I think we need more info about number of mafia kills.
Warban was definitely murdered. paraphrasing "He Felt something sharp" and he was watching wolves just before he did. Which we saw the skinchangers (in the form Dagon) change slip into the bodies of.
Obifett's is a bit ambiguous since he is just never heard from again, so he could have gotten lost or something.
Alegis went to sleep and never woke up from it. So he could have gotten smothered/neck slit.
Dagon's death is a bit odd. He slips into wolf form and then it mentions and another figure.
Bedlam just has his mutilated corpse.
I would say Alegis and warban seem mafia. Obi seems a bit up in the air.
Warban was undoubtedly killed by Skinchangers.
Bedlam was voted out.
Dagon was murdered by the very person that was supposed to be guarding him.
Alegis could be skinchangers, his own guard (probably not though), or a third faction.
I have no idea about Obifett.
I was just going off the narration and what is explicitly stated :P
Not really convinced of anything from anybody but kime seems more reasonable than the Gbarons wagon. Don't really get that one...maybe I missed the explanation?
Not really convinced of anything from anybody but kime seems more reasonable than the Gbarons wagon. Don't really get that one...maybe I missed the explanation?
He was lightning fast on the sirfab wagon, along with dagon. You might argue that two mafia would not jump on a wagon so quickly, and so close together, but I have definitely seen it happen on other days 1, and even later in a game's life as well.
Also, unless they come from before my time, they were both fairly new players, and that's an easy day 1 mistake to make. Now that Dagon has come up evil, I think it's a good shot. It's also worth saying that while bedlam was super quick to jump on stever, my initial barons vote got two votes pretty quick, and would have been the easier vote (at the time) for him to save himself.
Instead, he said nothing about it and voted on rend for no reason other than his self vote, and waited until a stever vote really got rolling, and jumped on it.
On top of switching from the retaba vote he had just made twenty minutes before.
I'm thinking Kime but greenbarons seems reasonable enough too.
0
Options
Sir FabulousMalevolent Squid GodRegistered Userregular
I would also like to point out the fact that kime was in a cabin with a mafia member. I would think the mafia would try to spread themselves out the first day.
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
0
Options
AnialosCollies are love, Collies are life!Shadowbrook ColliesRegistered Userregular
Stever777 for immediately jumping on the counter-wagon to greenbarons with no vote explanation as soon as gb made his vote.
0
Options
BaidolI will hold him offEscape while you canRegistered Userregular
If we assume six mafia, there were enough cabins for that, but, if I were mafia, I would be hesitant to put every single player at the mercy of the cabin guard.
Did we ever get an explanation as to why the cabin guard for Dagon decided to off him?
If we assume six mafia, there were enough cabins for that, but, if I were mafia, I would be hesitant to put every single player at the mercy of the cabin guard.
Did we ever get an explanation as to why the cabin guard for Dagon decided to off him?
If we assume six mafia, there were enough cabins for that, but, if I were mafia, I would be hesitant to put every single player at the mercy of the cabin guard.
Did we ever get an explanation as to why the cabin guard for Dagon decided to off him?
GLAAAAARG
I don't have time for your mumblings! I have a class to prep for! Give me information!
Ok, I am not trying to put too much out there, and I don't want to pressure anyone to reveal this if they're uncomfortable, but I have reports of at least five people getting sick last night.
That is from three different cabins.
The effect of being sick makes it pretty much a mafia ability only.
If it is more than five people who got sick (and even with five), that is a huge number of sick people in one night. I think it might be useful to hear how many cabins were affected, but not who claimed it or how many in a cabin.
If it's a mafia ability, they know who got sick, we are really only hiding it from ourselves. I think that being sick will be a really convenient excuse for someone to a) not be indited for not guarding and b) seem to be innocent because they were targeted by a mafia attack.
GLAAARGH IF IT'S CABIN SPECIFIC IT'S CLEARLY AN ATTEMPT TO FORCE PEOPLE TO SWAP CABINS EACH NIGHT AND WE SHOULD PROBABLY FIGURE OUT IF THAT IS THE CASE SO WE CAN PLAY ACCORDINGLY BLLUUARRRGH
Haha ok so let me explain some things, first off when I voted for Sir Fab, I didn't know there was a wagon on him and I did it because he had a vote for me.
Alegis and I hooked up when I was talking about roughing it in the wilderness and he was looking for a cabin. He sent a pm to me offering and I was all high-five and at first, Alegis proposed we both guard but once I pointed out that there was a 2 day cool down, he offered to guard. I retracted my guard order in the cabin order. As far as I know, we were the only two in that cabin.
So I didn't stab my bunkmate. Also random thought, who did the people who got sick vote for? Did any of them vote for the known mafia? Because when Bedlam died, it talked about him moving bodies as if he was still alive.
So, in addition to all of that, do we think that the guard-vig who killed dagon should form a network today?
If dagon was mafia, he relayed the guard schedule to the mafia before he died, so they know who killed him. Unless they pull something fancy, that guy is going to get axed tonight. But he might be able to coordinate specials and maybe get a for real guard if there is one?
Also, Egos shutting the door on my face day 1 and now voting for me because I wanted to LIVE! Can't have none of that.
Shutting the door on your face would be if I had room. And how am I voting for you because you wanted to live? I'm voting for you because of poor placement on a wagon and because of your cabin mate being mysteriously murder-ized.
Yes well, I wouldn't of been in the same cabin as my recently murder-ized cabin mate if you hadn't of shut the door in my face due to being full! Well, you and a couple others.
Because there are 2? people left who can confirm he was guarding that night.
Although there's nothing keeping someone who wasn't guarding as far as the rest of the cabin knowing from being the one who sent in orders to the host to guard and kill someone.
My friend is working on a roguelike game you can play if you want to. (It has free demo)
Posts
I was just going off the narration and what is explicitly stated :P
Retaba is a he. When he first showed up, I think he was a she because his avatar looked like the poster for 'Dead like Me'.
Man I messed that one up bad, apologies Retaba.
Don't worry SirFab, he's going to Canada tomorrow!
Not really convinced of anything from anybody but kime seems more reasonable than the Gbarons wagon. Don't really get that one...maybe I missed the explanation?
On top of switching from the retaba vote he had just made twenty minutes before.
I can see it from my house on a clear night.
Also I have to disagree with Rysk.
I think that the late vote on Bedlam would be way too much a a newbie mistake for a player like kime to make.
On the other hand, I think that Greenbarons is new enough to make the mistake his band wagon is placed on.
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
I would make the newbie argument and say he's not an experienced player. For Dagon, can't really say, think I've played with him before..? Not sure.
The votes are so skewed I'll just leave them where they lie for now.
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
Did we ever get an explanation as to why the cabin guard for Dagon decided to off him?
GLAAAAARG
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
I don't have time for your mumblings! I have a class to prep for! Give me information!
Yeah it's a pretty big part of the whole guard thing. You can stab the shit out of one of your cabinmates while they lie sleeping.
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
That is from three different cabins.
The effect of being sick makes it pretty much a mafia ability only.
If it is more than five people who got sick (and even with five), that is a huge number of sick people in one night. I think it might be useful to hear how many cabins were affected, but not who claimed it or how many in a cabin.
If it's a mafia ability, they know who got sick, we are really only hiding it from ourselves. I think that being sick will be a really convenient excuse for someone to a) not be indited for not guarding and b) seem to be innocent because they were targeted by a mafia attack.
I can confirm this, specifically, is not the case. Unless my cabin is lying to me.
Switch Friend Code: SW-1406-1275-7906
Alegis and I hooked up when I was talking about roughing it in the wilderness and he was looking for a cabin. He sent a pm to me offering and I was all high-five and at first, Alegis proposed we both guard but once I pointed out that there was a 2 day cool down, he offered to guard. I retracted my guard order in the cabin order. As far as I know, we were the only two in that cabin.
That is my hypothesis.
As for the guard killing Dagon, he just looked suspicious.
3DS Friend Code: 3110-5393-4113
Steam profile
It involves PMs
Oh man, what are you guys doing with each other besides just talking!?
Quarantine time.
If dagon was mafia, he relayed the guard schedule to the mafia before he died, so they know who killed him. Unless they pull something fancy, that guy is going to get axed tonight. But he might be able to coordinate specials and maybe get a for real guard if there is one?
Shutting the door on your face would be if I had room. And how am I voting for you because you wanted to live? I'm voting for you because of poor placement on a wagon and because of your cabin mate being mysteriously murder-ized.
Although there's nothing keeping someone who wasn't guarding as far as the rest of the cabin knowing from being the one who sent in orders to the host to guard and kill someone.