one of my picks dies a villager.
tldr; Villagers, if you're voting me you're the biggest geese.
It seems we have a case of the good, the bad and the ugly, the problem is who is which. Phyphor, Romanqwerty, or Garick.
Here's the thing. There are good reasons for why phyphor and garick are suspicious. But me? I haven't done or claimed anything? The troubling thing is that I think the mafia is keeping me at the forefront in order to have an easy bandwagon when one of my picks dies a villager.
tldr; Villagers, if you're voting me you're the biggest geese.
It seems we have a case of the good, the bad and the ugly, the problem is who is which. Phyphor, Romanqwerty, or Garick.
Here's the thing. There are good reasons for why phyphor and garick are suspicious. But me? I haven't done or claimed anything? The troubling thing is that I think the mafia is keeping me at the forefront in order to have an easy bandwagon when one of my picks dies a villager.
tldr; Villagers, if you're voting me you're the biggest geese.
You've just been very quick to point fingers and seize confusing situations, that's all. Now that I see all this though, I may vote Garick though, so you may just be the ugly...
schuss on
0
Options
Sir FabulousMalevolent Squid GodRegistered Userregular
edited January 2011
Phyphor. Everyone ever is the silliest geese for believing his "I got roleblocked" bullshit yesterday. There is no chance in hell that there are two guards in a vanilla game.
Thank you and goodnight.
Garick is not cleared. All he proved was that he was in touch with a vig.
Be careful when you're making assumptions about things that must or must not be a certain way because it's a "vanilla game." There's no hard and fast definition to that. We can safely assume there won't be anything completely out of left field, but it's not like we can say a guard is vanilla and a bus driver is not.
Alright, I was a bit inactive yesterday. But I'm caught up now. Phyphor's story seems way too sketchy.
If he turns out to be mafia, I would believe that Heffling and schuss seem to be encouraging the spread of this roleblock rumor. But I'm also not sure how new they are to phalla. It's also possible that they do not realize they are being influenced by the rumors. If there are multiple seers in the game, they would sound like good targets to me.
What is the order of actions? Do mafia kills take priority over other actions?
From the look of it, Vote -> Guard -> All other actions (mafia kills and vig kills simultaneously).
Alright, I was a bit inactive yesterday. But I'm caught up now. Phyphor's story seems way too sketchy.
If he turns out to be mafia, I would believe that Heffling and schuss seem to be encouraging the spread of this roleblock rumor. But I'm also not sure how new they are to phalla. It's also possible that they do not realize they are being influenced by the rumors. If there are multiple seers in the game, they would sound like good targets to me.
What is the order of actions? Do mafia kills take priority over other actions?
From the look of it, Vote -> Guard -> All other actions (mafia kills and vig kills simultaneously).
I would hope so.
Someone should make a backwards phalla Vig>Guard>vote!
Yeah, I might have gotten a bit carried away on that one, still not 100% sure on what "vanilla" constitutes. Target me if you want, but I assure you it would be a waste of time. I just have a lot of time to kill whilst queries run at work (and thus be posting a lot yo).
Changing to Garick from Roman, as I don't think Roman is a top target today and we all have to make our votes count before there's no one left.
Oh, and obviously i'm not calling a kill anymore because nobody else contacted me. Actually at this point, I don't think there are even any more specials alive that it would matter if they contacted me.
Actually... what i'm curious about is why tipsy didn't guard our seer. Or say anything when another person claimed to be a guard. Guess we can't know cus he is dead but hmm.
Also, care to explain why you think Cow would be a good target Roman? You seem a much better one to me... we would get so much more information from your death.
That or any of the people voting for me... I hate to target new players, but i'm just getting this overwhelming feeling that one of them is, and catching that person would really reveal alot about the other mafia since he is undoubtedly copying their votes.
Last would be Zandra... what's with the no reasoning throwaway votes every day man? I don't think we would learn alot by killing him, but damn if that's not mafia behavior trying to stay as low as possible while not contributing anything.
You seem a much better one to me... we would get so much more information from your death.
Everyone keeps saying this and it's bullshit. What information would we get from my death? I've done nothing but make arguments about things. If I die village, that doesn't mean i was right about my arguments. Same thing if i die mafia, I could (and likely would) be accusing some of my team-mates too.
That or any of the people voting for me... I hate to target new players, but i'm just getting this overwhelming feeling that one of them is, and catching that person would really reveal alot about the other mafia since he is undoubtedly copying their votes.
You're incredibly suspicious and I can't fault anyone for voting you. I'm happy to go into reasons why, but there's too much for this post.
Last would be Zandra... what's with the no reasoning throwaway votes every day man? I don't think we would learn alot by killing him, but damn if that's not mafia behavior trying to stay as low as possible while not contributing anything.
Zandracon always acts like this. Village or mafia. He is almost impossible to read and if we didn't have a huge number of better targets, he'd be a good choice.
Roman... you are far to engrossed in this game to be a normal villager. Since all the other specials are dead that leaves mafia or vig.
Your posts would be entirely unnecessary if you were a vig, and almost all of your posts have been trying to manipulate people.
The mafia would have noticed this too, and either killed you for being a likely special, or... well, hopefully you see now why your death would tell alot.
Posts
Phyphor for now, but I'm afraid the mafia is leading us in the wrong direction.
Did we clear Garick? I'm still not comfortable with his role. A vig contacted him, he called a kill that was a villager and a vig died by mafia hands. I don't think he's mafia, although the possibility exists in my mind. My un-coffee processed thought is that he' a neutral with his own goals.
You might be right, but my suspicions are on roman first right now. Moving into second place would probably be phyphor at this juncture (unless he's the unluckiest guard ever at this point). Garick would probably be #3, tied with a few others.
Doesn't really matter, as I'm probably next on the block if my suspicions are right around Roman (since a lot of others who've suspected him have been mafia'd).
reg rysk
cheez
extermatott
mr. d
Steam
Steam
"We believe in the people and their 'wisdom' as if there was some special secret entrance to knowledge that barred to anyone who had ever learned anything." - Friedrich Nietzsche
2) Two guards is also somewhat unlikely
3) I got roleblocked and the other guard wasn't on to protect the seer
3DS FCode: 1993-7512-8991
He claimed he was a guard two days ago and later claimed that he was role blocked (which is why kellie, our seer died). However, last night's kills show that Tipsy was a guard, and multiple guards are not common in vanilla games.
Whether Garick is mafia or not, town drunk's posting obviously showed he supported Garick's plan and then this happened before vote close-
So, this is just as likely what led to losing our vig as the possibility that Garick is mafia baiting new players.
Here's the thing. There are good reasons for why phyphor and garick are suspicious. But me? I haven't done or claimed anything? The troubling thing is that I think the mafia is keeping me at the forefront in order to have an easy bandwagon when one of my picks dies a villager.
tldr; Villagers, if you're voting me you're the biggest geese.
Unless Garick calls a kill again tonight (or something else surfaces), i'm voting him out tomorrow.
I'm not saying you are bad, you can be ugly. ;-)
I can live with that.....I hope...
You've just been very quick to point fingers and seize confusing situations, that's all. Now that I see all this though, I may vote Garick though, so you may just be the ugly...
Thank you and goodnight.
Geese.
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
ba-caw...
quack...
Wooonk...
What sound does a goose make anyway?
hissss?
There are approximately 5 hours left. Give or take.
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
Garick is not cleared. All he proved was that he was in touch with a vig.
Be careful when you're making assumptions about things that must or must not be a certain way because it's a "vanilla game." There's no hard and fast definition to that. We can safely assume there won't be anything completely out of left field, but it's not like we can say a guard is vanilla and a bus driver is not.
If he turns out to be mafia, I would believe that Heffling and schuss seem to be encouraging the spread of this roleblock rumor. But I'm also not sure how new they are to phalla. It's also possible that they do not realize they are being influenced by the rumors. If there are multiple seers in the game, they would sound like good targets to me.
What is the order of actions? Do mafia kills take priority over other actions?
From the look of it, Vote -> Guard -> All other actions (mafia kills and vig kills simultaneously).
I would hope so.
Someone should make a backwards phalla Vig>Guard>vote!
Actually nevermind
Changing to Garick from Roman, as I don't think Roman is a top target today and we all have to make our votes count before there's no one left.
*Cut*
Skarsol- "ITS A TRAP!"
Vote> Guard> Vig> Mafia>Other
Democrats Abroad! || Vote From Abroad
Phyphor
Phyphor
The Cow King would make a very good target for death tonight.
Also, care to explain why you think Cow would be a good target Roman? You seem a much better one to me... we would get so much more information from your death.
That or any of the people voting for me... I hate to target new players, but i'm just getting this overwhelming feeling that one of them is, and catching that person would really reveal alot about the other mafia since he is undoubtedly copying their votes.
Last would be Zandra... what's with the no reasoning throwaway votes every day man? I don't think we would learn alot by killing him, but damn if that's not mafia behavior trying to stay as low as possible while not contributing anything.
Say it to who? And remember, two guards is very much possible.
Have a look at his voting history. He's been on counter-wagons to Phyphor every time. Everyone keeps saying this and it's bullshit. What information would we get from my death? I've done nothing but make arguments about things. If I die village, that doesn't mean i was right about my arguments. Same thing if i die mafia, I could (and likely would) be accusing some of my team-mates too.
You're incredibly suspicious and I can't fault anyone for voting you. I'm happy to go into reasons why, but there's too much for this post.
Zandracon always acts like this. Village or mafia. He is almost impossible to read and if we didn't have a huge number of better targets, he'd be a good choice.
Your posts would be entirely unnecessary if you were a vig, and almost all of your posts have been trying to manipulate people.
The mafia would have noticed this too, and either killed you for being a likely special, or... well, hopefully you see now why your death would tell alot.