The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.

Anti-Gay Concentration Camps

Squall LeonhartSquall Leonhart Registered User regular
edited June 2011 in Debate and/or Discourse
This is just a heads up, but what you're about to read might disturb you, so brace yourself. A company in Utah named "Teen Escort Services" is regularly contracted to kidnap LGBT teenagers in the middle of the night, deport them to a concentration camp in a country that doesn't extradite to the US, and torture them. The goal of these concentration camps is to beat "the gay" out of them. It's legal because homophobic parents sign over legal documents allowing them to go to these camps to "cure" their homosexuality. They are not allowed to leave these camps and are regularly tortured, they are also banned from speaking about the outside world. According to some testimonies, the teenagers tried to rebel against their Nazi overseers, but were gunned down with rubber bullets.

Please don't blame the entire United States for these crimes against humanity. In Utah (and Jamaica, which is where one of the concentration camps is located) teenagers lack the same basic human rights as adults and Utah is known for being predominantly Mormon. For those of you who don't know, Mormonism is a radical far right wing sect of Christianity that often does outrageous things and promotes incest, inbreeding, and now apparently the kidnapping & false imprisonment of minors. This is legal because the companies involved "donated" large sums of money to many politicians and the leader of one of the concentration camp operating companies, World Wide Association of Specialty Programs and Schools, is a close personal friend of many politicians, including Mitt Romney.

Here's one victim's story: http://www.reddit.com/r/troubledteens/comments/hk0xy/a_gay_teen_describes_her_experience_at_a_utah/
On May 10th of 2007 at around 2:30 in the morning two strangers barged into my bedroom. I started screaming and crying, as in my mind I was sure that these two strangers had broken into my house and were going to abduct me, rape me, kill me, or in some way harm me. They immediately told me that if I did not shut up that they would handcuff me. I was not being in any way violent or threatening. I was reacting in fear for my life by being vocal and hoping that someone would come to help. I had no idea what was going on. I stopped screaming, still in fear for my life. They started going through my closet digging out clothes as I was only in a night gown. They still had not explained what was going on. I asked, frightened, what the wanted from me, trying to see if I could in some way appease them and get them to leave. They then explained that they were going to take me to a school. It took me a second to understand what they meant by this, as this was an extremely bizarre way to introduce a child to a new school. It then occurred to me that this was what my mother had arranged for my brother several years ago when she had him shipped away to Cross Creek. The two strangers were from Teen Escort Service, a for-profit company that transports teenagers, usually by force, to WWASP (World Wide Association of Specialty Programs) facilities.

I was extremely upset and cried the entire trip, but I obeyed all of their orders. Even though I was being cooperative they said it was their policy to put a belt around the bust of the child and hold the belt so that there would be no chance of attempting to run. It was so humiliating to be led around like a fucking dog around the airport. It was also extremely uncomfortable to have this strange older male putting his hand so close to my breast. I never understood how any of this was legal but definitely knew that none of it was ethical. To this day I feel extremely angered, disturbed, and violated by this entire experience. In addition to this they “forgot” all of the psychiatric medication I had been on at my house. It’s not that I am for psychiatric meds, but it certainly did not feel healthy or normal to go from taking this medication regularly, to just not having it and stopping with out tapering off of it.

From the moment I arrived at Cross Creek, I was treated as though I was broken, dirty, and inhuman. During my stay I saw many others treated this way. I had never spoken to R., the program director, before and my first experience with him was horrible. He asked me why I was there, and I told him all of the things I’d done that I could think of that could possibly be perceived as “bad”. He yelled at me, saying that I was lying and that I didn’t love or care about my parents. I was shocked and confused, unsure of what I had done to deserve this treatment from someone I had just met. To this day, the only thing I can think of that I possibly could have left out was my attraction to other females. In one of the Parent-Child seminars we were made to attend, my mother shared with me that this was one of the biggest “issues” that caused her to send me to Cross Creek. Not the drugs, not the sex (she told me she had no knowledge of me being sexually active prior to being forced to disclose it to her), not the issues with school, but just the fact that there was a possibility that one day I might fall in love with a female. Sorry for not realizing what a horrible, broken child this made me, R.

Shortly after I arrived, my “HOPE buddy” (the student they assign to “mentor” you and teach you the rules in your first few weeks) started asking me about my past, why I was there, and what issues I needed to work on. I talked briefly about my experimentation with soft drugs, my issues with depression (something I’m pretty sure most teenagers experience), and the abusive relationship I had been in with my first girlfriend. As soon as I said the words “girl” and “relationship” in the same sentence she said “STOP! STOP! We can’t talk about that.” I was filled with shame regarding my sexuality simply from the fact that I was not even allowed to talk about homosexuality in any way shape or form. Shortly after this incident I started talking to the therapist they assigned me to there about this abusive relationship I had experienced, and how it bothered me that I was not allowed to talk about a part of me that I have no control over. His response was that I DID have a choice over whether or not I was attracted to females and that I should just deal with these thoughts of same sex attraction. His opinion was that this was probably a result of some anger I had toward men, particularly my dad and that I probably just wanted to be with females because they were “safer” (even though I had been with an abusive female before!!!) He also said that ultimately this was probably just a phase and a result of my crazy teenage hormones. He believed that if I tried hard enough and ignored these thoughts and feelings one day I might marry a nice boy.

I had no interest in having a relationship with anyone there, but when other girls formed relationships with each other, the repercussions were pretty extreme. I understood why it was not allowed, as relationships are generally distracting no matter the gender of either partner, but the way people were treated was pretty unnecessary in my opinion. It usually involved lots of yelling, ostracizing, and shaming. I remember one R. meeting where two girls were being confronted about this and R. was yelling about how stupid they were being and how no one would be able to trust them now. He went on to say that he had “nothing against homosexuality, but it was not the way God intended things.” and that the Bible definitely did not condone it. These “God” and bible references were used on a regular basis, along with religious videos, praying, etc. even though Cross Creek claimed that they were not in any way religious. The rule book and protocol also appeared to be directly based off of the Mormon religion (no caffeine etc.) The program reprimanded children for telling their parents about this religious influence and regularly tried to hide it from parents. I am in no way against people having their own beliefs and following what ever religion is right for them, however I think that it’s completely and totally immoral to lie to parents about what they are getting. More on this later.

The queer shaming was present in nearly every aspect of the program, including the language used. We were not allowed to use curse words such as “shit”, or “bitch”, but I never saw anyone reprimanded for saying “fag” or “faggot.” This fostered an environment in which teasing and bullying for all sorts of things were fully tolerated. I even remember a facilitator in a seminar trying to trigger a girl by calling her a “dyke.” And no, before you say something, I really don’t care about breaking confidentiality of seminars at this point because I am fed up. What these people said and did broke me down and created so much shame inside of me.

In addition to shaming people on basis of sexual orientation, they taught children that sex was evil and damaging outside of marriage, another blatantly religious notion. We were forced to regularly watch videos involving horror stories of abortions gone wrong, shown gruesome pictures of STDs that had been left unattended for long periods of time, and told that if we had sex before marriage we would likely die or get some horrible ailment. Rather than promoting safer sex methods, we were shown that abstinence was the only option that would not result in death or unwanted pregnancy.

Rigid gender roles were also a big part of the Cross Creek way of life. Many of the rules were extremely gender based. Boys were allowed to crack their backs and knuckles, though girls were not because it was “unladylike”. Boys got meal portions double the size of girls. Boys were allowed to use more curse words than girls were. The list goes on.

I remember when they moved the girls from Center 1 to Pro 1 (these are all names of the dorms we stayed in.) The boys had been living in Pro 1, and when they moved the girls in the dorms were extremely messy. Rather than having the boys come back and clean up this mess, they made the girls clean all day. This was completely, and totally humiliating. What a great way to build confidence and teach girls how to be independent and stand up for themselves.

Before I say this next part, I want to state that it is not my intention to bash all of the staff at Cross Creek. Some of the staff were very supportive (A.D., M.C., etc.) and this is not in any way meant to be directed at you, nor is it a blanket statement. There were staff however, that made me feel very unsafe and uncomfortable. Some of the staff, in my opinion, were downright cruel, hurtful and borderline (if not blatantly) abusive. I can’t tell you how many times I saw staff make comments about myself or others insinuating that we were bad children, unclean, impure, dirty, not innocent, untrustable, the list goes on. The grievance system that was in place was, in my opinion, ineffective on the whole. From being a part of the student government system for some time that handled grievances, I observed that grievance system, like everything else at Cross Creek, put the blame on the student and diverted responsibility away from the adult.

I’d also like to mention how many times I saw staff and administration, tackle and restrain children when it was completely unnecessary. So many times I saw kids simply refuse to go to gym class or get out of bed and as punishment they were violently tackled, restrained in a painful position, and taken to a small isolation room where they were usually watched by two or three staff members. This was also what they did when a child harmed themselves. This method is extremely violent, and I remember at least one incident that happened when I was there where they tackled a girl and restrained her face down against the ground and as a result she got rug burn on her face to the point that she was bleeding and had visible scabs on her face. Another time a girl shared that being tackled and restrained gave her flashbacks of a rape she’d experienced, to which the program director responded that he felt no remorse for it and that it was really her fault for doing what ever she’d done to be restrained. You could argue that this might be appropriate in cases where a kid is being violent towards others, but from what I saw, more often than not, this was absolutely not the case and the child being restrained was not being violent. In addition to tackling and restraint being (in my humble opinion) immoral, it is unsafe, and this has been proven. If you look on the website for the Coalition Against Institutionalized Child Abuse, you can see a long list of deaths that have occurred in “behavioral modification” facilities not unlike Cross Creek as a result of tackling and restraint. http://www.caica.org/RESTRAINTS%20Death%20List.htm

Cross Creek’s methods of “therapy” and recovery were also extremely invasive, humiliating, and in my opinion did much more harm than good. As someone who does intern work at a local rape treatment center and talks with victims of assault on a regular basis, as well as being someone who has survived various forms of violence and abuse, I have seen how damaging it can be to force someone to share about such delicate issues before they are fully prepared and ready. I can not speak for every one, but for me, being forced to disclose information that was not ready to come out was extremely painful and humiliating. The seminars based your success on how “emotional” you were, meaning that if you did not share some horrible part of your life or simply did not have one, or if you were not crying and sniveling while you did it, you were booted out of the seminar and forced to stay in the program another two months. The obsession the program had with “accountability” also led to them blaming people who had experienced abuse for their abusive situations. I vividly remember a facilitator yelling at a girl while kicking her out of a seminar for not participating or being “real” enough. She told her in an extremely vivid and foul language (the f-bomb included) that if she continued the behavior that got her to the program she would be raped again. She had the student write an essay on this.

I will forever be haunted by the day that I was in group and the program director barged in and started saying that it’s as if I have “ABUSE ME” written on my forehead, insinuating that I was just asking to be abused in some way by the way that I carried and presented myself. I carry so much shame from this comment, and because of it constantly have to remind myself not to blame myself for the abuse I have experienced.

The way that Cross Creek taught me to interact with people was to analyze every facial expression, action, and word, and reflect this back to them in a cold, harsh, and usually demeaning way. I feel so much remorse for the way I treated people at Cross Creek, as well as the way I allowed people to treat me. It took me a while after I graduated to discover that this method did not work at all in the real world, and that if I was to have any friends, I would need to drop the robotic, unempathetic, and borderline malicious way of interacting with others that I had learned to use for two and a half years. I’d like to sincerely apologize to those of you who spent time with me at Cross Creek that I treated this way. I feel nothing but sadness when I realize how heartless and programmed I became.

What disturbs me more than anything is that I believed all of the things I was told. When people use the word “brainwashing” to describe what went on at Cross Creek and other WWASP programs, I don’t think it is in any way exaggerating or being over dramatic when you consider all of the media we were FORCED to watch, read, and listen to. The program director used to joke about and downplay the brainwashing claims by saying that some of our brains “could really use some washing.” The “educational/emotional growth” videos we had to watch twice a day, the “motivational” tapes three times a day, the “self-help” books we were forced to read, and more than anything the “motivational seminars” with facilitators up in your face yelling about all the things you did wrong to mess up your life and land yourself in a program all contributed to this. With all of this influence coming at me from every direction at every moment I believed that following the rules, “working my program”, going to the seminars, etc. was genuinely going to improve my self esteem, my relationship with my parents, and the overall outcome of my life. I tried hard to follow the endless list of rules, be “accountable”, and when I got “dirty in my program” (another good example of shaming lingo and language that means you broke rules without giving yourself demerits) I would confess and take the consequences what ever consequences were involved.

I by no means had a perfect program, but I gave it all of my honest effort and did what I could to be a good Cross Creek student. By putting faith in this system however, I also internalized all of the stigma, shame, and religious beliefs forced upon me. I believed that maybe if I just suppressed my sexuality , as well as ignored my obvious attraction to girls, that maybe all of this would go away. My body and subconscious reacted to this. Shortly after arriving at Cross Creek, I stopped getting my period for about 8 months. This was apparently a common thing that happened in the program when girls first arrived, as the body was reacting to some serious stress. I also started wetting the bed shortly after arriving at the program. This had not been an issue for me since the age of 3 or 4. This bed wetting issue continued until I left the program. After I graduated, it stopped completely.

The program director and other administration on several occasions acknowledged that Tranquility Bay, another WWASP program that has now much to my relief been shut down, did indeed have an infamous history of reported abuse. He used this to say that we were so very “fortunate” to be in Cross Creek and not at programs like that. Yet kids who were “acting out too much” at Cross Creek were sent to Tranquility Bay as punishment. Some have said that Tranquility Bay was merely a “last resort” or that the things that happened at TB were just a “part of Jamaican culture” but I would have to strongly disagree about both of those things. Since when is abuse ever an appropriate option? It isn’t. No matter what someone has done, it’s not okay. It is also extremely racist and ethnocentric to say that abuse is just a part of the culture of Jamaica, especially when you look at American society, which I could very well say the same thing about.

Shortly after I left the program I was raped. I shared what happened with my mother, who then told me, like Cross Creek did, that it was my fault, I asked for it, and that I should have known it would happen. She then proceeded to share her own twisted version of the story with my Cross Creek therapist, who shared it with my group. I was mortified and my self-esteem was completely destroyed by this utter lack of confidentiality and complete betrayal of trust.

It has taken me so much time to recover and de-program myself from all of the lies I was fed at Cross Creek. It took me a while to realize just how badly and inappropriately I and others had been treated at this facility. It’s not to say that there were not a few small kernels of wisdom that I can still use from the program, but they came at such a huge cost. My soul feels wounded from the things I saw and experienced at Cross Creek and healing will be a continual process.

If there was one thing that I gained from my experience at Cross Creek, it was realizing that no one regardless of their past or current actions deserves to be treated the way this program and other WWASP facilities treated me and so many other students. Abuse is abuse, no matter how you slice it. This realization along with other life experiences is partially responsible for my current carreer path regarding abuse prevention and recovery, as well as my involvement and activism in the human rights movement.

Even if you choose not to believe me or anything that I have written, there are piles of evidence to support the idea that there is mistreatment at Cross Creek and other WWASP affiliated facilities. A little bit of research will reveal that this lawsuit is not the first that WWASP or Cross Creek has faced. My therapist used to use a phrase when he suspected that kids were “dirty in their program.” He used to say “Where there’s smoke, there’s fire...” That is certainly the case with WWASP and Cross Creek. There is a reason that the Coalition Against Institutionalized Child Abuse, Community Alliance for The Ethical Treatment of Youth, and many other organizations like them exist. There is a reason why seventeen WWASP affiliated schools have been shut down. There is a reason there have been so many lawsuits. Clearly if all of this has happened, I must not be completely insane.

The rebuttal against this argument has included that Cross Creek is no longer a part of WWASP. This argument is pretty much void seeing as they are still directly affiliated in that all of the WWASP affiliated programs still use the same seminars as each other, the same escort service, the same billing company, and are all still a part of Teen Help LLC, the marketing arm of WWASP and the entity that processes admissions paperwork. They also refer to each other and send children to other WWASP affiliated facilities when one facility can’t handle them. I don’t think it would be at all presumptuous to conclude that the people who ran WWASP are the same people who are still raking in all of the money with these programs.

WWASP officials claim that the organization itself is out of business, probably because of their infamous history of abuse, but clearly all of the WWASP programs are still affiliated and WWASP has not completely faded out. Many schools have changed their names multiple times, including Cross Creek (formerly Browning Academy) and it’s clear to me that there is a lot of shadiness and hiding goes on with in these programs. It seems as though WWASP and it’s affiliates are trying to sweep some things under the rug, and outright lie to parents, students, former students, and the general public.

Here’s a bit about the history of WWASP and Cross Creek. WWASP was founded by Robert Browning Lichfeild. He started Browning Academy, now Cross Creek, the first WWASP affiliated school in 1987, at a time when he had little money and was living in a small apartment with his wife and four children. His field of study was in business (he attained absolutely no credentials or education in psychology, therapy, or education) though he never graduated college and within several years he had become a very rich individual and had added many more schools to his chain of “behavior modification”/”tough love” schools. He was indeed mormon and has, in several interviews stated that God was his inspiration in starting these schools and one of his goals was to “get kids in touch with their higher source.” He is also a major contributor to the Republican party, donating thousands of dollars each year http://www.city-data.com/elec2/elec-LA-VERKIN-UT.html. From what I’ve read his massive sum of money and big political influence have gotten him and his colleagues out of the situations in which he and his criminal organization have been questioned. But please, do not take my word for it. Do your own research. This information is readily available to those who are willing to look.

Original Discussion on Facepunch: http://www.facepunch.com/threads/1092275-A-gay-teen-describes-her-experience-at-a-Utah-WWASP-brainwashing-facility

Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Wide_Association_of_Specialty_Programs_and_Schools

Squall Leonhart on
«1345

Posts

  • KageraKagera Imitating the worst people. Since 2004Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Damn, they are running a train on those poor LGBTQ K'nadles.

    Kagera on
    My neck, my back, my FUPA and my crack.
  • Solomaxwell6Solomaxwell6 Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    This is evil. It's absolutely disgusting that parents let their kids be subjected to this.

    Solomaxwell6 on
  • override367override367 ALL minions Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Who do I contact to open a camp for parents who would send their kids to one of these places

    You know, to beat the stupid out of them

    override367 on
  • Solomaxwell6Solomaxwell6 Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Who do I contact to open a camp for parents who would send their kids to one of these places

    You know, to beat the stupid out of them

    Try these guys.

    Solomaxwell6 on
  • PreacherPreacher Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Last I checked you can't legally allow someone to commit an illegal act. No contract you sign allows the other party to break the law.

    Preacher on
    I would like some money because these are artisanal nuggets of wisdom philistine.

    pleasepaypreacher.net
  • MrIamMeMrIamMe Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    America is all sorts of crazy.

    This is what happens when you don't smack religion down when it rears its head.

    Im really happy Australia becomes more secular by the day.

    MrIamMe on
  • Fuzzy Cumulonimbus CloudFuzzy Cumulonimbus Cloud Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    While the comparison to concentration camps is hyperbolic and unneeded, the ability to involuntarily commit your children to placements is something that can't keep going on.

    For those of you that don't know, the juvenile justice system runs on "placement" programs. There are a bunch that are subsidized by the state that are 100% legitimate and a far better opportunity for rehabilitation for juveniles than plunking them in a detention center. There is a caveat though: you cannot leave the facility unless the facility deems you able to leave. This is not a problem at all for legitimate programs. However, the WASP programs are not legitimate programs.

    Where normal juvenile programs are staffed by professionally licensed therapists, counselors, clinicians, and psychologists, this specific program is staffed by clearly religious Mormons with certificates in "Family and Marriage Practices." The reason these people can't be disbarred is because they were never members of the APA in the first place.

    The restraint techniques are standard fare for all 24-hour facilities. The abuse is rather over the top, though. They aren't beaten. When you get "placed" in a placement, if it is "residential", then any attempts to leave are met with tackling and restraints. If you try to go somewhere you aren't supposed to be, or do something you aren't supposed to do, you're also restrained.

    Fuzzy Cumulonimbus Cloud on
  • SparvySparvy Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Not sure you ca go all "Fuck America!" on this one seeing as half the concept is to ship the kids to other countries with (I imagine) less oversight

    Sparvy on
  • Solomaxwell6Solomaxwell6 Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Sparvy wrote: »
    Not sure you ca go all "Fuck America!" on this one seeing as half the concept is to ship the kids to other countries with (I imagine) less oversight

    9/16 American facilities have been closed
    8/10 foreign facilities have been closed

    This is something the American justice system should've jumped on with both feet. Although, I will grant that the foreign ones are probably the ones where harsher methods are used.

    Solomaxwell6 on
  • nightmarennynightmarenny Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    I could not finish that. That is just awful. I think if I was ever confronted by someone who worked there I wouldn't be able to stop myself from getting violent. Just... my god.

    nightmarenny on
    Help me raise a little cash for my transition costs
    https://gofund.me/fa5990a5
  • WotanAnubisWotanAnubis Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Sparvy wrote: »
    Not sure you ca go all "Fuck America!" on this one seeing as half the concept is to ship the kids to other countries with (I imagine) less oversight
    Guantanamo.

    People blame the US for that one, too. And I'm not sure it's entirely unjustified.

    WotanAnubis on
  • KageraKagera Imitating the worst people. Since 2004Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Hell America ships it's own terrorist prisoners overseas to be interrogated too.

    Kagera on
    My neck, my back, my FUPA and my crack.
  • Blitz RawketBlitz Rawket Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    fake and gay

    Blitz Rawket on
  • klokateer9047klokateer9047 A.K.A Captain Freezeezy Long island,NYRegistered User regular
    edited May 2011
    ...what the fuck are we as a race even doing right anymore? If this is really what we've come to I truly don't want to live on this planet anymore.

    klokateer9047 on
    Steam:Klokateer9047

    Xbox live:Wonderboy9047

    @Astonishingmike on twitter

    STILL THE BEST 1973-FOREVER
  • LorahaloLorahalo Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Well this is downright terrifying.

    Lorahalo on
    I have a podcast about Digimon called the Digital Moncast, on Audio Entropy.
  • FuruFuru Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    ...what the fuck are we as a race even doing right anymore? If this is really what we've come to I truly don't want to live on this planet anymore.

    It's silly to imply that this even ranks in the top ten atrocities of the human race.

    Not to say this isn't horrible (if it's all true) but there's terrible shit going on every day that should have made you feel that way before now!

    Furu on
  • Endless_SerpentsEndless_Serpents Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    I've heard of this before and I honestly think the people involved with the camps and the parents of these children should be quietly removed from society and put down. No graves.

    Endless_Serpents on
  • SynthesisSynthesis Honda Today! Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Sparvy wrote: »
    Not sure you ca go all "Fuck America!" on this one seeing as half the concept is to ship the kids to other countries with (I imagine) less oversight
    Guantanamo.

    People blame the US for that one, too. And I'm not sure it's entirely unjustified.

    At the risk of sounding provocative...how would one not justify it?

    I mean, you're speaking of Guantanamo Detention Camp, located entirely in Guantanamo Naval Base, the American enclave controlled and administered by the United States Government (via, I assume, the Department of the Navy), which has been controlled by the same country for more than a century. The current Cuban government isn't that old.

    If you were going to blame a specific nation for this...who else would you blame? Cuba, a government with admittedly shady detention centers of its own, at least in the past if not the present, which has repeatedly attempted to force Americans out of their enclave since the revolution, and would probably keep trying if it wasn't for the threat of invasion (very real) or nuclear obliteration (less real, but widely used)?

    Who else is responsible? I mean, blaming a nation is hardly ideal--especially if you want to hold someone accountable--but if the Russian Military were shipping POWs or suspects from Chechnya or elsewhere to Kaliningrad, where they were (allegedly) tortured and beaten, and on occasion killed in custody, blaming Poland or Lithuania (with their own shady human rights records) would seem...totally irrelevant? I guess it might be more justified to blame the United States Navy or the Defense Department or the CIA or something....but country wise, the United States seems to have more control over Guantanamo Bay than perhaps any other part of the world, thanks to modern technology and its status as a military enclave, or at least one of the top ten (including the basement of the Pentagon).

    Synthesis on
  • DemiurgeDemiurge Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Zimbabwe has been doing this for years, complete with encouraging rape of the girls in the camp to produce patriots.

    http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/programmes/from_our_own_correspondent/3537511.stm

    Demiurge on
    DQ0uv.png 5E984.png
  • LearnedHandLearnedHand Registered User, __BANNED USERS regular
    edited May 2011
    I concur with Fuzzy Cumulonimbus Cloud. I was expecting really shocking stuff. I didn't see it.

    I mean, it's some Jesus nut thing and taking the kid in a leash taken around the airport...if true (which I tend to doubt) is weird. But for mental health and behavioural problems I suppose they do have people who can use force to get people to the facility.

    But the part where she's talking about people getting restrained over "minor" things like not wanting to go to class...that is just how it's done. I briefly worked at a mental health facility. Absolutely awful place, by the way. But yeah, if you don't follow instructions and start kicking off, you're restrained. This is normal procedure.

    So the only weird things I saw revolved around the Jesus stuff. But some people are religious fanatics.

    I didn't read anything about beating or torture. Weird, religion-based therapy lead by probably unqualified Jesus nuts? Yeah, sure. But clearly the mother is a fanatic too. So it raises some issues.

    It's also true that Jamaica has different views on disciplining children. Hitting children isn't considered inappropriate. This isn't racist, it's reality.

    LearnedHand on
  • nightmarennynightmarenny Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Nothing unusual? The being abducted in the middle of the night thing seemed pretty abnormal.

    nightmarenny on
    Help me raise a little cash for my transition costs
    https://gofund.me/fa5990a5
  • WotanAnubisWotanAnubis Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Synthesis wrote: »
    Sparvy wrote: »
    Not sure you ca go all "Fuck America!" on this one seeing as half the concept is to ship the kids to other countries with (I imagine) less oversight
    Guantanamo.

    People blame the US for that one, too. And I'm not sure it's entirely unjustified.

    At the risk of sounding provocative...why shouldn't they?
    Yeah, that's pretty much what I meant. My ocassional tendency towards severe understatement and needlessly complicated phrasing comes back to haunt me once again.

    To put it bluntly, here's what I was trying to convey:
    First, Sparvy claims that people shouldn't blame the US for the whole kidnapping teenagers and abusing them thing. Which is fair enough. Unfortunately, he then goes on to say that it's not because the whole of the US doesn't consist of the kind of zealots that would do this sort of thing to their kids, but because (some of the) kids are shipped to some other country.

    I then pointed to Gitmo as a kind of very well-known precedent for the US shipping people overseas to abuse them and people blaming the US for doing so even though Gitmo is kinda-sorta part of Cuba (though, granted, not really). I also tried to say that people blaming the US for this is justified (not certain it's unjustified -> leaning towards feeling certain it's justfied).

    By making this connection I was hoping to point out that 'the US' doesn't escape blame by virtue of shipping teenagers overseas. They escape blame by not all being silly geese from Utah.

    WotanAnubis on
  • SynthesisSynthesis Honda Today! Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Synthesis wrote: »
    Sparvy wrote: »
    Not sure you ca go all "Fuck America!" on this one seeing as half the concept is to ship the kids to other countries with (I imagine) less oversight
    Guantanamo.

    People blame the US for that one, too. And I'm not sure it's entirely unjustified.

    At the risk of sounding provocative...why shouldn't they?
    Yeah, that's pretty much what I meant. My ocassional tendency towards severe understatement and needlessly complicated phrasing comes back to haunt me once again.

    To put it bluntly, here's what I was trying to convey:
    First, Sparvy claims that people shouldn't blame the US for the whole kidnapping teenagers and abusing them thing. Which is fair enough. Unfortunately, he then goes on to say that it's not because the whole of the US doesn't consist of the kind of zealots that would do this sort of thing to their kids, but because (some of the) kids are shipped to some other country.

    I then pointed to Gitmo as a kind of very well-known precedent for the US shipping people overseas to abuse them and people blaming the US for doing so even though Gitmo is kinda-sorta part of Cuba (though, granted, not really). I also tried to say that people blaming the US for this is justified (not certain it's unjustified -> leaning towards feeling certain it's justfied).

    By making this connection I was hoping to point out that 'the US' doesn't escape blame by virtue of shipping teenagers overseas. They escape blame by not all being silly geese from Utah.

    Understood, I'd probably do the same thing. It just wanted to wonder if anyone besides the truly ridiculous (among other things) actually thought some country besides the United States had a say in what happens in the United States Naval Base at Guantanamo Bay. As though the Cuban Government had mastered mind control via tainted water, and instead of ejecting thousands of armed soldiers out of the enclave forcibly established in their country, was using it to just make them do really nasty things.

    Synthesis on
  • kedinikkedinik Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    For those of you who don't know, Mormonism is a radical far right wing sect of Christianity that often does outrageous things and promotes incest, inbreeding, and now apparently the kidnapping & false imprisonment of minors.

    Granted that the Mormon church and LGBT communities do not get along.

    And that this is largely because the Mormon church, despicably, devoted a lot of resources to promoting anti-gay marriage laws.

    And without question these camps sound systematically inhumane.

    But incest and polygamy have been banned and aggressively punished by the actual Mormon church for just about a century by now. Literally relegated to ex-communicated fringe yokels for a long time now.

    kedinik on
  • DarkPrimusDarkPrimus Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    LearnedHand: It's clear that most of the abuse and torture the author received was psychological in nature. That it didn't leave physical scars doesn't make it any less deplorable.

    DarkPrimus on
  • Fuzzy Cumulonimbus CloudFuzzy Cumulonimbus Cloud Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    kedinik wrote: »
    For those of you who don't know, Mormonism is a radical far right wing sect of Christianity that often does outrageous things and promotes incest, inbreeding, and now apparently the kidnapping & false imprisonment of minors.

    Granted that the Mormon church and LGBT communities do not get along.

    And that this is largely because the Mormon church, despicably, devoted a lot of resources to promoting anti-gay marriage laws.

    And without question these camps sound systematically inhumane.

    But incest and polygamy have been banned and aggressively punished by the actual Mormon church for just about a century by now. Literally relegated to ex-communicated fringe yokels for a long time now.
    Not really. Polygamy is rampant and ignored by everyone in the community. Mainly because everyone in Mormon communities is Mormon, so guess which law enforcement officers look the other way? Hint, its the Mormon ones.

    Fuzzy Cumulonimbus Cloud on
  • kedinikkedinik Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    You're thinking of these guys, who splintered off and became ex-communicant fringe psychos a century ago in large part because the actual Mormon church aggressively banned polygamy.

    Frankly, it doesn't do the LGBT community any long-run favors to slander Mormon sexuality with patently false info, any more than it serves Mormons to claim gays are destroying civilization.

    Though I suppose maybe it feels good.

    kedinik on
  • InvisibleInvisible Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    These aren't new and you can find numerous reports about similar camps being shut down due to illness, injury and death.

    While I can understand a parent's desperation, these sort of places clearly have no sort of certification, and they're not often taking trouble youth, but just youth who happen to be gay.

    Actually well regulated, private camps with certified medical personnel might actually be beneficial for some people, but even then I question the need to rip a child from their bed in the middle of the night without warning or notification. It's one thing if the child is mentally disturbed, it's another if they are otherwise normal.

    Really, I'm curious to how the youth respond once they escape. If my parents had ever done something like that to me, I don't think I'd ever forgive them. Such a huge violation of trust.

    Invisible on
  • TehSpectreTehSpectre Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Someone made a movie about these kind of camps a few years back. (Not particularly anti-gay camps, but the same "style")

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DKOWcJfc-IA&feature=related

    TehSpectre on
    9u72nmv0y64e.jpg
  • 21stCentury21stCentury Call me Pixel, or Pix for short! [They/Them]Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Honestly, I think this should be about "Private Child Prisons" in the US, the WWASP. They do a whole lot more than just "gay teens". Tranquility Bay... That is pretty out there. I could post an article about it, maybe? It's not about gay teens, though, so would it be off-topic?

    21stCentury on
  • TheOrangeTheOrange Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    I would totally expect my son to come to me and say "you will never see your grandchildren" if I sent him there.

    TheOrange on
  • ShanadeusShanadeus Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    This is actually happening in a first world country?
    How barbaric.

    Shanadeus on
  • Salvation122Salvation122 Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Honestly, I think this should be about "Private Child Prisons" in the US, the WWASP. They do a whole lot more than just "gay teens". Tranquility Bay... That is pretty out there. I could post an article about it, maybe? It's not about gay teens, though, so would it be off-topic?

    If I remember correctly Tranquility Bay got wiped off the planet by a hurricane back in like 2006 or something and was never rebuilt.

    Salvation122 on
  • TaramoorTaramoor Storyteller Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Shanadeus wrote: »
    This is actually happening in a first world country?
    How barbaric.

    Well, to be fair, the majority of it does not seem to.

    Taramoor on
  • Element BrianElement Brian Peanut Butter Shill Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    kedinik wrote: »
    For those of you who don't know, Mormonism is a radical far right wing sect of Christianity that often does outrageous things and promotes incest, inbreeding, and now apparently the kidnapping & false imprisonment of minors.

    Granted that the Mormon church and LGBT communities do not get along.

    And that this is largely because the Mormon church, despicably, devoted a lot of resources to promoting anti-gay marriage laws.

    And without question these camps sound systematically inhumane.

    But incest and polygamy have been banned and aggressively punished by the actual Mormon church for just about a century by now. Literally relegated to ex-communicated fringe yokels for a long time now.
    Not really. Polygamy is rampant and ignored by everyone in the community. Mainly because everyone in Mormon communities is Mormon, so guess which law enforcement officers look the other way? Hint, its the Mormon ones.

    Actually you're full of shit and the LDS community here in Utah despises and looks down on the fundamentalist who still practice polygamy. Theres even claims from defense lawyers that Polygamist Leaders cant be tried in Utah because of how much the rest of Utah despises them. But you probably know more about it living outside of the state than I do actually living here.

    Element Brian on
    Switch FC code:SW-2130-4285-0059

    Arch,
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t_goGR39m2k
  • EgoEgo Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    About half my relatives are mormon, and I'm fairly certain none of them have secret wives I don't know about. If it were common, you'd think one of us non-mormon relatives would have spotted one by now :).

    Ego on
    Erik
  • either,oreither,or Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Is this something that could be avoided in the future by ratifying the Convention on the Rights of the Child?

    either,or on
    steam_sig.png
    3DS friend code: 4811-7214-5053
  • ThanatosThanatos Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    kedinik wrote: »
    You're thinking of these guys, who splintered off and became ex-communicant fringe psychos a century ago in large part because the actual Mormon church aggressively banned polygamy.

    Frankly, it doesn't do the LGBT community any long-run favors to slander Mormon sexuality with patently false info, any more than it serves Mormons to claim gays are destroying civilization.

    Though I suppose maybe it feels good.
    Absolutely wrong.

    The crazier you make Mormons sound, the more you show them to be the insane right-wing, magic-underpants-wearing, space-alien-believing, "Jesus-was-a-Native-American" nuts they are, the more harm you can do to their religion, the better off it is for the LGBT community.

    I mean, the Mormons clearly have absolutely zero problem spreading lies in order to harm the LGBT community; I don't see why anyone should feel anything remotely resembling guilt at pulling off the same thing aimed at them.

    Thanatos on
  • DoctorArchDoctorArch Curmudgeon Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    Brian and Ego are absolutely right (and my own anecdotal experience coincides with theirs), and people shouldn't be tossing around accusations like those regarding incest, inbreeding, and support for polygamy. The FLDS and the LDS are two separate churches, and they should be acknowledged as such.

    Than, while I agree with your sentiment, we shouldn't spread lies because we are better than them. That said, I have zero problem taking all the rope that they've provided and hanging them out to dry for it. It's just better to nail them with the truth instead of lies.

    But as far as fair game goes, I found an interesting little site for Evergreen LDS which is one of those "pray out the gay" outfits. Also interesting, this foundation is following in the footsteps of a Brigham Young University experiment in which the University attached electrodes to the genitals of homosexual men in order to curb them of their impulses. Here's the link for that wonderful piece of God's love.

    DoctorArch on
    Switch Friend Code: SW-6732-9515-9697
  • ThanatosThanatos Registered User regular
    edited May 2011
    And these camps have been around for years, just not necessarily for gay teens (it seems they've branched out, though). I think 60 Minutes (or another, similar news program) did a pretty extensive exposé on them a few years ago.

    The problem is that the laws of the U.S. view children as chattel property, instead of as people. I mean, we won't sign the UN Declaration on Children's Rights because it won't let us kill kids; how fucked up is that?

    Thanatos on
Sign In or Register to comment.