The new forums will be named Coin Return (based on the most recent vote)! You can check on the status and timeline of the transition to the new forums here.
The Guiding Principles and New Rules document is now in effect.
EA Sports has recently stated that they will be adapting even more sports into game licences, and with the recent attempt from EA to buy out Take2 and its 2K sports line, Is there a chance or the demand to warrant a CFL licenced game? How many Canadians here would purchase a game like this? Are there any Americans that watch or care about CFL Football?
I figure the audience for a game like this is probably low, as there are many Canadians that actually prefer NFL, but couldn't the company that has brought you Madden and NCAA for countless years, and also an Arena Football game, couldn't they turn out a reskined, re-rostered Madden with a few rule and field differences with no problems?
What other sports have yet to get the EA treatment that you'd like to see? Randy Ferby: Championship Curling 2009? EA ultimate frisbee.
The problem with hoping for a CFL game, I think, is the way the developers look at markets. NTSC U/C titles are made for the U.S. and Canada, to be sure, but for the most part (speaking as a Canadian) they're made for the U.S.
The reason for this isn't a comment on culture, but market size.
Estimated population of Canada: 33,390,141 (July 2007)
Estimated population of the U.S: 301,139,947 (July 2007)
I can't say I know how many Americans are all about the Canadian football, but something tells me when they want a football game they'll go out and buy Madden like every other North American. Even if such a game existed, it wouldn't surprise me if half the Canadian football fans stuck with Madden. It would certainly find its niche with hard core football enthusiasts up here and ex-pats down in the States or oversees, but I can't see this number being big enough to warrant the amount of cash that goes into game development and promotion these days.
Nobody hopes to make it big in Canada. Making it big in Canada is still, for the most part, not the rout to fortune and fame.
Chance on
'Chance, you are the best kind of whore.' -Henroid
I don't particularly care either way aboot the NFL or CFL, eh. If they have some log rolling man or igloo building games, I'll be all over that, eh. But if I was all civilized-like, I'd probably enjoy sittin on my chesterfield and playin some NFL and CFL all in one darn game, eh. But it's EA, so I'd probably have to drop money down on three separate games for college, NFL and CFL, eh.
JeanHeartbroken papa bearGatineau, QuébecRegistered Userregular
edited March 2008
Just give us a hockey game on Wii already and I'll be happy.
I couldnt care less about football, be it american or canadian.
Jean on
"You won't destroy us, You won't destroy our democracy. We are a small but proud nation. No one can bomb us to silence. No one can scare us from being Norway. This evening and tonight, we'll take care of each other. That's what we do best when attacked'' - Jens Stoltenberg
I would buy a CFL game in a second. Hell, I'd settle for some CFL DLC for Madden. Just give me the logos and player names and I'd pretend the rules are different. Of course, it'll never happen because the market is way too small to profit from this.
I've always wondered, forgetting the rule differences, how much work would it be to take Madden, build a team and change all the names and make it your favourite CFL team? Can you design logos?
ya, never gonna happen just for the fact that we have 1/10 the number of people.
they could take the madden engine, change the rules, then add the players/teams and they still wouldn't make money on the game.
As much as I loooove the CFL, a league with a 4.2million dollar salary cap to split among 50 players really shoudlnt' get a video game.(to all the americans, yes, $4.2million as in, $4,200,000)
A curling game would be alot of fun on the Wii, as for release time, inturn/outturn, speed. I think it would add a whole new variation to something similar like Wii bowling.
The CFL option in Madden would be a great way to open the league to american audiences as well. I could see die hard Maddenites having fun with the 3 downs, no fair catch, wider field, and 20 yard deep endzones, as a challenge to the game that tests thier strategy and skills in a new way. Just remember that short passes aren't worth the risk.
A curling game would be alot of fun on the Wii, as for release time, inturn/outturn, speed. I think it would add a whole new variation to something similar like Wii bowling.
The CFL option in Madden would be a great way to open the league to american audiences as well. I could see die hard Maddenites having fun with the 3 downs, no fair catch, wider field, and 20 yard deep endzones, as a challenge to the game that tests thier strategy and skills in a new way. Just remember that short passes aren't worth the risk.
I betcha we will see curling in the upcoming (in 1.5 years) Mario and Sonic at the Winter Olympics. I really want that game, and curling in the vein of the M&S Beijing game would totally fly.
Speaking of Mario and Canadian sports. I want a damn Mario Hockey game! Come who wouldn't love seeing DK crushing Mario with a huge check along the boards. Or having Diddy in nets flipping around stopping pucks.
I would looooove a CFL game.
But, the combined salary of all the CFL doesn't even meet one NFL teams salary. Also, with the Bills playing games in Toronto now I could see some expansion of the NFL into Canada.
CFL option in Madden sounds like the best bet. It would take almost nothing to implement too.
As for Canadian sports to make into games:
- Lacrosse
- Curling
- Broomball (wtf eh?)
Also, Mario Hockey would be awesome.
Curling would be cool.
Mario Hockey is genius.
Retarded_Turkey on
0
JacobyOHHHHH IT’S A SNAKECreature - SnakeRegistered Userregular
edited March 2008
I just want whoever is making the most popular NHL game to send the money trucks to the CBC and get the Hockey Night In Canada people in on it. Coach's Corner FTW!
I think that the internet has been for years on the path to creating what is essentially an electronic Necronomicon: A collection of blasphemous unrealities so perverse that to even glimpse at its contents, if but for a moment, is to irrevocably forfeit a portion of your sanity.
Xbox - PearlBlueS0ul, Steam
If you ever need to talk to someone, feel free to message me. Yes, that includes you.
I live in the US, but I'd but be interested in Canadian sports games. Change is good, and it could be interesting to learn about teams in another country. Granted, I've bought one or two madden games ever, so I'm probably not terribly indicative of the market though.
That's about the extent of my knowledge on the subject.
I'm surprised they don't attempt to lump the CFL and the European Football League (is it called that? does it still exist?) in with Madden. Don't they kinda do this with FIFA or am I mistaken?
Then again seeing as how American football is mostly an....er....American interest, I suppose I can't imagine adding the other leagues as being cost effective.
As far as Canadian sports go, I'm all for it if the market is available.
Frigging A there should be a CFL mode for Madden. Why not? They have a version directed at Spanish speaking gamers. It can't be that hard to change the rules and the field. They used to have NFL Europe teams. Why not the CFL? I'm sure it wouldn't cost EA too much to get the license. And put in an Ottawa Renegades logo/uniform kit so I can resurrect my beloved Ottawa "Beavers". I miss them.
And wouldn't it be awesome to be playing and after a first down you would hear:
"You won't destroy us, You won't destroy our democracy. We are a small but proud nation. No one can bomb us to silence. No one can scare us from being Norway. This evening and tonight, we'll take care of each other. That's what we do best when attacked'' - Jens Stoltenberg
Frigging A there should be a CFL mode for Madden. Why not? They have a version directed at Spanish speaking gamers. It can't be that hard to change the rules and the field. They used to have NFL Europe teams. Why not the CFL? I'm sure it wouldn't cost EA too much to get the license. And put in an Ottawa Renegades logo/uniform kit so I can resurrect my beloved Ottawa "Beavers". I miss them.
And wouldn't it be awesome to be playing and after a first down you would hear:
Frigging A there should be a CFL mode for Madden. Why not? They have a version directed at Spanish speaking gamers. It can't be that hard to change the rules and the field. They used to have NFL Europe teams. Why not the CFL? I'm sure it wouldn't cost EA too much to get the license. And put in an Ottawa Renegades logo/uniform kit so I can resurrect my beloved Ottawa "Beavers". I miss them.
And wouldn't it be awesome to be playing and after a first down you would hear:
Frigging A there should be a CFL mode for Madden. Why not? They have a version directed at Spanish speaking gamers. It can't be that hard to change the rules and the field. They used to have NFL Europe teams. Why not the CFL? I'm sure it wouldn't cost EA too much to get the license. And put in an Ottawa Renegades logo/uniform kit so I can resurrect my beloved Ottawa "Beavers". I miss them.
And wouldn't it be awesome to be playing and after a first down you would hear:
I'm sure they could get the license for like a bucket of chicken and case of beer to each PLAYER.
Come on man, we're not THAT cheap up here.
Well, you know that if EA came knocking on the CFL's door asking for the license the CFL would pretty much give it away. Could you imagine the exposure.
I'd be all over a curling game but I'm one of those Canadians who is a giant NFL fan. I couldn't care less about the CFL, though sometimes I watch because my province has a good team.
Posts
That would be great.
The reason for this isn't a comment on culture, but market size.
Estimated population of Canada: 33,390,141 (July 2007)
Estimated population of the U.S: 301,139,947 (July 2007)
I can't say I know how many Americans are all about the Canadian football, but something tells me when they want a football game they'll go out and buy Madden like every other North American. Even if such a game existed, it wouldn't surprise me if half the Canadian football fans stuck with Madden. It would certainly find its niche with hard core football enthusiasts up here and ex-pats down in the States or oversees, but I can't see this number being big enough to warrant the amount of cash that goes into game development and promotion these days.
Nobody hopes to make it big in Canada. Making it big in Canada is still, for the most part, not the rout to fortune and fame.
I couldnt care less about football, be it american or canadian.
Let's see some hardcore physics engine action in a curling game!
*KACLACKBOOM*
And red beats yellow by three points, after yellow took out all of their own rocks.
The skip would spend most of his time telling people what to do. Tycho would love it.
I've always wondered, forgetting the rule differences, how much work would it be to take Madden, build a team and change all the names and make it your favourite CFL team? Can you design logos?
Switch - SW-3699-5063-5018
they could take the madden engine, change the rules, then add the players/teams and they still wouldn't make money on the game.
As much as I loooove the CFL, a league with a 4.2million dollar salary cap to split among 50 players really shoudlnt' get a video game.(to all the americans, yes, $4.2million as in, $4,200,000)
The CFL option in Madden would be a great way to open the league to american audiences as well. I could see die hard Maddenites having fun with the 3 downs, no fair catch, wider field, and 20 yard deep endzones, as a challenge to the game that tests thier strategy and skills in a new way. Just remember that short passes aren't worth the risk.
I betcha we will see curling in the upcoming (in 1.5 years) Mario and Sonic at the Winter Olympics. I really want that game, and curling in the vein of the M&S Beijing game would totally fly.
Switch - SW-3699-5063-5018
But, the combined salary of all the CFL doesn't even meet one NFL teams salary. Also, with the Bills playing games in Toronto now I could see some expansion of the NFL into Canada.
As for Canadian sports to make into games:
- Lacrosse
- Curling
- Broomball (wtf eh?)
Also, Mario Hockey would be awesome.
Curling would be cool.
Mario Hockey is genius.
Switch: nin.codes/roldford
Also, BC SUCKS! (Just for you turkey)
If you ever need to talk to someone, feel free to message me. Yes, that includes you.
Well, yes they do.
In case your referring to my avatar, it's Winnipeg:P
That's about the extent of my knowledge on the subject.
I'm surprised they don't attempt to lump the CFL and the European Football League (is it called that? does it still exist?) in with Madden. Don't they kinda do this with FIFA or am I mistaken?
Then again seeing as how American football is mostly an....er....American interest, I suppose I can't imagine adding the other leagues as being cost effective.
As far as Canadian sports go, I'm all for it if the market is available.
And wouldn't it be awesome to be playing and after a first down you would hear:
ARRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRGGGGGGGGGGGGGGOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSSSSSSSSS!
I don't like the Argos but the chant is awesome.
I'm sure they could get the license for like a bucket of chicken and case of beer to each team.
Come on man, we're not THAT cheap up here.
Well, you know that if EA came knocking on the CFL's door asking for the license the CFL would pretty much give it away. Could you imagine the exposure.
oh my god
another person from saskatchewan
I never thought I'd see the day
I would probably buy a CFL themed game
and yes, Mario Hockey would, in fact, be the shit. Not shit, but the shit.
Every single person from Sask that I have met either online on in person (I work with 2!) is a CFL nutjob. What's up with that?
Video Evidence
Xbox Live Gamertag: Suplex86
Dear friends: let me just say there is a reason the entire nation of Canada treats people from Saskatchewan very delicately.
Let us leave it at that.
As for shoving it in as an extra with Madden, the field size and core rules are different enough that I doubt the AI could adapt.
猿も木から落ちる
Haha yes.
Don't get me wrong I looooove my NFL (Go Steelers!) but, the CFL will always be number one in my books.
This. The AI can't even really cope with one set of instructions.
It is kinda sad when you realize that NFL Blitz for the N64 is the closest thing to a CFL game you're ever going to get.
How about Mario and Sonic at the Lumberjack games? That would be pretty neat.
won the grey cup this year yeaaaaaaahhhhhh
I never finish anyth
Oo\ Ironsizide