The Homestar Runner Mini-[Phalla]

Cythraul

Yeah way to go vig! Pop that tire!!

But uh, did we lose a special ourselves? Or were some of you blessed with character names while the rest of us got stuck as generic Citizens?

/throw baby

Void Slayer

I suspect as this is a standard game, most roles should be displayed when the person is revealed.

But just in case.

Will the narrations contain information on the roles of those who die?

Also we should note a mafia gacve the second vote in the Langly wagon, I am thinking at least one was in the votes for someone not in the tiebreaker.

SeGeTai, kuhlmeye, Tayrun, Peccavi, Alegis, Caulk Bite 6 : all did not vote for one of the leaders.

SeGeTai can probably be counted out for being so early in the day and KetBra trying to take out jdarkson late in the day.

I am going to go for Caulk Bite 6 for his switchyness.

I am bad at this though so... Wooo... day two vote analysis go!

Bedlam

whats the 4th classic village role? Im counting Vig, seer, guard, and ???

KetBra

bus driver?

Bedlam

Oh does mason count? I had heard there were masons.

Cythraul

Maybe there's a Homsar VI? :P

Tayrun

As I've been listed, I'd like to point out that my vote yesterday was a pure "Day 1 lol kime" vote, nothing more.

Edit: Akshully, Void, I find it suspicious that you didn't exclude me from suspicion due to it being such an obvious Kimevote. I'm suspicious of you, SeGeTai and KetBra. A little.

MrTLicious

ooOOOOooOOoOOO

Et tu, Brute?

ooOOOOooOOoOOO

Taya

Population: no tire

kime

Void Slayer wrote: »

I suspect as this is a standard game, most roles should be displayed when the person is revealed.

But just in case.

Will the narrations contain information on the roles of those who die?

Also we should note a mafia gacve the second vote in the Langly wagon, I am thinking at least one was in the votes for someone not in the tiebreaker.

SeGeTai, kuhlmeye, Tayrun, Peccavi, Alegis, Caulk Bite 6 : all did not vote for one of the leaders.

SeGeTai can probably be counted out for being so early in the day and KetBra trying to take out jdarkson late in the day.

I am going to go for Caulk Bite 6 for his switchyness.

I am bad at this though so... Wooo... day two vote analysis go!

Reasoning

Caulk Bite 6

SeGaTai

Yea thought about trying to keep Langly alive late last night but way to close to vote close to change my vote-have yelled at silly geese for less. The Caulk Bite vote makes sense, but going to go with Jdarksun may be a reason why the langly wagon picked up so much

Silas Brown

Void Slayer wrote:

Will the narrations contain information on the roles of those who die?

It may be possible to infer the role of those who die. It is possible that you'll be wrong.

Taya

Lots of people switched their votes yesterday. People are automatically suspicious of vote switchers and the mafia know this, so let's not be too hasty.

Bedlam

Honestly Id be more suspicious of those that throw their vote on a random person and leave it there. Having a low vote leader can lead to the mafia switching to anyone they want.

Also dont see the reason to vote for someone just because they were in second. I cant think of anyone who WANTS to die, especially day 1.

SeGaTai

My reason for wanting to kill the 2nd place from day 1 is it gives us the most insight into who people voted for with one day of vote history

B:L

>
>

(Please note that ye still doth have friendship from !JLARPSON the pony and it be raging.)

Thanketh the heavens. Relief is moments away. You are in the infirmary. There is a Seer Doctor here and a Homeosociopathic Kimeologist. Whatever, she's a Healer. And she smells like fruity dirt. Or dirty fruit. Or Always Evil. A sign readeth, "Ask thy doctor about BANDWAGON TOOLS"

What wouldst thou deau?
>

Alegis

I was tempted to vote on one but I usually avoid bandwagons day 1. Started as a mafia practice that I had to keep up as villager, lest people figure out my mafia persona. So I got to agree with bedlam considering I voted on someone with no vote at the time to further establish my baseline.

Keep in mind that any heuristic involving "oh x or y are suspicious for doing this in the wagons" is only valid if indeed one of the mafioso was in danger of racking up votes. If you believe jdarksun to be a villager there's little reason to suspect someone switching between jdarksun and langly.

Cythraul

I would think the people switching wagons would be more suspect than the people being wagoned on day 1. Was about to vote for CB but he switched off of Langly, unless I'm missing something.

Will check into this with more detail when I'm off work. My boss already complains I always seem to be checking this site so much :P

Alegis

Because there's no such thing as villager uncertainty? The mafia know who the mafia are. IF jdarksun and langly are village (and by this I don't mean to try to subconsciously get into your mind that jdark is village, for I have no clue) can you imagine mafia being undecided between those 2?

My point being finding someone suspicious for trying to influence the vote to save a mafia is linked with a mafia being saved. Where there's smoke etc

Caulk Bite 6

Void Slayer wrote: »

I suspect as this is a standard game, most roles should be displayed when the person is revealed.

But just in case.

Will the narrations contain information on the roles of those who die?

Also we should note a mafia gacve the second vote in the Langly wagon, I am thinking at least one was in the votes for someone not in the tiebreaker.

SeGeTai, kuhlmeye, Tayrun, Peccavi, Alegis, Caulk Bite 6 : all did not vote for one of the leaders.

SeGeTai can probably be counted out for being so early in the day and KetBra trying to take out jdarkson late in the day.

I am going to go for Caulk Bite 6 for his switchyness.

I am bad at this though so... Wooo... day two vote analysis go!

it's worth noting that since my first phalla got Kuhlmeye killed off by my then mafia hand, the games we are in start with us grudging each other. the second time he was mafia and I outed him.

as for my switchiness, I switched onto langly, then onto kuhlmeye again. I was being, quote "Fickle".

Caulk Bite 6

all that said, this may not be the best time to do this. but whatever.

I, like most of you, am powerless.

But! I refuse to remain so. I call upon the Name-eds of the non-strongbadians (who I will not honour with capitalisation) to reach out and use me as their figurehead, their Primary Target to shield them from the enemy. Use me, as you would use any nameless soldier.

For I have What It Takes to join the Homestarmy!

I HAVE FIVE BUCKS!

Caulk Bite 6

also, continuing to vote kuhlmeye until something better comes up. Possibly via PM if people think I'm trustworthy enough.

Capfalcon

kime wrote:

Reasoning

Caulk Bite 6

Caulk.

I think Kime has a poi- OH GOD WHAT'S HAPPENING TO THE WORLD!

Caulk Bite 6

I was kind of hoping my revelation of unwise affection for The Man With No Plan (or arms) would bring about someone with info on a mafia.

Instead, I'm now tied with Second Worst from the last vote, due to shoddy reasoning.

kuhlmeye

Wait just a minute. Let me get your plan straight here caulk.

You are claiming villager. Ok, so would most people (mafia included). You are then asking the village specials to contact you (an unverified villager, with no current way to prove you are who you say you are).

If you are a mafia fishing for village specials, your aren't doing it very well, caulk bite 6.

Caulk Bite 6

I'm doing the same thing I did last time I was village.

Looks like I'll be vindicated (posthumously) by next narration.

Capfalcon

Caulk Bite 6 wrote:

all that said, this may not be the best time to do this. but whatever.

I, like most of you, am powerless.

But! I refuse to remain so. I call upon the Name-eds of the non-strongbadians (who I will not honour with capitalisation) to reach out and use me as their figurehead, their Primary Target to shield them from the enemy. Use me, as you would use any nameless soldier.

For I have What It Takes to join the Homestarmy!

I HAVE FIVE BUCKS!

I'm a villager, and all you specials should contact me. You know it's safe to contact me because I'm a villager, not a mafia member.

VILLAGERS UNTIE!!!1!

Caulk Bite 6

precisely.

it really shouldn't fail.

maybe it bothers people that I'm ignoring some of the long held beliefs of How To Play.

Capfalcon

Caulk Bite 6 wrote:

precisely.

it really shouldn't fail.

maybe it bothers people that I'm ignoring some of the long held beliefs of How To Play.

Ok. If you're a villager, it's a good idea.

What if you're lying?

Caulk Bite 6

Capfalcon wrote: »

Caulk Bite 6 wrote:

precisely.

it really shouldn't fail.

maybe it bothers people that I'm ignoring some of the long held beliefs of How To Play.

Ok. If you're a villager, it's a good idea.

What if you're lying?

only one way (that I'm aware of) to know for sure, but by that point, it's already too late.

Caulk Bite 6

well, two, if you count seering. but that's unavailable right now, unless someone isn't speaking up for some reason.

Capfalcon

Caulk Bite 6 wrote:

precisely.

it really shouldn't fail.

maybe it bothers people that I'm ignoring some of the long held beliefs of How To Play.

Caulk Bite 6 wrote:

only one way (that I'm aware of) to know for sure, but by that point, it's already too late.

You don't see a problem reconciling these two statements?

Caulk Bite 6

people could just trust me?

Stop laughing, I'm serious

SeGaTai

So theres no reason for everyone to have blind faith in you(sorry but its the way it is). We assume there's a seer-why not just wait for them to try seer someone who shows up as a vanillager and have them be the mouthpiece, theres a good chance this could have already happened and if not almost certain by tomorrow

Bedlam

Yeah im not feeling either wagon really. Caulk is only in his 3rd game I think, I dont think he is effecting a great strategy but what you gonna do. Jdark I dont know.

Unless I better target comes up Im just going to go with Kime today. Always evil, meh meh meh.

kuhlmeye

caulk, because I don't honestly believe the mafia would be so bold as to request village specials to contact them.

We'll see where things end up later.

Peccavi

kime. I don't normally vote him early, and there haven't been any startling revelations yet to guide my vote.

Caulk Bite 6

hmm... wondering if my head will engsmsplode tonight.

kime

kuhlmeye wrote: »

caulk, because I don't honestly believe the mafia would be so bold as to request village specials to contact them.

We'll see where things end up later.

...Why not?

SeGaTai

Going with 20% mafia-4 people down to 3, outing one of you at that point seems fairly ballsy- good on ya if they tried it