The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.
Should games feature characters that are bisexual/homosexual?
I think so-mostly because it's a fact of life, partially for the sake of realism.
Are you saying that we should somehow be able to recognize them?
You apparently think that all gays and bisexuals are eminently noticeable by their appearance.
I want to go on a rant here but I think that I should let you clear up your thesis.
Picardathon on
0
Irond WillWARNING: NO HURTFUL COMMENTS, PLEASE!!!!!Cambridge. MAModeratorMod Emeritus
edited June 2007
I think it's high time I was finally able to use the "pound a dude" button on my 360 controller. It's like no developer even supports this feature.
Really, though, I don't have a problem with it. It would probably be market suicide considering how many parents regard even casual exposure to homosexual themes as a horrible thing for their kids.
I've got no problem with the presence of bisexual or homosexual characters, but don't force it. I don't need to see Dante wearing an absolutely fabulous pink trenchcoat just to appease people, but if you can make it suitably realistic that a character likes, or prefers their own gender, go for it.
I've got no problem with the presence of bisexual or homosexual characters, but don't force it. I don't need to see Dante wearing an absolutely fabulous pink trenchcoat just to appease people, but if you can make it suitably realistic that a character likes, or prefers their own gender, go for it.
Because clearly one's choice in clothing is an indicator of sexuality.
I think so-mostly because it's a fact of life, partially for the sake of realism.
Are you saying that we should somehow be able to recognize them?
You apparently think that all gays and bisexuals are eminently noticeable by their appearance.
I want to go on a rant here but I think that I should let you clear up your thesis.
I'm as confused as picard. Is the OP talking about dating sims or something?
Though I do think we need a platformer starring Rip Taylor
I have nothing against homo/bisexuals in games. But it shouldn't really matter unless their sexuality is important to the story, but game writing needs to take a step up before we can really start worrying about that.
I mean we don't know the sexuality of the vast majority of video game characters anyway.
I've got no problem with the presence of bisexual or homosexual characters, but don't force it. I don't need to see Dante wearing an absolutely fabulous pink trenchcoat just to appease people, but if you can make it suitably realistic that a character likes, or prefers their own gender, go for it.
Because clearly one's choice in clothing is an indicator of sexuality.
How old are you, again?
I was making a joke. The joke being that they would not only take a normally-straight character and make them gay for no reason, but would do it very flamboyantly.
I really think, and sadly, that making a main character homosexual would be market suicide.
I remember when they announced GTA:SA, people actually complaining about not wanting to play as a black guy. Now imagine how many people would complain or ignore a game starring a gay character.
I've got no problem with the presence of bisexual or homosexual characters, but don't force it. I don't need to see Dante wearing an absolutely fabulous pink trenchcoat just to appease people, but if you can make it suitably realistic that a character likes, or prefers their own gender, go for it.
Because clearly one's choice in clothing is an indicator of sexuality.
How old are you, again?
I was making a joke. The joke being that they would not only take a normally-straight character and make them gay for no reason, but would do it very flamboyantly.
I remember when they announced GTA:SA, people actually complaining about not wanting to play as a black guy. Now imagine how many people would complain or ignore a game starring a gay character.
And exactly how many copies did San Andreas sell?
YodaTuna on
0
ShadowenSnores in the morningLoserdomRegistered Userregular
edited June 2007
I don't get it. Do people ask, "Should video games have black characters?" Or "Should video games have women characters?"
Asking it about gays makes about as much sense to me as either of those.
And after I post, I realize that apparently people do ask the question "Should this game have a black character?"
I remember when they announced GTA:SA, people actually complaining about not wanting to play as a black guy. Now imagine how many people would complain or ignore a game starring a gay character.
Really, television just got to the point where gay characters were more than just stereotypical flamers. Billy Crystal on Soap may have been one of the first to decently portray a homosexual, but it hasn't picked up much since then.
I don't see a decent narrative starring or otherwise featuring a homosexual character or relationship with any level of decency or seriousness in this decade. I mean, fuck, look at God Hand. Great game, featured a pair of gay characters that were villains. After beating them, the hero looks down and makes a snide comment about their anii.
Really, television just got to the point where gay characters were more than just stereotypical flamers. Billy Crystal on Soap may have been one of the first to decently portray a homosexual, but it hasn't picked up much since then.
I don't see a decent narrative starring or otherwise featuring a homosexual character or relationship with any level of decency or seriousness in this decade. I mean, fuck, look at God Hand. Great game, featured a pair of gay characters that were villains. After beating them, the hero looks down and makes a snide comment about their anii.
Issue: God Hand also had you fighting a GORILLA. And had poisonous chihuahuas. That game handled NOTHING with any level of decency or seriousness. Great game, but it is ridiculous and over the top, and on purpose.
yalborap on
0
Irond WillWARNING: NO HURTFUL COMMENTS, PLEASE!!!!!Cambridge. MAModeratorMod Emeritus
I've got no problem with the presence of bisexual or homosexual characters, but don't force it. I don't need to see Dante wearing an absolutely fabulous pink trenchcoat just to appease people, but if you can make it suitably realistic that a character likes, or prefers their own gender, go for it.
What, draping him in red leather was too straight for you?
Irond Will on
0
Irond WillWARNING: NO HURTFUL COMMENTS, PLEASE!!!!!Cambridge. MAModeratorMod Emeritus
I have nothing against homo/bisexuals in games. But it shouldn't really matter unless their sexuality is important to the story, but game writing needs to take a step up before we can really start worrying about that.
I mean we don't know the sexuality of the vast majority of video game characters anyway.
Enchanted Arms had a central flamboyant yaoi-type character as part of the story.
I've got no problem with the presence of bisexual or homosexual characters, but don't force it. I don't need to see Dante wearing an absolutely fabulous pink trenchcoat just to appease people, but if you can make it suitably realistic that a character likes, or prefers their own gender, go for it.
What, draping him in red leather was too straight for you?
Really, television just got to the point where gay characters were more than just stereotypical flamers. Billy Crystal on Soap may have been one of the first to decently portray a homosexual, but it hasn't picked up much since then.
Well, there was Will & Grace. I guess.
Though I remember hearing about some bizarre plot twist where Will winds up deciding he's straight and fucks Grace.
So... maybe not so much.
Also, there was that DS9 episode with Jadzia and that other Trill chick, although they qualify that with the premise that they were husband and wife in previous hosts.
Target Practice on
0
Irond WillWARNING: NO HURTFUL COMMENTS, PLEASE!!!!!Cambridge. MAModeratorMod Emeritus
I've got no problem with the presence of bisexual or homosexual characters, but don't force it. I don't need to see Dante wearing an absolutely fabulous pink trenchcoat just to appease people, but if you can make it suitably realistic that a character likes, or prefers their own gender, go for it.
What, draping him in red leather was too straight for you?
I've got no problem with the presence of bisexual or homosexual characters, but don't force it. I don't need to see Dante wearing an absolutely fabulous pink trenchcoat just to appease people, but if you can make it suitably realistic that a character likes, or prefers their own gender, go for it.
What, draping him in red leather was too straight for you?
I mean, I'd like to see some main characters in JRPGs be older than 16 (and not be whiny little bitches all the time who just happen to be the world's last hope), but it's not going to happen.
I have nothing against homo/bisexuals in games. But it shouldn't really matter unless their sexuality is important to the story, but game writing needs to take a step up before we can really start worrying about that.
I mean we don't know the sexuality of the vast majority of video game characters anyway.
Enchanted Arms had a central flamboyant yaoi-type character as part of the story.
The merchants from Shadow Hearts 2 were pretty flamboyant, what with their naked man card collecting.
Really, television just got to the point where gay characters were more than just stereotypical flamers. Billy Crystal on Soap may have been one of the first to decently portray a homosexual, but it hasn't picked up much since then.
I don't see a decent narrative starring or otherwise featuring a homosexual character or relationship with any level of decency or seriousness in this decade. I mean, fuck, look at God Hand. Great game, featured a pair of gay characters that were villains. After beating them, the hero looks down and makes a snide comment about their anii.
Issue: God Hand also had you fighting a GORILLA. And had poisonous chihuahuas. That game handled NOTHING with any level of decency or seriousness. Great game, but it is ridiculous and over the top, and on purpose.
I mean, that's true, but my point was that I couldn't readily recall another instance of homosexuality in a video game. 'Cept maybe Tingle, but you know.
Wonder_Hippie on
0
Irond WillWARNING: NO HURTFUL COMMENTS, PLEASE!!!!!Cambridge. MAModeratorMod Emeritus
I mean, I'd like to see some main characters in JRPGs be older than 16 (and not be whiny little bitches all the time who just happen to be the world's last hope), but it's not going to happen.
Androgynous teenagers are our ultimate saviors, Marty.
some rpg had a gay character
metal gear solid 2 had vamp, the creepy as bisexual vampire, and MGS3 had Volgin, the creepy ass bisexual evil russian general
bully lets you smooch dudes along with girls
but yeah, no one would want to play as a gay dude. video games are marketed to youngish men, and who do they want to bang in the virtual world, busty prostitutes or toned twinks?
How many realistic heterosexual relationships are there in video-games? I'm not optimistic.
I wish I could lime this even harder. I don't like silly romantic plots getting ham handed by a shitty team of emo video game writers, I definitely won't like one if it feels like the relationship is homosexual just to be "interesting" or "different" or "edgy."
You shouldn't make a gay character just because there hasn't been one before, you should make one because somehow his sexual preference impacts on the game in a somewhat entertaining or critical way.
It's always going to happen in an industry dominated by men and aimed largely at adolescent boys. One of the reasons we need more women in the creative process.
You shouldn't make a gay character just because there hasn't been one before, you should make one because somehow his sexual preference impacts on the game in a somewhat entertaining or critical way.
Oh and umm, everyone is gay for bridget.
I want a game where the lead character comes on to the player through the fourth wall.
Æthelred on
pokes: 1505 8032 8399
0
Irond WillWARNING: NO HURTFUL COMMENTS, PLEASE!!!!!Cambridge. MAModeratorMod Emeritus
You shouldn't make a gay character just because there hasn't been one before, you should make one because somehow his sexual preference impacts on the game in a somewhat entertaining or critical way.
Oh and umm, everyone is gay for bridget.
I want a game where the lead character comes on to the player through the fourth wall.
Its about time a xander (from drawn together) got a freaking game.
I don't have a problem with a gay dude being in game. I do have a problem with a gay dude's sexuality being crammed down my throat with a "SEE - HES GAY! HEY GUESS WHAT? HES GAY!!!"
I also didn't like san andreas, not cos of a black dude, but I hate that gangster/hood crap so much.
Posts
Just going to have to get more gay game makers. Then when people refer to a game as "gay" they may at least be accurate.
Are you saying that we should somehow be able to recognize them?
You apparently think that all gays and bisexuals are eminently noticeable by their appearance.
I want to go on a rant here but I think that I should let you clear up your thesis.
Really, though, I don't have a problem with it. It would probably be market suicide considering how many parents regard even casual exposure to homosexual themes as a horrible thing for their kids.
aw too late
You might as well ask if games should feature Black characters.
Because clearly one's choice in clothing is an indicator of sexuality.
How old are you, again?
I'm as confused as picard. Is the OP talking about dating sims or something?
I mean we don't know the sexuality of the vast majority of video game characters anyway.
I was making a joke. The joke being that they would not only take a normally-straight character and make them gay for no reason, but would do it very flamboyantly.
I obviously can't joke. Sor-fucking-ry, you dick.
I remember when they announced GTA:SA, people actually complaining about not wanting to play as a black guy. Now imagine how many people would complain or ignore a game starring a gay character.
YOU SHOULD BE SORRY.
White FC: 0819 3350 1787
And exactly how many copies did San Andreas sell?
Asking it about gays makes about as much sense to me as either of those.
And after I post, I realize that apparently people do ask the question "Should this game have a black character?"
*shakes his head with mild contempt*
One zillion.
I don't see a decent narrative starring or otherwise featuring a homosexual character or relationship with any level of decency or seriousness in this decade. I mean, fuck, look at God Hand. Great game, featured a pair of gay characters that were villains. After beating them, the hero looks down and makes a snide comment about their anii.
Issue: God Hand also had you fighting a GORILLA. And had poisonous chihuahuas. That game handled NOTHING with any level of decency or seriousness. Great game, but it is ridiculous and over the top, and on purpose.
It. Was. A. JOKE!
Though I remember hearing about some bizarre plot twist where Will winds up deciding he's straight and fucks Grace.
So... maybe not so much.
Also, there was that DS9 episode with Jadzia and that other Trill chick, although they qualify that with the premise that they were husband and wife in previous hosts.
...Dammit.
Not many games really shoot for realism.
I mean, I'd like to see some main characters in JRPGs be older than 16 (and not be whiny little bitches all the time who just happen to be the world's last hope), but it's not going to happen.
The merchants from Shadow Hearts 2 were pretty flamboyant, what with their naked man card collecting.
I mean, that's true, but my point was that I couldn't readily recall another instance of homosexuality in a video game. 'Cept maybe Tingle, but you know.
some rpg had a gay character
metal gear solid 2 had vamp, the creepy as bisexual vampire, and MGS3 had Volgin, the creepy ass bisexual evil russian general
bully lets you smooch dudes along with girls
but yeah, no one would want to play as a gay dude. video games are marketed to youngish men, and who do they want to bang in the virtual world, busty prostitutes or toned twinks?
I wish I could lime this even harder. I don't like silly romantic plots getting ham handed by a shitty team of emo video game writers, I definitely won't like one if it feels like the relationship is homosexual just to be "interesting" or "different" or "edgy."
Oh and umm, everyone is gay for bridget.
plus gays because they're like women right
I want a game where the lead character comes on to the player through the fourth wall.
Really put that rumble feature to use, huh?
I really don't have an issue with Luigi questing to save his boyfriend from Donkey Kong.
That way, when homophobic parents get all uppity, you can point out that junior CHOSE the butt sex option.
Its about time a xander (from drawn together) got a freaking game.
I don't have a problem with a gay dude being in game. I do have a problem with a gay dude's sexuality being crammed down my throat with a "SEE - HES GAY! HEY GUESS WHAT? HES GAY!!!"
I also didn't like san andreas, not cos of a black dude, but I hate that gangster/hood crap so much.
I know; it was a bit like "hey cool, a black lead character for once. Wait, he's a gangster.. yay?"
Enchanted Arms handled it so badly though. So sick of the stereotype.
The harder the rain, honey, the sweeter the sun.