We have two confirmed witch kills: enlightenedbum and lonelyahava. We know they were witches because the vigilante killed them and their role was revealed as such. Also, in both cases the narration portrayed it as occurring to the witches in mid-newting. That leaves us with the five we burned.
I'm pretty sure we can't kill seven witches and still have a game going. I still believe there are only about five of them, which clearly means we've missed our mark at least three times (assuming one left), or maybe they're all wrong. I think, based almost entirely on intuition, that we've hit at least one. We've had pretty good reasoning for most on that list, I have trouble believing they were all wrong.
So lets assume a pretty bad scenario: that we have killed three total. That leaves two. Under that, lets consider how much time we have. Best case, we nail both of them to a cross consecutively, game ends Sunday night. Worst case, we lose three a night and don't hit shit, game ends Sunday night. If we hit one, we go to Tuesday night. That is our time table.
So, ten left, two witches. It has been five full days. Surely we each have theories by now. Let's hear 'em.
We have two confirmed witch kills: enlightenedbum and lonelyahava. We know they were witches because the vigilante killed them and their role was revealed as such. Also, in both cases the narration portrayed it as occurring to the witches in mid-newting. That leaves us with the five we burned.
I'm pretty sure we can't kill seven witches and still have a game going. I still believe there are only about five of them, which clearly means we've missed our mark at least three times (assuming one left), or maybe they're all wrong. I think, based almost entirely on intuition, that we've hit at least one. We've had pretty good reasoning for most on that list, I have trouble believing they were all wrong.
So lets assume a pretty bad scenario: that we have killed three total. That leaves two. Under that, lets consider how much time we have. Best case, we nail both of them to a cross consecutively, game ends Sunday night. Worst case, we lose three a night and don't hit shit, game ends Sunday night. If we hit one, we go to Tuesday night. That is our time table.
So, ten left, two witches. It has been five full days. Surely we each have theories by now. Let's hear 'em.
The problem is we don't know which of our votes were right, and which were wrong. I agree, I think it highly unlikely that we didn't hit a single witch with the vote yet. But that doesn't really help narrow down any potential targets. It's really hard to use any kind of voting record or anything to link bad-guy-ness when we don't know which votes to compare. Except, of course, for enlightenedbum and ahava, but they both died several days ago and didn't really do much.
So yeah, don't really have any good targets or theories. Although I guess, just from what's happened recently, that I'm leaning towards delroland. Just because I don't find you (Dusda) suspicious for the very reasons he seems to, which seem silly: you're trying to promote discussion and ideas. And I dunno, you did it in a a manner that seems legit. But I have a feeling delro was just being silly and not evil. So I dunno. I'm gonna hold off my vote for a bit (even though there are only several hours left) and see if I get a brainblast. If not I'll probably go with delro.
Dusdais ashamed of this postSLC, UTRegistered Userregular
edited March 2009
Ugh, I hate knee jerk voting people like that. However, unless someone else out there has some information we don't (either we have the worst seer imaginable, or there isn't one), I may not have a choice.
I'll hold my vote for now, but we're running out of time.
Frankly, at this point, I think you and kime are in cahoots. Unfortunately, voting anyone off gives us jack squat as far as info goes, and I'm not sure we have a vig left to give us conclusive info.
I just thought the whole, "Follow me, I know the way!" bit felt a little Badguy Endgame to me.
delroland on
EVE: Online - the most fun you will ever have not playing a game.
"Go up, thou bald head." -2 Kings 2:23
I just thought the whole, "Follow me, I know the way!" bit felt a little Badguy Endgame to me.
Ummmm. Can I point out that neither Dusda nor I actually said anything remotely like that? And that, in fact, you were the one who threw the first vote?
Well, I'm pointing it out anyways. Your statement there is rather hypocritical.
Ugh, I hate knee jerk voting people like that. However, unless someone else out there has some information we don't (either we have the worst seer imaginable, or there isn't one), I may not have a choice.
I'll hold my vote for now, but we're running out of time.
Yeah, we have less than three hours left and not even a page since the last narration. People are being quiet and it isn't helping .
Dusdais ashamed of this postSLC, UTRegistered Userregular
edited March 2009
Where did I say follow me? I said "here's what I think, lets see what everyone thinks and maybe we can piece together something solid to go on." Pardon me for wanting something besides another day of us shoving our heads in the sand.
Well, since it seems we aren't going to be getting any more discussion, I guess I'll just go with delroland. Not that you seem evil, I just don't think Dusda is.
Well, since it seems we aren't going to be getting any more discussion, I guess I'll just go with delroland. Not that you seem evil, I just don't think Dusda is.
...
Actually, I changed my mind. You are eviiiiiil!
OooOoOo
Kime, that sentence is so contradictory, that if I were playing, I would vote for myself just so I would have to read it.
Just wanted you to know
OooOoOo
Well, since it seems we aren't going to be getting any more discussion, I guess I'll just go with delroland. Not that you seem evil, I just don't think Dusda is.
...
Actually, I changed my mind. You are eviiiiiil!
OooOoOo
Kime, that sentence is so contradictory, that if I were playing, I would vote for myself just so I would have to read it.
Just wanted you to know
OooOoOo
Ultros64 was butchering a cow in his shop today when a cloaked figure came in asking for lamb’s blood. Lamb’s Blood was in rather high demand lately and when pressed on why he needed it the cloaked man replied.
“To turn you into a newtâ€
The butcher shop closed early that day and no one ever saw Ultros64 ever again.
Simonwolf the carpenter had been overproducing woodcrafts. This was due to the overwhelmingly huge stockpile of wood Mr. Defecation had left after his disappearance and it needed to be used. Now simonwolf had so much product that everything he made was now worthless. Taking pity on the soon to be penniless pauper a cloaked figure came by and gave simonwolf a simpler existence.
Today Delroland the Rancher was on the stand.
“Delroland you know the charges that are being brought against you. How do you plead?â€
“Not Guiltyâ€
“Very well on with the prosecution. Now did you or did you not have intercourse with your livestock?â€
“What kind of question is that?â€
“Everyone knows witchs are the most perverted creatures imaginable now just answer the question.â€
“Well umm, of course I haven’t you know done it with a sheep or anything.â€
Delroland was visibly sweating.
“What about a cow?â€
“*cough* *ahem* Well it depends on your definition of intercourse, I mean, effectively I’m giving a handjob to a cow to milk it.â€
“GIVING HANDJOBS TO A COW!?! YOU ARE A DISGUSTING WITCH AND YOU WILL BURN ON EARTH AND IN HELL. TAKE HIM AWAYâ€
And from that day onward, anyone who handled livestock was never looked at the same way again.
After the burning the Mayor had an announcement.
Umm, do to lack of funds since our tax collector is deceased I’m afraid we can only afford to continue the trials one more day. I hope you’ve all enjoyed yourselves this past week. Have a good evening and we’ll see you same time, same place to burn another witch.
Sunday is the last day
HOWEVER, due to circumstances beyond my control I won’t have the final results and narration up until Monday morning. Apologies for the inconvenience.
Ohtsam on
0
Options
Tommy2Handswhat is this where am iRegistered Userregular
After the burning the Mayor had an announcement.
Umm, do to lack of funds since our tax collector is deceased I’m afraid we can only afford to continue the trials one more day. I hope you’ve all enjoyed yourselves this past week. Have a good evening and we’ll see you same time, same place to burn another witch.
Oh wait, yeah, I forgot about the witch burning thing. Though, I think in all of the narration, it never mentioned him getting burned. Also, I though Masons didn't have any powers usually.
I just figured the shooter was Jason Todd, since the shootings stopped that night.
The shootings didn't occur night one, though, either. And the shooter never killed anyone except a witch. That's rather uncanny aim. I'm thinking maybe it only works if he targets a witch? Or it may have been Jason Todd and he just forgot an order the first night. And Zand, being a "FreeMason" doesn't necessarily mean he was a "mason" in Phalla-terms. Rarely are masons actually given a role name of "mason." And sometimes masons have powers, yeah, although I wouldn't have expected it here in just a mini.
Gonna have to think about the vote some more. . . It would be kind of nice if someone could admit to being a witch and make it easy on us :P.
Dusdais ashamed of this postSLC, UTRegistered Userregular
edited March 2009
Actually kime, you're probably spot on. It makes sense that the vigilante would only kill if the target turned out to be a witch; each night a shot was fired it was during an "attempted newting." That is probably exactly how it works. It's also an interesting mix of vig and seer; that sounds like something Sloth would put in the game.
Since this is the last day I will reveal and tell you that I'm the guard in this game. If someone wants to step up and also claim that title I'm fine with it, because I know who to vote for and it probably would increase the village chance of survival by narrowing down the possible targets.
You didn't bold the "l" in "reveal." It kind of bothers me. . .
Are you now? Ugh you bugger, why couldn't you have done this earlier? You wait until 4 hours before the game literally ends to give a reveal that cannot be proven in any way before endgame . And a reveal that doesn't seem to serve any purpose so far. . .
Bleh. OK, assuming you are telling the truth, do you have any leads? Did you manage to get networked or anything?
Posts
But I heard you were his father's brother's nephew's cousin's former roommate.
"Go up, thou bald head." -2 Kings 2:23
arasaki
Ultros64
kime
TheLawinator
delroland
MacGuffin
Dusda
Zandracon
JaysonFour
GrimmyTOA
Sticks
Toxic Toys
Tommy2Hands
So lets assume a pretty bad scenario: that we have killed three total. That leaves two. Under that, lets consider how much time we have. Best case, we nail both of them to a cross consecutively, game ends Sunday night. Worst case, we lose three a night and don't hit shit, game ends Sunday night. If we hit one, we go to Tuesday night. That is our time table.
So, ten left, two witches. It has been five full days. Surely we each have theories by now. Let's hear 'em.
I would have died to inactivus anyway.
Oooooo
Either he's in a good network, and my vote won't get enough support, or he's a witch trying to witch-handle the vote.
"Go up, thou bald head." -2 Kings 2:23
You are asuming that there is a good network and that it has more people in it then they're are witches left.
delroland
If there are more witches than there are networked goodies, we're screwed.
"Go up, thou bald head." -2 Kings 2:23
That is one of the things that has me worried. I don't have a network at all. Very unusual at this point in the game.
And how am I speaking in tongues?
!Delroland. Seems a little more suspicious than Dusda at the moment.
The problem is we don't know which of our votes were right, and which were wrong. I agree, I think it highly unlikely that we didn't hit a single witch with the vote yet. But that doesn't really help narrow down any potential targets. It's really hard to use any kind of voting record or anything to link bad-guy-ness when we don't know which votes to compare. Except, of course, for enlightenedbum and ahava, but they both died several days ago and didn't really do much.
So yeah, don't really have any good targets or theories. Although I guess, just from what's happened recently, that I'm leaning towards delroland. Just because I don't find you (Dusda) suspicious for the very reasons he seems to, which seem silly: you're trying to promote discussion and ideas. And I dunno, you did it in a a manner that seems legit. But I have a feeling delro was just being silly and not evil. So I dunno. I'm gonna hold off my vote for a bit (even though there are only several hours left) and see if I get a brainblast. If not I'll probably go with delro.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
I'll hold my vote for now, but we're running out of time.
I just thought the whole, "Follow me, I know the way!" bit felt a little Badguy Endgame to me.
"Go up, thou bald head." -2 Kings 2:23
AH! How did you find out!?
Agreed, which is the biggest problem here. We've just got so little info to work with. . .
Ummmm. Can I point out that neither Dusda nor I actually said anything remotely like that? And that, in fact, you were the one who threw the first vote?
Well, I'm pointing it out anyways. Your statement there is rather hypocritical.
Yeah, we have less than three hours left and not even a page since the last narration. People are being quiet and it isn't helping
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
And yes, I'm pretty sure our vig is dead.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
I'm just going with my gut at this point. It's worked for me in the past.
"Go up, thou bald head." -2 Kings 2:23
...
Actually, I changed my mind. You are eviiiiiil!
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
OooOoOo
Kime, that sentence is so contradictory, that if I were playing, I would vote for myself just so I would have to read it.
Just wanted you to know
OooOoOo
:P I'm here to please!
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
"Go up, thou bald head." -2 Kings 2:23
Need votes from Zandracon, Dusda, JaysonFour, Simonwolf
Stay tuned
Witches are always into Bestiality
Ultros64 was butchering a cow in his shop today when a cloaked figure came in asking for lamb’s blood. Lamb’s Blood was in rather high demand lately and when pressed on why he needed it the cloaked man replied.
“To turn you into a newtâ€
The butcher shop closed early that day and no one ever saw Ultros64 ever again.
Simonwolf the carpenter had been overproducing woodcrafts. This was due to the overwhelmingly huge stockpile of wood Mr. Defecation had left after his disappearance and it needed to be used. Now simonwolf had so much product that everything he made was now worthless. Taking pity on the soon to be penniless pauper a cloaked figure came by and gave simonwolf a simpler existence.
Today Delroland the Rancher was on the stand.
“Delroland you know the charges that are being brought against you. How do you plead?â€
“Not Guiltyâ€
“Very well on with the prosecution. Now did you or did you not have intercourse with your livestock?â€
“What kind of question is that?â€
“Everyone knows witchs are the most perverted creatures imaginable now just answer the question.â€
“Well umm, of course I haven’t you know done it with a sheep or anything.â€
Delroland was visibly sweating.
“What about a cow?â€
“*cough* *ahem* Well it depends on your definition of intercourse, I mean, effectively I’m giving a handjob to a cow to milk it.â€
“GIVING HANDJOBS TO A COW!?! YOU ARE A DISGUSTING WITCH AND YOU WILL BURN ON EARTH AND IN HELL. TAKE HIM AWAYâ€
And from that day onward, anyone who handled livestock was never looked at the same way again.
After the burning the Mayor had an announcement.
Umm, do to lack of funds since our tax collector is deceased I’m afraid we can only afford to continue the trials one more day. I hope you’ve all enjoyed yourselves this past week. Have a good evening and we’ll see you same time, same place to burn another witch.
Results
Delroland – WITCH –BURNED
Simonwolf – Carpenter – Newted
Ultros64 – Butcher – Newted
Sunday is the last day
HOWEVER, due to circumstances beyond my control I won’t have the final results and narration up until Monday morning. Apologies for the inconvenience.
oOoOoOo
Told you.
ooooO
No thoughts on anything important because it's late so I'll just sound silly.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
*hic*
Anyway, !JaysonFour because I know I'm human.
Gonna have to think about the vote some more. . . It would be kind of nice if someone could admit to being a witch and make it easy on us :P.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
Are you now? Ugh you bugger, why couldn't you have done this earlier? You wait until 4 hours before the game literally ends to give a reveal that cannot be proven in any way before endgame
Bleh. OK, assuming you are telling the truth, do you have any leads? Did you manage to get networked or anything?
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile