If that's the case, then...it wouldn't exile. You'd sacrifice it with Cry on the stack, so the exile wouldn't happen.
0
Options
Munkus BeaverYou don't have to attend every argument you are invited to.Philosophy: Stoicism. Politics: Democratic SocialistRegistered User, ClubPAregular
Oh then yeah the card is worded and acts differently than previous effects that have done that so I can absolutely understand not playing around it perfectly. I would have absolutely missed that if my opponent didn't correct my actions.
I dunno how the paper magic meta is different from arena, but cry isn't that uncommon, and the exile effect often isn't that much of an afterthought IMO. I also don't really care about competitive magic though so I have no real input
With arena, those things are automated, which means you don't have to think about it. This kind of effect is fairly new to magic (usually these types of cards don't exile)
I dunno how the paper magic meta is different from arena, but cry isn't that uncommon, and the exile effect often isn't that much of an afterthought IMO. I also don't really care about competitive magic though so I have no real input
With arena, those things are automated, which means you don't have to think about it. This kind of effect is fairly new to magic (usually these types of cards don't exile)
and while there are sweepers that kill/exile (e.g. below), I think this is the first one that exiles everything that died during the entire turn, both before and after resolution
I dunno how the paper magic meta is different from arena, but cry isn't that uncommon, and the exile effect often isn't that much of an afterthought IMO. I also don't really care about competitive magic though so I have no real input
With arena, those things are automated, which means you don't have to think about it. This kind of effect is fairly new to magic (usually these types of cards don't exile)
and while there are sweepers that kill/exile (e.g. below), I think this is the first one that exiles everything that died during the entire turn, both before and after resolution
I dunno how the paper magic meta is different from arena, but cry isn't that uncommon, and the exile effect often isn't that much of an afterthought IMO. I also don't really care about competitive magic though so I have no real input
With arena, those things are automated, which means you don't have to think about it. This kind of effect is fairly new to magic (usually these types of cards don't exile)
and while there are sweepers that kill/exile (e.g. below), I think this is the first one that exiles everything that died during the entire turn, both before and after resolution
That one also does the same thing.
There's a slight difference with Cry of the Carnarium. Cry says, "if a creature would die this turn, exile it instead" or something to that effect. So even if you sacrifice a creature in response to Cry of the Carnarium, then when Cry resolves, that creature still died that turn and gets exiled instead.
+4
Options
KalTorakOne way or another, they all end up inthe Undercity.Registered Userregular
Cry exiles everything that it kills, everything that died earlier that turn, and everything that dies later that turn. Anger only exiles creatures that it damaged.
It'd be very easy to have a Cry resolve and forget to go through graveyards for something that died that turn, or to exile something that died later.
I dunno how the paper magic meta is different from arena, but cry isn't that uncommon, and the exile effect often isn't that much of an afterthought IMO. I also don't really care about competitive magic though so I have no real input
With arena, those things are automated, which means you don't have to think about it. This kind of effect is fairly new to magic (usually these types of cards don't exile)
and while there are sweepers that kill/exile (e.g. below), I think this is the first one that exiles everything that died during the entire turn, both before and after resolution
That one also does the same thing.
To clarify why this is incorrect:
You cast Anger, opponent sacs bodyguard to itself. It dies, then Anger hits stuff, Bodyguard is in the GY.
You cast Cry opponent sacs bodyguard to itself. It dies, then Cry hits stuff. Bodyguard is moved to exile by Cry's exile clause. You still get a death trigger for the bodyguard if it's relevant, but it is exiled.
I was so close to getting to that platinum constructed, and have lost 12 in a row and im down to almost dropping to Gold 3. I can't seem to get there regardless of list.
1. First non-male PT/MC winner and thereby
2. The first enby PT/MC winner
3. First English PT/MC winner
4. First winner under the new "Mythic Championship" label
KayWhat we need...Is a little bit of PANIC.Registered Userregular
The fact that Autumn hasn't had a GP Top 8 is confusing. They're an astonishingly good player. I've said hi a couple times at local GPs, but they actually used to play with some of my more local MTG friends, and thus know them better.
Genuinely impressed with the language used by coverage, misgendering all of twice that I caught on the final day, and never a “him”
Rich Hagon in particular was flawless, as far as I heard.
Bdm too. S’funny, the older guys were flawless but the younger guys dropped the “her”s. you’d think they would, as a generational consequence, be more used to a pronoun change? my lgs of choice has also been Marshall’s for the last decade(the rare fnm or prerelease he’s not traveling) and I know through personal experience he can do better, I don’t think he’s misgendered me once and we’ve played a bunch of times
Oh then yeah the card is worded and acts differently than previous effects that have done that so I can absolutely understand not playing around it perfectly. I would have absolutely missed that if my opponent didn't correct my actions.
Genuinely impressed with the language used by coverage, misgendering all of twice that I caught on the final day, and never a “him”
Rich Hagon in particular was flawless, as far as I heard.
Bdm too. S’funny, the older guys were flawless but the younger guys dropped the “her”s. you’d think they would, as a generational consequence, be more used to a pronoun change? my lgs of choice has also been Marshall’s for the last decade(the rare fnm or prerelease he’s not traveling) and I know through personal experience he can do better, I don’t think he’s misgendered me once and we’ve played a bunch of times
I think singular 'they' may be slightly more aliwn to most as something people use in their everyday lives. I almost never use it and qould likely fuck it up a few times.
Genuinely impressed with the language used by coverage, misgendering all of twice that I caught on the final day, and never a “him”
Rich Hagon in particular was flawless, as far as I heard.
Bdm too. S’funny, the older guys were flawless but the younger guys dropped the “her”s. you’d think they would, as a generational consequence, be more used to a pronoun change? my lgs of choice has also been Marshall’s for the last decade(the rare fnm or prerelease he’s not traveling) and I know through personal experience he can do better, I don’t think he’s misgendered me once and we’ve played a bunch of times
I think singular 'they' may be slightly more aliwn to most as something people use in their everyday lives. I almost never use it and qould likely fuck it up a few times.
This would be my guess as well. The fact that they never dropped "he/his" suggests that they got the general message down but fumbled on specifics occasionally. Live commentary is hard.
It has occured to me that the singular they ahould be the default pronoun in my vernacular but it's hard to get my brain to accept it after 36 years of gendered pronouns. Can someone just download the new firmware into my skull? TIA
It's a four card combo (you need two familiars to go infinite, right?) reliant on squishy creatures. You don't even need to tech against it besides the general philosophy of "kill weird suboptimal creatures because it's probably a jank combo"
I ate an engineer
0
Options
admanbunionize your workplaceSeattle, WARegistered Userregular
It has occured to me that the singular they ahould be the default pronoun in my vernacular but it's hard to get my brain to accept it after 36 years of gendered pronouns. Can someone just download the new firmware into my skull? TIA
I realized a few weeks ago that I default to “he” when discussing anonymous Magic Arena players with myself* and it has been both difficult and surprisingly effective at reprogramming my brain.
It has occured to me that the singular they ahould be the default pronoun in my vernacular but it's hard to get my brain to accept it after 36 years of gendered pronouns. Can someone just download the new firmware into my skull? TIA
I realized a few weeks ago that I default to “he” when discussing anonymous Magic Arena players with myself* and it has been both difficult and surprisingly effective at reprogramming my brain.
*yes I talk to myself a lot while playing Arena
I've found myself in the same situation, although usually it's via recounting good/bad beat stories and not self- dialogue.
AnialosCollies are love, Collies are life!Shadowbrook ColliesRegistered Userregular
I've finally saved up enough gems for a Traditional Draft in Arena. What do you guys suggest trying to draft? I know the AI prioritizes certain things so trying to draft those is futile.
Posts
No, it would.
With arena, those things are automated, which means you don't have to think about it. This kind of effect is fairly new to magic (usually these types of cards don't exile)
ineedmayo.com Eidolon Journal Updated
3DS FCode: 1993-7512-8991
a lot of the community seems really invested in it and to me it's just, shrug
not my lane to try and find people doing it, not my responsibility to mete out justice
Maybe it SHOULD be your job to mete out justice, have you tried it?
and while there are sweepers that kill/exile (e.g. below), I think this is the first one that exiles everything that died during the entire turn, both before and after resolution
That one also does the same thing.
There's a slight difference with Cry of the Carnarium. Cry says, "if a creature would die this turn, exile it instead" or something to that effect. So even if you sacrifice a creature in response to Cry of the Carnarium, then when Cry resolves, that creature still died that turn and gets exiled instead.
Cry exiles everything that it kills, everything that died earlier that turn, and everything that dies later that turn. Anger only exiles creatures that it damaged.
It'd be very easy to have a Cry resolve and forget to go through graveyards for something that died that turn, or to exile something that died later.
Reid Duke was so good about the game too, sad to see him knocked out, but stoked for a possible Autumn vs LSV final!
3DS FCode: 1993-7512-8991
To clarify why this is incorrect:
You cast Anger, opponent sacs bodyguard to itself. It dies, then Anger hits stuff, Bodyguard is in the GY.
You cast Cry opponent sacs bodyguard to itself. It dies, then Cry hits stuff. Bodyguard is moved to exile by Cry's exile clause. You still get a death trigger for the bodyguard if it's relevant, but it is exiled.
Good play by Ikawa to bait the trade.
Nintendo ID: Pastalonius
Smite\LoL:Gremlidin \ WoW & Overwatch & Hots: Gremlidin#1734
3ds: 3282-2248-0453
I know the format isn't Standard, but Mono-U seems like it'd REALLY benefit from this, and it's already strong.
Guess they benefit from being on the play twice though.
Steam: YOU FACE JARAXXUS| Twitch.tv: CainLoveless
A well-earned tackle, mind.
1. First non-male PT/MC winner and thereby
2. The first enby PT/MC winner
3. First English PT/MC winner
4. First winner under the new "Mythic Championship" label
Congrats to them, it was a great set of games!
ineedmayo.com Eidolon Journal Updated
3DS FCode: 1993-7512-8991
it's a hell of a way to start off their new OP branding at the very least
Rich Hagon in particular was flawless, as far as I heard.
Given Autumn's rep at Nationals (and I assume UK GPs) I think Rich has had more time to practice.
3DS FCode: 1993-7512-8991
Bdm too. S’funny, the older guys were flawless but the younger guys dropped the “her”s. you’d think they would, as a generational consequence, be more used to a pronoun change? my lgs of choice has also been Marshall’s for the last decade(the rare fnm or prerelease he’s not traveling) and I know through personal experience he can do better, I don’t think he’s misgendered me once and we’ve played a bunch of times
I think singular 'they' may be slightly more aliwn to most as something people use in their everyday lives. I almost never use it and qould likely fuck it up a few times.
This would be my guess as well. The fact that they never dropped "he/his" suggests that they got the general message down but fumbled on specifics occasionally. Live commentary is hard.
but I am having surprisingly good results with my biomancer's familiar, ruthless knave, slimefoot the stowaway infinite damage combo deck
I realized a few weeks ago that I default to “he” when discussing anonymous Magic Arena players with myself* and it has been both difficult and surprisingly effective at reprogramming my brain.
*yes I talk to myself a lot while playing Arena
I've found myself in the same situation, although usually it's via recounting good/bad beat stories and not self- dialogue.
I've been grinding Pauper, I ain't got time to update thread titles!