The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent
vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums
here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules
document is now in effect.
The current plan is to attempt to start the Holiday Forums on December 23rd sometime during the day. During this time, the Future State Planning Center will remain open. The Holiday Forum merge will last (if Vanilla cooperates) until January 3rd.
Carnival Catastrophe (Mini)Phalla! Carnie (village) win!
Posts
3DS: 1289-8447-4695
Yup, that's me on Steam.
If you are interested in playing, discussing, or hosting Arkham Horror, click here!
assuran, mi-go, wiet, spoit and stever777 were the mafia.
You were wrong.
Still I repeat, I didn't know MrT was the vote manip till day three. With two villagers dead and stever turn up red on one of the wagons, assuming there was on the ani wagon wasn't terribly play. If I had known vote manip was on the village side, I probably wouldn't have pushed for mafia on the ani wagon as hard as I did. I still would have said stever most of had it, just to ensure the mafia didn't suspect me of being in a network.
edit: that is to say the mafia would want to keep him alive since he looked so mafia
1. Get Day 1'd
2. Enjoy PAX
3. ???
4. Profit!
I suppose there was some coordination day three but that was after things got out of hand. I also felt MrT wasn't the only vote manip out there, with the votes being 4 for mi-go, 4 for kime and 5 for you before my switch, there was the possibility of 2-3 village dying. Depending on what happened that could have brought attention to MrT (not that it matters since the mafia killed that night anyways), so I switched to ensure we had a clear vote leader.
I know Kilnaga thought Typhus was a good target for his vig action when I called for the kill on spoit.
Hilariously, if you hadn't gotten the kime wagon going and if the vote had stayed on spoit, we would have been voting out Cayrus on day 4. I have no idea if that change of events would have made him hold off on killing mi-go or not. I have a feeling Kilnaga would have still suggested Typhus after I made the call, which would have led to mi-go being the suggested target.
Edit: I did learn that when successful guards aren't mentioned. Probably should seer people like Cayrus the night after they reveal special, if they happen to be alive, sure a guard could have saved them or they could be immune to all kills that aren't the vote.
well the kime wagon as after some talk with mi-go and spoit (sadly )and I think mi-go had talked to kilnaga. Oddly I gave spoit the benefit of the doubt because of labor day. And there was only one vote on spoit. Part of the reason for the secrecy was as ironic as it was, was to gauge the mafia's reaction. To see who blindly jumped. Like typhus. The votes on me would have been shady as hell also, when you consider no explanation for any of the votes really. Granted we didn't give one for kime, but his reaction of 'HAHAHAHA" and saving his vote
Regardless if you have a better idea you should go with it, aside from what nonsense is going on in the day- instead of something that seems silly. Also risk takers are rarely mafia. Considering I started a bw on kime and I had the deciding vote on Wiet (which boggles my mind that nobody cared about). Should have caused alarm.
I was kinda convinced kime was innocent after he did "you are acting evil" thing , since he did that in a past game. I was gonna switch my vote onto typhus (since he went "ok kime because bwing him is fun!" and then "egos because there is some reason to har har" , also the langly stuff) - probably wouldn't have gone anywhere. But seems like it was a good thing I didn't.
Good job thyphus too, I was leaving you alive because you were being so suspicuous in the thread, I thought there was no way you would be a special
The SK role was pretty neat. The only problem I see with it is that it helps the mafia be a tad bit too strong in this game. They know who they are, so when the SK kills one of them, they aren't in the dark. The village on the other hand is SoL, we don't know who they are and when someone vanishes without a trace we can't use them to try and figure things out (could have been mafia, could have been village). I'm also looking at from the whole package view because the mafia also has two kills and those seem to happen even if the remaining mafioso dies as evidenced by me and kime dying. So there are options either narration notes number of teenagers left or mafia power is reduced a little (less kills, number of kills tied to number of teenager).
I think if the mafia didn't have such terrible luck they might have won this easily, the only problem is two died day one, another got voted out day two, another died day three with the remaining one being seered. If the SK had only hit one, with nothing else changed, they might have easily won since the missing record could have shielded one. I hate to imagine how things would have gone if Typhus died on day one or two.
Anyways, thanks for running this Slym.
Sadly, I don't think Cayrus wanted to off the mafia that quickly. I'll laugh even more if he was in the dark as much as the village before the mafia told him anything.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Didn't get a chance to tell him anything! He said hi, but then didn't respond after that!
Also.... who was the Seer? And did he/she ever Seer me or plan to?
Yup, that's me on Steam.
If you are interested in playing, discussing, or hosting Arkham Horror, click here!
@Lucedes I was The Shooting Gallery Operator, aka The Vig
- Terence McKenna
i always go for the specials.
;____;
I also killed you with my guns last night had it gone through. ;>_>
- Terence McKenna
it's my superpower
(my heart always kills village specials)
You said something that lead me to believe you were figuring out the mechanic, let me look for it.
Here it is:
Henri Emmanuel Gratien St Pierre in Where No Man Has Gone Before
Lord Augustus Cumberbatch in Eclipse Phase
I vote from somewhere lower. Gut instinct. It is hit and miss. I mean... I got stever Day 1 and then Cayrus was the top of my dunalist after him, and I had voted for him, but the bandwagon moved away from him after that.
I'm also surprised @mi-go hunter
I totally let things slip to you in PM I shouldn't have... things that should have made it fairly obvious I was the vig. ;>_>
- Terence McKenna
Sorry for ignoring all your inquiries and @'s. I simply couldn't answer them after day 1 since I was erased from the phalla. In the future, if I stop posting in a phalla, but I'm still active elsewhere on this site, figure I died somehow in the phalla (or was silenced, etc).
It was frustrating realizing how boned the mafia was on day 2, but not being able to warn my mafia mates.
Cayrus for village mvp ;p.
Here our the mafia proboards; prizesforeveryone.freeforums.net/index.cgi
Oh.... DAMN IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIT!!!!
Ehehehehehehe. I fooled Egos too. Might you have killed me eventually @Kilnaga ?
Yup, that's me on Steam.
If you are interested in playing, discussing, or hosting Arkham Horror, click here!
Nope. In my talks with Mill, he conveyed the Seers order for me to vig you and I was all "AWWWWWWWWWWwwwwwwwww not Mi-go." Then we realized you had already been disappeared anyway and it didn't matter.
- Terence McKenna
You're so sweet Kilnaga!
Yup, that's me on Steam.
If you are interested in playing, discussing, or hosting Arkham Horror, click here!
I believe mi-go and I were talking about how SlyM wasn't updating the player list ,ironically, just before she posted that.
@Egos
So then you got Mi-go killed by the SK?
- Terence McKenna
Thanks for taking the heat Day 2 over the whole killing stever thing. :P
I had put that order in like right as the day started, before you guys brought up the whole sports thing (I was worried at one point that I might have to change it because stever was getting votes). Totally didn't intend to set you up to eat that mafia kill but you did so with some serious grace. Pro vanillager play.
- Terence McKenna
mi-go probably wanted to ask regardless because of assuran. I just brought up inactivity with 38th who I didn't notice was missing from the list and 23 players ( i had forgotten 25 had signed up)- SlyM not making additions like "blank got killed night 1 " and such didn't help. I just assumed he was a lazy host. And then she said she was gonna ask in the thread if he could update the OP.
Of course, I never thought that asking such a harmless question would result in death!
Yup, that's me on Steam.
If you are interested in playing, discussing, or hosting Arkham Horror, click here!
In response to the thralls question. No one received incorrect information, but they did occasionally receive no information.